This is it: Welcome to Teh 28th Diurnal Stundie Awards for 2007!!!

Who was the best of the worst in 2007? Vote now!

  • January: Lyte Trip's see-saw analogy.

    Votes: 30 17.6%
  • February: Killtown's evil faces.

    Votes: 7 4.1%
  • March: Roscoe's eggsperiment.

    Votes: 14 8.2%
  • April: Imstellar28's vacuum implosion.

    Votes: 9 5.3%
  • May: Louder Than Words' arrogance.

    Votes: 4 2.4%
  • June: Craig Ranke CIT's circular logic.

    Votes: 25 14.7%
  • July: Malcolm Kirkman's 'gravity'.

    Votes: 36 21.2%
  • August: Alex Jones' knowledge of history.

    Votes: 6 3.5%
  • September: Terral's ten-foot Pentagon.

    Votes: 9 5.3%
  • October: FadetooBlack's comet-proof towers.

    Votes: 6 3.5%
  • November: C1ph4's true lies.

    Votes: 20 11.8%
  • December: Edward Mitchell's anti-metallurgy.

    Votes: 4 2.4%

  • Total voters
    170
  • Poll closed .
This must have been one of the months when I was too busy to vote. :( The original thread is apparently no longer available, but I'm wondering: is it possible that this person meant to refer to the de Havilland CometWP, a contemporary of the 707? If so this wouldn't even be a nomination-worthy gaffe.

Well he said "passenger jets" and the comets were that too it seems.
 
Ok in the end I had to go with Killtown because P-freakin-Doherty was the voice of reason.:eye-poppi
 
imstellar28 for actually "proving" using "science" that "faster than gravity" falling buildings not only has some resemblance to what actually happened, but was to be expected, because all imploded buildings demonstrate this by design! :jaw-dropp

And he then tops it off by providing an "example" to the poor addle-brained, science-challenged debunkers out there that might be confused by all the science-y talk.

I gotta wonder what the egg-drop contests are like over at Troofer-U's engineering department.
 
I had to go with the see-saw. It was pure genius, especially in context. I don't think you can truly appreciate his comment without seeing his accompanying art work.

And also I nominated it :D

-Gumboot
 
Evidence of deception (by the government) exists. The government's planted evidence was the original deception.

hmm, "evidence" is doing double duty. simplify further and embellish:

The government attempted to deceive us by planting evidence. But I, for one, am not fooled. No siree.


It's worse than that. Going one step back (the first thing I quote above) is closer.

Craig is basically saying that you cannot use evidence to refute his position. His position is that evidence is planted. The evidence you are trying to use against him is also planted, so any attempt to counter him actually strengthens his case.

It's not just a circular argument, it's a circular argument with built-in positive feedback! I've never seen anything like it.


Anyway, I abstain from the Stundies. Craig's entry, though, belongs in logic textbooks. And humour magazines.
 
I hate to pick a favorite because I love them all. Had to go for the eggsperiment though. The thought of simulating the aircraft by hitting the egg tower with a spoon just made me cry from laughter. I'd like to see a youtube vid of someone performing this.
 
This was a tough call. Each and every entry is a master piece, an absolute gem. It is difficult to cast only one vote when faced with such a choice.

I went for July, simply because it made me laugh the most.
 
Question: I know I should remember this, but was Lyte Trip Craig Ranke
Yes.

This must have been one of the months when I was too busy to vote. :( The original thread is apparently no longer available, but I'm wondering: is it possible that this person meant to refer to the de Havilland Comet, a contemporary of the 707?
Unfortunately, no.
 
I had to go with the see-saw. It was pure genius, especially in context. I don't think you can truly appreciate his comment without seeing his accompanying art work.

And also I nominated it :D

-Gumboot

Where is that picture??? I tried to track it down for the thread, but couldn't find it...
 
Has to be the see saw. And your work throughout last year has been appreciated moby.

Thanks. It looks at this early stage as though Craig "Lyte Trip" Ranke is going to win the award...I wonder if maybe the truthers just don't care as much if the quality has gone down throughout the year. The other alternative I can think of is that they got smarter, and, well...

Does anyone know a way to contact Steve S? No response to my PM, and I'm waiting on the final version of the year end award!
 
In my heart they are all winners, so I took the only sensible option and went for the Donkey Vote. No 1 for me. Lyte Trip's see saw analogy (although I always thought you Yanks called it a Teeter-Totter, I guess not everything on The Brady Bunch was true either).
 
It can be called either see-saw or teeter-totter.

At least, here in Canada it can be....
 
It's either see-saw or teeter-totter in the US as well.

I ended up going with the circular logic argument; there are simply not words to describe the level of brain cells I feel like I lost just trying to comprehend that statement.
 
I sure hope the word "diurnal" in the thread title is a deliberate injection of a little Stundie spirit into the topic, rather than an actual (minor) Stundie in itself.

Do votes cast at night count?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
I also went for Craig's circular logic. Not only is it a perfect example of Bad Reasoning, the language really adds that je ne sais quoi with a cherry on top.

It's as if he were channelling Donald Rumsfeld and Sir Humphrey Appleby at the same time. :)
 
I also went for Craig's circular logic. Not only is it a perfect example of Bad Reasoning, the language really adds that je ne sais quoi with a cherry on top.

It's as if he were channelling Donald Rumsfeld and Sir Humphrey Appleby at the same time. :)
Sir Humphrey would have thrown a "slippery slope" reference in there somewhere.
 
I sure hope the word "diurnal" in the thread title is a deliberate injection of a little Stundie spirit into the topic, rather than an actual (minor) Stundie in itself.

Do votes cast at night count?

Respectfully,
Myriad

Only if you fill in the vampire exclusion form VMP01B.

On another note, Kirkman is catching up to Lyte...excitement, eh?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom