US Politics [split from] Iranian Pres Denies Existence of Homosexuals...

You still don't get my point, do you?


My point is:

A. America is whining about Gays and "Free Choice".
B. Iran is whining about Gays.

Iran isn't whining about gays. Iran is killing them.

Killing them so well that Iran's President proudly states that there aren't any in his country.

But at least he isn't Bush, so they have that going for them.
 
You still don't get my point, do you?


My point is:

A. America is whining about Gays and "Free Choice".
B. Iran is whining about Gays.

My point is: I REALLY, REEEEEALLY DO NOTCARE, YOU'RE
BOTH IDIOTS ... BOTH! ... Period.
This rather broad stroke, illogical equivocation must be the european intellectualism you were refering to. Your ability to stereotype is not at all provincial.
 
This rather broad stroke, illogical equivocation must be the european intellectualism you were refering to. Your ability to stereotype is not at all provincial.


What Stereotype. Point out inasmuch Gay's don't have problems
in the US, especially in the stereotypic Bible-Belt.
 
So now you accepted that Iran is no nuclear threat and
you're trying to ride the "Gay-Horse" instead to justify
your antipathy towards another POV?

Sorry, but this sounds exactly like a White supremacist's
Point of View. You just fail to see your own hate.
Oliver, I'm German as you are (like that would matter as far as the point at hand anyway). In one way I do understand your points and especially I can relate to you whenever you are being accused of being of a certain ethnicity and/or nationality suggesting you have to shut up just because of that.

Whoever does that better be prepared to answer the question of whether Anne Frank should be "guilty" of the original Sin of being German as well or should we rather make distinctions based on ethnicity rather than nationality and go from there all the way down...

Having said that, the only reason why I would not advocate regime change in Iran is the same reason I did not advocate regime change in Iraq. It comes down to "democracy" and "freedom" not being absolute values for them selfs, but rather means to an end.

Humanism is concerned about what serves humans best. If there was a way to "flip a switch" on Iranian society that would make it ...well... somewhat more democratic... without anyone getting hurt, I would flip that switch at an instance.

What you are having in mind, probably, is to point out that there is no such switch, and, on top of that, it could be argued that there is no western society that isn't in dire need of any such switch either!

You are right with that one. And I sure do share your concerns as far as our western warmongers using about any excuse they could fit into a powerpoint slide in order to bomb another country in the name of "freedom".

This does, however, not excuse anything happening in Iran as far as their Shariah business. It merely means that changing it would hurt more people than leaving it the way it is.

Is there anyone left I haven't offended with this post? *wonders*
 
Last edited:
Oliver, I'm German as you are (like that would matter as far as the point at hand anyway). In one way I do understand your points and especially I can relate to you whenever you are being accused of being of a certain ethnicity and/or nationality suggesting you have to shut up just because of that.

Whoever does that better be prepared to answer the question of whether Anne Frank should be "guilty" of the original Sin of being German as well or should we rather make distinctions based on ethnicity rather than nationality and go from there all the way down...

Having said that, the only reason why I would not advocate regime change in Iran is the same reason I did not advocate regime change in Iraq. It comes down to "democracy" and "freedom" not being absolute values for them selfs, but rather means to an end.

Humanism is concerned about what serves humans best. If there was a way to "flip a switch" on Iranian society that would make it ...well... somewhat more democratic... without anyone getting hurt, I would flip that switch at an instance.

What you are having in mind, probably, is to point out that there is no such switch, and, on top of that, it could be argued that there is no western society that isn't in dire need of any such switch either!

You are right with that one. And I sure do share your concerns as far as our western warmongers using about any excuse they could fit into a powerpoint slide in order to bomb another country in the name of "freedom".

This does, however, not excuse anything happening in Iran as far as their Shariah business. It merely means that changing it would hurt more people than leaving it the way it is.

Is there anyone left I haven't offended with this post? *wonders*


Unfortunately the War-Mongerers don't care about the Human
factor. They never did and they never will. But they manage to
lie to their people with slogans like "Freedom, Patriotism, Democracy".
And at this point I have to say: "BS!".

My point regarding the gays in Iran is that the west is the last
group of people who should impose anything onto the Iranians,
especially the Iranians because they didn't forget their shared
History with American interventions. Und das kann ich den Jungs
wirklich nicht übel nehmen. (No Idea how to translate that).

But I agree that the punishment of Gays in Iran is a shame. But
there is nothing we can do about that thanks to the Situation
"we manoeuvered in", making diplomacy a very hard task. :covereyes
 
Oliver,
All State Sodomy laws (most of them blue laws anyway) were invalidated by a sweeping decision of the Supreme Court in 2003 in Lawrence vs. Texas:
Source http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_v._Texas


I remember an old law that married people are not allowed to have
anal-sex as well - but I don't know if it still exists. It's not solely
about laws - it's also an issue of more fundamental Christians and
as such, the pressure they are able to put onto a system that
should separate State and Religion.

So I often wonder why many issues in the US are so controversial
or why they aren't more "modern" - but the US also is a big country
with many open-minded regions as well. It's hard to understand
why there are not more shared views - but this also could be a
result of the size of America.
 
I'm sorry - but from my european POV, I really, really doubt
that the Media in the US is "free":


[please take the time to understand the european, intellectual POV]


You should stop thinking you're speaking for Europeans. The vast majority of Europeans would prefer not having anything to do with you and your likes ... :rolleyes:
 
I remember an old law that married people are not allowed to have
anal-sex as well - but I don't know if it still exists.

What does it matter if the law exists or not if they are not enforced? When was the last time anybody was investigated, arrested, and prosecuted for breaking such laws in the US?

It's not solely about laws...

Actually this discussion was about laws.

...it's also an issue of more fundamental Christians and
as such, the pressure they are able to put onto a system that
should separate State and Religion.

So you don't think fundamentalist Christians have the right to their opinions and to be political? Interesting. I may disagree with them, but they have their rights to believe what they want, and their efforts to legislate those beliefs are steadily being eroded by the tide of both public and legal opinion.

So I often wonder why many issues in the US are so controversial
or why they aren't more "modern"...

So, in other words, you wonder why the US just doesn't stop everything and only do things condoned by you? Silencing and not even considering dissenting opinions? That doesn't sound democratic, that sounds autocratic, which is the opposite of what many consider "modern." Controversy exists because the public of the USA isn't one big monolithic entity in its opinions and beliefs. A country where there is no controversy is a country where someones opinions are being suppressed.

Is that what you want? Lock up the fundamentalists because you don't consider their beliefs to be "modern" or adhering to what you call the "European Intellectual POV?"

It's starting to become clearer why you defend dictators.

...but the US also is a big country
with many open-minded regions as well.

The US is a big country, but please describe what areas are not open minded, why they are not, and exactly what being "open-minded" is? I have a sneaking suspicion that "open-minded" is simply code-talk for "whatever I believe."

It's hard to understand
why there are not more shared views - but this also could be a
result of the size of America.

I fear the day when every view is shared in America. There's a name for societies where all views are the same, "dystopia."
 
Mutilating female genitals in the name of religion is the worst
thing I can imagine. Of course - that doesn't matter to some
in here, but personally I think it's the first thing that should be
banned from this planet.


Genital mutilations in Africa are done in the name of tradition, not religion. No religious text promote them, despite what local clerics have told the populations (the muslim missionaries, like the christian missionaries, tend not to antagonise local traditions when they don't obviously contradict the official doctrine and despite their potential to harm the populations - shame on them), and the populations that have never practiced it don't start whenever they convert to islam. One of the really efficient actions against them * is to teach the imams about what the coran actually says (or rather doesn't say) about them (many imams in Africa have learnt part of the coran only, or have memorised it by rote because they're unable to read arabic).

* other actions imply to graphically show men what it actually entails, ending up in them asking for cessation of the custom, or to resort to symbolic procedures only. However, the best action is to ensure access to education for girls and women.
 
Reports from Japanese newspapers, all quote Ahmadinejad` s speech quite fairly:

「ホロコーストの研究不十分」 イラン大統領、疑問視
2007年9月25日 夕刊

 【ニューヨーク=池尾伸一】国連総会に出席のため訪米中のイランのアハマディネジャド大統領は二十四日、ニューヨークのコロンビア大学で講演し、ナチス・ドイツによるホロコースト(ユダヤ人大虐殺)について「別の視点からの研究が十分にされていない」として歴史的事実の存在にあらためて疑問を呈した。

 同大統領は従来もホロコーストについて「でっち上げ」などと事実を否定。ただ、今回の講演では「全くなかったとは話していない」とも述べ、わずかながら“軌道修正”もした。

 同大統領は「異なる視点から研究しようとした欧米の学者が何人も投獄されている」と指摘。「仮に(ホロコーストが)事実だったとしてもなぜパレスチナの人々が代償を支払わねばならないのか」としてイスラエルや同国を支援する欧米を非難した。核開発については「核兵器転用の狙いはなく国際原子力機関(IAEA)の監視下でやっている」としてあらためて正当化した。

 また会場から「イランはホモセクシュアル(同性愛者)を処刑しているのか」との質問が出されると、「わが国には同性愛者はいない」と応じる場面もあった。

 イランについては米政府がテロ支援国家に指定しており、米中枢同時テロで崩壊した世界貿易センター跡で献花したいとする同大統領の申請をニューヨーク市当局が拒否。同大学でも学生らが講演開催に抗議するデモを行った。

http://www.chunichi.co.jp/article/world/news/CK2007092502051533.html
 
Reports from Japanese newspapers, all quote Ahmadinejad` s speech quite fairly:

「ホロコーストの研究不十分」 イラン大統領、疑問視
2007年9月25日 夕刊

 【ニューヨーク=池尾伸一】国連総会に出席のため訪米中のイランのアハマディネジャド大統領は二十四日、ニューヨークのコロンビア大学で講演し、ナチス・ドイツによるホロコースト(ユダヤ人大虐殺)について「別の視点からの研究が十分にされていない」として歴史的事実の存在にあらためて疑問を呈した。

 同大統領は従来もホロコーストについて「でっち上げ」などと事実を否定。ただ、今回の講演では「全くなかったとは話していない」とも述べ、わずかながら“軌道修正”もした。

 同大統領は「異なる視点から研究しようとした欧米の学者が何人も投獄されている」と指摘。「仮に(ホロコーストが)事実だったとしてもなぜパレスチナの人々が代償を支払わねばならないのか」としてイスラエルや同国を支援する欧米を非難した。核開発については「核兵器転用の狙いはなく国際原子力機関(IAEA)の監視下でやっている」としてあらためて正当化した。

 また会場から「イランはホモセクシュアル(同性愛者)を処刑しているのか」との質問が出されると、「わが国には同性愛者はいない」と応じる場面もあった。

 イランについては米政府がテロ支援国家に指定しており、米中枢同時テロで崩壊した世界貿易センター跡で献花したいとする同大統領の申請をニューヨーク市当局が拒否。同大学でも学生らが講演開催に抗議するデモを行った。

http://www.chunichi.co.jp/article/world/news/CK2007092502051533.html



:confused: :p
 
What does it matter if the law exists or not if they are not enforced? When was the last time anybody was investigated, arrested, and prosecuted for breaking such laws in the US?

Frank Sinatra was arrested by the Bergen County, New Jersey sheriff in 1938 and charged with carrying on with a married woman (yes, you could get popped for that back then). The charge was later changed to adultery, and eventually dismissed.

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/mugshots/sinatramug1.html
 
By the way, how did Female Genital Mutilation get worked into this discussion? It's terrible, yes, but how is it relevant to the topic at hand?
 
Frank Sinatra was arrested by the Bergen County, New Jersey sheriff in 1938 and charged with carrying on with a married woman (yes, you could get popped for that back then). The charge was later changed to adultery, and eventually dismissed.

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/mugshots/sinatramug1.html

The US certainly wasn't the only country where adultery was crime in the 30s. It was in the law books in Finland until 1948 (cohabitation of unmarried couples was legalized in the late 1920s).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom