U.S. Hands Off Pacified Anbar, Once Heart of Iraq Insurgency

BeAChooser

Banned
Joined
Jun 20, 2007
Messages
11,716
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/02/w...&ref=todayspaper&pagewanted=print&oref=slogin

RAMADI, Iraq — Two years ago, Anbar Province was the most lethal place for the Americans in Iraq, with a marine or a soldier dying here nearly every day. The provincial capital, Ramadi, was a moonscape of rubble and ruins. Islamic extremists controlled large pieces of territory, with some so ferocious in their personal views that they did not even allow the sale of bread.

On Monday, following a parade on a freshly paved street, American commanders formally returned responsibility for keeping order in Anbar Province, once the heartland of the Sunni insurgency, to the Iraqi Army and police force. The ceremony capped one of the starkest turnabouts in the country since the war began five and a half years ago.

And none of this would have happened had we done what Obama proposed back in January 2007.

Instead, Iraq would now be in utter chaos.

Is that the type of *change* Obama will bring?
 
Things would be going even better.

By all means, please explain how. Keep in mind that even Biden doesn't agree with you. He said back in January of 2007 that "My impression is he (BAC - Obama) thinks that if we leave, somehow the Iraqis are going to have an epiphany" of peaceful coexistence among warring sects. "I've seen zero evidence of that."
 
I thought the liberal media was covering up the "good news" coming from Iraq?
 
I thought the liberal media was covering up the "good news" coming from Iraq?

Well at some point, even they can't hide a good thing. They'd look utterly foolish if they tried.

But that doesn't stop the rest of the democrat party from looking foolish in their place. :D
 
Where are the mobile biological weapons labs that Colin Powel said were there?
Where is the reconstituted nuclear weapons program that Dick Cheney warned about?
Why haven’t Iraqi Oil revenues paid for reconstruction like Paul Wolfowitz said they would?
Why has the price of Oil more than tripled since the Iraq war began?
Why is the US economy is shambles?
Why is the Federal Budget deficit worse than ever before?
Why are thousands of American soldiers dead?
Why are hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civilians dead?
Why are millions of Iraqis refugees?

The Iraq War has been a Fiasco, a disaster.
 
Uh... Wow. That's some world you live on.

So you and BeAChooser claim that you know what what have happened?

You don't have the faintest idea what would have happened if the bipartisan Baker Commission approach had been tried. Neither do I. That is why I can make the above claim with as much evidence and certainty as you can make the opposite claim.
 
So you and BeAChooser claim that you know what what have happened?

You don't have the faintest idea what would have happened if the bipartisan Baker Commission approach had been tried. Neither do I. That is why I can make the above claim with as much evidence and certainty as you can make the opposite claim.
Ah, so you're just making things up.

An ongoing terrorist bloodbath that was only stopped through escalation of force would have been magically evaporated by your piercing Democrat Happy Rays.

As I said, that's some world you live on.
 
Ah, so you're just making things up.

An ongoing terrorist bloodbath that was only stopped through escalation of force would have been magically evaporated by your piercing Democrat Happy Rays.

As I said, that's some world you live on.

Force was helpful but mostly it was the sunni decideing that the shia were more of a problem than the americans. Not an unreasonable conclusion on their part.
 
The Iraq War has been a Fiasco, a disaster.

To begin with, regardless of your and Obama's OPINION that we shouldn't have gone into Iraq in the first place, Obama still needed to demonstrate that once we were in he was capable of making the right decision ... a "responsible" decision. He did not. Instead, he demonstrated quite clearly in January 2007 and throughout 2007 that he was stuck on stupid. Even his running mate strongly disagreed with him.

Now as to your specific questions, let me respond with questions of my own.

Where are the mobile biological weapons labs that Colin Powel said were there?

Why didn't Saddam simply tell us what the items where when they were discovered and talked about by Powell? Afterall, there were sound reasons to suspect they might be what Powell said they were.

Where is the reconstituted nuclear weapons program that Dick Cheney warned about?

Why did David Kay, chief ISG inspector, state after the inspection process was well underway that what the ISG found in Iraq suggests that Iraq was even more a threat from the standpoint of terrorists obtaining WMD related materials than anyone thought before the invasion? And why did Saddam keep so many nuclear weapons experts on his payroll if he'd decided to forego development of them?

Why haven’t Iraqi Oil revenues paid for reconstruction like Paul Wolfowitz said they would?

Why have democrats ignored the role of terrorists in keeping Iraqi oil production depressed? Why have democrats ignored the role of terrorists in damaging newly reconstructed facilities? Are WE the only bad guys in democrat minds?

Why has the price of Oil more than tripled since the Iraq war began?

Why do democrats not understand the market role of supply and demand? Do they not understand the effect of China on the demand side of the equation? China's consumption from 2003 to 2008 has risen by over 2 million barrels a day. Do democrats think that has no effect but a 1 million barrel a day decrease in supply (the amount of oil production lost in Iraq during the insurgency) does? Why would a million barrel supply decrease cause oil prices to triple ... especially when top democrats are claiming that a increase in oil output of about a million barrels a day from ANWR would have no significant impact on oil prices? And why, now that Iraq production has exceeded the pre-war values, has the price of oil not come down? Do you see the inconsistency in your argument, PC?

Why is the US economy is shambles?

Is it? Well maybe it has something to do with the price of oil. And isn't your concern ironic given that democrats have resisted even the notion of drilling for more oil? And resisted the notion of opening up our coal reserves to the production of oil? And resisted the notion of nuclear power? Do you see the hypocrisy inherent in your question, PC? :D

Why is the Federal Budget deficit worse than ever before?

Why have democrats insisted that even Bush's compassionate efforts to placate them with more spending on social programs and education are not enough if they are all that concerned about the deficit? Could that spending have had something to do with the deficit? Why do democrats insist social security spending should be even higher or that we need another trillion in social programs ... if they are all that concerned about the deficit? And again, do democrats think the price of oil has nothing to do with our deficit? Or that fighting a world war (because that's what we are doing now) will have no impact on the deficit? And do you really think that sending almost a trillion dollars overseas as part of Obama's "Global Poverty Act" will help the deficit? Will the 8 trillion dollars in reparations that his core supporters demand help the deficit? And, besides, is the deficit really worse now than ever before ... as you claim? Afterall, the deficit as a percentage of GDP is not worse than it was during the last world war.

Why are democrats unable to face the fact that the only reason the deficit went down during Clinton's term was because of spending restraints from republicans, a booming economy that had more to do with the computer/internet boon than anything else, and because Clinton cut military spending (perhaps too much) following the end of the Cold War? Why can democrats not see that Clinton had the advantage of not having a trillion dollar attack on the country during his term and not having a war to fight that many have compared to WW2 in importance. Why do they miss the fact that Clinton also didn't have a recession whereas Bush had to deal with one that ironically began at the end of Clinton's term (arguably because of his policies)? So do you see the illogic in your question, PC?

Why are thousands of American soldiers dead?

Why do most soldiers understand that reason and support the republican party rather than the democrat party? Do democrats really think that if we hadn't invaded Iraq the war on terror would be over or that al-Qaeda wouldn't have made some other locale the battleground where American soldiers would have died? Are democrats that naive?

Why are hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civilians dead?

Why do democrats keep making this bogus claim when over and over it has been shown that the studies on which those claims are based are deeply flawed and didn't even ask whether the claimed dead were civilians? Why do democrats think that hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civilians would not have died in Iraq in the last 5 years if we hadn't invaded when prior to the war the UN, WHO and many on the anti-war side were claiming that many thousands of innocent women and children were dying in Iraq every month because they weren't getting proper food, water and medical care (a lack that was due to the actions of Saddam)? Why do democrats ignore the fact that prior to our invasion Saddam was responsible for the deaths of MILLIONS, not only Iraqis but those in other countries too?

Why are millions of Iraqis refugees?

Why were millions of Iraqis refugees even before we invaded ... driven out of their homes in Shiite and Kurd areas? And who made those people refugees? Was it us or the terrorists who made Iraq into a hell AFTER Saddam fell? Why are democrats not happy now that those terrorists are almost gone and Iraqis will now be able to return to a country that is democratic and prosperous?

Can you answer these questions for me, PC?

Because I think they answer your questions. :D
 
You don't have the faintest idea what would have happened if the bipartisan Baker Commission approach had been tried. Neither do I. That is why I can make the above claim with as much evidence and certainty as you can make the opposite claim.

ROTFLOL! You do realize, don't you, that the Baker Commission ruled out even the possibility of an Iraq victory? Guess they, like Obama, were wrong too. :D

And for the record, the Baker Commission presented Bush with TWO options (http://www.nysun.com/national/bakers-panel-rules-out-iraq-victory/41371/ ). One was the "Redeploy and Contain" option which Obama latched onto. The other was the "Stability First" option, which is closer to what was actually done. Guess you just forgot about that option in your haste to support Obama. :rolleyes:
 
Why should we have gone into Iraq?

Did you ever read Bush's State of the Union Address in January of 2003? Because that contains the answer to your question.

And another answer to your question might be this: http://freeinidaho.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/06/purple-finger.jpg .

Or what is happening in Anbar province, right now. :D

In any case, I do find it curious how after all the chanting by democrats for years that "Bush Lied, People Died", that slogan didn't get mentioned at the democratic National Convention. Well maybe I just missed it (I must admit I failed to watch much of the Convention). So could you point out who voiced that argument from the podium ... or if no one did, why democrats suddenly forgot their roots, Mark? :D
 
Did you ever read Bush's State of the Union Address in January of 2003? Because that contains the answer to your question.

And another answer to your question might be this: http://freeinidaho.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/06/purple-finger.jpg .

Or what is happening in Anbar province, right now. :D

OPINION, all of it. Find me something that isn't OPINION.

In any case, I do find it curious how after all the chanting by democrats for years that "Bush Lied, People Died", that slogan didn't get mentioned at the democratic National Convention. Well maybe I just missed it (I must admit I failed to watch much of the Convention). So could you point out who voiced that argument from the podium ... or if no one did, why democrats suddenly forgot their roots, Mark? :D

If I went to the DNC, maybe I could tell you.
 
OPINION, all of it. Find me something that isn't OPINION.

Mark, I never said there was anything wrong with having an opinion. What I said is that Obama was not acting RESPONSIBLY when he authored that bill to pull our combat forces out of Iraq back in January of 2007. And his running mate agreed with my view at the time. :D
 
Ah, so you're just making things up.

An ongoing terrorist bloodbath that was only stopped through escalation of force would have been magically evaporated by your piercing Democrat Happy Rays.

As I said, that's some world you live on.

Do you or do you not know what would have happened if the Baker Commission approach had been taken?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom