Here is another medium that Zammit claims was genuine and had proven the afterlife in scientific conditions:
The Brazilian medium Carmine Mirabelli
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carmine_Mirabelli
As shown on my other thread, Mirabelli was a known fraud, his levitation photograph was discovered to be a fake. Let's have a look at one of his "materializations".
http://psychictruth.info/Mirabelli_Spirit_Produced_Centre.jpg
The spiritualist Carlos de Castro is on the right, a spirit materialization of a dead poet is supposed to be in the middle and Mirabelli is on the left.
What does this photograph look like to you?
Yes, it is a living human! Just some paid accomplice to sneak into the séance half way through and pose on the chair!
Note that Mirabelli's hands and feet are both free, they are certainly not tied down like Zammit claimed most materialization mediums are. As stated above there is no evidence materialization mediums have been tied down to a chair.
So what do we have? A pitch black room and some guy pretending to be a "spirit" in the middle of the photograph, certainly no scientific controls in place. But according to Zammit it's scientific evidence for the afterlife! Oh and Zammit claims in his book that Mirabelli performed his "materializations" in broad daylight... does that dark room look like daylight?
Here is just some of the nonsense that Zammit writes regarding Mirabelli:
http://www.victorzammit.com/book/4thedition/chapter10.html
So according to the spiritualists Mirabelli floated into the air and on another occasion teleported 90 kilometres away?? It seems the sources for this are nothing more than hearsay. I would love to see scientific evidence for such a thing. When will Zammit learn that unconfirmed hearsay and magical word of mouth stories are not scientific evidence for the afterlife?
The Brazilian medium Carmine Mirabelli
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carmine_Mirabelli
As shown on my other thread, Mirabelli was a known fraud, his levitation photograph was discovered to be a fake. Let's have a look at one of his "materializations".
http://psychictruth.info/Mirabelli_Spirit_Produced_Centre.jpg
The spiritualist Carlos de Castro is on the right, a spirit materialization of a dead poet is supposed to be in the middle and Mirabelli is on the left.
What does this photograph look like to you?
Yes, it is a living human! Just some paid accomplice to sneak into the séance half way through and pose on the chair!
Note that Mirabelli's hands and feet are both free, they are certainly not tied down like Zammit claimed most materialization mediums are. As stated above there is no evidence materialization mediums have been tied down to a chair.
So what do we have? A pitch black room and some guy pretending to be a "spirit" in the middle of the photograph, certainly no scientific controls in place. But according to Zammit it's scientific evidence for the afterlife! Oh and Zammit claims in his book that Mirabelli performed his "materializations" in broad daylight... does that dark room look like daylight?
Here is just some of the nonsense that Zammit writes regarding Mirabelli:
At a well-attended seance in Sao Vicente the chair on which the entranced Mirabelli was sitting rose and floated in the air two meters above the floor. Witnesses timed its levitation for 120 seconds. On another occasion Mirabelli was at the da Luz railroad station with several companions when he suddenly vanished. About fifteen minutes later a telephone call came from Sao Vicente, a town ninety kilometers away, stating that he had appeared there exactly two minutes after he had disappeared from da Luz.
http://www.victorzammit.com/book/4thedition/chapter10.html
So according to the spiritualists Mirabelli floated into the air and on another occasion teleported 90 kilometres away?? It seems the sources for this are nothing more than hearsay. I would love to see scientific evidence for such a thing. When will Zammit learn that unconfirmed hearsay and magical word of mouth stories are not scientific evidence for the afterlife?
Edited by jhunter1163:
Edited for Rule 5. Do not hotlink images.
Last edited by a moderator: