Truther Speaks.............So Nobody listen!!!!

Not necessarily, some of the documents released by NARA explain why some of these reported volumes aren't accurate. See http://media.nara.gov/9-11/MFR/t-0148-911MFR-00138.pdf to begin, and I think there are other Cella/ SEC files there with more information. (Sorry, I'd look myself but I'm horribly busy right now.)

Mike.

I'm willing to fully concede the numbers and the volume. I'll completely and utterly take those numbers.

It still leads to a SO WHAT?

We all know this is part of the attempt to use the "put options" to insinuate that people knew in advance and were using that knowledge to make money. Unfortunately there is no proof. Zip, zilch, nada. Like with almost all truther claims.
 
Mike.

I'm willing to fully concede the numbers and the volume. I'll completely and utterly take those numbers.

It still leads to a SO WHAT?

We all know this is part of the attempt to use the "put options" to insinuate that people knew in advance and were using that knowledge to make money. Unfortunately there is no proof. Zip, zilch, nada. Like with almost all truther claims.
It also greatly expands the list of people "in on it" which makes the lack of evidence and "whistle blowers" even more telling.
 
It also greatly expands the list of people "in on it" which makes the lack of evidence and "whistle blowers" even more telling.

DJ.

Exactly.

And when you read the SEC investigation you see that 95% of all the purchases were through Merryl Lynch based on their own newsletter from 9/9. Go figure.
 
Mike.

I'm willing to fully concede the numbers and the volume. I'll completely and utterly take those numbers.

It still leads to a SO WHAT?
Well, yes - I guess I was responding to the idea that these figures are "true" and "accurate". The SEC memo explains why they're exaggerated, which matters because the numbers are really all the truthers have.

But you're right, though, from a debating point of view that's something of a diversion. It's a bit like the "Popular Mechanics" thread: we could get into (and have, actually) a semantic debate over what this or that sentence means, but if the issue doesn't lead anywhere then there really isn't any point.

And actually I think the truthers know that, too. The September 10th AMR puts are supposedly the best example of "inside knowledge", but NARA told us months ago who was responsible for the tip: Steve Sarnoff & his newsletter. What have truthers done, now they have his name? Nothing, from what I can see, perhaps because they realise he just might have the resources to make them pay if they start libelling him as gaining financial advantage from mass murder.
 
That' s a very hard question, At first, I used to say that they did do it on purpose for the money. But then I thought, would the government really kill thousands of people for billions. I wouldn't like to think of it that way, and according to many people, its seems ridiculous. Very simple concept and has been human nature, but I then I thought, No. Because the Government just let this slip through the cracks for the mere fact that they didn't take it as a serious threat, and didn't want to say that the most terrible day in America could of been prevented.


How could it have been prevented?
Would you ground every plane in the country?
Would you have profiled for muslim terrorist?
Please state just how this could have been prevented!
Short of having air marshals on every plane with orders to shoot and kill I dont see how it could of been stopped!
 
Sure - from snopes.com:

On 6 and 7 September 2001, the Chicago Board Options Exchange handled 4,744 put options for United Airlines' stock, translating into 474,000 shares, compared with just 396 call options, or 39,600 shares. On a day that the put-to-call ratio would normally have been expected to be roughly 1:1 (no negative news stories about United had broken), it was instead 12:1.

On 10 September 2001, another uneventful news day, American Airlines' option volume was 4,516 puts and 748 calls, a ratio of 6:1 on yet another day when by rights these options should have been trading even. No other airline stocks were affected; only United and American were shorted in this fashion.
​

Koodos on having a go, unfortunately the numbers, as Mike pointed out are inaccurate, and as Snopes itself pointed out, they have been verified as having nothing to do with 9/11 other than their timing. You can still try and come up with something that is verifiably connected to 9/11 if you wish though.
 
Mostly the date, number of people killed and the location of the attacks.

You are going to think that I'm making this up, but I swear to you that it is true.

EIGHT YEARS after 9/11, bill smith, after arguing it 6 days a week for over a year, could not accurately locate WTC7 on a map of the WTC complex.

After being told repeatedly where it was, he insisted that The Winter Gardens was really WTC7.

"5%" may be optimistic...

Tom
 
You are going to think that I'm making this up, but I swear to you that it is true.

EIGHT YEARS after 9/11, bill smith, after arguing it 6 days a week for over a year, could not accurately locate WTC7 on a map of the WTC complex.

After being told repeatedly where it was, he insisted that The Winter Gardens was really WTC7.

"5%" may be optimistic...

Tom

We have also had a poster here get the date wrong.
 
You are going to think that I'm making this up, but I swear to you that it is true.

EIGHT YEARS after 9/11, bill smith, after arguing it 6 days a week for over a year, could not accurately locate WTC7 on a map of the WTC complex.

After being told repeatedly where it was, he insisted that The Winter Gardens was really WTC7.

"5%" may be optimistic...

Tom
Bill's a "special" case. I seriously doubt he/she (yes it's believed by some Bill is a she) believes any of the things he/she says. I think he/she just likes to argue for kicks (or is very bored).
 
Last edited:
My theory about bs being 4 drunk German college students on a blackberry has yet to be disproven.
 
Bill's a "special" case. I seriously doubt he/she (yes it's believed by some Bill is a she) believes any of the things he/she says. I think he/she just likes to argue for kicks (or is very bored).

My theory about bs being 4 drunk German college students on a blackberry has yet to be disproven.


I will not hear anything bad spoken about The Greatest Performance Artist Of Our Time!

I will not!
 
You are going to think that I'm making this up, but I swear to you that it is true.

EIGHT YEARS after 9/11, bill smith, after arguing it 6 days a week for over a year, could not accurately locate WTC7 on a map of the WTC complex.

After being told repeatedly where it was, he insisted that The Winter Gardens was really WTC7.

"5%" may be optimistic...

Tom

I'm looking forward to Vivalenses' answer though. I'm sure we all are...http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5580134&postcount=95 hyperlink
 
Last edited:
So when you were a Truther presumably you. like every other Truther alive thought that WTC7 was a controlled demolition.

What made you change your mind about WTC7 ?

The controlled demolition theory seemed to far-fetched. A lot of explosives are needed in order to collapse buildings, and to "sneak" them in at the base of the building without anybody noticing, or finding anything suspicious, seems a bit odd and quite impossible to do.

But To get in more specifics, many people seem to underestimate the Damage that WTC7 actually had. Stating that WTC7 had very minor damage, therefore, it is impossible for it to had collapse. But in reality, about one third of the face to the center (and about 25 percent of the depth of the building) had been critically damaged. Along with intense fires and these structural damages, it caused what I believe is defined as a "progressive collapse."

Another thing that I dont want to send on this reply as a fact, is that I believe that WTC7 had some unusual structural designs in the columns. I heard this awhile back, so if somebody wants to shed some light on this, by all means go ahead. But im saying right now, im not sure if this is a fact.
 
Last edited:
How could it have been prevented?
Would you ground every plane in the country?
Would you have profiled for muslim terrorist?
Please state just how this could have been prevented!
Short of having air marshals on every plane with orders to shoot and kill I dont see how it could of been stopped!

Well, after much discussion, I came to the conclusion that it could of been prevented, but it was all at hand sight 20-20.
 
Well, after much discussion, I came to the conclusion that it could of been prevented, but it was all at hand sight 20-20.

I agree that it could have been prevented, but hindsight really is 20/20.

Had the CIA, NSA, and FBI freely communicated instead of seeing each other as opponents and being bound up in red tape about who and how they could communicate and so just not doing so at all then they would likely have picked up the connections between Khalad al-Mihdhar and Nawaf Hazmi and Al Qaeda. They would have been able to track them down faster, or even have prevented their entry into the US.

Had Immigration had the right of search when dealing with overstayers, then they would have found the e-mails on Zacarias Moussaoui's laptop and connected the dots based on them. Even if the courts had allowed the FBI to look at them this might have been found in time.

Had the FBI paid more attention to its field agents and not been so over worked, they might have actually read the memo that recommended checking flight schools for Muslim Extremists and thus located Atta, Jarrah, Hanjour, and Shehhi before they finished up.

Having said that, Al Qaeda did send more opperatives than they managed to get into the country. they had aound another 10 people that were rejected for Visas or turned back at the border, mostly Yemanese and mostly because Immigration was worried they were planning to be illegal migrants.

On the day, the only possible thing that could have been changed was having Fighters get to NYC before Flight 175. Had NEADS found Flight 11, or launched without it eariler (they did so in the end anyway) perhaps because NYATCC had told Boston ATCC that the hijack they were working was 175 and not 11, then had NYATC allowed the fighters into the NYC airspace faster, they might have been in position before 175 got there, though since most believed that 11 was still an accident and there was no shoot down order and the planes were unarmed, it's doubtful they could have done much but watch.

Other things that might have saved lives would be like having not had the WTC Tower roof doors locked. This was done after '93 in case Terrorists landed on the roof, and many have said that it would have been near impossible to land a chopper on the roof on 9/11 due to the heat and smoke, but it may have saved lived.

Unfortunately we really only know these things after the fact....
 
Last edited:
Here you go: http://www.snopes.com/rumors/putcall.asp

I'm not "quote mining" anything - the volume numbers are verifiable facts, as requested.

Here is part of the article that you initially tried to hide:

further investigation has revealed that the trading had no connection with 9/11. A single U.S.-based institutional investor with no conceivable ties to al Qaeda purchased 95 percent of the UAL puts on September 6 as part of a trading strategy that also included buying 115,000 shares of American on September 10. Similarly, much of the seemingly suspicious trading in American on September 10 was traced to a specific U.S.-based options trading newsletter, faxed to its subscribers on Sunday, September 9, which recommended these trades.



You lied when you said you didn't quote-mine.
 
Bill's a "special" case. I seriously doubt he/she (yes it's believed by some Bill is a she) believes any of the things he/she says. I think he/she just likes to argue for kicks (or is very bored).

Or is in dire need of attention.
 
While we're talking put options, and because no-one else mentions this, here's the newsletter alert that recommended people buy American Airlines puts:

September 9, 2001
Vol. 12, No. 28

Stocks Skid On A Jump In The Jobless Rate. This Week, We Take To The Air

This past week, stocks were pressed to the downside -- with the highlight being Friday's blue chip decline. Wall Street was surprised by a spike, to a four-year high, in the jobless rate. And the market took its lumps. This week, I see opportunity for you to have fun and profit with an airline play. So, without further ado, here's…

This Week's Option Recommendation

Buy the AMR October $30 put for $170, or less, good this week.

Shares of AMR Corp. trade on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol "AMR". The symbol for this option reco is "AMRVF". American Airlines closed the week at $30.15. The 52-week range for AMR is $27.62-$43.93. My downside price target is $22-$26.

The major airline is under pressure. At $25, each $30 put would have $500 of intrinsic value. If AMR is at or above $30 on the third Friday in October, your option will expire worthless. That is your risk. Set your stop-loss at $100, to preserve capital, in case my expectations go awry.

That's buy the AMR October $30 put for $170, or less, good this week.
(No reference link as it's not available online.)

That was the view of Steve Sarnoff, editor of the Options Hotline. Perhaps one day truthers will tell us whether they think he was lying. And if the answer is "no", then cross this particular trade off the "suspect" list.
 
Bill's a "special" case. I seriously doubt he/she (yes it's believed by some Bill is a she) believes any of the things he/she says. I think he/she just likes to argue for kicks (or is very bored).

It is quite possible that Bill Smith also shares the same top draw as Dr Judy. Right next to the knickers/briefs.

Bill transforms once in a while to come here and sprout about beam rays being directed from outerspace and into the arial masts on the WTC buildings then being dissipated down the columns to melt them. The airplanes didnt exist or where holgrams - but Bill wont be drawn on that as he/she is just asking questions and wanting to know the truth.

Ya couldnt make it up! COULD YA?:jaw-dropp
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom