• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more

What if plants had feelings?

What if science could demonstrably show that plants had the ability to experience pain?


What would vegetarians and/or vegans do?

Not being either I can't comment but if there are any vegetarians/vegans out there that have an opinion, I would be grateful for your input.


It seems as if Plants DO HAVE feelings given the fact that they can produce substances that warn other plants in the neighborhood:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biocommunication_(science)
 
Forget this nonsense of plants having feelings or if Vegans tremble at the thought of eating "plants that feel."

I propose a solution to 1) world population, world hunger, world strife, ect.

2) global warming

3) insert your choice here. . .

However repugnant my idea may seem, ponder the actual possibilities of a successful campaign.

Cannibalization as a means to "reduce" the contemporary problems facing the World today.

The only problem, as I see it, would be trying to find "healthy food"

Having driven past more 'golden arches' than I care to count, some of their customers seem to have an agenda of prepping for a distaster of some kind by "storing " excess energy as body fat.

Of course there is always an Organic/Health store to stalk for a tasty morsel.

I await your replies. . . :cool:
.
With my luck, I'd get Johnson's gamy leg!
 
Biocommunication (science)Signs... signals... That ain't what I'd call 'feelings'...


FEELINGS (Morris Albert)
Feelings, nothing more than feelings,
trying to forget my feelings of love.


Feelings, wo-o-o feelings,
wo-o-o, feel you again in my arms.
Feelings, feelings like I've never lost you
and feelings like I've never have you again in my heart.
 
Forget this nonsense of plants having feelings or if Vegans tremble at the thought of eating "plants that feel."

I propose a solution to 1) world population, world hunger, world strife, ect.

2) global warming

3) insert your choice here. . .

However repugnant my idea may seem, ponder the actual possibilities of a successful campaign.

Cannibalization as a means to "reduce" the contemporary problems facing the World today.

The only problem, as I see it, would be trying to find "healthy food"

Having driven past more 'golden arches' than I care to count, some of their customers seem to have an agenda of prepping for a distaster of some kind by "storing " excess energy as body fat.

Of course there is always an Organic/Health store to stalk for a tasty morsel.

I await your replies. . . :cool:

Swift! Is that you, Swift?
 
On my evening constipational last evening just before sunset, I noticed this cluster of flowers "looking" directly at the sun.
Went out this morning to the same cluster, hoping to see what I saw, which was the flowers having reoriented themselves quite a bit to "look" at the sun.
They're not -aware-, not being conscious but they do respond in a manner that presents the maximum surface of the flowers.. and even tho stems that are going to have flowers, to the sun.
And saw my first bee of 2009.
Usually at this time of year they're all over the flowers and blossoms on the trees, and quite conspicuous by their absence so far this year.
The guy I saw seems to have an underground hive. Disappeared in amongst some flowers and didn't come back out for a while.
 

Attachments

  • Flower-Sun-01.jpg
    Flower-Sun-01.jpg
    108.1 KB · Views: 1
  • Flower-Sun-02.jpg
    Flower-Sun-02.jpg
    127.3 KB · Views: 1
scienceclarified.com Science of Everyday Things: Phototropism

...A tropism is the growth of a plant as a response to a stimulus, and phototropism occurs when a plant responds to light by bending in the direction of the light. Although plant physiologists (scientists who study how the processes of a plant actually work) know that this growth is caused by a plant hormone, they still do not fully understand exactly how it works.

<snip/>
Words to Know

Auxin: Any of various hormones or similar synthetic substances that regulate the growth and development of plants.

Photosynthesis: Chemical process by which plants containing chlorophyll use sunlight to manufacture their own food by converting carbon dioxide and water to carbohydrates, releasing oxygen as a by-product.

Tropism: The growth or movement of a plant toward or away from a stimulus.

How phototropism works


It was not until the 1920s that Dutch botanist Frits W. Went (1903–1990) proved the connection between phototropism and a plant hormone called auxin. Went discovered that plants manufacture a growth stimulant (which he named auxin) in their tips, which they then send to other cells in the plant. In phototropism, however, this growth hormone is distributed unevenly when the light source comes from only one direction. Specifically, more auxin flows down the dark side, meaning that it grows faster than the exposed side of the plant. This unequal or one-sided growth (also called differential growth) brings about the curving or bending of the plant toward the light source. <snip/>

Understanding what plant tropism is and, specifically, what happens during phototropism makes us realize that plants, as living things, necessarily demonstrate the several characteristics of life. Specifically, this includes growth, response to stimuli, and adaptation. It is because of its hormones that a plant's stem always grows upwards and its roots always grown downward. <snip/>

Source: http://www.scienceclarified.com/Oi-Ph/Phototropism.html
 
scienceclarified.com Science of Everyday Things: Phototropism
.
I knew that! :)
It's another thing I've forgotten I knew.
There's more every day.
Sob!
 
What if science could demonstrably show that plants had the ability to experience pain?

Lots of plants weep from the wound if you beat them hard enough - does that count?

These dandelions ...

Dandelions?

These are dandelions.

What you showed were ice plants, which are succulents and no relation whatsoever to dandelion, a broad leaf grass.

Both close in the dark, though.
 
I only eat meat and dairy, because I can't abide the suffering of the plants. Vegans/vegetarians, and especially fruitarians disgust me. Eating the very things that the plants spend their lives producing, egad!

Well, okay, meat, dairy, and chocolate donuts, but who could resist chocolate donuts?!?!?
 
Some people say that rappers don't have feelings. We do have feelings. Some people say we're not rappers. We are rappers. It hurts our feelings.
I don't enjoy meat so I don't eat it. I like just about everything else. I have no problem with anyone else eating meat.

Also, I love questions like this where the goal is just to get the person responding to say what you want them to say.

"OK, but what if the plant licked your nose and was really cute."
"OK, but what if the plant looked and acted exactly like an animal you like and would never eat?"
 
So, as a vegetarian, in response to the OP: If plants were of a very different nature than evidence suggests, I would have to rethink the ethical portion of my decision to be a vegetarian. Trying to shift my diet to use products that did not require killing th producing organism would be a possibility. Whether there's any point in spending too much brain power on this kind of hypothedical, I doubt very much.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom