What did the GOP Congress do for health-care in 12 years?

Thunder

Banned
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
34,918
From 1994 to 2006, the Republicans controlled the Congress.

And from 2001 to 2006, the Republicans controlled Congress AND the White House.

In those 12 years of semi-control and 6 years of total control, what did the GOP do to reform health-care in the USA?

Did they pass a law allowing Americans to buy health insurance across state lines?

Did they pass a law forbidding insurance companies from not covering pre-existing conditions?

Did they pass a law forbidding insurance companies from dropping people when they get sick, or raising premiums when they get sick?

What exactly did the GOP do, in 12 years, to reform health-care in the USA? Millions of Americans would love to know.

:confused:
 
They didn't do a whole lot. That's because it wasn't much of a political issue. Terrorism and war were.
 
Really, what legislation did the GOP Congress pass to reform health-care, from 1994 to 2006?

anything? anybody?

Bueller?
 
So the GOP did nothing, therefore the Dems had to do something stupid? Is that the point of this thread parky?
 
So the GOP did nothing, therefore the Dems had to do something stupid? Is that the point of this thread parky?

no. the point of this thread to is to find out what legislation the GOP controlled Congress passed to reform health-care in the USA, from 1994 to 2006.

Millions of Americans lost their insurance during those 12 years. Millions more Americans had their premiums go way up.

So what did the GOP do to solve...or even tackle... this problem?
 
no. the point of this thread to is to find out what legislation the GOP controlled Congress passed to reform health-care in the USA, from 1994 to 2006.

Millions of Americans lost their insurance during those 12 years. Millions more Americans had their premiums go way up.

So what did the GOP do to solve...or even tackle... this problem?
They did nothing... so therefore the Dems had to do something stupid?
 
r u sure about that?

they passed ZERO legislation to reform health care? nothing at all?

i kinda assumed they had passed something.

im a bit surprised.

The passed Medicare-D, which provided subsidies to Medicare patients to purchase pharmaceuticals. Not only did it have no price controls, but it specifically prohibited Medicare from bargaining for better prices, leading to the whole thing becoming much, much more expensive than it had any reason to be. It was basically a massive cash transfer from taxpayers to Big Pharma.
 
It is a valid question. The beginning of the health care reform discussions, the need for health care changes were clearly and succinctly outlined. Indeed, Republicans didn't challenge the facts:
1. Health care is the most costly here.
2. Cost of health care is growing at rates far beyond what people can afford
3. The primary cost to our government is health care.

Since then, Republicans have offered up their freemarket solutions to health care:
1.) Open up insurance across state lines.
2.) tort reform

The main question is, Why didn't they go after these issues?
 
The plan passed last night is not a perfect plan. It would have been much better if it included a public-option, and more cost saving measures.

But compared to the status-quo..it will be a huge improvement.

And compared to the GOP plans, which only covered an additional 3 million Americans, its a better plan.

I hope that in the next ten years or so, a public-option is added to the mix, so the for-profit corporate HMOs have REAL competition. Competition that will force them to put the needs of their customers first, and profits second.
 
I'm fairly pleased that there isn't an expensive public option included here. I'd rather this bill have been killed in committee, but that obviously didn't happen. What I would have rather seen is someone in the Health Industry recognize that something needed to be done, and action taken so that the rest of us could actually afford health coverage. That would have indicated there was some leadership. This is why you hire CEOs and the like.

But, no. We went with the Veeps sitting around the 19th hole at the country club, sipping their overpriced blended Scotch, trying to figure out new and improved ways to gouge the public. And if history is any indication, they'll turn this into one of the most expensive and useless boondoggles ever. We'll wind up cursing the name of Barack Obama for this waste of taxpayer money, when the blame will actually belong to Pelosi and Reid.

The only winner here is the Insurance Companies.

As to the Republicans: Rope, tree, politician. Some assembly required.
 
well, if we passed a public-option, the HMOs would have to reduce their costs, in order to compete. But the GOP didn't want that, so we scrapped that idea.

I hope we can at least create a non-profit co-op within the next few years. I think Americans should have the ability to choose a non-profit as their health insurance provider.
 
well, if we passed a public-option, the HMOs would have to reduce their costs, in order to compete. But the GOP didn't want that, so we scrapped that idea.

I hope we can at least create a non-profit co-op within the next few years. I think Americans should have the ability to choose a non-profit as their health insurance provider.

I would agree with this, provided it's privately run, and provided it was truly non-profit. Some "non-profits" look suspiciously like for profit outfits, and the "board members" live pretty well.

Why would we need to wait? Why not find someone who's willing to put the up-front capital, and others who are willing to do the work to get it going? Sometimes the greatest rewards aren't found in our bank accounts.
 
What did the GOP Congress do for health-care in 12 years?

Nothing, because The People didn't really care about it.

As for the current year, and 1992-93, both of those were generated "emergencies" by certain political interests. Having been devastated by that politically in the 1993 elections, Clinton abandoned that and suddenly "It's the economy, stupid" became the mantra of the emergency du jour.

Said "emergency du jour" varies depending. Beyond the two above, it may also be Teh Environments or Teh Campaign Finance Censorship Reform



cynic : n : Someone who sees reality as it is, and not as he wishes it to be. -- Ambrose Bierce
 
Last edited:
This is Parky you're talking to. In his world, doing something that one knows is unimaginably stupid is better than doing nothing at all.

i am in support of the health care bill passed last night. its not perfect, but it will improve the lives of millions of Americans.

unimaginably stupid? I think not. what would have been stupid, is to leave the status quo..or to pass a BS bill that only covers 3 million more Americans.
 
As with almost all heath care related legislation this bill was passed with great controversy. Also, like the previous reforms, I believe, this will prove to be wildly popular in due time.

Perhaps someone can clear this up for me but I believe the mandate doesn't come into effect for several years. This would give us plenty of time to further expose the private healthcare industry for the scam that it is and garner the support for a public option. Even a private non profit would have my support. I do not want me or the company I work for to have to shovel money into the pockets of for profit healthcare.
 
Perhaps someone can clear this up for me but I believe the mandate doesn't come into effect for several years. This would give us plenty of time to further expose the private healthcare industry for the scam that it is and garner the support for a public option. Even a private non profit would have my support. I do not want me or the company I work for to have to shovel money into the pockets of for profit healthcare.
How would a public option bring down the costs of health care?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom