Was the MST-13 timer fragment planted in the wreckage of Pan Am 103?

Rolfe

Adult human female
Joined
Sep 11, 2003
Messages
55,386
Location
NT 150 511
Imagine, just for a moment, that you are a terrorist. Your one aim in life is to cause a transatlantic flight from London to New York to fall out of the sky. You're not a suicide bomber though, so getting on the plane yourself is out. How would you set about it?

By the way, it's winter. Just before Christmas.

Suppose you have a neato electronic timer, that can be set for any time you like from 1 minute to 999 hours. And you have a bomb disguised as a radio-casette player, and a suitcase of clothes to put it in.

Do you decide to introduce the unaccompanied bomb into the system in Malta, on an Air Malta flight to Frankfurt, there to negotiate the baggage system to get itself on to a Pan Am flight to Heathrow, where it will be unloaded again and transferred to the actual transatlantic flight?

And then do you set the timer to so short a time that if anything delays the timetable for only an hour, the bomb will almost certainly go off on the ground somewhere?

Terrorists are not stupid, why would anyone decide on a plan like this?

First, the bag is going to have to get through not one airport security system but three, each one with its own x-ray surveillance, and each one liable to pull an apparently suspicious or even unaccompanied bag out for closer examination. And second, the bag is going to have to manage not to get lost - probably not so hard on a single leg, but with two changes of plane, what are the chances? And third, not just one but three flights are going to have to be up to time and running on schedule - in late December, in northern Europe.

And the one thing you might do to hedge against delays, which is to set the timer so that the explosion happens perhaps half an hour before the flight is scheduled to reach Newfoundland, so that even if it's two or three hours late it'll already be over the ocean - you choose not to do. You set the timer for only one hour into the on-time flight.

And yet that's what we're led to believe was the cunning plan that brought down Pam Am 103 over Lockerbie in 1988.

In fact nothing much went wrong with the plan, if that's what it was. The flight was delayed, but only by 25 minutes. The crash happened over southern Scotland, rather than the Outer Hebrides or maybe Ireland. But does it make any sense to devise a plan with so many opportunities for it to fall flat on its face?

Note that this argument is the same irrespective of the identity of the terrorists. Palestinians, Libyans, Al Qaida, IRA, doesn't matter. Why would you choose to send your carefully-placed bomb on such a chancy journey?

Of course, there have been allegations that the bomb could have got on board in Frankfurt, or at Heathrow. This makes better sense, especially the latter. Only one flight to worry about catching. Only one set of security surveillance systems to negotiate. Much less chance of the luggage doing what luggage does only too often - go astray.

So maybe that's what happened. Maybe it really was smuggled on at Heathrow. So, does the problem go away?

Not really.

You still have that cool elecronic timer. You can set it for any time you like up to nearly six weeks in advance. It's still December in northern Europe. And by the way, it's the rush hour. Planes are not exactly guaranteed to take off on time, even if the luggage has been loaded on schedule.

So you set it to go off only an hour after the scheduled take-off time. In a flight that should last nearly eight hours.

Really?

That's why the presence of the MST-13 timer in association with the Lockerbie bombing makes no sense at all. It doesn't matter whether you're talking about some daft scheme to get the thing through the continental airport baggage system on three different flights, or a direct up-load at Heathrow. It makes no sense to set such a versatile timer to such a short fuse, under these circumstances, no matter who you are or where the bomb began its journey.

Consider in contrast the original assumption for why the crash happened so early.

In October of 1988 a Palestinian terrorist cell was busted in Frankfurt. Four improvised explosive devices were seized, all constructed from Toshiba radio-casette players, and apparently intended for attacks on airliners. For reasons that might be interesting later on if this turns into a LIHOP, the ringleaders (including the bomb maker) were released after only a few days. It was known or suspected that a fifth bomb existed that had not been seized.

The seized devices didn't have your spiffy electronic timers. They had things called "ice-cube" timers, much less sophisticated in that they had a pre-set time in them that the operator couldn't vary. They were however sophisticated in a different way. They incorporated aneroid barometers, so that they would be safe indefinitely at sea level but would start to tick if the atmospheric pressure fell below 950mB. These things were deadly if smuggled on to airliners, and it didn't matter when the plane actually took off, the explosion would happen at the pre-determined time into the flight. The devices seized at Frankfurt were set to explode between 35 and 45 minutes after takeoff.

Maid of the Seas
blew up 38 minutes after taking off from Heathrow.

The suitcase and the clothes and the radio-casette bomb and its triggering device were scattered all over Dumfriesshire and points east. It was something of a miracle that fragments of anything so close to the explosion were recovered, but they were. Enough to identify the make and style of the suitcase, and the model of radio-casette player, and trace the origin of the clothes. It was even determined where exactly in the hold the suitcase had been when it exploded.

Then, at some time in 1989, or possibly 1990, a small fragment of a MST-13 timer was allegedly identified in the debris collected.

The confusions surrounding that tiny fragment of debris are legion. The label of the original collection bag was altered, by an unknown party. The notes relating to its examination in England appear to have been falsified, appearing on an extra page interpolated into a loose-leaf folder, with subsequent pages re-numbered to compensate. Oh yes, and the "scientist" doing the examination was the same guy as was responsible for the false conviction of the Maguire Seven.

Then things get even murkier. Was the circuit board green or was it brown? Was it hand-made or machine-made? Was there solder on the terminals showing it had been connected to a bomb, or not? Was the fragment shown to the manufacturer at the trial the same item as the fragment allegedly found embedded in a shirt collar at the crash site? Was the manufacturer playing silly buggers in the witness box (and if so, why?), or was he genuinely confused by mysterious changes that had taken place in the fragment? Is it even possible for an object of that nature to have survived at all, so close to that amount of Semtex going up?

Why did the shopkeeper swear two affidavits saying that he hadn't sold a shirt to the purchaser of the other clothes, and then suddenly change his mind and declare that he had sold him a shirt of the right make in a later statement?

This seems to be the nub of the CT surrounding Lockerbie, once you've got past the point of realising that Megrahi was quite obviously framed by the prosecution, who were being fed information from the US investigators into the case. Re-examining the evidence brings you smack against the MST-13 timer every time. Nobody who had such a timer would have taken the risk of setting it to explode only an hour into an eight-hour flight.

And yet a fragment of such a timer was allegedly found in the wreckage. This then became the "breakthrough find", that diverted the investigation away from the Palestinian/Syrian/Iranian line of enquiry, and switched to implicate Libya.

Is the suggestion that the timer fragment was planted in order to obfuscate the investigation and eventually lead on to the indictment of Libya for the crime entirely fanciful?

Why not leave the thermite and the holographic planes for a bit and look at this one?

Paul Foot's 2001 Private Eye investigation is a good place to start - Flight from Justice. It's behind a £5 paywall, but worth the money.

There are a number of documentary films covering the issues, all taking rather different lines. And none of them are made by Dylan Avery.
The Maltese Double Cross (2hrs 30min, and actually quite hard to follow despite having won a film festival prize)
Lockerbie and the CIA (Aspect ratio problem, but interesting and watchable)
The Conspirady Files: Lockerbie (This BBC production seems a bit too trusting of the Official Version in one or two places.)
Flight into Darkness Part 1
Flight into Darkness Part 2
The Lockerbie Cover-up (shortened version of "Flight into Darkness", but with extra material at the end)

And for a lot more information and links, the best source is probably the web site of the official UN observer at the trial of the "Lockerbie Bomber" in 2000-2001.
Dr. Hans Kochler

The senior academic lawyer who was responsible for getting the trial at Camp Zeist organised has a blog on the subject with a collection of relevant articles.
Professor Robert Black

Megrahi was framed. That seems indisputable. However, was this simply over-enthusiastic investigators cavalierly pinning the crime on someone who happened to be handy due to pressure to "get a conviction"? Or is it more sinister than that?

Rolfe.
 
Methinks someone has become obssesed with a case.

It happens, and sometimes it results in a guilty verdict being justifiably overturned. Many times, in fact.
Sheer pressure of logic can work.
 
Can you connect the dots, please, because I'm not seeing it.


Oh dear, sorry. I thought I was being clear.

It makes no sense at all to set a timer with a range of about 6 weeks to go off only 1 hour into an 8-hour flight. Even if you don't want the plane to drop into the Atlantic and so render the evidence unrecoverable, the risk that the plane might be delayed by an hour or so, leading to the device detonating relatively harmlessly on the ground, is simply not worth taking. Not when you have the means to set the timer for, say, six hours into the flight.

And yet, a tiny fragment of just such a timer was allegedly found on the ground after the crash of Pan Am 103.

The provenance of the fragment is extremely peculiar, involving alteration of evidence records, a witness changing his sworn testimony, and forensic "scientists" with very dubious pedigrees. It has been suggested, alleged and downright asserted that the fragment was planted, probably by the CIA. Is this a tenable position?

Rolfe.
 
Methinks someone has become obssesed with a case.


And this is a problem because?

If this forum can rake over thermate and thermite and holographic planes and flyovers and whether mobile phones can connect from airliners in flight and all the rest of the 9/11 stuff, I can't think of a better place to figure out what might or might not be plausible as regards an earlier, similar atrocity.

If you're not interested, don't read the thread.

Rolfe.
 
Great, this is the "movie version." At the moment I'm too busy to dig in, but I'm seeing a mammoth OP and a need for point-by-point progress. I hope other members will read it if not comment. I'm not sure what to ask about first... I'll be back.

Oh, and I lean towards "something more sinister," but I'm open to where this goes.
 
Oh dear, sorry. I thought I was being clear.

Actually, I thought Triskett was being ironic -- you couldn't possibly have connected the dots any more clearly.

It makes no sense at all to set a timer with a range of about 6 weeks to go off only 1 hour into an 8-hour flight. Even if you don't want the plane to drop into the Atlantic and so render the evidence unrecoverable, the risk that the plane might be delayed by an hour or so, leading to the device detonating relatively harmlessly on the ground, is simply not worth taking. Not when you have the means to set the timer for, say, six hours into the flight.

I have to say, this is an exceedingly interesting and valid point. Pure timing doesn't seem to make sense given the vagaries of air travel. Something triggered by air pressure is far more reliable.


And yet, a tiny fragment of just such a timer was allegedly found on the ground after the crash of Pan Am 103.

The provenance of the fragment is extremely peculiar, involving alteration of evidence records, a witness changing his sworn testimony, and forensic "scientists" with very dubious pedigrees. It has been suggested, alleged and downright asserted that the fragment was planted, probably by the CIA. Is this a tenable position?

Tenable, yes. Compelling, perhaps. But why attribute this to the CIA, couldn't it have been just about anyone? And although planting evidence is an absolute wrong, and it calls into question the legality of the trial, how much does it call into question al-Megrahi's actual guilt? Was this tiny fragment the only thing connecting him to the bombing? (I'm afraid I'm not well versed on the exact particulars of the case, so I really don't know.)
 
Rolfe, I don't know about most of the questions you pose, but one thing that I do know: whether a PC board was machine-soldered or hand-soldered would be instantly apparent to any knowledgeable techie. In fact, if you show me a PC board which has not yet been stuffed and soldered, I could tell you at a glance if it was intended to be machine-soldered or not.
 
Tenable, yes. Compelling, perhaps. But why attribute this to the CIA, couldn't it have been just about anyone?

A good question to start with. The CIA is supposed to have pressured witnesses too. I'm curious what we know pointing to specific parties like CIA. Aside from the evidence that it was planted by someone and thus not good evidence.

And although planting evidence is an absolute wrong, and it calls into question the legality of the trial, how much does it call into question al-Megrahi's actual guilt? Was this tiny fragment the only thing connecting him to the bombing? (I'm afraid I'm not well versed on the exact particulars of the case, so I really don't know.)

But this is a better point yet vis-a-vis this discussion. Where does the circuit board fit in with the other evidence? From what I gather, it's one of three main pieces, the others being Giaka's testimony that was tossed out as bogus (thus the accomplice let off), and the shopkeeper's testimony (which never matched al Megrahi anyway). There are probably other bits of evidence of lesser importance, but none of greater. Rolfe will be baack by now I'm sure anyway...
 
Rolfe, I don't know about most of the questions you pose, but one thing that I do know: whether a PC board was machine-soldered or hand-soldered would be instantly apparent to any knowledgeable techie. In fact, if you show me a PC board which has not yet been stuffed and soldered, I could tell you at a glance if it was intended to be machine-soldered or not.


I have to confess, I don't entirely follow that part of the evidence. I note the court threw out Bollier's evidence as unreliable, and Bollier does indeed seem to be a slippery customer. However, I'm not clear what reason he had to lie at the trial, unless of course it was just the prospect of that damn $4 million reward offered to anyone who provided evidence to convict Megrahi and/or Fhimah. And I have recently read an article which implies that Bollier was simply completely thrown by the fact that the fragment was different every time he was shown it.

That one's quite a long way down the rabbit hole though, and I have some difficulty swallowing it.

But look at the piece Robert Black blogged about today.

For example, consider the case of the Lockerbie bomber. One piece of "evidence" that was used to convict Megrahi was a piece of circuit board from a device that allegedly contained the Semtex that exploded the airliner. None of the people, who have very firm beliefs in Megrahi’s and Libya’s guilt and in the offense of the Scottish authorities in releasing Megrahi on allegedly humanitarian grounds, know that circuit boards of those days have very low combustion temperatures and go up in flames easily. Semtex produces very high temperatures. There would be nothing whatsoever left of a device that contained Semtex. It is obvious to an expert that the piece of circuit board was planted after the event.


Here's the full original article, dated yesterday. Is this a valid point?

Rolfe.
 
Methinks someone has become obssesed with a case.

And I just had to say something on this. It seems someone is displaying a pointed interest to not learn more. I'm willing to bet you don't even know enough about this case to know what's actually wrong about it. I do thank you for piping up to make this attitude visible and present in this thread. Beyond that, you could help by digging in and bringing any debunks you can find. Let's check this stuff out. Passive willful ignorance is not compatible with skepticism. :thumbsup:
 
that damn $4 million reward offered to anyone who provided evidence to convict Megrahi and/or Fhimah.

Yeah, imagine if Randi quadrupled the prize and all the applicants had to do was not contradict themselves too bad. And it's testing ad libbing abilities, not psychic. Giaka didn't make the cut, tho I think he got paid anyway, as much hush money as anything, but it looks like two other finalists scored.

Honestly, I'm talking out my ass and don't know the details of this part. So maybe the science of the board should be the main focus - all evidence and descriptions available. We don't have any photos or sketches, do we? I'm not much good there either but others here might be...
 
I note Ktesibios said something quite pertinent about this early in the previous thread (just showing you were way ahead of me).

One thing that has always struck me as odd about this case is the idea of a national secret service designing a bomb around a timer that's a special order which, if identified, will lead directly and inescapably back to them.

That's a dumb move just on G.P.; when you consider that designing a timer that's more than accurate enough for the application, from parts available off the shelf from ordinary electronics distributors, would be trivial for anyone with an associate-degree level of training, it becomes indescribably stupid.


The MST-13 timer was, as you say, some sort of special order. Traceable.

Not a huge problem if you plan on the evidence all ending up in the middle of the Atlantic. And you have a three or four hour window which will allow you to achieve exactly that. All you have to do is set the timer to detonate at the time the flight ought to be about half an hour east of Newfoundland.

So you set it to detonate only one hour after takeoff, when the plane would barely have cleared Scotland (or Ireland), in the rather unlikely event of its actually taking off on time.

:confused:

Rolfe.
 
There are pictures. Put MST-13 Lockerbie into Google images.

Though I have to say, it's the timing of the various events between January 1989 and June 1990 (outbreak of the First Gulf War) that is intriguing me, as related by Paul Foot.

I seriously advise giving the Eye its fiver.

Rolfe.
 
I know little of this case, but it does sound odd to rely on a timer alone.
Combining a timer with a pressure sensor would be much more reliable.
 
My first thought is that I would have definitely chosen to check the bomb through at Malta over either Frankfurt or Heathrow for a couple of reasons: at the time airport security at the Malta was far more porous than at the other airports and it would be far easier to make myself scarce after checking the bag (My logic here is based upon my personal experience - I flew in and out of all of those places many times in the early 1980s.) At the same time I could put a lot of time and geography between me and the scene of the crime in the interval between my placement of the bomb and its expected detonation.

The decision to plant the bomb in Malta with my ultimate target sortieing from Heathrow many hours later drives my choice of detonating devices - it must be able of detonating reliably many hours hence.

Not knowing how the MST-13 was set I do not know how easily it could be miss-set. It is possible that the timer was miss-set in Malta and was intended to detonate much later.

FWIW the Malta and detonator selections do not, at first blush, bother me.
 
Last edited:
The thing is, the evidence given is absolutely in contradiction to that. Luqa airport was the most secure of the three involved, with the least possibility of a suspect case having gone on. In contrast, there was very concrete evidence of a breach in security at Heathrow, and the possibility of a stray bag from Damascus or Warsaw getting on at Frankfurt.

ETA: Here's an excerpt from the actual judgement at Camp Zeist dealing with this issue. Starts at paragraph 38.

Luqa airport had a relatively elaborate security system. All items of baggage checked in were entered into the airport computer as well as being noted on the passenger's ticket. After the baggage had passed the sniffer check, it was placed on a trolley in the baggage area to wait until the flight was ready for loading

When the flight was ready, the baggage was taken out and loaded, and the head loader was required to count the items placed on board. The ramp dispatcher, the airport official on the tarmac responsible for the departure of the flight, was in touch by radiotelephone with the load control office. The load control had access to the computer and after the flight was closed would notify the ramp dispatcher of the number of items checked in. The ramp dispatcher would also be told by the head loader how many items had been loaded and if there was a discrepancy would take steps to resolve it.

In addition to the baggage reconciliation procedure, there was a triple count of the number of passengers boarding a departing flight, that is there was a count of the boarding cards, a count by immigration officers of the number of immigration cards handed in, and a head count by the crew.

The records relating to KM180 on 21 December 1988 show no discrepancy in respect of baggage. The flight log (production 930) shows that fifty-five items of baggage were loaded, corresponding to fifty-five on the load plan.

On the face of them, these arrangements seem to make it extremely difficult for an unaccompanied and unidentified bag to be shipped on a flight out of Luqa.

If therefore the unaccompanied bag was launched from Luqa, the method by which that was done is not established, and the Crown accepted that they could not point to any specific route by which the primary suitcase could have been loaded.

The absence of any explanation of the method by which the primary suitcase might have been placed on board KM180 is a major difficulty for the Crown case.


After a British TV company broadcast a documentary showing someone putting a bag on board at Luqa then sloping off, Air Malta sued for libel and won, convincing that court that such a course of events was impossible.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Your one aim in life is to cause a transatlantic flight from London to New York to fall out of the sky.

Rolfe, why is this assumed to be my one aim in life? Why wouldn't I settle for an 80% chance of crashing the plane, a 10% chance of detonating the bomb in the plane while it was delayed at the gate or on the taxiway, a 7% chance of detonating the bomb in the baggage-handling machinery, and a 3% chance of having the bomb be discovered by security personnel and safely disposed of?

I mean, I'm a terrorist, right? I'm not obsessed with knocking airplanes out of the sky, like an arsonist who can't live without fire. I'm obsessed with causing terror, with disrupting the complacency of the drones and sheeple of a society I despise. Any attack that stands a good chance of doing that is suitable.

Taking down a plane in flight is ideal, but there are several less-spectacular outcomes that would still be satisfactory trade-offs between maximal damage and maximal avoidance of capture.

Your entire argument hinges on the assumption that the means and the end are blatantly unsuited to each other. I don't see where you justify that assumption in any meaningful way.
 
You say yourself, blasting a plane out of the sky would be ideal. And as for your motives, you're either acting under orders from Gadaffi to exact revenge on the US for the bombings of Tripoli and Benghazi in which his infant adopted daughter was killed, or you're being paid $10 million by Iran specifically to knock out a US airliner in flight as revenge for the shooting down of the Iran Air airbus by the Vincennes. Absolutely nothing to do with drones or sheeple or despising a society.

Why would you "settle for" a chance of not knocking out a US airliner, but instead maybe causing a non-fatal explosion in a baggage hall in London? When all you have to do is set the timer to go off at midnight GMT instead of 7pm?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom