Victor Zammit's new book claiming science has proven the afterlife

Here is another medium that Zammit claims was genuine and had proven the afterlife in scientific conditions:

The Brazilian medium Carmine Mirabelli

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carmine_Mirabelli

As shown on my other thread, Mirabelli was a known fraud, his levitation photograph was discovered to be a fake. Let's have a look at one of his "materializations".

http://psychictruth.info/Mirabelli_Spirit_Produced_Centre.jpg

The spiritualist Carlos de Castro is on the right, a spirit materialization of a dead poet is supposed to be in the middle and Mirabelli is on the left.

What does this photograph look like to you? :rolleyes:

Yes, it is a living human! Just some paid accomplice to sneak into the séance half way through and pose on the chair!

Note that Mirabelli's hands and feet are both free, they are certainly not tied down like Zammit claimed most materialization mediums are. As stated above there is no evidence materialization mediums have been tied down to a chair.

So what do we have? A pitch black room and some guy pretending to be a "spirit" in the middle of the photograph, certainly no scientific controls in place. But according to Zammit it's scientific evidence for the afterlife! Oh and Zammit claims in his book that Mirabelli performed his "materializations" in broad daylight... does that dark room look like daylight?

Here is just some of the nonsense that Zammit writes regarding Mirabelli:

At a well-attended seance in Sao Vicente the chair on which the entranced Mirabelli was sitting rose and floated in the air two meters above the floor. Witnesses timed its levitation for 120 seconds. On another occasion Mirabelli was at the da Luz railroad station with several companions when he suddenly vanished. About fifteen minutes later a telephone call came from Sao Vicente, a town ninety kilometers away, stating that he had appeared there exactly two minutes after he had disappeared from da Luz.

http://www.victorzammit.com/book/4thedition/chapter10.html

So according to the spiritualists Mirabelli floated into the air and on another occasion teleported 90 kilometres away?? It seems the sources for this are nothing more than hearsay. I would love to see scientific evidence for such a thing. When will Zammit learn that unconfirmed hearsay and magical word of mouth stories are not scientific evidence for the afterlife? ;)

Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for Rule 5. Do not hotlink images.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is a scream! I should point out that the idea that Mediums have been held down / tied down and unable to move their legs and arms during their miracles is not just a conceit of Zammit. Several noted Parapsychologists have made that claim, notably the late John Beloff. It does appear to be the case that the examples given of this supposed, "strict" testing circumstances invariably turn out to have been in actual fact far less strict in reality. Also researchers like Beloff are annoying in that they frequently resorted to reversing the onus as a rhetorical tool to get around the bad evidence for their claims.

Beloff also didn't seem to understand the rather obvious reason's why there was a decline in the number of mediums who claimed and produced physical paranormal miracles, like ectoplasm. I personally think it had something to do with electric lights and the flashlight.
 
Victor Zammit pushes delusional psychic detectives?

Victor Zammit has a long history in pushing various psychic detectives and psychic mediums inside North America as well. His stunning support behind such psychic detective actresses as Noreen Renier and Laurie McQuary appears to be a means to market delusional mind melds.

See http://www.gpinquirygroup.com/gpinquirygroup/Victor%20Zammit%20page.html for his more recent antics in completely missing his favorite target --- skeptics.
 
This is a scream! I should point out that the idea that Mediums have been held down / tied down and unable to move their legs and arms during their miracles is not just a conceit of Zammit. Several noted Parapsychologists have made that claim, notably the late John Beloff. It does appear to be the case that the examples given of this supposed, "strict" testing circumstances invariably turn out to have been in actual fact far less strict in reality. Also researchers like Beloff are annoying in that they frequently resorted to reversing the onus as a rhetorical tool to get around the bad evidence for their claims.

Beloff also didn't seem to understand the rather obvious reason's why there was a decline in the number of mediums who claimed and produced physical paranormal miracles, like ectoplasm. I personally think it had something to do with electric lights and the flashlight.

Pacal it is interesting to see you mention Beloff. I am in agreement with you.

Beloff was one of the very last parapsychologists to defend physical mediumship. Many parapsychologists have been convinced most mediumship is fraud and have rejected the spirit hypothesis and nearly all parapsychologists have rejected physical mediumship. See for example the books by Eric Dingwall, Harry Price etc.

Little psychical researchers/parapsychologists have ever supported physical mediums as they caught them in fraud, notice for example how Zammit has little references to the Society for Psychical Research (SPR) in his books.

I am not sure how the myth came about that physical mediums have been tied down and produced ectoplasm in scientific conditions, this was never ever the case, even the photographs and reports contradict it.

In his book Zammit has spiritualist stories where the lights in the séance room were turned on and supposedly the skin of the medium was burned, and he even claims mediums came close to death. This is complete nonsense, it is just an excuse for physical mediums why ectoplasm cannot be produced in light conditions. In the dark they can easily place cheesecloth, muslin etc around the room.

Zammit also sets up a straw man by claiming the skeptics say most physical mediums hide the ectoplasm down their throat and regurgitate it through their séances. The skeptics have never said this apart from in the case of Helen Duncan, Duncan was an obese lady with a very large stomach and had no problem regurgitating very large rolls of cheese-cloth.

Of course nobody is claiming that the mediums regurgitated full size rubber dolls, they were easily hidden in the séance room beforehand. Most mediums including Duncan herself worked with secret and hidden accomplices (her husband for example). Like all spiritualist fundamentalists Zammit does not mention this.

Zammit also sets up another straw man by claiming skeptics say that the mediums hide their ectoplasm in their anus. I have been studying mediumship for a long time, and I have only ever read about two mediums doing this. As stated the easiest way to get the ectoplasm in the séance room was by secret accomplices. In most cases they were not searched before these séances took place and neither were the séance rooms themselves. The are much evidence of séance rooms where trap doors have been found.

The fraud medium Gordon Higginson used to hide his fake ectoplasm cloth under the seats in his séances. Spiritualists never used to thoroughly check the séance room beforehand, but as soon as psychical researchers or investigators were invited they started to look and easily find the stuff hidden in the room. I have read many times how ectoplasm muslin or cheesecloth was hidden under floorboards in the séance room or hidden in secret compartments in the room.

There has never ever been ectoplasm produced in full light conditions. The reason ectoplasm declined was because of the upgrade in technology. People started asking for séances to be performed with video camera equipment or infra-red cameras etc with these in place it would rule out chances of fraud. Most mediums realised this so gave up physical mediumship as they could no longer just walk around the séance room placing the cheesecloth about or dressing up in cloth. After 1960 most mediums turned to purely mental mediumship.

If you go to any modern day spiritualist church, some spiritualists are actually embarrassed about physical mediumship and don't like talking about it. If you ask them why it stopped and no modern medium is doing it anymore they have no response, I mean they aren't going to be honest and admit it was fraud are they but deep down most of them probably know it was unless of course they have fooled themselves like Zammit ;)
 
Last edited:
Zammit's FAQ is also filled with porkies :rolleyes:

He writes:

Q8. Have many sceptics applied for the million dollar reward if they can rebut the evidence for the afterlife?

Answer: Oh yes, a few did. Whenever I inform them what they have to do - rebutting mostly the objective evidence I included in my book on the net, they do not write back. A few academic sceptics complained that the test 'proving beyond possible doubt' is impossible. Their claim is "nothing is absolutely certain in this world." My reply is that this is the test that the skeptics are demanding! And since the cash reward is very high so must be the test of validity. Besides, I stated, of course, there are certain things which are absolutely certain in this world. For example, I made the statement about the mortality of the human condition -we humans physically die. One American Ph.D sceptic tried to argue with me that no one can prove that!! I just replied, if he could show me that President Kennedy is not dead, or Princess Diana or Mother Theresa or Elvis Presley are not dead, my sponsors will gladly hand over the million dollars!

I would love to see some proof of this.


Q9. You are making an offer which is impossible to prove because 'you can't prove the negative'. Can you explain ?

Answer: I am NOT asking anyone to 'prove the negative.' I received many emails from skeptics saying that - but they themselves have not read my challenge - they read the website of some skeptic who deliberately misled them about what I have on my website. Then these skeptics waste my time repeating what some other skeptic has deliberately misrepresented about my offer.

If the reader goes to my home page - it is clearly expressly stated that the challenge is about rebutting the 'EXISTING EVIDENCE.' The evidence is in my book - click on the BOOK on the homepage - you will then see the evidence which has to be rebutted - chapters 3 to 24. Now, that is NOT proving the negative. That is technical evidence which is admissible in a court of law - all the way up to the Supreme Court of the United States, the High Court of England and the High Court of Australia and in all civilised countries in the world. I state that only lawyers know what technically constitutes admissible evidence. Check with your own lawyer. That skeptical stage magician who has been disseminating negative propaganda to fool the uninformed knows absolutely NOTHING about laboratory experimentation and what constitutes admissible technical evidence.

http://www.victorzammit.com/FAQs/index.html

Zammit's nonsense regarding mediumship has already been debunked in this thread. You can see the type of lies he spreads. He's been duped into believing rubber dolls and cheesecloth are "objective" scientific evidence for an afterlife. :)
 
Last edited:
Here is another medium that Zammit claims in his book had scientifically proven the afterlife.

Mina Crandon

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mina_Crandon

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6f/Mina_Crandon_Fake_Ectoplasm.jpg[/qimg]

The above photograph is a picture of Mina Crandon in a séance with her "spirit" hand... and yes the hand looks like a piece of animal tissue. That is because that is what it was!

In one séance the "spirit" hand was grabbed, it was examined by biologists and was found to be made of a piece of carved animal liver. :eek:

Of course no mention of any of this in Zammit's book. You can only call Zammit dishonest for ignoring such facts, it amazes me how 80 people almost on amazon give his book 5 stars when this information is only a click away on the internet. :jaw-dropp

Heh...I was reading about that and when I saw that picture I thought it looked like a pile of something else. Ugh. And coming from between her legs? UGH!

I truly cannot fathom how ANYBODY was ever fooled by all this nonsense. And to use such old "evidence" as fact for today is simply ludicrous. Of course no-one who did such flap-doodle craziness is alive today to debunk, so I guess Zammit feels he is safer from criticism.
 
I truly cannot fathom how ANYBODY was ever fooled by all this nonsense. And to use such old "evidence" as fact for today is simply ludicrous. Of course no-one who did such flap-doodle craziness is alive today to debunk, so I guess Zammit feels he is safer from criticism.

Ah, but physical mediumship is back in style. And with people like Stephen Braude jumping on the bandwagon.

http://felixcircle.blogspot.com/

~~ Paul
 
Ah, but physical mediumship is back in style. And with people like Stephen Braude jumping on the bandwagon.

http://felixcircle.blogspot.com/

~~ Paul

No it's not back in style. Most spiritualist church's stay far away from physical mediumship and now only practice mental mediumship. There are only a handful of "physical" mediums left world-wide.

Stephen Braude is a very rare exception. Most parapsychologists have rejected physical mediumship as fraud since the 1940s.

The typical spiritualist claim that Braude is a skeptic is false, in his early books he seems to reject fraud as an explanation for mediumship and just claim "super ESP" is doing it all, now he's apparently converted to the spiritualist hypothesis. He may have a phd in philosophy but he knows nothing about science. He is actually being dishonest when it comes to writing about mediumship.

All of the historical mediums he claims were genuine were frauds, you only need to read this book, to see that:

http://archive.org/stream/isspiritualismba00mccarich#page/n3/mode/2up

Is Spiritualism Based on Fraud? by Joseph McCabe. The problem is, is that the spiritualists never read the skeptical material and have no interest in any evidence which has debunked their mediums as frauds.

As for the Felix Circle blog, stuff like this is laughable:

http://felixcircle.blogspot.co.uk/2008/09/ectoplasm-and-full-form.html

It's just cheesecloth and newspaper clipping cut outs of peoples faces or people dressed in cloth. I find it hard to believe that anyone deep down believes this is real, if they do they have fooled themselves is a form of self-delusion, fantasy prone personality or mental illness.
 
Last edited:
I truly cannot fathom how ANYBODY was ever fooled by all this nonsense.

I have never understood it either. Only a minority of devout spiritualists like Victor Zammit or Michael E. Tymn or those from the Felix Circle believe such sillyness is genuine. Most parapsychologists reject physical mediumship as it is nothing but fraud, even J. B. Rhine the "father" of American parapsychology rejected physical mediumship as fraud! Parapsychologists are no support to the spiritualists, but you won't usually hear about this from the spiritualists.
 
Here is another medium that Zammit claims in his book had scientifically proven the afterlife:

Eva Carriere

[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/45/Cardboard_cut_out_with_Eva_C.png[/qimg]

The "man" on the left was a large cardboard cut-out of Ferdinand I of Bulgaria, the head was adapted from a newspaper article. You can read about it here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eva_Carrière

Yet Zammit claims the cut-out figure was a real spirit materialization, Zammit also forgets to mention that Eva was nude in her séances :rolleyes:

If she is nude in that photo there has been some serious retouching going on. On this page you can see what I presume to be the un-retouched version (NSFW: breasts!).
 
If she is nude in that photo there has been some serious retouching going on. On this page you can see what I presume to be the un-retouched version (NSFW: breasts!).

Yes the breasts were removed from the photographs due to censorship issues regarding nudity. You can read about it here in the book Phenomena of Materialisation by Baron von Schrenck Notzing who was involved in taking the photographs at her séance tests.

http://archive.org/stream/phenomenaofmater00schr#page/n339/mode/2up

See the photograph, and on page 221 Schrenck Notzing writes:

On the photographs intended for publication, Eva's naked body was, for obvious reasons, retouched in such a way that the sex characteristics (breasts, etc) are not seen.

The uncensored photographs were released by Eva's lesbian lover Juliette Bisson. Bisson was present during Eva's séances and was involved in her ectoplasm "materialization" frauds. They were made from cardboard, cloth, newspaper clippings and other materials.
 
Last edited:
Here is a paper from Stephen E. Braude from 1992. In this paper he supports the super-psi hypothesis of mediumship opposed to the survival hypothesis.

http://www.scientificexploration.org/journal/jse_06_2_braude.pdf

It's a pretty embarrassing paper and I guess that's why only the fringe paranormal journal - The Journal of Scientific Exploration published it. I read the whole thing but no evidence for the super-psi hypothesis of mediumship was given :rolleyes:
 
No it's not back in style. Most spiritualist church's stay far away from physical mediumship and now only practice mental mediumship. There are only a handful of "physical" mediums left world-wide.
True, but it seems as if they are back in action after a long period of silence. Perhaps I just wasn't paying attention and they've been futzing around all along.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
True, but it seems as if they are back in action after a long period of silence. Perhaps I just wasn't paying attention and they've been futzing around all along.

~~ Paul

Even if we assume physical mediumship is genuine it is contradictory by their own beliefs. If you speak to most spiritualists they would admit that they believe in apparitions or ghosts (Zammit even cites a small chapter on people witnessing apparitions). Apparations/hauntings/ghosts have nothing to do with mediumship. Now apparitions do not need a medium to "materialize" or to be seen, in fact they don't materialize at all. There is no "ectoplasm" from apparitional experiences or sightings of ghosts. Ghosts and mediumship contradict each other.

So if these "spirits" could come back to earth (which spiritualists believe) as ghosts (without the need of a medium) then why do they need to assume physical mediumship as well? There is no need for a medium at all. According to various books on ghost hunting one does not need any "psychic" power to witness a ghost.

Of course what I am saying here is based on their own beliefs. They (the spiritualists) have never explained this issue, and they usually ignore it. They contradict themselves by their own reasoning. I understand that the spiritualists do not usually mention ghosts, but they have expressed their belief in them.

The issue was raised in the book Hauntings and Poltergeists: Multidisciplinary Perspectives by James Houran, Rense Lange. But this issue has been around for over 70 years. You won't usually read about this, but ghost hunters because of this very reason have been very critical towards mediumship which they claim is mostly nothing more than a scam. Andrew Green one of the worlds most famous ghost hunters was very critical towards mediumship. Ghost hunters are no friends of physical mediumship but when you flick open Zammit's book he doesn't mention any of this.
 
Last edited:
:) Thanks Sherlock ,for that interesting link on Victor Zammit,excellent reading material ,it gave me some food for thought[and a headache].!
 
Are there any lawyers here? Perhaps we could launch some kind of "counter lawsuit" to Zammit's.
 
Not sure if this has already done the rounds but it looks like Victor is after Stephen Hawkings now :D

To-day’s brief talk is to show you why this closed-minded Professor of Cosmology Prof. Stephen Hawking is deluding himself when he says there is no afterlife. He further stated in the television documentary ‘Curiosity … Who Created the Universe’ that there is no God. This professor made serious blunders and failures which I believe have completely destroyed the credibility of his anti-afterlife argument.

http://www.victorzammit.com/articles/stephenHawking exposedyoutube.htm
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom