What does it take to be a Christianphobic bigot?

Glenn Beck is now on board with Obama omitting the "under God" phrase as being very, very terrible.

http://www.video.theblaze.com/media/video.jsp?content_id=31230715
"the man has an issue with God" and "he is changing our history, he is changing our traditions"
Also Chris Plante thinks it is all "curious."

One nation under God? Under President Obama, maybe not so much.
As first reported on WMAL's Chris Plante Show Tuesday, the Commander-in-Chief joined a cast of 61 other noted lawmakers, politicians, news anchors and celebrities, including every living President, in reciting the Gettysburg Address, which President Abraham Lincoln delivered on November 19, 1863.
The dignitaries all delivered the address as Lincoln had written it, including the phrase, "that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom." (Click to listen). Curiously, however, in his version of the address, President Obama omitted the words "under God."
 
Put it like this: Is it really that rational to consider Obama's reading of the Gettysburg address - from a copy that, as already mentioned, didn't have "under God" in it anyway - as even a piece of evidence of Obama being "anti-Christian" in the first place?

Indeed.
If Obama's remarks are consider "more evidence" then I would suggest that this guy's definition of evidence might be wacky enough that the other unmentioned evidence may not be evidence at all.

Although I do like "he has an intolerance." It is very LOL-speak: "I has an anger. I has an intolerance, too."


...............

Just as I thought. The Conservapedia article on the G.A. says "under God." The Wikipedia article says that different written versions have slightly different wording.
 
Last edited:
Both of these seem like obvious, rational arguments to make based on the citation in the OP.

But it's like Donald Rumsfeld once said: You rebut the argument the OP has, not the argument the OP wishes they had or wanted to have at a later time.

The OP didn't make an argument. Bryan Fischer's statements were moronic. Do you have some further information that would justify his assessment?
 
Actually, "he has" is grammatically correct.


OK. I never said "he has" was incorrect. I was commenting on "has an intolerance" as being unidiomatic.

Apparently the real problem with lolspeak is that it impairs one's ability to recognize proper English when they see it.

Well played.
I, like you, love adding grammatical errors to posts that criticize the grammatical errors in other people's posts.
 

Attachments

  • Everett_1864_AbeLincoln's_GettysburgAddress.JPG
    Everett_1864_AbeLincoln's_GettysburgAddress.JPG
    96.1 KB · Views: 26
Last edited:
What does it take to be a Christianphobic bigot?

Christ, fear, and prejudice. In that order.
 
The words are an addition. They interfere with the flow of the thought in the sentence. "That this nation shall shall have a new birth of freedom" praises the sacrifice of the soldiers at the battle, nothing more.
.
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/835636-nicolay-copy.html
.
It is not unknown that a pious redactor would add or subtract words that the redactor thought were appropriate, especially someone pious.
Pious frauds litter history.
 
The words are an addition. They interfere with the flow of the thought in the sentence. "That this nation shall shall have a new birth of freedom" praises the sacrifice of the soldiers at the battle, nothing more.
.
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/835636-nicolay-copy.html
.
It is not unknown that a pious redactor would add or subtract words that the redactor thought were appropriate, especially someone pious.
Pious frauds litter history.


Perhaps, but according to everything I've read about the origins of the various written versions of the Gettysburg Address in circulation, the pious redactor in this case could only be Lincoln himself. Therefore, whether or not he actually included the words "under God" in the speech as he orated it in Gettysburg is unknown.

Given the evidence, it is not unreasonable to include the words in a modern reprise of the address. It is also not unreasonable to omit them. It is unreasonable to assume malign motives for doing either one.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Perhaps, but according to everything I've read about the origins of the various written versions of the Gettysburg Address in circulation, the pious redactor in this case could only be Lincoln himself. Therefore, whether or not he actually included the words "under God" in the speech as he orated it in Gettysburg is unknown.
Indeed. In fact, not only does the first draft, the "Nicolay Copy" that was given to President Obama to read, lack the words "under God," but the "Hay Copy," the so-called second draft, also lacks those words. Only the three subsequent manuscript copies include the words "under God" and were penned by request after the event. According to http://www.gettysburgfoundation.org/41 :
The “Hay” or “second draft” version was probably made by Lincoln shortly after his return from Gettysburg. Its phrasing more closely matches contemporaneous accounts of the speech than that of the “Nicolay” or “first draft” version.
Thus, it is entirely possible that Lincoln did not use those words when he spoke. It is also possible that he added them to the later copies because he did in fact speak them, but as you say, we don't know whether he did or didn't.
 
Last edited:
According to Bryan Fischer all it takes to be a Christianphobic bigot is to read aloud a version of the Gettysberg Address that does not include the phrase "Under God."

Cool. Where do I get a copy?
 
Christians have been the social and political driving force for so long that being treated even less specially then they have been in the past, to say nothing of being treated like everyone else, feels like persecution to them.
 
Particularly because the reason that version of the Gettysburg Address that Obama read does not include the phrase "Under God" is because Lincoln wrote it that way.
Yes but this is the idiot who complained about the "feminization" of the Medal of Honor
So the question is this: when are we going to start awarding the Medal of Honor once again for soldiers who kill people and break things so our families can sleep safely at night? […] We have feminized the Medal of Honor


Perhaps, but according to everything I've read about the origins of the various written versions of the Gettysburg Address in circulation, the pious redactor in this case could only be Lincoln himself. Therefore, whether or not he actually included the words "under God" in the speech as he orated it in Gettysburg is unknown.

Given the evidence, it is not unreasonable to include the words in a modern reprise of the address. It is also not unreasonable to omit them. It is unreasonable to assume malign motives for doing either one.

Respectfully,
Myriad
IIRC aren't their four common version of the speech? Lincoln's before and after notes, his later Bliss version and one transcribed as he spoke.
 
Yes but this is the idiot who complained about the "feminization" of the Medal of Honor




IIRC aren't their four common version of the speech? Lincoln's before and after notes, his later Bliss version and one transcribed as he spoke.

What? You mean you don't have proof of what Lincoln actually said? Gettysburg is a MYTH!!!!!

Quick, where's Youtube?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom