Warmer alarmist lies repository

link?

and 1 lie proofs what exactly?

is this exposing a huge conspiracy? the big Climate Change Hoax?

No, it just shows there are two sides to some fences.:)
My friends who are 'warmers' say that deniers lie. This thread is about showing there comes lies, exaggerations and propaganda from warmers too.

Flannery's probably mixing up meters with feet.

Yeah right.:D
 
No, it just shows there are two sides to some fences.:)
My friends who are 'warmers' say that deniers lie. This thread is about showing there comes lies, exaggerations and propaganda from warmers too.



Yeah right.:D

nothinig new, especially since politicans are also involved.

i dont see how this will expose the huge mega conspiracy aka AGW hoax
 
I didn't realise that's what I was doing (proving an AGW hoax).

Honestly, all I want to do is show that there is lies, disinformation and propaganda from both sides - there is a thread for one side already, so here's its counterpart.
Many of the warmers here at JREF (and elsewhere) seem to think there "is no debate", "the science is settled" and all warmers wear virgin white.
 
Well so far all you've got is one "it could be a lie". I encourage you to try harder, I'd be happy to denounce any legit lies.
 
I didn't realise that's what I was doing (proving an AGW hoax).

Honestly, all I want to do is show that there is lies, disinformation and propaganda from both sides - there is a thread for one side already, so here's its counterpart.
Many of the warmers here at JREF (and elsewhere) seem to think there "is no debate", "the science is settled" and all warmers wear virgin white.

No worry, you arent :)
I first have to see a real scientist doubting global warming, not to speak about bringing up evidence. Ist like claiming the science about 9/11 isnt settled yet. There atleast you can find some real scientists/expets doubting WTC7. But pointing out disinfo and or misstakes is good. aslong you can proof your case.
 
Now or Never, Professor Tim (Flannery) quotes James Hansen “who is the world’s leading thinker in this area” saying that “we are on the brink of triggering a 25 metre sea-level rise”. Tim goes onto say “So anyone with a coastal view from their bedroom or kitchen window is likely to lose their house as a result of that change”. The Australian of 5th March 2010 quotes a Tim Flannery estimate of a 60 metre sea-level rise.

http://www.quadrant.org.au/blogs/doomed-planet/2010/03/flannery-nags-launceston

Many can't even remember their own lies so make up new ones.



More on that topic

Rise of sea levels is 'the greatest lie ever told'

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/...sea-levels-is-the-greatest-lie-ever-told.html



Ya know, it's funny. Even an environmentalist should be ashamed by some of the fraudulent, dishonest claims being made.

There once was a CNN article (which I saved off lest I think my memory was crazy) that warned in its title, "Global warming sea rise will be like tsunami!", this being just after the horrible tsunami in the Indian ocean a few years ago.

Down near the bottom in the fine print was "the seas will rise about 25-30 feet over the course of the next 100 years", which was the same amount the tsunami raised water levels in a few seconds.


Scumbucketry in the extreme.
 
Oh no! Not another catagory 3? Surely you can't be serious. The "Katrina fear factor" grates on my nerves like nails on a blackboard. Either, he is making stuff up as he goes along and never actually researched a thing about it or he is counting on the ignorance of his audience. For the last time, the devastating factor about Katrina was where it hit, not how strong it was when it hit. Heck, if it hit east coast Fl, we would have yawned and stocked up on beer before the alcohol ban went into affect.

And the fact that the wetlands between New Orleans and the Gulf have been systematically destroyed.

If global warming is true will there be more populated areas in the world vulnerable to flooding?
 
well, I mean, any subject you have in the world, no matter how true, is going to have people who lie about it, or who make errors. That's just plain simple human nature.

What's important is not if a lie has been made, because if you look, again, on ANY subject, you will find people lying or being wrong about it.

The question should be: how important is the lie to the central argument? If that lie is in fact a lie, is it big enough to be damaging to the overall integrity of the central idea? How often is the lie repeated by how many people?

One person lying about one thing doesn't go a long way to being harmful to a central thesis.

However, let's look at one of the most common warmer argument: that there is not actually a consensus in the scientific community over global warming (as is claimed by those who believe in AGW), and we know this because there is a petition which carries the names of over 30,000 scientists which disputes global warming. This IS central to the denier meme that there really is a huge debate within the climatology community over the validity of global warming.

http://www.petitionproject.org/

In fact, here are the qualifications one needs to be able to sign this petition: A BS degree. That's it.

1. A BS in science does not make you a scientist. You get a BS for a psychology degree, for pity's sakes. A BS in psychology does not make one a scientist.

2. Being a scientist does not mean you know one single thing about climate and are in a position of authority to weigh in on the matter. If I am a research biologist at a hospital, I have absolutely zero scientific credentials when it comes to climate because these are completely unrelated fields. Would you want a climatologist to diagnose your cancer pathology slides? No? Then what business does a pathologist have in lending their scientific credentials to the anti warming movement?

3. The organization does not even do background check on those who signs the position to even see if they actually hold BS degrees.
 
Last edited:
http://american.com/archive/2010/march/when-to-doubt-a-scientific-consensus

Maybe some of them aren't lying - I actually think a lot of that is true in that many many scientists are honest hardworking individuals however....

I located this article and it largely sums up a lot of my feelings around this.

In short, it gives a number of reasons why the 'consensus' might not be so.

.... Your best bet is to look at the process that produced, maintains, and communicates the ostensible consensus. I don’t know of any exhaustive list of signs of suspicion, but, using climate change as a test study, I propose this checklist as a rough-and-ready list of signs for when to consider doubting a scientific “consensus,” whatever the subject. One of these signs may be enough to give pause. If they start to pile up, then it’s wise to be suspicious.
(1) When different claims get bundled together
(2) When ad hominem attacks against dissenters predominate
(3) When scientists are pressured to toe the party line.
(4) When publishing and peer review in the discipline is cliquish.
(5) When dissenting opinions are excluded from the relevant peer-reviewed literature not because of weak evidence or bad arguments but as part of a strategy to marginalize dissent.
(6) When the actual peer-reviewed literature is misrepresented.
(7) When consensus is declared hurriedly or before it even exists.
(8) When the subject matter seems, by its nature, to resist consensus.
(9) When “scientists say” or “science says” is a common locution.
(10) When it is being used to justify dramatic political or economic policies.
(11) When the “consensus” is maintained by an army of water-carrying journalists who defend it with uncritical and partisan zeal, and seem intent on helping certain scientists with their messaging rather than reporting on the field as objectively as possible.
(12) When we keep being told that there’s a scientific consensus.

The writer expands on each of the numbered items.
Interesting reading.

And as is said...If they start to pile up, then it’s wise to be suspicious.
 
Last edited:
You might be best advised to see what starts to pile up around the author of that article you link to.

Check out his Discovery Institute stuff on Intelligent Design.

Yes, it is starting to pile up....... all around Jay Richards.
 
You might be best advised to see what starts to pile up around the author of that article you link to.

Check out his Discovery Institute stuff on Intelligent Design.

And Einstein married his cousin. Should I dismiss everything he said because I don't agree with that? Hmmm?
 
And Einstein married his cousin. Should I dismiss everything he said because I don't agree with that? Hmmm?

Do you not see an exact parallel between the methodology that Richards uses to try and discredit Evolutionary science and the methodology he uses to try to discredit Climate science?

It's a failed methodology. Einstein marrying his cousin has no impact on the methodologies that Einstein used in his scientific work.

Capiche?
 
Global Warming
Climate Change
AGW

Three completely separate definitions :

- Global warming covers just global warming.

- Climate change covers regional/global warming, regional/global cooling, and everything in between.

- AGW covers the manmade aspects/causation of global warming.


Scientists are not "disputing global warming" as one poster above said. They are disputing certain aspects of the AGW theory/hypothesis (like causation behind certain aspects of it, for example).

That doesn't make them deniers of anything. That makes them scientists questioning certain aspects/methodology of a theory/hypothesis. A perfectly normal process of the scientific principle.

Big difference.

I wish people would use the proper terminology when discussing this subject, for clarity's sake. Otherwise it becomes misrepresentations and circular semantics.

:mgbanghead
 
Scientists are not "disputing global warming" as one poster above said. They are disputing certain aspects of the AGW theory/hypothesis (like causation behind certain aspects of it, for example).

which scientists are these? Better yet provide some links to recent papers in high impact journals like Science, PNAS or Nature.
 
which scientists are these? Better yet provide some links to recent papers in high impact journals like Science, PNAS or Nature.

From that I assume you are advocating the "bundling" referred to in #1. It says:

(1) When different claims get bundled together.

Usually, in scientific disputes, there is more than one claim at issue. With global warming, there’s the claim that our planet, on average, is getting warmer. There’s also the claim that human emissions are the main cause of it, that it’s going to be catastrophic, and that we have to transform civilization to deal with it. These are all different assertions with different bases of evidence. Evidence for warming, for instance, isn’t evidence for the cause of that warming. All the polar bears could drown, the glaciers melt, the sea levels rise 20 feet, Newfoundland become a popular place to tan, and that wouldn’t tell us a thing about what caused the warming. This is a matter of logic, not scientific evidence. The effect is not the same as the cause.

There’s a lot more agreement about (1) a modest warming trend since about 1850 than there is about (2) the cause of that trend. There’s even less agreement about (3) the dangers of that trend, or of (4) what to do about it. But these four propositions are frequently bundled together, so that if you doubt one, you’re labeled a climate change “skeptic” or “denier.” That’s just plain intellectually dishonest. When well-established claims are fused with separate, more controversial claims, and the entire conglomeration is covered with the label “consensus,” you have reason for doubt.

To me that makes a lot of sense and from what I do understand seems to be echoed by the serious scientists in the field.
The warmbeciles like to make a "denier" out of anyone with any level of skepticism on the points 1, 2, 3, 4 provided in the second paragraph, and as said, that and the bundling is dishonest.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom