Third-Graders renact the Holocaust (Washingtion Post)

Graham2001

Graduate Poster
Joined
Aug 19, 2006
Messages
1,771
This appeared in the Washington Post.


A Watkins Elementary School staff member told third-graders in library class to reenact scenes from the Holocaust, directing them to dig their classmates’ mass graves and simulate shooting the victims, according to an email from the school’s principal. The instructor was placed on leave Friday.


She allegedly assigned specific roles to students. She cast one student as Adolf Hitler, according to an email from Watkins Elementary School Principal MScott Berkowitz to the third-graders’ parents. He did not name the staff member. That student is Jewish, according to the parent of a student who was asked to participate. At the end of the exercise, the child was told to pretend to commit suicide, as Hitler did.





Originally, the students were in library class on Friday for a self-directed project they would present to their classmates before winter break. But the instructor had students participate in the reenactment during their allotted research time, Berkowitz wrote to parents.


...


The instructor allegedly made antisemitic comments during the reenactment. The parent said that when the children asked why the Germans did this, the staff member said it was “because the Jews ruined Christmas.”


https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2021/12/19/holocaust-reenactment-watkins-school-dc/


Note, this is the least inflamatory version of this story.
 
Jesus mother of ****.

I'd seen the headline kicking around and figured this was another brainless attempt at a "living history" assignment or lesson, but it wasn't even that. The children were in the school library for a completely unrelated reason and it sounds like a staffer in the library (or something?) just came up from out of nowhere and started making them do this.
 
Jesus mother of ****.

I'd seen the headline kicking around and figured this was another brainless attempt at a "living history" assignment or lesson, but it wasn't even that. The children were in the school library for a completely unrelated reason and it sounds like a staffer in the library (or something?) just came up from out of nowhere and started making them do this.

The story refers to the person as an instructor. A library assistant wouldn't have the authority to tell a class to ignore their teacher's previous instructions.
 
Last edited:
It's librarian Kimberlynn Jurkowski. And she is quite the piece of... work.

According to the second parent, Jurkowski told students that “the reason Germans did this to the Jews was because they stole Christmas.” She then allegedly told students not to tell anyone about the reenactment, according to the parent.

Jurkowski was fired from a job as a school librarian in 2013 after being convicted of fraud in a $24,000 tutoring scam. In 2017 she was stripped of her New Jersey teaching license for a period of three years, due to the conviction. She was also charged with animal cruelty in 2019, after allegedly keeping five dogs outdoors in freezing temperatures, leading to one death.
The Watkins parent said these aspects of the librarian’s past were widely known at the school, including among students. “Everyone knew,” she said. She said she approached the principal with concerns about Jurkowski about a month ago.
 
The story refers to the person as an instructor. A library assistant wouldn't have the authority to tell a class to ignore their teacher's previous instructions.

Wouldn't have the authority - according to whom? Nobody in any context had the "authority" to teach this particular "lesson" to anyone, but someone did anyway.

The practical truth of the matter is any adult school staff member the kids recognize as such really has all the "authority" they need to get a class of third-graders to do pretty much anything that isn't obviously physically dangerous, because they are very young children and they're just going to do what the adult in charge tells them.

In this case, apparently it was the librarian. The class was in the library and not otherwise attended, so they understood that the librarian was in charge and they did what she told them to do.
 
Yeah - I do wish people would use ages.

Mind you - in this case whatever the age this is a "WTF" (What the flipping heck!)

Yeah, it's definitely out of line whatever age the kids, but the younger they are, the more despicable it becomes. That clown should never be allowed near a school again.
 
Yeah. Shocking, but they buried the lead!

At the end of the exercise, the child was told to pretend to commit suicide, as Hitler did.

Hitler only pretended to commit suicide? He could still be out there!
 
Obviously inappropriate and the "Jews ruined Christmas" bit is grounds for immediate termination. That said, I suspect that at least some of the kids got into the part. Is there an 8-year-old boy who hasn't pretended to have been shot or killed some other way so they can do the dramatic death scene? I'm sure I did it a few dozen times.
 
Obviously inappropriate and the "Jews ruined Christmas" bit is grounds for immediate termination. That said, I suspect that at least some of the kids got into the part. Is there an 8-year-old boy who hasn't pretended to have been shot or killed some other way so they can do the dramatic death scene? I'm sure I did it a few dozen times.

We played a game called, "Who died the coolest?" where we'd take turns being "gunned down" by the rest, with all the drama a kid could muster, then we'd vote on, who died the coolest.
 
We played a game called, "Who died the coolest?" where we'd take turns being "gunned down" by the rest, with all the drama a kid could muster, then we'd vote on, who died the coolest.

I was exactly that age when JFK was shot and remember we all tried to imitate Oswald's grimace as Jack Ruby gunned him down. And we all knew what it looked like because we made a collage of photographs from the assassination and the aftermath in our third-grade class.
 
Did the kids have fun?

Parent: Hey Buddy. You seem happy.
Kid: Guess what we did today!?
Parent: Wow, usually extracting what happened is like pulling a tooth. Whatdya do today?
Kid: We did the Holocaust. I dug ditches, Brian was Hitler and he killed himself! But after he killed the Jews for stealing Christmas.
Parent: Finally, they're teaching REAL history. Remember, son, never be ashamed of being white.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom