What are your favorite arguments that never fail to stump the twoofers?

Hey pagan,

Who's stealing the Iraqi oil when the US imports from Iraq have dropped 3% from 2001 and all money from the sale of Iraqi Oil goes into the Iraqi Government coffers?
 
Pagan I suggest you rent some world view that actually has some basis in fact. The one you are leasing now seems to be broken.
 
I know I've said it before- but the easiest way to defeat a truther in one step is to ask the question "what fact or piece of evidence would it take for you to admit you're wrong?" Often times they're not only unprepared to deal with the logic of the issue, but they're also confronted with what they quickly realize is an appropriate way to shine a gigantic spotlight on their bias.

This is a good technique. I used it to slow the ramblings of a (non-9/11) conspiracy theorist recently.

We started a list of things he initially thought might convince him he was mistaken, but, interestingly, he then shot down every one of his own possible proofs -- explaining why each still really wouldn't be enough to convince him after all.

I still don't know if it did any good. But I don't think I could have had a better example to point out how he was just constructing a non-falsifiable (and thus non-scientific) belief structure.
 
Hey pagan,

Who's stealing the Iraqi oil when the US imports from Iraq have dropped 3% from 2001 and all money from the sale of Iraqi Oil goes into the Iraqi Government coffers?
Please let me bolster your argument by expanding on your figure. :)

In 2001, crude oil from Iraq constituted 8.52% of all U.S. crude oil imports that year. In 2006, oil from Iraq constituted 5.48% of all U.S. crude oil imports. Compared to the total of U.S. imports, Iraq declined 3.04%. (So who was the #1 supplier of crude oil to the U.S. in 2006? The answer: Canada. It supplied 17.66% of all the crude oil imported by the U.S. that year.)

However, if you compare Iraq's figures to itself, the decline is much greater. In 2001, Iraq supplied 289,998,000 barrels of crude oil to the U.S.; in 2006, it was down to 201,959,000 barrels of crude oil. That's a reduction of 30.36%, a much more substantial number.
 
Hey pagan,

Who's stealing the Iraqi oil when the US imports from Iraq have dropped 3% from 2001 and all money from the sale of Iraqi Oil goes into the Iraqi Government coffers?

Good point, PhantomWolf and Corsair 115. Furthermore, a new Iraqi law will probably soon be passed that decrees that the oil revenue will divided amongst the Iraqi people themselves:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6399257.stm

http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/02/26/news/iraq.php

BAGHDAD: The Iraqi cabinet approved a draft of a law Monday that would set guidelines for countrywide distribution of oil revenues and foreign investment in the immense oil industry.

The endorsement was a major agreement of the country's ethnic and sectarian political blocs on one of Iraq's most divisive issues.

The draft law approved by the cabinet allows the central government to distribute oil revenues to the provinces or regions by population, which could reduce the economic concerns of the rebellious Sunni Arabs, who fear being cut out of Iraq's vast potential oil wealth by the dominant Shiites and Kurds.
 
Sure, that's the name of the game. You are aware of the fact that the pres. of the US is a very powerful person. And that people who question the official story gets gag orders or gets the boot?
Remain where you are, the Black Helicopters will be with you shortly.
 
Pagan - are you going to continue to evade the Architect's questions (amongst others)?
 
Haha, what on earth would that be. Would it be...

"It is right to kill Arabs and steal their oil"?

No, it's just right to trivialise them as ignorant idiots who cannot hijack a plane and fly it into a building. What was the phrase you lot use? Oh yeah, "caveman".
 
1913:
About 5000 suffragists March in Washington DC. When they got to Pennsylvania Ave those watching the march become abusive, they strike the marchers, throw lit cigars mob them 150-200 marchers are injured.

[stuff]

*applause*
 
Congratulations to Architect for posting a truther-stumping question in a thread about truther-stumping questions!

*applause*
 
Congratulations to Architect for posting a truther-stumping question in a thread about truther-stumping questions!


I feel that the irony of the moment will be wasted on Pagan, MagZ, Lyte, and our other resident Troofers
 
Hey Pagan!

What do you make of the Edinburgh and Sheffield University Papers? And the Arup calculations?

Do you really think he even read the NIST report let alone these?

Perhaps we should get him to answer your other stumping question about why building codes require fireproofing on steel?

Nah, there's a better chance of me waking up tomorrow in St. Barthelemy with Natalie Portman.
 
Please let me bolster your argument by expanding on your figure. :)

In 2001, crude oil from Iraq constituted 8.52% of all U.S. crude oil imports that year. In 2006, oil from Iraq constituted 5.48% of all U.S. crude oil imports. Compared to the total of U.S. imports, Iraq declined 3.04%. (So who was the #1 supplier of crude oil to the U.S. in 2006? The answer: Canada. It supplied 17.66% of all the crude oil imported by the U.S. that year.)

However, if you compare Iraq's figures to itself, the decline is much greater. In 2001, Iraq supplied 289,998,000 barrels of crude oil to the U.S.; in 2006, it was down to 201,959,000 barrels of crude oil. That's a reduction of 30.36%, a much more substantial number.


That would imply US crude oil imports (and thus consumption) is significantly down, wouldn't it? I'm also surprised that the largest exporter of crude oil to the US only had 17.66%, that suggests the US gets their crude oil from a wide range of places.

-Gumboot
 
That would imply US crude oil imports (and thus consumption) is significantly down, wouldn't it? I'm also surprised that the largest exporter of crude oil to the US only had 17.66%, that suggests the US gets their crude oil from a wide range of places.
Crude oil imports by the U.S. were 8.2% greater in 2006 than they were in 2001 (3,684,715 thousands of barrels compared to 3,404,894 thousands of barrels, respectively). While the share of the total comprised by Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Kuwait, to name three examples, have declined since 2001, the share contributed by other nations have risen to take their place. Canada, Mexico, Angola, Algeria, and Ecuador are among those exporting more to the U.S.

The distribution in 2006 looked like this:

The top country (Canada) accounted for 17.66%. The top two countries (Canada and Mexico) accounted for 33.37%. The top five countries (Canada, Mexico, Saudi Arabia, Venezuela, and Nigeria) accounted for 68.96%. The top ten countries accounted for 87.52% of U.S. crude oil imports; the remaining 12.48% was spread among 38 other countries.

All raw data from Energy Information Administration (http://www.eia.doe.gov).
 
Dang, I was just firing a shot across pagan's bow to see if he'd blink, Corsair 155 and orphina nay shot the poor guy down in flaming wreakage.

I wonder if he'll ever actually come back to this thread now.....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom