Truthers: what if you are wrong?

Two plains hit the World Trade Center. Moments before the plains hit the world trade center there were explosions in both basements.

Why before the PLANES hit? Why the basement? The collapse initiated at the impacted floors, meaning the building didn't fall bottom first....so why the bomb?

So I just want to get this straight. So you are saying the fire on the impacted floors caused the initial collapse but the bomb furthered it some how? Please explain


Sorry to derail the thread.
 
Apart from the horror of that day, I distinctly remember feeling with regards to the Pentagon and Shanksville, that to me it did not look like a plane had crashed in either place.

Aside from all the airplane debris and bodies...

When the passport was found in NY city and the evidence found in the cars of the hijackers fairly soon after, I must admit I greeted it with a certain amount of skeptism. Uncle Sam's lucky finds?

That's because you have a Hollywood view of crashes.

That was when I heard of the alternative version of the story. I dismissed it immediately but couldnt seem to get it out of my head and I spent a lot of time subsequently reading up on it. To me there are an awful lot of unanswered questions.

And unanswered questions are viewed by you as evidence ?

I really don't believe the official story - too many coincidences.

How many is too many ? Almost everything that happens is a coincidence in some way, so how many does it take, then ?

Every historical event, in hindsight, will reveal many coincidences. Does that mean that every historical event is fake ?

I have read Dr Greenings arguments on the collapse of the Twin Towers and I must admit I love it when he riles you all

When you get your fun from annoying other people, it doesn't bode well for your social skills.

So to try and answer your question as briefly as I can, if I was proved wrong, then I am wrong. However PM guys don't convince anyone. They are too young to be answering questions quite obviously outside their expertise.

PM ?

At this moment in time I'm not interested in evidence.

What would you prefer ? Fantasy ?

And all has gone astonishingly quiet - so much for debate.

The thread is a question for truthers, Ox.
 
In 1990, at the age of 14, I was a Rush Limbaugh fan. I've grown up enough to know the error of my ways. By the year 2026 when all classified information from the day of 911 becomes public record, we will have a much clearer picture of who's in error.

Although the clarity of the picture probably will be substandard.

Talk about preparing a cop-out 20 years in advance... :rolleyes:

I don't feel it is possible I'm wrong about a conspiracy relating too 911.

Why not ? Don't you follow the evidence ?

History has proven times of war are really good for the economy.

Not always. I do believe that the US got lots of debts after WWII.

When a democrat takes office in 2008 the war will end. The economy will most likely slump and by 2012 or 2016 a Republican will once again hold office.

You should try to replace Sylvia Brown, then.

Two plains hit the World Trade Center.

I thought those were hills.

Moments before the plains hit the world trade center there were explosions in both basements.

Moments before they hit someone CLAIMS there were explosions.

But it's quite possible they are actually describing the impact, isn't it ? After all they didn't see the plane.

A missile hit the Pentagon.

...and left all those airplane debris and bodies.

If you look at the Pentagon from the outside they have an exceptional number of camera's. Yet even with speculation the videos haven't been released.

Which videos ? Are you still speculating ?

NORAD was conducting training missions at the discretion of Vice President Dick Cheney. Because of these training missions there was a great deal of confusion.

Gosh, OldSchool. If you had bothered to do ANY research at all, you'd know this is a complete lie. So, why do you lie ?

Another hi-jacked plain was shot down in Pennsylvania.

Evidence ? The recorder disagrees with you.
 
In 1990, at the age of 14, I was a Rush Limbaugh fan. I've grown up enough to know the error of my ways. By the year 2026 when all classified information from the day of 911 becomes public record, we will have a much clearer picture of who's in error.

Although the clarity of the picture probably will be substandard.

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/groundzero/cleanup.html

It does not help your case when you link to a website page that says this

Since no steel-framed buildings had ever collapsed due to fires

Now, who mentioned errors?
 
I don't feel it is possible I'm wrong about a conspiracy relating too 911. The only thing which remains to be seen is if and when such a conspiracy is exposed. I give government an awful lot of credit. History has proven times of war are really good for the economy. Once again, the republicans claim an improved economy during the Bush Administration. When a democrat takes office in 2008 the war will end. The economy will most likely slump and by 2012 or 2016 a Republican will once again hold office.

When you need to argue your position based on facts, you should actually have factual knowledge in what you type.

The next President doesn't take office until January 2009. The current Dem front runner (Hilary) is against withdrawal. The 2nd runner up Obama says he wants to invade Pakistan. Oh well. There goes your theory.

Actually History does NOT prove that war is good for the economy. It actually shows the opposite. Take a look at the "Broken Window" theory of economics. Take time to think about it, and how it pertains to war in general. However, INNOVATION that comes out of war does help economies. But that is a by product of war.
 
Why before the PLANES hit? Why the basement? The collapse initiated at the impacted floors, meaning the building didn't fall bottom first....so why the bomb?

So I just want to get this straight. So you are saying the fire on the impacted floors caused the initial collapse but the bomb furthered it some how? Please explain


Sorry to derail the thread.

Not to mention he's claiming that bombs went off in the basement (which people escaped from in the time before collapse) before each of the planes hit... First off, does he realize that there was a gap in time between each hit? And not one witness heard explosions BEFORE the plane hit?
 
Then I guess Quintiere is as well since he said this about WTC 7:


“And that building was not hit by anything,” noted Dr. Quintiere. “It’s more important to take a look at that. Maybe there was damage by the debris falling down that played a significant role. But other than that you had fires burning a long time without fire department intervention. And firefighters were in that building. I have yet to see any kind of story about what they saw. What was burning? Were photographs taken? Nothing!”

"The heat must have been tremendous. There was so much [expletive] fire there. This whole pile was burning like crazy. Just the heat and the smoke from all the other buildings on fire, you [couldn't] see anything." - Lt. William Ryan

"A little north of Vesey I said, we’ll go down, let’s see what’s going on. A couple of the other officers and I were going to see what was going on. We were told to go to Greenwich and Vesey and see what’s going on. So we go there and on the north and east side of 7 it didn’t look like there was any damage at all, but then you looked on the south side of 7 there had to be a hole 20 stories tall in the building, with fire on several floors. Debris was falling down on the building and it didn’t look good." - Capt Chris Boyle

"No, not right away, and that’s probably why it stood for so long because it took a while for that fire to develop. It was a heavy body of fire in there and then we didn’t make any attempt to fight it." - D.C. Peter Hayden


I would have to say he didn't get a chance to talk to any of the firefighters there yet.

And before you jump on his statement about fires burning a long time. There's a big difference between fires that can smolder and burn for a long time and an inferno. If it was an inferno, as the doctor suggests, where are the photographs of it?

I know the difference between a smoldering fire and an inferno, I had to write a paper on it for my Firefighter Class. First off a smoldering fire wouldn't produce that much smoke because the fuel would be limited it would start to decay. Also a smoldering fire is considered a fuel controlled fire and I don't think the firefighters would said there was a lot of fire if it was smoldering. So maybe you should look up the definition of the two before claiming one of the other.


If you'll oblige a bit of subjective analysis, his use of the phrase "you had" might be akin to 'you reported,' as opposed to saying 'there were fires burning a long time.'

A subtle but important difference. Double quotes for direct quotations, single for illustrative phrases.

Maybe he isn't going to jump to conclusions without definitive information and evidence? I mean that would be the proper thing to do
 
In that long post, I will just use this to illustrate what's illogical about your statements.

The government is not going to indict itself. How ridiculous is it to assume that the gov't is going to pursue an investigation that leads to members within itself.
Unsubstantiated assumption on your part. Evidence countering such assumption:
* Iran/Contra
* Whitewater
* Watergate
* Lewinski

There is sufficient history of the gov't investigating, indicting, and convicting members of the gov't to lay your claim to waste. You are making the erroneous assumption that the gov't is both homogeneous, and in lock-step; neither is the case.

This would be akin to asking Barry Bonds to investigate steroid use in baseball.
No, it would be akin to the Commissioner of Baseball, or some similar rules body, investigating steroid use and indicting B. Bonds.

Secondly, unless you don't own a TV, read a magazine or open a newspaper, the discussion of, and questioning of 9/11 has been all over mass media for the last year.
Fallacious appeal to authority. Being on TV, in print, etc does not automatically lend credibility to an individual or group's case, neither does it necessisarily represent the state of reality; to wit there have been a relatively large number of books, articles, etc over the last few years regarding evolution and intelligent design. This is in no way an indication that ID seriously poses any legitimate critiques of the ToE.

Who would really have thought that someone as extreme as Alex Jones would be on both CNN and the History Channel in the same year?
Yes, and Larry King (CNN) has had Sylvia Browne on multiple times and the History Channel regularly shows a one hour special on the Templar that includes numerous interviews with Davide Icke. Please refer to my above paragraph.

Both Steven Jones and Dr. Griffin have been interviewed on prime time news networks. Granted, they never get as much face time as Alex or Dylan because their measured tones and solid background info are not as easy to shoot down as these more extreme figures, including Fetzer.
Again you are making assumptions. Perhaps they are not getting as much face time because TV likes conflict, because conflict sells, and ranting lunatics like A. Jones do conflict well.
 
The government is not going to indict itself. How ridiculous is it to assume that the gov't is going to pursue an investigation that leads to members within itself.
You are making a slight error in perception here, and that is that the government is a monolithic, self-consistent entity. It is in fact rather fractious, a multi-faction collection that includes people who are willing to use any edge to oust, or get advantage against, a rival. Linda Tripp is a fine example.

I'll offer also the uncovering of Rep Duke Cunningham, and the current efforts to oust AG Gonzales, as modest examples of the government's various components going after one another, and indeed "indicting itself." Like him or not, Henry Waxman is pursuing hearings on any number of government internal errors, to include the lady heading GAO.

If a Democratic Party operative could get his hands on something like a smoking gun that Dylan Avery or Jones keeps trying to find, the betting money is on his using it to make a huge political splash, and to unseat any number of Republicans, or appointees of Republicans, in order to score a political advantage for himself and his faction.

I am pretty sure efforts to uncover such advantage have been undertaken, by smarter, more ruthless, and politically more savvy men than you, me, Avery, or Jones.

Who would really have thought that someone as extreme as Alex Jones would be on both CNN and the History Channel in the same year?
Sylvia Browne is also on TV a lot, as are any number of goons on reality TV and Jerry Springer, not to mention Larry King Live.

Eccentric people attract attention, and if they are loony enough, ratings. What Jones has not done is translate his appearances into a groundswell movement based on his unasaillable grasp of facts and well reasoned, and presented, argument. He has remained in the role of eccentric, and moonbat, to the detriment of his cause. Why? It appears that unlike Woodward and Bernstein, who uncovered a real plot, he hasn't found one, and he can't convince very many people that he has because his facts and arguments don't add up. If he had more meat and less vapor, it would be a different story. That many people think the government hasn't been fully forthcoming (Cover Your Arse is a standard governmental tactic when anything goes wrong, and 9-11 was certainly something going wrong) does not mean that Jones is right.
Both Steven Jones and Dr. Griffin have been interviewed on prime time news networks.
See above. They get their say and when exposed to the full light of public scrutiny, their ability to get support for their position fades. With better facts, and better support for their assertions, you'd see a different result.

If they had the goods, like the folks who investigated the Abu Ghraib matter, or the first reporters to uncover My Lai, they'd be getting better results.

The reason they don't is that their assertions and facts, and arguments, don't add up.

DR
 
Last edited:
The government is not going to indict itself. How ridiculous is it to assume that the gov't is going to pursue an investigation that leads to members within itself.

Considering how many truthers claim that the inside job was so botched that it's "obvious", I wouldn't put it past them.

[Gravy] continues to call the isolated pockets of fire, especially in WTC 7, an inferno.

There's a very good reason for that: it was an inferno. It certainly wasn't "isolated pockets" since the firefighters knew in advance that the building was going to collapse. Unless you're going to claim that they are in on this conspiracy, that means that the fires (and previous damage) compromised the building's integrity in a visible way.

To use your helpful description of "heavy" and "lite" researchers, simply replace "Truther" with "OCT," and we might agree that this is also accurate.

I'd think this is clever if I were 5.

Asking questions didn't seem to bother Socrates or Plato.

Yeah, but they weren't scientists, were they ?

"But other than that you had fires burning a long time without fire department intervention. And firefighters were in that building."

When were firefighters in 7 WTC ??

If it was an inferno, as the doctor suggests, where are the photographs of it?

"If a meteor crashed in Tunguska, where are the photographs of it?"
 
By the year 2026 when all classified information from the day of 911 becomes public record, we will have a much clearer picture of who's in error.
Just like when the JFK files were declassified and we learned the identity of the gunmen on the grassy knoll and what make of rifle they used. :rolleyes:
 
I've split out some uncivil posts to AAH. Please get back on topic. My apologies that some of the last few posts contain quotes that have been moved, but the bulk of the posts were ok to stay.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero
 
Pardalis,
To answer your question, do I ever consider that I may be wrong. Yes I do. And if fact I hope I am.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom