What are your favorite arguments that never fail to stump the twoofers?

Off the top of my head; troofers typical responses in italic:

- Perimeter column bowing; heat refraction !
- Molten metal flowing down the walls!!! ..... in WTC6; Botched thermite CD??
- Why is the worlds civil/structural engineering community(hundreds of thousands of people, I'm sure) covering up 9/11, especially those engineers in countries that aren't exactly friendly to the US?; They've been bribed and threatened!
- Why blow up WTC7 while the entire world was watching instead of simply destroying the evidence it housed?; Silverstein is an eebil money grubbing JOOO!
 
By this I mean the arguments that leave twoofers with no room to manouver.

When confronted with questions, most twoofers either flat out lie or make up something on the spot.

I'm looking for the kind of questions that leave them with the deer-in-the-headlights look; the long silence when they realize they're cornered.

For example, my favorite is to ask them to reconcile WTC7s demolition with the FDNY knowing the building would collapse well before it did. This also works with Silverstein's "pull it" comment to the fire chief.

Most twoofers know better than to claim the FDNY was in on the 9/11 plot, so they struggle to invent a logical scenario that explains the demolition without implicating the fire department in the plot. An impossible task, as we see here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75954

The more one tries to reconcile the FDNY testimony the more ridiculous the story becomes.


Another example would be what pomeroo calls the Osama Conundrum - asking the twoofer to explain Bush not using Osama to prevent the recent election loss.


Anyone have any other faves?



Again, the Osama Conundrum is devastating to a leftwing loon. With the Alex Jones/Ace Baker anarcho-libertarian types it's not as effective. They can't distinguish George Bush from Barack Obama and Bush is merely a stooge of the invisible army that controls everything.

Asking loons of all stripes why the Impossibly Vast Conspiracy manufactured wars with Afghanistan and Iraq while neglecting to make even one of their "hijackers" an Afghani or an Iraqi tends to give them pause.

The problem with all of these clever ploys is that they are designed to stimulate thought, to reveal irremediable flaws in their arguments. Nothing--absolutely nothing--is capable of stimulating thought in a twoofer. You can drive an eighteen-wheeler through the holes in their arguments, but, as they inhabit a zone outside logic and reason, they just don't care.
 
Odd as it may seem mine is:

"Do you know how much a 30 ton press weighs?"
 
whenever they get on about witnesses and experts being paid off ask how much it would take to pay the truthers off (if in person whip out your checkbook)

give a price, they undercut their "noble truthseeker" image, if they say they cant be paid off even they realize its unfair to assume everyone can be

I agree with orphia nay - that's one of the best ones I've heard.
 
How in God's name can you move several tons of explosives up two of the tallest structures in the world smack dab in the middle of lower Manhattan without a single person nor the NYPD nor the Port Authority police nor the swarms of other security guards and staff there 24/7 noticing?

Bought off? Do you really believe the NYPD, which lost so many of their own that day, which showed such bravery and self-sacrifice, was bought off and if you do, how can you?

Two, why is it so hard for you to believe that pissed off Muslims were behind 9/11 ?! Didn't they have a motive? Didn't Osama bin Laden and Al-Queda and the governments of Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan have a motive and a history of violence?! They're wanted terrorists for god's sake! Why can't you believe that terrorists could want to make a terrorist attack?! Don't you see a pattern in the USS Cole and the embassy bombing and all the rest?

Three, if this is so true, why are these CTs so conflicting with each other? Some people think it was the Jews, some think it was the Christians, anyone but fundamentalist Muslims.

Four, are you retarded? Is the answer yes?

Five, what are you smoking and can I have some of it?
 
I know I've said it before- but the easiest way to defeat a truther in one step is to ask the question "what fact or piece of evidence would it take for you to admit you're wrong?" Often times they're not only unprepared to deal with the logic of the issue, but they're also confronted with what they quickly realize is an appropriate way to shine a gigantic spotlight on their bias.

For the ones who do attempt to answer, they either present a requirement that is so obviously irrational that they shoot themselves in the foot- or they present criteria that actually makes sense, but is easily satisfied with the evidence. I may have even convinced some individuals with just that one question (I'll never know).

I'm still sometimes shocked by just how unfamiliar a lot of people are with reason and logic, though. Often I have this uncontrollable response which can best be described as a guffaw. For these types of people, the Challenge makes no difference- but then again, nothing in reality does.
 
Last edited:
What was the plan to destroy WTC7 if a gigantic piece of WTC1 did not fall on it, severely damaging one side and setting it on fire?
 
1. Why not just use bombs to bring down the buildings, and say it was the terrorists who planted the bombs? Why involve planes at all?

2. Even if all American news outlets and experts can be intimidated into silence ("They're afraid of losing their jobs!") what is stopping foreign journalists or scientists from blowing the lid? After all, CD is "obvious" from a glance at any video of the collapses...
 
I know I've said it before- but the easiest way to defeat a truther in one step is to ask the question "what fact or piece of evidence would it take for you to admit you're wrong?" Often times they're not only unprepared to deal with the logic of the issue, but they're also confronted with what they quickly realize is an appropriate way to shine a gigantic spotlight on their bias.

For the ones who do attempt to answer, they either present a requirement that is so obviously irrational that they shoot themselves in the foot- or they present criteria that actually makes sense, but is easily satisfied with the evidence. I may have even convinced some individuals with just that one question (I'll never know).

I'm still sometimes shocked by just how unfamiliar a lot of people are with reason and logic, though. Often I have this uncontrollable response which can best be described as a guffaw. For these types of people, the Challenge makes no difference- but then again, nothing in reality does.

Good points.

Most of us will never know we've convinced anyone of anything. I have found that 99% of twoofers will never admit that they were wrong about anything (at least, to their debunkers). Luckily, there are a few we know here who have given us great insight into the way their minds were working during their twooferdom, and it seems we are correct about their thought processes and mindset.

Highlighting these thought processes and logical fallacies is beneficial. One twoofer I was debating (almost) stopped instantly after I demonstrated the logical fallacies in her arguments. Posting links to logical fallacy definitions was very effective. She hasn't posted about 9/11 since even though she posts about other topics.
 
Originally Posted by defaultdotxbe View Post
whenever they get on about witnesses and experts being paid off ask how much it would take to pay the truthers off (if in person whip out your checkbook)

give a price, they undercut their "noble truthseeker" image, if they say they cant be paid off even they realize its unfair to assume everyone can be


I agree with orphia nay - that's one of the best ones I've heard.

I agree, that's a good point. They think they're so morally superior. They'd never take a payoff but the rest of us evil shills would gladly sell our souls for a few bucks. And if all of these people were payed off, why are they still showing up for work? Why aren't they on a beach in St. Barts?

Steve S.
 
One of my favorites: If the High Explosives were set-up in WTC 7 prior to the towers falling. How would the people that set the charges know where the fires and structural damage to WTC 7 would occur? Why wouldn't the debris damage or fires cause the explosives to either, go off prematurely, or damage the charge (wires, transmitter, thermate vessle) so as it wouldn't function at all?
 
Some really do not know how fire can damage steel. They think building fires like in Madrid did little damage. Some times when they realize tons of the unprotected steel fell in just a few hours they seem to dissolve. Plus a few of the truther buildings were out right totaled, had to be removed, this slows some truthers down. "Where are those two buildings today?" It works a little.

But this has not been a big show stopper; but I think the 16 or 20 minute Payne Stewart intercept becoming 76 minutes is one of the best, once it sinks in, as already mentioned.
 
One of my favourites is:

Why did "they" make the second tower that was hit collapse first?
 
Why drag Afghanistan into it anyway? Do they have oil?
Why perform 9/11 just to justify an expensive invasion of Iraq in order to get access to its oil when putting just half that money into developing the tar sands in Alberta would ultimately result in more petroleum than Iraq can produce?
 
For what conceivable reason would the 9/11 conspirators damage one potentially damning black box (the CVR) beyond usefulness but leave the other one (the FDR) that is definitely damning intact before planting both back at the Pentagon disaster site?
 
1. Why not just use bombs to bring down the buildings, and say it was the terrorists who planted the bombs? Why involve planes at all?

This brings up something that has often bothered me.

If it's possible for a building to collapse from the plane impact damage and resulting fires then why plant bombs at all?

If it's impossible for a building to collapse from the plane impact damage and resulting fires why fake a plane impact at all? Why not just pull another 1993 plot only bigger and better and bring the buildings down in one giant blast?

You would only fake something that's possible, faking the impossible is pointless.
 
This brings up something that has often bothered me.

If it's possible for a building to collapse from the plane impact damage and resulting fires then why plant bombs at all?

If it's impossible for a building to collapse from the plane impact damage and resulting fires why fake a plane impact at all? Why not just pull another 1993 plot only bigger and better and bring the buildings down in one giant blast?

You would only fake something that's possible, faking the impossible is pointless.
thats even assuming collapsing the towers was absolutely necessary, just crashing a plane into them would be the wrost terrorist attack ever
 
1. Why would Silverstein admit, in an interview he knew would be broadcast to the public, that he "pulled" WTC7, when he is allegedly trying to commit insurance fraud over the attacks?

2. Let's assume you are right - and none of this really happened the way we're being told. Then what did happen?

3. Why did "they" make such a complicated plan, where so many people were involved and so many things could go wrong, when they could have gone with a much simpler approach, such as the 1993 attack?

4. Approximately how many people are in on this conspiracy?

5. How much money has Dylan made out of selling this conspiracy to you?

6. How is it that so many highly intelligent and smart people, some of who are experts and professionals in analyzing these kinds of events, have been fooled by this, but you, an obviously under-educated below-average intelligence specimen with severe reading and comprehension problems and absolutely no qualifications in the relevant fields or even a basic understanding of scientific method, have managed to stumble on to the truth?

OK, maybe not that last one. :D
 
Hehehe, qarnos. :)


What was the point of "bombs in the basement prior to collapse" when the building was "demolished" from the top down?
 
"Lets Roll" Why include such an uplifting message to a populace you are trying to pin down.

Why did some of the WTC7 responders know about the building being blown up, and others didn't. How was the message broadcast, and what criteria was used to choose who knew and who didn't

Lastly, why was the Trinity Church tape faked?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom