Water-powered car

mattdick

Scholar
Joined
Apr 1, 2008
Messages
68
Gah.

I'm on a computer gaming mailing list and someone just brought up the off-topic conversation of a water-powered car. An "inventor" in the 1980s discovered he could generate oxyhydrogen from water and burn it to drive a car. Of course he, and the local news, had no idea that this is a well-known phenomenon and they went on and on (the guy provided a YouTube link to the broadcast) about how we'll all have water-powered cars soon.

So this mailing list guy went on about how the inventor was killed and his prototypes and plans "went missing".

Well I wrote back and explained water torches and oxhydrogen and why it's a really inefficient way to power a car, etc, etc, etc. He finally write back and rather politely thanked me for my long reply and that he had seen just too many unexplained things to be swayed by my all-powerful Science. He then told a cute little story about finding a bottle of water when he was really thirsty.

sigh

I guess I just needed to vent. Anyone have any suggestions on how to reply to his little anecdote totally invalidating all of science?
 
I have a question. I was googling info about turbo diesels and came across this page. Is it referencing your water car, or is this actually real?
 
I have a question. I was googling info about turbo diesels and came across this page. Is it referencing your water car, or is this actually real?
Short answer; no water will not improve your gas mileage.

Now as far as a diesel goes, under heavy loads water does help reduce the combustion temperature which will allow the engine to produce power more efficiently. This is a very fine line and for the most part it only works in heavy load applications (trains, generators. ships and so forth) where load is more or less constant. Bottom line, Metering/managing the amount of water to realize actual gains is impractical for road use.
 
Last edited:
generate oxyhydrogen from water and burn it to drive a car.
this method has a fundamental flaw

it takes as much energy to split the oxygen and hydrogen from one another as you get back from burning it, at best you can break even (and entropy will prevent that)
 
That sounds a lot like he's referring to Stanley Meyer, who claimed, back in the '90s, to have invented a method of electrolyzing water which would yield more energy from burning the resulting hydrogen than had been consumed in breaking down the water molecules.

The claims were nonsense and Meyer wound up being convicted of fraud for bilking gullible investors in his "Water Fuel Cell". He died a couple of years after that and to this day "free energy" woowoos maintain that he was murdered by The Powers That Be (instead of the more logical suspects, the people he had ripped off) and continue to take his claims as Gospel.

Here's a page written by a professor of analytical chemistry at the University of New South Wales that explains why Meyer's "resonance" notions won't improve the efficiency of electrolysis a bit:

The Chemical Free Lunch

You can also find engineer and author Don Lancaster's take on it here

I hope this is helpful. :)
 
this method has a fundamental flaw
it takes as much energy to split the oxygen and hydrogen from one another as you get back from burning it, at best you can break even (and entropy will prevent that)

This is exactly what I told him, but more condescendingly.
 
That sounds a lot like he's referring to Stanley Meyer,

Yes, and I would have provided the youtube link but I am not old enough yet.


He died a couple of years after that and to this day "free energy" woowoos maintain that he was murdered by The Powers That Be...

And yes, this was exactly what this guy was claiming.

I will provide the link to the Chemical Free Lunch, but I don't think I'm going to reach the guy with education, I tried that and got the water bottle story.

Thanks everyone. This is just another example in poor education and conspiracy thinking.
 
kinda reminds me of a guy i knew at my last job, he had this "great" idea for an electric car that didnt lack power like other electric cars

take the batteries and use them to run heater coils to boil water, and use that to power a steam turbine

as i attempted to explain entropy to him and told him this would be even less efficient than using the batteries to run the car directly i realized some people just cant be reasoned with
 
Yeah... the great thing about your coworker's idea is that it would less efficient than the electric car, and have the added benefit of having crappier acceleration!
 
Here's the happiest little thing that came of this. At the end of our discussion he said this:

However I am of the opinion that Science is spiritually dangerous, it's attempts to explain away the intelligent creational force behind life is laughable at best, but actually quite dangerous if you have a firm grasp of the true nature of reality.
 
Wow, wowee. So did I say I'd seen a happy little gem in my last post? Oh no, what followed from him next was even more spectacular. This is a little long, but the woo flows like a river. Has anyone else ever heard of William Tiller, PhD?

Following is his text to me:

One thing to add, not to get too far off tangent (too late?). Then I'll let it rest, because a lot of this is bordering on what isn't even allowed on this list. Much of this simply boils down to LOC (level of consciousness) of a person, organization, country, or even the world. The best example of someone quantifying LOC into a numeric form is the one put forth by Dr. Hawkins.



The best of science resides in the 400's. 85% of the human population resides under 200, that is below the level of integrity. Most humans are born at a specific level, the either remain the same, decline, or gain a small amount (+/- 5). Barring any great epiphany, mystical or spiritual revelation they generally won't have any quantum jumps in that lifetime. For example Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung were partners in psychology for decades until Jung had a mystical epiphany that launched him well above 500 (Freud was at 480 his entire adult life). This is where they parted ways, but they often had meetings arguing about such matters, at famous one meeting Jung got angry, and suddenly a bunch of books fell off Freuds shelf. Carl said "Now how do you explain that Sigmund?", Sigmund dismissed it, they argued more, and it happened again. At which point Freud demanded Jung leave his office and they never spoke again. Basically, in a nutshell, we're constrained only by our consciousness into what we will and will not accept or believe.

One example of this is my wife and I were in our mini-van with 4 other people sitting at red light. My wife was having a discussion about how a guy at work got a new VW car, but she didn't know what model it was. I said "Was it a VW Jetta?", she replied "Yes, I believe it was a Tan Jetta", I said "A Tan Jetta..", and right at that exact split second a Tan Jetta crossed in front of our car heading in the other direction. My wife and I are used to these matters, but the others in the car were amazed, saying "What are the chances?".

These things are difficult to explain relating to the non-linear, there are many books written on these things.(although I haven't read them) But in general, we aren't concerned with all of the synchronicities that manifested this man driving past us at that exact second, it is irrelevant in the scope of these matters. Once we understand that we're really living in a non-linear realm constrained by conscious acceptance of "Time" then we know that these things aren't the exception, they are the rule, we just have to actualize or recognize them. We know there is an underlying intelligent order that responds to our consciousness, and the intent of such.

An interesting final point is that consciousnes is self limiting for us in that we seldom gleam deep wisdom from something calibrating vastly higher than us simply because it deals with aspects that aren't in our framework of understanding or experience. But someone calibrating high reading something much less wouldn't gleam any new data either, they'd already know that, or it would be irrelevant to them. For example someone in the 500-700 range reading Dhammapada would gain insights, but someone in the 200's wouldn't understand it. Consequently someone in the 700's reading an Eckhart Tolle book would find it fairly trivial and meaningless, while someone in the 200's would find a Tolle book "Amazing". It really is a self constraining system as I said, barring any grand epiphanies. New Testament calibrating in the 790's would mean that almost all of humanity will always gleam insight from it although your level of understanding of the true meanings behind it would be drastically limited by your consciousness in relation to it. For example at consciousness of 200 you read it, and think "Yeah, ok, cool, nice stories.", lets say you have a giant consciousness upheaval that drives you to the 700's yourself (assuming it didn't drive you insane with the change). You read the NT again, suddenly it becomes "Ahh, yes, it all makes sense..", all of that stuff you once viewed as metaphorical suddenly becomes known to be literal and extremely relevant.

I am just trying to point out the framework from where Science is operating from so we can understand it's inherent limitations. That's not knocking it, some of the most brilliant scientific minds in history calibrated in the 400-490 range, which is great, but their inability to accept anything mystical, spiritual or beyond established paradigms ultimately proved self limiting for themselves, and the theories put forth. When some do breach this, they are generally ostracized for breaking established scientific paradigms. This happened to one of the most brilliant physicists if our century - William Tiller PhD. (as well as Jung, and MANY others)
 
Some people are a 400 and some are a 700? This whole thing just smacks to the ol' if you don't believe in (insert mystical being) you must not be open to it/there is something wrong with you. I also like how in most of these stories the scientific/academic community is just one big conspiracy trying to keep brilliant people from expressing their ideas, even though the scientific/academic community knows they are right.
 
The second law of thermo dynamics comes into play here.

Use electrolysis to create hydrogen, burn hydrogen, result: water, which when put through electrolysis becomes hydrogen. Problem is the electrolysis process takes energy. And this generates heat. You cannot turn heat into hydrogen, and so there's a loss of energy. Next motion, you cannot turn motion back into hydrogen, and so thats another loss of energy, friction between moving parts also generates heat.

Also water capture & onboard electrolysis would make a vehicle heavier, requiring more energy to move it.
 
Some people are a 400 and some are a 700? This whole thing just smacks to the ol' if you don't believe in (insert mystical being) you must not be open to it/there is something wrong with you.

This is very much the flavor of the ongoing conversation. He is implying that I'm just not able to get the argument because my LOC (I love the acronyms) is too low. I'm going to read the book and see what it says.

I also like how in most of these stories the scientific/academic community is just one big conspiracy trying to keep brilliant people from expressing their ideas, even though the scientific/academic community knows they are right.

It's amazing to me that these people deny human nature so completely. Humans are unable to conspire with each other at all. One episode of any reality show should teach them that as a species we are unable to stay true to commitment on any level.
 
It's amazing to me that these people deny human nature so completely. Humans are unable to conspire with each other at all. One episode of any reality show should teach them that as a species we are unable to stay true to commitment on any level.

Not quite true. People can conspire together. But only a small number of people for a very limited time.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom