US website sued over cheat 'slur'

Darat

Lackey
Staff member
Joined
Aug 3, 2001
Messages
131,407
Location
South East, UK
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/5135384.stm

...snip...

The creator of a US website that lets women complain about men they say have wronged them is facing legal action from a featured man

...snip...

The website owner compares herself with a coffee shop proprietor who is not liable for her customers' gossip.

...snip...

Mr Hollis says he is the one who has been wronged and the website has a duty to check the veracity of information it carries.

...snip...

Any predictions or rather educated ideas ;) on how (if it does go to court) this will pan out?
 
Women say they are looking for Mr. Perfect.

But they don't really want to find him. If they find Mr. Perfect, there's nothing for them to change about him. And that's not good...

Women love the idea of changing their men, more than they love the idea of Mr. Perfect.

;)
 
Suspect the complainant will be tossed out of court, and out-of-pocket big time. A website is like a newspaper, surely - all comments attributable to their authors, not the medium??
 
The website dontdatehimgirl.com has this as the first part of its TOS:

You are solely responsible for the content or information you publish, display or otherwise communicate in any manner (hereinafter, "post") on the Service, or transmit to other Registered Users.

I bet that's going to be their legal argument.
 
The website dontdatehimgirl.com has this as the first part of its TOS:



I bet that's going to be their legal argument.
Yeah, that's gonna work. Just like the sign in the coat check room saying "we are not responsible for lost or stolen items" gives them legal license to steal.
 
Yeah, that's gonna work. Just like the sign in the coat check room saying "we are not responsible for lost or stolen items" gives them legal license to steal.
Because...it's not the same thing??? :confused:

The website was not asked to write the comments on behalf of these women, they wrote them themselves...
 
It's the public 'soap box' argument. I believe that if the host does NO EDITING, it is a free and open site, then they are not responsible for content. Newspapers are different, they are in it for the money. But cities are not responsible for what is said by somebody standing on a soap box on the corner.
 
The reason a cloak room operated by a restaurant or other service is not responsible for damage or theft is usually because if that happens ........
damage to or theft of an expensive coat, the establishment's insurer's
are responsible.

If someone hands in a coat that has a rip in the lining for example and then claims the cloak room damaged the garment then the matter is referred to the establishment's insurers who decide whether or not to
fight or pay the claim.

Also as Zep says this is not the same thing.
 
I think the comparison with a coffee shop isn't appropriate either. A coffee shop doesn't broadcast the gossip spoken inside it over the entire globe. It doesn't collect a whole database of accusations made by gossipers.

I don't think an internet forum has the responsibility of checking every fact that is posted on it, but I do think it also problematic if people are allowed to post other's personal information and photos together with unverifiable accusations. It gets even more problematic if it keeps a large searchable database blacklist, and that's what 'Don't Date Him Girl' does.

If I was the judge I would also sentence the site owner to life-in-prison for the Annoying-and-Unnecessary-Use-of-Macromedia/Flash.
 
I think the comparison with a coffee shop isn't appropriate either. A coffee shop doesn't broadcast the gossip spoken inside it over the entire globe. It doesn't collect a whole database of accusations made by gossipers.

I don't think an internet forum has the responsibility of checking every fact that is posted on it, but I do think it also problematic if people are allowed to post other's personal information and photos together with unverifiable accusations. It gets even more problematic if it keeps a large searchable database blacklist, and that's what 'Don't Date Him Girl' does.

If I was the judge I would also sentence the site owner to life-in-prison for the Annoying-and-Unnecessary-Use-of-Macromedia/Flash.

I agree with you. The worldwide public nature of it, the entire purpose of the site, which is solely to smear real people very publicly, and the very forseeability of the slanderous nature of the comments made and to be made there might make some new law here. I don't find analogies to more traditional forms of public media to be particularly apt.

I made a post about this elsewhere yesterday, and discussed it briefly with some folks by chat last night. I find this whole concept deeply disturbing. It's far worse than a scarlet "A" in my opinion. The meanness and vileness behind the posts and the founding of the sites is deplorable. Although legally "truth" is a defense to libel or slander, I hope it doesn't shield the sites from liability. I find them disgusting.

Whatever happened to "don't kiss and tell" as an acceptable guideline for what happens between lovers?

AS

ETA: For a more balanced site, one that offers men the opportunity to trash women publicly too, go here. Any feminists thinking "Yay! The bastards can get their just desserts" might want to reconsider after seeing this one. http://www.playersandpsychos.com/index.php
 
Last edited:
So wait a sec, it's okay to post cheating men but not to post cheating women on this site?

from their site:


Do not post the names of alleged cheating women on this website!

The names will automatically be deleted!

www.DontDateHimGirl.com is for women to post the pictures and profiles of men who have allegedly cheated on them, NOT vice versa.
and

We do not remove profiles of the men in our database! If you have been deemed to have violated these rules [?] will be removed.

What about gay and lesbian cheaters? Or
trans-sexual cheaters? How do they reconcile these?
 
Last edited:
Here is the database entry for Todd Hollis, the guy who sues the site. (Hopefully the url gets parsed correctly. No guarantees from me). Apperently someone accuses him of spreading herpes.

As a policy, Don't Date Him Girl doesn't delete any entries, but invites men to "tell their side of the story". Since they can't do much but deny the accusations and won't be able to back anything up, this is a bit of a "have you stopped beating your wife" issue.

There is another entry in the database where apperently the original poster apologises for causing mr. Hollis any harm and claims it was all a joke. Presumably it is the same "Todd Hollis", but peculiarly he has turned from white to black.
 
I think the comparison with a coffee shop isn't appropriate either. A coffee shop doesn't broadcast the gossip spoken inside it over the entire globe. It doesn't collect a whole database of accusations made by gossipers.

I don't think an internet forum has the responsibility of checking every fact that is posted on it, but I do think it also problematic if people are allowed to post other's personal information and photos together with unverifiable accusations. It gets even more problematic if it keeps a large searchable database blacklist, and that's what 'Don't Date Him Girl' does.
Agreed. It's not black and white but it is not as simple as saying that the web site has no responsibility.
 
By now you should have noticed that almost all sites that deal with dating are firmly ingrained into the Hetero Man/Hetero Woman dichotomy.

No, I didn't notice that by now since I have never heard about this until now and don't keep up with "dating sites" myself as my wife might not understand. Neither would I.

Surely special interest/gender groups have dating sites also (e.g.: girls who love physicists or guys who want to marry nurses) and soon they will probably have cheating sites.

But thanks for pointing this out.
 
Women say they are looking for Mr. Perfect.

But they don't really want to find him. If they find Mr. Perfect, there's nothing for them to change about him. And that's not good...

Women love the idea of changing their men, more than they love the idea of Mr. Perfect.

;)

Hence the reason why makeover shows are so popular.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom