Francesca R
Girl
"Why is Sex Fun?--The Evolution of Human Sexuality" by Jared Diamond
Thanks, though the chick is me and I don't think I have much use for that one![]()
Hi, mrich from Seattle. Harriet the SkepDoc from Puyallup raves about that book. Guess skeptigirl from Bellevue is going to have to read it soon.Snake Oil Science: The Truth about Complementary and Alternative Medicine, by R. Barker Bausell, Ph.D.
What if someone with impeccable academic credentials and years of experience in designing rigorous clinical trials turned this expertise toward CAM (complementary and alternative medicine)? What if this same person reviewed the controversial and contradictory literature of CAM for efficacy? What if this same person went the extra mile and helped to develop a credible placebo for, say, acupuncture?
Find out answers to all 3 questions in this book, written by the former Research Director of a National Institutes of Health-funded Complementary and Alternative Medicine Specialized Research Center.
If I had 10 hands, I'd give this book all 10 thumbs up.
andI have 3 suggestions for you to improve your ability to evaluate published research:
(1) Read "Snake Oil Science" by R. Barker Bausell. He has a lot to say specifically about acupuncture as well as excellent general principles.
(2) Read "Critical Thinking about Research" by Julian Meltzoff - I learned more from this book than anywhere else and I wish it were a textbook in every med school.
(3) Read the Science-Based Medicine blog at http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/ It alone will gradually teach you everything you need to know, in painless doses, with reference to current issues. Another acupuncture study (in infertility) will be dissected there in the next few days.
Harriet Hall, MD
The SkepDoc
I will have to at least read the Snake Oil book. I'm still reading Valerie Plame's book and having fun with the audio version of, Death by Black Hole: And Other Cosmic Quandaries (2007) by Neil deGrasse Tyson. It's abridged but at 6 cds long, I don't think he cut much out of the audio version. I wish they wouldn't make abridged audio books. There's no reason for it.I have just finished reading an advance copy of Rose Shapiro's book, "Suckers: How Alternative Medicine Makes Fools of Us All." It is excellent and I highly recommend it. I'll be writing a book review for Skeptic magazine. She has consolidated a wealth of information in a book that is humorous and a delight to read. I learned a number of fascinating new facts about alternative medical silliness. I loved one of her illustrations: a photograph of a sign in a Chinese herbalist's window that mysteriously lost
an H and that reads: "Nature is your harmacy."
Thanks, Rose, for a most useful contribution. It goes on my short shelf of handy references.
Harriet Hall, MD
The SkepDoc
"Why is Sex Fun?--The Evolution of Human Sexuality" by Jared Diamond
Guns, Germs and Steel is excellent.I was reading his book "Guns, germs and steel"
He sure knows how to pen an appealing title
The Unbearable Lightness of Being by Milan Kundera.
It is a truly beautiful, though not necessarily uplifting book- originally written in Czech, but I am reading an English translation.
Does anyone here speak Czech/ read this book in Czech? I would be curious to have more insight on it, or to know how cleanly the concepts in it translate.
Oh yeah, and when I take breaks from that, I'm on "Alphege, or the Green Monkey" from Andrew Lang's "The Yellow Fairy Book."![]()
I enjoyed that book but agree that it is challanging. Is there any idea that is confusing you?
For something more accessable by Kundera, The Joke is excellent.