Trump and the use of Nazi/fascist imagery

*Cough* Critical Social Justice is all about this. The new definition of racism anybody?
I have no idea what you mean here.

OK. So it would be OK to be a Western Chauvinist, you just don't think they are?
There is no such thing as a "Western Chauvinist" - is that more clear? Some racists call themselves a fancy name.

OK, but you said that the Proud Boys were White Supremacist racists, and I was asking you how you account for their leader being Afrocuban and them having black members? This seems like an odd thing for white supremacists to do.
If a gay man takes a female date to an event, does that make him heterosexual?
 
Or are you saying that they don't actually think this and are really white supremacists? If it's the second thing, why the afrocuban leader and black members?

" McInnes said, "I love being white and I think it's something to be very proud of. I don't want our culture diluted. We need to close the borders now and let everyone assimilate to a Western, white, English-speaking way of life."

Gavin McInnes, founder of the Proud Boys.
 
Well, at least you have a theory under which the $88 baseball makes some arguable sense. I'm a little doubtful that any political science professor would find chasing the marginal neo-Nazi vote a tactic likely to result in victory, but maybe you argue that Trump doesn't listen to political science professors anyway.

I would argue that because he unambiguously has a history of giving shout-outs to white supremacists, the question of his motives would be best directed at him.
 
Because I don't think he is. This view that there are enough white supremacists, in the classical sense, rather than the "All White People" sense, for anybody running for president to care about reaching out to seems paranoid to me to the point of being almost incomprehensible. I don't like not being able to empathise with somebody elses point of view to this degree, so it interests me.

Do you acknowledge that Trump has given white supremacists a platform or is that part and parcel of your denial?
 
Because I don't think he is. This view that there are enough white supremacists, in the classical sense, rather than the "All White People" sense, for anybody running for president to care about reaching out to seems paranoid to me to the point of being almost incomprehensible. I don't like not being able to empathise with somebody elses point of view to this degree, so it interests me.

That you don't think he's racist is abundantly clear.
I don't think that Trump is 'reaching out' to racists necessarily intentionally but I do think he does personally care if they do support him (although he'd never admit this publicly). All he cares about are their votes
.

There are many examples of Trump's racism and bigotry that have been provided in this very forum by me and others: removal of black employees from the floor of his casinos when he was there, the comments about only wanting "the guys with yarmulkes" counting his money, the illegal barring of "coloreds" from his apartment building, wanting a "Muslim ban", and his latest excuse that police kill more white people than blacks despite blacks being killed 3.5X more per population percentage.

You can hand wave all this away as not evidence of his racism and bigotry but in the words of Gov. De Santis you "just don't want to recognize it because it challenges (youe) narrative."

Are you claiming that thinking the cultural tradition that goes through the Reformation, the Enlightenment, the Industrial Revolution and so on isn't something that one could subjectively feel is superior and should be celebrated and defended without being racist? Or are you saying that they don't actually think this and are really white supremacists?

Of course not. But that is not the point because The Proud Boys are racist. As their founder, Gavin McInness, said:

“I love being white and I think it's something to be very proud of. I don't want our culture diluted. We need to close the borders now and let everyone assimilate to a Western, white, English-speaking way of life.”

If that's not racist, I don't know what is. Perhaps you do?

If it's the second thing, why the afrocuban leader and black members?

Because there will always be those who, for whatever emotional/psychological reasons, support things that are inherently against their own interests. There are a lot of women who believe that women should always defer to men. Fundamentalist Mormon women believe men are totally in charge and can marry as many women as they want and the "Prophet" can take a woman from her husband and give her to another man. There was Vital Hasson, a Greek Jew, who hunted down Jewish refugees for the Nazis despite being a Jew himself. He was later executed for his role in the murder of thousands of fellow Jews.

You might find this interesting reading. The Proud Boys are discussed:

Why Young Men of Color Are Joining White-Supremacist Groups
 
I love how the defense is "No we're pretending to be racist because it's funny."

Scrap all the layers off it you want, you can't be evil ironically.
 
I love how the defense is "No we're pretending to be racist because it's funny."

Scrap all the layers off it you want, you can't be evil ironically.

We may have all misjudged Hitler.

Perhaps he was just playing a very elaborate prank.
 
I love how the defense is "No we're pretending to be racist because it's funny."

Scrap all the layers off it you want, you can't be evil ironically.



There are so many layers of irony in the red pill / white nationalist communities. They put the clown nose on and take it off and it’s all a joke when convenient. They are all like that guy in tropic thunder - a non-nazi playing a nazi, who is only making Holocaust denial jokes and sharing Pepe memes as a joke. Ha ha.
 
Pushing the racist/fascist Overton window by pretending it's all in jest is explicitly part of the alt-/far-right playbook.

This is not a joke, it's a strategy.
And Trump is a big part of it.
 
It is a joke sign. They know people like you will claim to interpret it like this and they think it is hilarious.

I know the history of the sign. The article I linked to even goes in to it.

I suppose the question is whether chummily sitting with members of a violent white power hate group and flashing a sign as a joke because it is a trolling in-joke amongst white supremacists is actually any better than chummily sitting with members of a violent white power hate group and flashing a white supremacist sign in a manner that is sincere. You're free to make that case, if you want.
 
Last edited:
I'm happy to agree some of it is probably this. For the sake of argument, I'm happy to suppose all of it is.

"Ha! Look at those libs! They think we're Nazis because we keep using Nazi imagery, hang out with Nazis, and say and do racist things! Triggered! Lol!"

I wonder at what point it'll occur to them that if they're not actually racists that these jokes might be something of a self-own?
 
There are so many layers of irony in the red pill / white nationalist communities. They put the clown nose on and take it off and it’s all a joke when convenient. They are all like that guy in tropic thunder - a non-nazi playing a nazi, who is only making Holocaust denial jokes and sharing Pepe memes as a joke. Ha ha.

Yes, this is exactly how it works, and why memes have been such a good recruiting tool for the far-right. You say and do racist things ironically, but is it really ironic? 'course it is. Except, you know...maybe it isn't? But it totally is. Although perhaps not always...?

It's like those videos of people bullying other people and then excusing it by saying "it's just a prank, bro!"
 
There are so many layers of irony in the red pill / white nationalist communities. They put the clown nose on and take it off and it’s all a joke when convenient. They are all like that guy in tropic thunder - a non-nazi playing a nazi, who is only making Holocaust denial jokes and sharing Pepe memes as a joke. Ha ha.

Trolling and "owning" the other side has become so common on the internet that I don't doubt a good number of people are doing exactly that. It's become hard to distinguish the genuine article from the imitator.
 
I know the history of the sign. The article I linked to even goes in to it.

I suppose the question is whether chummily sitting with members of a violent white power hate group and flashing a sign as a joke because it is a trolling in-joke amongst white supremacists is actually any better than chummily sitting with members of a violent white power hate group and flashing a white supremacist sign in a manner that is sincere. You're free to make that case, if you want.

Exactly.
 
Hey preaching to the choir. I've been on team "I don't give a flying rat's rectum if you're honest, a troll, or a Poe" for a while. That distinction being this uber-important thing that we simply must acknowledge has always be coming from other sources.

But I have an "Action and their results" based view on morality. Like I've said I don't care if you're crapping in the salad bar because you're an evil psychopath, an ironic troll, somehow trying to create the paradox of being an ironic troll but doing that ironically, a nihilistic jerktard trying to show up people who are being "too dramatic" about you crapping in the salad bar, some kind of performance art piece about society's complicated relationship with crapping in salad bars, or suffer from irritable bowel syndrome and your crippling social anxiety prevents you from popping anywhere else.... there's still chunks of feces in my Waldorf.
 
Yes, this is exactly how it works, and why memes have been such a good recruiting tool for the far-right. You say and do racist things ironically, but is it really ironic? 'course it is. Except, you know...maybe it isn't? But it totally is. Although perhaps not always...?

It's like those videos of people bullying other people and then excusing it by saying "it's just a prank, bro!"

That's pretty much the life cycle of fascists throughout history. They're insincere and evasive until they have power and don't have to play games anymore.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom