Thought experiment: Pearl Harbour as a 9/11 target

In friendly or home port in peacetime a warship is a sitting duck. Crew will be ashore, weapons systems will be stood down, radar will probably be stood down maybe even most of the ships power will be off line. Engineers tend to fix and maintain things when in port, that's when you don't need them. I know if we were alongside we would operate off shore power and water when we could so work could be done.
I wasn't on a Carrier but I know we never had any live weapon systems in peacetime unless we were going into firing exercises.
If we got an Air Alert alongside in peacetime I reckon it would have taken anywhere up to half an hour to get the power up, round up a crew, get the Ops room on line, get ammunition or missiles up from the magazine. That's if we didn't have lumps of the ship in bits with a gang of Tiffs trying to make it work again.
 
Either the plane is on a course to actually hit the ship, or it isn't.

This kind of stuff is the behavior of somebody who has no actual case to make for his/her position and has decided to plug his/her ears and refuse to apply any reasoning.

That is a very ignorant comment. If over a dozen new targets showed up at once, that would bog down a modern military radar system so much that the task of identifying and determining the position and trajectory of all of them (so nobody's sitting around guessing whether they're headed toward the ship because they know) might be slowed down all the way to a couple of seconds.

I have no idea why you feel you have to be so vehement and personalize the discussion. You are wrong, though. You're discussing the capabilities of a carrier group on a war footing. A carrier at rest in a friendly harbor is not nearly the same thing.
 
Carriers are heavily armored both at the waterline, in the hangars and on the flight deck. They are designed to withstand an aircraft loaded with bombs crashing on deck and still survive. They are designed to withstand armed aircraft catching on fire and exploding causing even more aircraft to explode. They are designed to withstand a torpedo attack at sea. They can withstand multiple missile strikes. The weapons that they do have for the aircraft they launch are kept in multiple heavily armored magazines deep in the bowels of the ship until just before they are attached to the aircraft and even the elevators for them (also heavily armored) have multiple "Airlock" type areas to contain any accidental detonations in any one area from spreading to another.

Like all naval ships and shore commands the USN has a policy of neither confirming nor denying the presence of nuclear weapons even on ships clearly designed for them as a primary mission (SSBNs) and their support facilities. All that they will say is whether or not a ship or platform is capable of utilizing those weapons. That being said the navy has stated that it is not now, nor has it been since the mid 90's, a standard practice for ships to be nuclear armed (excepting SSBNs) even when the capabilities exist. From that I can surmise that the odds are low that any given carrier would be carrying nuclear weapons although you can't rule it out as a possibility.

That being said the safety devices on nuclear weapons are such that the odds of a nuclear detonation in port from any type of terrorist attack on any ship carrying them are so unlikely that it's not even worth discussing any further. The main worry would be sympathetic detonation of the conventional HE used in the weapon and the spread of localized contamination that would follow.

Due to design considerations (mainly weight) the reactors are centered both longitudinally and athwart ship, which is also where the ships are the most heavily armored (and would be true even if there were no reactors on board) because that's the most likely place far any weapon to be aimed and have the best chance of a hit. The shielding used to contain the reactors would also help to minimize any damage to the cores if an attack got through the thick armor of the hull.

All US warships in US ports come in unarmed (meaning the major weapon systems are shut down) and for safety reason certain cables are kept disconnected to prevent accidental weapon discharges (this may have changed since 9/11 but I don't think that they have unless a credible threat is known in advance). That means that they are essentially unprepared to defend against any threat greater than repelling boarders and other internal security threats.

Additionally every naval ship in port on a visit will, as a general rule, only have enough people on duty to get her out to sea and safely navigate (they also double as the security forces and the damage control teams). Everyone else is out on shore doing whatever it is that they are doing to have some fun so there's very little possibility of killing thousands of the crew in port even if for some reason an attack is extraordinarily successful in causing catastrophic damage. Any attack would have a very narrow window limited to just after it pulled in to just before it pulled back out if the goal was to kill sailors.

What all of that boils down to is that while a carrier in Pearl Harbor could have been a target on 9/11 the odds of the attacks being catastrophic are slim to none. Yes the ship would be out of commission for awhile. Yes there would probably be crew casualties and perhaps that number might reach into the hundreds including injuries to the people fighting the casualty. But as a terrorist target for that type of attack it's much better prepared than the Pentagon was or ever will be and as has been mentioned above it's a valid military target which would most certainly lessen any rage or fears of the public at large when compared to a purely civilian target like the World Trade Center.
 
to see what modern Carrier can survive look Here, USS Forrestal

The Forrestall fire was used to identify weaknesses and to fix them. Carriers built since then are even more robust and the ones that were in service at the time of that casualty have been modernized with that incident in mind (or decommissioned). But yeah, that's a good example of how tough carriers can be to sink.

From a military standpoint simply putting one out of commission for an extended period is usually considered just as good as a kill but from a terrorist's point of view anything less than sinking it wouldn't have as much of an impact on the public as the World Trade Center did.
 
The Forrestall fire was used to identify weaknesses and to fix them. Carriers built since then are even more robust and the ones that were in service at the time of that casualty have been modernized with that incident in mind (or decommissioned). But yeah, that's a good example of how tough carriers can be to sink.

They also learned that laying down a blanket of foam meant you shouldn't use a 2 1/2" hose to wash it away immediately. I remember that footage very well from Fire Fighting School in Norfolk.
 
The Forrestall fire was used to identify weaknesses and to fix them. Carriers built since then are even more robust and the ones that were in service at the time of that casualty have been modernized with that incident in mind (or decommissioned). But yeah, that's a good example of how tough carriers can be to sink.


It also demonstrated again the most vulnerable time for an aircraft carrier: when it has armed and fueled aircraft sitting on the flight deck. (Which had been amply demonstrated 25 years previous at the Battle of Midway.)

A carrier in port is not going to have a lot of armed and fueled aircraft sitting on the flight deck awaiting combat operations.
 
I took the OP to be about the symbolism of the attack as well as the actual damage that could be delivered. As Pearl Harbor was a tactical, but not strategic, victory for Japan that awoke a slumbering giant into decisive action, then the symbolism and impact may not have been what AQ were looking for.
 
I took the OP to be about the symbolism of the attack as well as the actual damage that could be delivered. As Pearl Harbor was a tactical, but not strategic, victory for Japan that awoke a slumbering giant into decisive action, then the symbolism and impact may not have been what AQ were looking for.

A quick note on the "I fear we have awakened a sleeping giant and filled it with a terrible resolve." Yamamoto was dead for about twenty years before he said that. There's no record of it at all prior to the movie "Tora, Tora, Tora". The produced confessed to wanting an upbeat ending for the US audience to exit on.
 
And, don't get me wrong, an aircraft carrier is always most vulnerable while in port. This is because what protects a carrier is a web of other ships and submarines around it. While at sea it also uses it's own airwing to patrol an even larger area. Aside from a few Phalanx cannons an aircraft carrier has no real indigenous self defense capabilities. And those cannons would be of little help against a 777 heading straight for it at 500mph.



Actually I think you'd find a Phalanx CIWS would reduce a B777 to mincemeat pretty rapidly.
 
It seems as though there are differences of opinion on if this is a valid method of attack.

My point is that if it is this easy to sink an aircraft carrier, then someone has really missed a huge contingency. This (to my knowledge) is not one of the hallmarks of the US Navy.

If you can't protect them at Pearl Harbor (or any other place) then they shouldn't be there.



Hang on, are we talking about hitting, or sinking?

If someone flew a commercial airliner into an aircraft carrier there would be very little damage to the ship itself, and there's no way it would sink.

After the USS America (CV66) was decommissioned she was used in 2005 for live-fire tests designed to assess the survivability of future aircraft carriers (no supercarrier had ever been exposed to that sort of direct fire). For four weeks the Navy hammered her with an incessant barrage of different munitions, above and below water, intended to simulate torpedos, cruise missiles, suicide attacks, and so forth. She remained afloat, and after the tests were done had to be scuttled.

The Navy was reportedly quite surprised (and pleased) with how much of a hammering the ship was capable of absorbing.
 
How is the White House protected from this happening?
Big "no-fly" zone, right?

No. And it's not protected.



Shouldn't there always be one in place around such a piece of hardware? Doesn't that just make sense?

Ideally, yes. Practical? No.


I see tinges of cold war error logic in your response Travis (not attributing it to you necessarily), which does make sense. Surely the Russians wouldn't try such a tactic. However, in our post 911 world, shouldn't this be at least on the radar?

Ultimately the cost to society to prevent such an attack is much greater than the cost in the (highly unlikely) event of such an attack happening.



Whom would we retaliate against in a stateless attack?

Iraq... ;)



I initially thought that the most advanced piece of military hardware out there could protect itself from a nut hijacking a 747. Hence, I wasn't concerned. Now, seeing multiple arguments explaining that they can't do so, I wouldn't say I am concerned, just that I find it upsetting that they aren't taken care of better than this.


You're just not paying attention. Of course an aircraft carrier can protect itself from a nut hijacking a 747.

It comes down to the specifics of a given scenario. You didn't just propose an aircraft carrier being attacked by a hijacked airliner. You proposed an aircraft carrier alongside right next to a major international airport. That's not the same thing at all.

If I came around to your house on a hot sunny day while you were home, and saw that all the windows and doors were wide open, would it be fair to conclude that it was impossible for you to protect your house from burglars?

Of course not. You can take measures to secure your house, but those measures have their own negative side effects, so you only take them when they're reasonable measures to take to avoid a threat.

Are you aware that when the Pearl Harbor attack began, many of the ships immediately attempted to head out to sea?

Do you know why that might be? Because a warship in port is extremely vulnerable.

The best way to protect an aircraft carrier from any sort of attack is to not being in dock, which is precisely why they're so seldom in dock. Obviously they sometimes need to be in dock, and when that happens you accept the heightened risk.

You really don't seem to have thought this through at all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom