Cont: Trans Women are not Women II: The Bath Of Khan

Status
Not open for further replies.
If this is true, then the Russians and the Chinese are going to dominate all the women's events within a few olympiads. Not that Europe and the Americas won't try. I just don't think that even modern western wokeness can compete with good old fashioned national chauvinism.


I understand the South Africans have employed a coach to scout for intersex babies being brought up as girls who might have potential as top athletes because they're really biologically male. Like Caster Semenya. (In countries with better neonatal care such infants would be brought up as boys these days.) They might as well call off the hunt because it will be much easier just to "persuade" a few second-string men to transition.

I'm not going to predict which countries are going to be at the forefront of this, but women's sports are going to be a thing of the past. In the name of the great God "inclusion", women will be excluded from their own events.
 
Interesting stories. I'm glad to hear that creepy JY lost her lawsuit and has been ordered to pay three of the defendants.

Here's another story though:

YouTuber ContraPoints Attacked After Including Controversial Buck Angel in Video

ContraPoints is a youtube channel I recently started watching. It's videos produced by a trans woman named Natalie Wynn. She has help, and her videos tend to have pretty good production values for YouTube. I guess she's a bit controversial in the trans community, however.

YouTuber Natalie "Contrapoints" Wynn is currently embroiled in a wave of dissent and harassment after her newest video featured Buck Angel, a controversial figure in the transgender and nonbinary community.

By featuring Angel, some online have accused Wynn of enabling his exclusionary ideology, going so far as to label her as a "truscum" or "transmedicalist," which are people who believe gender transitioning through medical means is the only way to be considered transgender.

I looked up these terms:
truscum (plural truscum) (slang, usually derogatory) A person (often transgender) who adheres to a strict medical definition of transgenderism/transsexuality and believes that gender dysphoria is an essential trait.
Transmedicalism is a term for a wide range of beliefs in the transsexual community that are critical of transgender people who are not, or do not desire to be, transsexual.

(Having watched many of Wynn's videos, I don't think either of these terms applies to her beliefs. Perhaps they do apply to Buck Angel; I don't know what his beliefs are.)
 
They've certainly been calling Buck Angel a TERF.

I don't think Buck Angel is terribly bright. She was doing her usual "tranpa" thing, sage advice to young women wanting to transition, and she came across some TRA stuff she (quite rightly) recognised as harmful and said so. I just happened to read her twitter timeline at that point. She was completely taken aback by the vitriolic backlash that came at her, and didn't know how to deal with it. Last seen trying some sort of damage limitation, who me I'm a real trans ally of course I am, without much sign of understanding what was going on or analysing the situation. Well-meaning, quite sweet really, but not smart.
 
If this is true, then the Russians and the Chinese are going to dominate all the women's events within a few olympiads. Not that Europe and the Americas won't try. I just don't think that even modern western wokeness can compete with good old fashioned national chauvinism.


You think China may be testing the boundaries with this one?

Women’s 400m runners go viral on Chinese social media ‘for looking like men’
They were part of the 4x400m relay and their Hunan team strolled to gold by almost three seconds. Liao also won the 400m with Tong taking bronze.
Their 400 meter times are still slower than the minimum for the Olympics.
aN0Z4Q3_460s.jpg

rue042107c08e.jpg
 
You think China may be testing the boundaries with this one?


Oh, I rather think so, don't you? I saw that at the time on Twitter and without getting into the detail of that debate. I mean, come ON. Only one of these people looks like someone devoid of an SRY gene, to my eye (and most other people's eyes too, as I recall).
 
Last edited:
Oh, I rather think so, don't you? I saw that at the time on Twitter and without getting into the detail of that debate. I mean, come ON. Only one of these people looks like someone devoid of an SRY gene, to my eye (and most other people's eyes too, as I recall).

I saw that the state-run China Peoples Daily followed the reactions to the photo and asked what people thought about it. Sounded like an informal poll on public opinion.
Hard to believe there was even debate on it. Quite bold of them really.

In the end, China sent a traditional 'conforming' team to represent in Doha for a spot in Tokyo 2020 (which they fumbled badly)

[
05b729df5eb53804aaba0546f7b30381
 
I see two men and two women. They are all allegedly women?

Yes. From a facebook post by People's Daily, China:

A picture of 4 athletes, who won the Women's 4x400 Relay at the annual Chinese Athletics Championships, has become a trending topic on Chinese social media. The gender of 2 athletes in Hunan team, Liao and Tong (in the middle of the first pic), was called into question. Lots of netizens say judging from how they look or how they speak it’s hard to tell that Liao and Tong are women. The Chinese Athletic Association later announced that both athletes are women. What’s your take on this?
 
I see two men and two women. They are all allegedly women?


Look closer. Three men and one woman.

However, since it has been the stated position of many in this thread, and it is the legal position in countries such as Canada, that any man who says he is a woman, or feels like a woman in his head (whatever the hell a woman feels like, how would I know) is literally actually a woman, this is going to be an interesting point to argue.
 
Last edited:
The person on the far right of the photograph looks like a woman to me.

The person on the far right looks ambiguous to me. Put the face on a female body and I could believe it's just a masculine looking woman. Put the face on a male body and I could believe it's just a feminine looking man.

But two of those, yeah.
austin-powers-a-man-baby-300x259.jpg
 
Maybe we're all just bad, sexist people for having sexist assumptions about how a woman should look. Maybe they don't mind being mistaken for men. Maybe they prefer it that way. The Chinese Athletic Association claims that they are indeed both women. Did they clarify that means regular two X chromosomes women? Or did they just say they're women and leave it at that?
 
Look closer. Three men and one woman.

I sorta see what you mean, but the third one's more ambiguous. Most people have focused on just two of them. If I passed them on the street, I wouldn't even wonder. Large heads, square jaws, men's hairstyles, men's-style glasses on one.
 
Maybe we're all just bad, sexist people for having sexist assumptions about how a woman should look. Maybe they don't mind being mistaken for men. Maybe they prefer it that way. The Chinese Athletic Association claims that they are indeed both women. Did they clarify that means regular two X chromosomes women? Or did they just say they're women and leave it at that?

Your question makes me realize that I actually do not know if any 'official' Chinese statement was made. Several reporters and some commenters 'seem' to know they are competing as women and what the Chinese stated.

Maybe the whole thing is a viral hoax to get people to defend actual men, who present fully as men, as women.

Do you read Chinese? haha
 
Your question makes me realize that I actually do not know if any 'official' Chinese statement was made. Several reporters and some commenters 'seem' to know they are competing as women and what the Chinese stated.

Maybe the whole thing is a viral hoax to get people to defend actual men, who present fully as men, as women.

Do you read Chinese? haha

I don't. That's what it says in the article you linked to though. I'm assuming what's being reported is accurate, and not part of any hoax. There's a youtube video of them being interviewed at what looks like a sports stadium. If it's a hoax they really went to a lot of trouble to make everything look very real. I think it's real.

They could just be unusual looking women after all.
 
Quite a good view of the beer belly too. McKinnon is not fit, no matter how much he talks about his training regime and so on. He's flabby. And he's still beating hard-as-nails women who have been doing this sport for many years longer than he has.
 
Quite a good view of the beer belly too. McKinnon is not fit, no matter how much he talks about his training regime and so on. He's flabby. And he's still beating hard-as-nails women who have been doing this sport for many years longer than he has.
Difficult to imagine that "she" has got as far as "she" has without some serious behind-the-scenes greasing of "her" career in the form of directives issued on how it's reported in the corporate media.

As I've said before (yeh, yeh, I know - 'conspiracies' is that-a-way ===>), I perceive a long game, a social engineering project with clear objectives is behind the apparent madness, and this unbelievably shameless ***** is just another tool (knowing or not).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom