Pete Hegseth
@PeteHegseth
Stop quoting laws to MEN WITH SWORDS.
Quote
Department of State
@StateDept
SECRETARY RUBIO: Earlier this year, President Trump made the unprecedented decision to sanction the fake International Criminal Court. A fake court, which is an unelected world tribunal which claims to supersede the laws and constitutions of sovereign states, even those who never signed up for it.
Link
No it doesn't.
What tribunals or courts are elected?
The ICC only has jurisdiction in countries who are ICC members. It is true that US citizens who commit crimes in other countries are subject to the jurisdiction of other countries and that may ultimately include the ICC. It does not supersede the laws and constitutions of sovereign states, since it is only has jurisdiction when countries have agreed to having jurisdiction. The ICC will only investigate when national courts are unable to hear cases.
An example would be a crime by a member of the IDF in Palestine or Gaza (signatories to the ICC, so allowing ICC jurisdiction), where Israel failed to extradite the accused, or failed to investigate, or failed to prosecute where there was a prima facie case. Arguably Hesgeth would be subject to ICC jurisdiction for persons he ordered killed on the high seas contrary to international maritime law (which the US is a signatory to), international humanitarian law and laws of war, but only if the persons killed were citizens of an ICC member state or the vessel attacked was flagged to an ICC member state giving those countries jurisdiction. But only if the US failed to investigate etc. e.g. if he was granted a presidential pardon. What couldn't happen is the ICC becoming involved in persons killed or detained by ICE agents as this is under the jurisdiction of a non-ICE member state.
Effectively the ICC is no different in its jurisdiction from any other court of a foreign nation. It functions where no national court can, because of will, or because (e.g. Venezuela or Palestine) it is under occupation or the military control of another country, or the accused is too powerful for a fair trial in the nation with jurisdiction. Israel might argue that Netanyahu wouldn't get a fair trial for war crimes before a Palestinian court (just as it could be argued Palestinians wouldn't get a fair trial before an Israeli military court where neither they nor their lawyers are allowed to know the evidence against them), so an international court can ensure a fair trial.
It is also true that the ICC only prosecutes the most serious of crimes, it wouldn't become involved in a robbery.
The extra-territoriality claim is odd coming from a country that appears to feel it can invade foreign countries kidnap the head of state, kidnap people off the streets in foreign countries, torture them and detain them without trial, particularly when the vast majority of the victims of US extra-territoriality are innocent.