What happened to all the people who were certain Megrahi was guilty?

Rolfe

Adult human female
Joined
Sep 11, 2003
Messages
55,387
Location
NT 150 511
Maybe I should have started this thread earlier, as Bunntamas has gone away for now. However, I'll give it a shot.

Last year, any thread started regarding the Lockerbie bombing or Abdelbaset al-Megrahi attracted a fair number of posters who were keen to support the position that Megrahi carried out that atrocity. In a poll in September last year, 17 members stated that they were familiar with the evidence in the case and believed him to be guilty, though as the poll was anonymous, I don't know who they were. Many posters commented in Lockerbie threads that they disagreed with me in believing the conviction to be perverse.

Bunntamas, who joined the forum in August, lost her father on Pan Am 103, and believes Megrahi to be the perpetrator. She obviously has quite considerable familiarity with the evidence. I encouraged her to join, assuring her that she wouldn't be in a minority of one, because JREF posters are generally supportive of "official versions" and don't like conspiracy theories, and because I knew there were quite a few posters here who had expressed the same belief as her.

She posted in several threads both here and in conspiracy theories, and received no support at all. I think she may have felt she was being ganged up on. I now feel quite guilty for assuring her she would have support here, and wouldn't be arguing her corner alone.

So what happened? Has there inded been a general change of mind/heart about this case, although very few people actually came out and said so? Or what?

I'm posting in this forum area because most of the older posts I'm referring to were made here, and because I don't want to get into theories, evidence or whatever. I'd just like to know what happened to the "I'm quite sure he did it" school of thought.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Maybe I should have started this thread earlier, as Bunntamas has gone away for now. However, I'll give it a shot.

Last year, any thread started regarding the Lockerbie bombing or Abdelbaset al-Megrahi attracted a fair number of posters who were keen to support the position that Megrahi carried out that atrocity. In a poll in September last year, 17 members stated that they were familiar with the evidence in the case and believed him to be guilty, though as the poll was anonymous, I don't know who they were. Many posters commented in Lockerbie threads that they disagreed with me in believing the conviction to be perverse.

Bunntamas, who joined the forum in August, lost her father on Pan Am 103, and believes Megrahi to be the perpetrator. She obviously has quite considerable familiarity with the evidence. I encouraged her to join, assuring her that she wouldn't be in a minority of one, because JREF posters are generally supportive of "official versions" and don't like conspiracy theories, and because I knew there were quite a few posters here who had expressed the same belief as her.

She posted in several threads both here and in conspiracy theories, and received no support at all. I think she may have felt she was being ganged up on. I now feel quite guilty for assuring her she would have support here, and wouldn't be arguing her corner alone.

So what happened? Has there inded been a general change of mind/heart about this case, although very few people actually came out and said so? Or what?

I'm posting in this forum area because most of the older posts I'm referring to were made here, and because I don't want to get into theories, evidence or whatever. I'd just like to know what happened to the "I'm quite sure he did it" school of thought.

Rolfe.
We gave up, due to your obsession with the guy.
 
Gave up believing he was guilty?

Or do you have some killer insight you could have brought out to help Bunntamas, but didn't?

Funny how the Amanda Knox discussion is at about 25,000 posts and counting. Doesn't seem too hard to find support for either side of that debate, obsessive or not.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Gave up believing he was guilty?

Gave up in trying to convince you that your obsession is pointless.

Smashing brick walls to bits with your forehead is just as pleasurable, but much more productive.

McHrozni
 
Contrary to claims made, I would suggest it is because the case and arguments for Megrahi's guilt are not supported by the evidence, and people have actually accepted that. If not openly, then tacit acceptance is clear.

The evidence does not support, nor identify, Megrahi as the purchaser of the clothing.

The evidence, of which there is none, thus does not support the allegation that the bomb was inserted at Luqa in Malta.

And all the other evidence, which is subject to interpretation, scepticism and tenuous inference, could perhaps be an indication of involvement by a particular State or group, but cannot be attributed to any single individual, and certainly not Megrahi.
 
Interpretation, scepticism, tenuous inference... it's an inconclusive dead-end.

The Apollo Project is one of the most thoroughly-documented, publically-available projects ever undertaken.

The collapse of the WTC towers on 9/11 provides a wealth of evidence and presents a solvable problem in structural engineering.

For these questions, there are answers. I haven't looked at any of the Amanda Knox threads lately, but last time I checked everybody involved seemed to think there were answers there as well.

Last time I looked at any of the Lockerbie threads, all I saw were questions. The State has answers, but you don't like those answers. I admit, the walls of text, the endless, laborious appeals to incredulity and supposition... After a while, I gave up trying to wade through it all.

Did you ever get to the point of having answers? Or is it still in the seemingly-endless unaswered questions phase?
 
Interpretation, scepticism, tenuous inference... it's an inconclusive dead-end.

The Apollo Project is one of the most thoroughly-documented, publically-available projects ever undertaken.

The collapse of the WTC towers on 9/11 provides a wealth of evidence and presents a solvable problem in structural engineering.

For these questions, there are answers. I haven't looked at any of the Amanda Knox threads lately, but last time I checked everybody involved seemed to think there were answers there as well.

Last time I looked at any of the Lockerbie threads, all I saw were questions. The State has answers, but you don't like those answers. I admit, the walls of text, the endless, laborious appeals to incredulity and supposition... After a while, I gave up trying to wade through it all.

Did you ever get to the point of having answers? Or is it still in the seemingly-endless unaswered questions phase?

The problem with that argument is that in the case of 9/11 there isn't much in the way of alturnative groups who could have done it in a way consistent with the evidence. Thus "okey who do you think did it?" is a reasonable question. In the case of the lockerbie bombing you are talking 1980s europe where there was not exactly a shortage of groups who could potentialy have done it.
 
What happened to all the people who were certain Megrahi was guilty?

We're waiting for the election of an administration that will have the balls to bomb Libya again.
 
Gave up in trying to convince you that your obsession is pointless.

Smashing brick walls to bits with your forehead is just as pleasurable, but much more productive.

McHrozni

MC, you poser. You never smashed a thing with anything. And it sounds like you're over trying at that? Feel free to move on then and best wishes.

ETA: Should make it less personal. McHrozni, you've done some good work on Pearl Harbor, at the least. But on this issue, you raised nothing of major import. A few worthy considerations, and a lot of argument by incredulity. Neither you nor anyone at this forum has yet really said anything of weight against the body of facts pointing to a frame-up or at least some kind of epic wrongness.
 
Last edited:
Did you ever get to the point of having answers? Or is it still in the seemingly-endless unaswered questions phase?

A clear definition of "answer" might be helpful here. I think Rolfe, Buncrana, and myself agree on the best guesses to all the really relevant questions, but admittedly none of that's been enshrined as legal reality yet, if that's what you mean.

We're sure Megrahi was not the buyer of the clothes at Gauci's shop.

We're fairly certain, one way or another out of two options, that the evidence suggesting an unaccompanied bag leaving Megrahi's position and loaded to 103 is at the least highly inconclusive.

We're pretty certain the PFLP-GC really did the crime, via an unknown agent loading the fifth Khreesat bomb directly into container AVE4041 at Heathrow at about 16:1GMT
http://lockerbiedivide.blogspot.com/2010/02/interline-shed-chronology.html
(or perhaps later, depending...)
http://lockerbiedivide.blogspot.com/2010/06/yet-another-red-flag-from-heathrow.html

We're not as in agreement as to what physical evidence might have been planted, and going into that takes us too far in the CT direction for the current discussion, which is about Megrahi's guilt, not alleged frame-ups.

What was it about these answers you found unconvincing? What mitigates against them?
 
Last edited:
The problem with that argument is that in the case of 9/11 there isn't much in the way of alturnative groups who could have done it in a way consistent with the evidence. Thus "okey who do you think did it?" is a reasonable question. In the case of the lockerbie bombing you are talking 1980s europe where there was not exactly a shortage of groups who could potentialy have done it.

Indeed. And one of those groups, the PFLP-GC, was in touch with Iran as early as 4 July 1988 to help them avenge the 3 July shoot-down of Iran Air 655. Same group reportedly paid $11 million by Iran's Interior Minister. Same group built five altitude sensitive bombs disguised in radios. Four of these five were recovered. These were set to blow app. 30-60 minutes after takeoff following first introduction. PA103 blew up 38 minutes after leaving Heathrow.

And further, the evidence that eclipsed all this and pointed to Libya instead is rather cartoonish.

We're waiting for the election of an administration that will have the balls to bomb Libya again.

Typical American. Just continue to not use your God-given reason in the interim, or you might have to back down on that certainty. Stay tough, eh?
 
Typical American. Just continue to not use your God-given reason in the interim, or you might have to back down on that certainty. Stay tough, eh?

I assume he was being sarcastic. Or maybe ironic. But either way, I don't think he meant it literally....
 
Typical American. Just continue to not use your God-given reason in the interim, or you might have to back down on that certainty. Stay tough, eh?

I'm a Canadian citizen.

If Libya is going to support terrorism, they can suffer the consequences... again.
 
Contrary to claims made, I would suggest it is because the case and arguments for Megrahi's guilt are not supported by the evidence, and people have actually accepted that. If not openly, then tacit acceptance is clear.

I've largely given up talking to a couple of the usual gang of idiots over in the 9/11 CT section because they adhere to the most astronomically stupid theories about the attacks, they've exhausted their minimal entertainment value and they simply will not listen to anything that is being said to them.

By your absurd and asinine reasoning, I am now a no-planer/death rays from space kook.
 
The problem with that argument is that in the case of 9/11 there isn't much in the way of alturnative groups who could have done it in a way consistent with the evidence. Thus "okey who do you think did it?" is a reasonable question. In the case of the lockerbie bombing you are talking 1980s europe where there was not exactly a shortage of groups who could potentialy have done it.
"Ability, therefore culpability"? No shortage of groups, and no way to narrow it down, apparently.

A clear definition of "answer" might be helpful here. I think Rolfe, Buncrana, and myself agree on the best guesses to all the really relevant questions, but admittedly none of that's been enshrined as legal reality yet, if that's what you mean.
I mean that all of it amounts to "best guesses".


Have you ever heard of the board game, Clue? It's based on the principle of "best guesses", too. But at the end of the game, the truth is revealed, and we learn whether or not the guesses are correct. The three of you have given your best guess: Not Professor Plum, not in the Library, not with the Candlestick, but maybe somebody else, in some other room, with some other implement. But until the envelope is produced, and the cards revealed, it's still just a guess. And that's the current state of play: guesses.

What was it about these answers you found unconvincing? What mitigates against them?
That they are founded upon supposition and appeals to incredulity. In short, questions, but no answers.
 
I'm a Canadian citizen.
That's funny, because I'm an American.

If Libya is going to support terrorism, they can suffer the consequences... again.

Little sarcasm there, it seems. Did you miss the part where it really seems they didn't support or order terrorism, at least in the case of PA103? I understand legal and widely accepted truth is often hard to separate from verifiable physical truth. But do remember with some humbleness there many men out there could feel the acute difference standing at the bar, hearing the punishment they're to pay for their heinous crime they know they didn't commit.

FWIW, Megrahi's punishment is less severe than many wrongfully convicted of just one murder here in the states. It's not so much for his sake that I'm all fired up about this issue.

Sword_Of_Truth said:
Originally Posted by Buncrana
Contrary to claims made, I would suggest it is because the case and arguments for Megrahi's guilt are not supported by the evidence, and people have actually accepted that. If not openly, then tacit acceptance is clear.
I've largely given up talking to a couple of the usual gang of idiots over in the 9/11 CT section because they adhere to the most astronomically stupid theories about the attacks, they've exhausted their minimal entertainment value and they simply will not listen to anything that is being said to them.

By your absurd and asinine reasoning, I am now a no-planer/death rays from space kook.

Sorry, not sure how the one follows from the other. I think it's fair to say no-planers and official story supporters share at least one trait in common - they've lost in battle of reason here at this forum thus far.

Otherwise, the differences are quite obvious to all of us here, and no one will argue that the official story of Megrahi's plot makes a bit more sense than real-time 3-D open-air mid-day holographics, convincing from all angles, synched with sound source and explosives to fake its devastation, with real planes and passengers eliminated elsewhere, and... etc...

How much more sense is open to debate. But the debate should be kept to the CT forum, where the informal consensus here has been reached and should be firmly challenged, someday, hopefully.
Especially this thread:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=169917
It would behoove anyone who's sure of the supposedly debunked positon to actually back that up with arguments and evidence, rather than flippantly dismiss those on the other side as obviously wrong, somehow. It's what we demand of moonbats and CTists, isn't it? So why shouldn't we live up to it ourselves?

So the disagreements aside, where are all the people who are so sure Megrahi is guilty? Why aren't they involved in discussions about that? Until now anyway?

So far we've got:

We gave up, due to your obsession with the guy.
(valid in its way, but obviously in no other way)

Gave up in trying to convince you that your obsession is pointless.
(gave up before starting)

Interpretation, scepticism, tenuous inference... it's an inconclusive dead-end. [...] Did you ever get to the point of having answers? Or is it still in the seemingly-endless unaswered questions phase?
(diqualified - unanswered questions implies theprestige isn't certain of Megrahi's guilt)

and my favorite:
We're waiting for the election of an administration that will have the balls to bomb Libya again.
(covered above)
 
Last edited:
"Ability, therefore culpability"? No shortage of groups, and no way to narrow it down, apparently.


I mean that all of it amounts to "best guesses".


Have you ever heard of the board game, Clue? It's based on the principle of "best guesses", too. But at the end of the game, the truth is revealed, and we learn whether or not the guesses are correct. The three of you have given your best guess: Not Professor Plum, not in the Library, not with the Candlestick, but maybe somebody else, in some other room, with some other implement. But until the envelope is produced, and the cards revealed, it's still just a guess. And that's the current state of play: guesses.


That they are founded upon supposition and appeals to incredulity. In short, questions, but no answers.

On its own, Geni's post showed that your comparisons with 9/11 are unfounded. But in your response to him and me, I can't help but notice that you completely glossed over the answers I provided on group, motive, technology, and how it fits in with the evidence. There's much more I didn't mention, like the primary-style suitcase (brown or maroony hards-shell Samsonite style) placed into AVE4041 at Heathrow, that COULD NOT have been from Malta, and that no one can testify just where it came from. Just appeared ... then disappeared after the bombing, with fragments of a brown hard-shell Samsonite being found and presumed as the primary suitcase, and not one other such case accounted for in everything recovered.

If you have the debunks on why this must all be coincidence, take it to this thread:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=165824

Here it's about Megrahi's guilt, and I'd like to see someone defend Tony Gauci's supposed identification of Megrahi, upon which the judgment rested. Can anyone show how their acceptance was reasonable? It's even simpler to grasp than the Amanda Knox stuff, believe it or not.
 
Gave up in trying to convince you that your obsession is pointless.

Smashing brick walls to bits with your forehead is just as pleasurable, but much more productive.


McHrozni was the only poster to admit that he'd been wrong about the strength of the evidence against Megrahi, before bowing out of the discussion. So I gave him some credit for that.

However, this "obsession" is "pointless"? Pointless in what way? That no amount of evidence for Megrahi's innocence is going to convince you? Or what?

Of course, arguing with people with obsessions is so pointless, especially whan you're right. That's why the 9/11 subforum is a lonely wasteland of twoofers posting their fantasies, without any debunkers in sight.

That's why the Amanda Knox threads are entirely populated by people who believe she's innocent, and those who believe she's guilty have taken their solid, evidence-based arguments away because it's pointless.

Oh wait....

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Last time I looked at any of the Lockerbie threads, all I saw were questions. The State has answers, but you don't like those answers. I admit, the walls of text, the endless, laborious appeals to incredulity and supposition... After a while, I gave up trying to wade through it all.

Did you ever get to the point of having answers? Or is it still in the seemingly-endless unaswered questions phase?


Questions about what?

The thread is about posters who believe Megrahi actually carried out the Pan Am 103 bombing. Not about who else might have done it.

Certainly, once you start enquiring into who actually carried out that atrocity, you get a helluva lot of questions. However, that's stage 2. Stage 1 is the realisation that whoever it was, it wasn't Megrahi. If you seriously can't follow the arguments to the point of figuring that part out, I don't think you've been paying much attention at all.

The question was about belief in Megrahi's guilt. Not about theories regarding who was really guilty.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom