Truthers: How would you run an investigation?

The truthers would use the Bush administration method.

Decide on the cause, then find evidence to support it, don't look for any which doesn't.
 
Bump for HereticHulk:

More assertions of LIHOP. We need a new investigation. It looks like there is an initiative to get a vote on whether or not a new investigation of 9/11 should take place. NYC 911 Ballot Initiative would appear on the Nov 6th 2008 General Election ballot.

Here is a link to the instruction for completing the petition for NY'ers wanting to do so.

Given that we've rolled over a whole page with silliness waiting for someone who wants a new investigation to post, here's the OP again:

I suppose this is a variation on the "What should an investigation be carried out?" question; but, for the sake of an intellectual exercise I'm proposing that we forget about a lot of the practical obstacles to a new investigation.

Imagine that you are in charge of a new investigation. You can call any witness you like, ask for expert testimony from anybody you want, examine all the physical evidence and records that you like. All questioning would be under oath.

There are some limitations:

1. All witness have the same constitutional rights as they would in a courtroom (including those provided by the Fifth Amendment).

2. You have no special powers to tell if a witness is lying or not.

3. There is nothing currently kept secret that would instantly and explicitly prove an inside job (for example, the unreleased Pentagon video tapes; or some memo that tells the whole story and has been suppressed). For the purposes of this exercise, we have to assume that anything obvious has been kept completely secret and shared only between a small number of conspirators. As soon as orders are passed to a large number of people (NIST, NORAD, the FDNY, field officers of the CIA and FBI, etc) they would have to be constructed in such a way as to not make those people suspicious that they were participating in a terrorist attack against their own people. The same must apply to any information they are made privy to. We have to assume that the number of people who really knew what was happening was small enough to ensure that nobody spilled the beans and that they all had a very good reason for conspiring.

4. You are trying to build a case which will become the basis for a prosecution. Therefore, you can expect all your witnesses to be cross-examined and all your expert testimony to be challenged by other experts. The case that you build will have to convince a jury in the face of the best defence lawyers that money can buy. I don't want to get too far into imagining an actual trial here, but imagine that you would have to use this investigation to produce a report to a prosecutor that would convince them it was worth going to trial.

So, what witnesses do you call? What questions would you ask? What would ask your investigators and experts to look at?

After all that, what do you imagine your case for the prosecution would look like?

Anybody want to take a bash at this?

I'm really not sure what the Truth Movement is expecting from a new investigation.
 
Last edited:
I feel a little foolish saying this, since the topic has pretty well been done to death. Still, here goes.

First, a serious investigation can't be done in the US. Or rather, an investigation accepted as serious by Truthers. And they ought to step up and recognize that. From their perspective, any American panel would be unacceptable. Its political figures (like Kean) would be core members of the American political elite. Its staff members would have to be professional bureaucrats or the like. Its expert witnesses, if they were to be taken seriously by the scientific community, would be unacceptable to the Truther world. The next president will probably be one of 3 or 4 of the present leading candidates.

OK, let's try to move it to another country. Canada? Western Europe, or other traditional allies? Same objections as above. No matter how much things seem to get tense with some countries in this list, their elites and their experts are in 1/ fundamental agreement with the results of the Kean commission, and 2/ in cahoots with the American elites and experts. (Define "cahoots" any way you like, it comes out the same.)

Other countries?? Non-US allies? I don't think even the Iranian government or the Venezuelan is doing more than making vague rambunctious noises. I doubt any country would host it.

OK, try for an "independent" commission. NGO type. Well, where... OK, at a US or foreign university would seem the best bet... But you run into the same problems. Darn those experts. To be taken seriously, you need those political elites (the Keans, the Hamiltons) and those scientific experts.

The only logical conclusion, in my opinion, is that the Truthers should establish a fully independent commission to their own specifications. Chaired by anyone they like, staffed likewise, using their own experts.

Go to it, guys. In the spirit of cooperation I herewith state that I will make a small donation, say the same amount I just gave to Moby7 for Malcolm's award: $25.

In the spirit of "OK, damn it, have your investigation. Here is a small token to encourage you to do it, and go away."

Edit: Maybe Chavez would fund it, if not host it.
 
Last edited:
My question is slightly different: I've assumed that they magically get the funding and legal powers to carry out an investigation from somewhere. I want to know how they imagine such an investigation would proceed.

I agree that asking for a new investigation that is independent of the US government is completely impractical. The NYC proposal is for a $10,000,000/year budget from "private sources" but there is no indication about how this budget could be obtained. Nor is there any indication of the scope of the investigation and when it would be finished.

I think a realistic political aim would be to pick specific issues that are not addressed by the various investigations so far and to lobby Congress to investigate them again.

ETA: I've started a thread about this on the Loose Change Forum:

http://s1.zetaboards.com/LooseChangeForums/topic/69188/
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom