The Trump Presidency VII

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes. Duties are levied based on the country of origin of the goods, not intervening ports of call.

As an example, I can import lovely Cheshire Cheese from the UK to Canada without paying tariffs, but I cannot sell them in the US without paying a tariff as the goods did not originate in Canada. Simply bringing goods into Canada doesn't make them Canadian.

But more specifically he is saying Mexico and Canada can integrate imported parts into things they manufacture. That is the loophole.
 
It's not a loophole. Every manufacturer uses component from various countries.
 
But more specifically he is saying Mexico and Canada can integrate imported parts into things they manufacture. That is the loophole.

Does any trade treaty have a provision for this?

I must say, this is a rather bizarre description to characterize it as a loophole. It just sounds like how manufacturing works.

ETA:is this about ROO?
 
Last edited:
Yes. Duties are levied based on the country of origin of the goods, not intervening ports of call.

As an example, I can import lovely Cheshire Cheese from the UK to Canada without paying tariffs, but I cannot sell them in the US without paying a tariff as the goods did not originate in Canada. Simply bringing goods into Canada doesn't make them Canadian.

For the person you are responding to:

the current rule for cars requires that 62.5 percent of the value of an imported vehicle must originate in Canada, Mexico, or the United States to be eligible for zero duties

A US Content Requirement in NAFTA Could Hurt Manufacturing
 
Does any trade treaty have a provision for this?

I must say, this is a rather bizarre description to characterize it as a loophole. It just sounds like how manufacturing works.

ETA:is this about ROO?

This is about access to the largest market in the world. We have an agreement with Canada and Mexico that allows other countries we don’t have agreements with access our markets. It’s been huge for the economies of Canada, Mexico and Wall Street. Not so much for Main Street.

Which is why so many are pissed about losing their gravy train.
 

Just a few short years ago, when Republicans were polled, the vast majority of them supported free trade, now the majority do not. Was it some thoughtful reevaluation of the evidence? Nope, just your faith in the Great Pumpkin. You guys are lost and adrift at sea with Trump as your captain.

Why has Trump dominated? Part of it is tribalism. In any tribal war people tend to bury individual concerns and rally to their leader and the party line. As late as 2015, Republican voters overwhelmingly supported free trade. Now they overwhelmingly oppose it. The shift didn’t happen because of some mass reappraisal of the evidence; it’s just that tribal orthodoxy shifted and everyone followed.
--David Brooks
 
This is about access to the largest market in the world. We have an agreement with Canada and Mexico that allows other countries we don’t have agreements with access our markets. It’s been huge for the economies of Canada, Mexico and Wall Street. Not so much for Main Street.

Which is why so many are pissed about losing their gravy train.

That doesn't mean it is a loophole.
 
Just a few short years ago, when Republicans were polled, the vast majority of them supported free trade, now the majority do not. Was it some thoughtful reevaluation of the evidence? Nope, just your faith in the Great Pumpkin. You guys are lost and adrift at sea with Trump as your captain.

I’m guessing you’re wrong about a majority of Repubs not wanting free trade.
 
This is about access to the largest market in the world. We have an agreement with Canada and Mexico that allows other countries we don’t have agreements with access our markets. It’s been huge for the economies of Canada, Mexico and Wall Street. Not so much for Main Street.

Which is why so many are pissed about losing their gravy train.

As far as I can tell, Mexico isn't sending over imported goods. They are taking imports, making something and then exporting what they make. In the absence of their decision to import from there it isn't necessarily clear what would happen. It isn't even clear if there is an injured party here.

ETA: further, it would require looking at the whole picture of the economy to figure out why certain actions are taken. This reminds me of accusations of dumping which economists look into and often find actual reasons for over supply needing to be sold below variable cost.
 
Last edited:
Just a few short years ago, when Republicans were polled, the vast majority of them supported free trade, now the majority do not. Was it some thoughtful reevaluation of the evidence? Nope, just your faith in the Great Pumpkin. You guys are lost and adrift at sea with Trump as your captain.


--David Brooks

I have a different name for it and I'm not the first one to say it: Racist backlash against the Obama era. Those tribal hypocrites are just latching on to the racists because they are GOP conservatives which has been courting single issue voters and ignoring the hypocrisy for decades. There's not a whole lot more thought to it than that.

It's not going to last. Two steps forward, one step back.
 
You brought it up, you do it.

I only mentioned the fact of Obama’s anemic economy, which you can only agree with because it is indisputable.

Sure it's disputable. You brought it up, so you look it up. It was a recovering economy from a debacle stemming back from a decade of mismanagement and misguided ideas about the purity of the banks and financial institutions. Suckled by Bill Clinton (the moderate-conservative) and raised to its ugly maturity under George W. Bush (the conservative-moderate).

Obama was merely its baby-sitter while it was getting its sentencing and probation.
 
One option on these trade questions is to simply trust that Donald Trump knows what's best for the U.S. and would not misrepresent the situation in any way.

Another is to really drill down on the data, down to the literal nuts and bolts, to find out how much a vehicle in the U.S. would cost if the U.S. used only domestic supply chains, certifying that all vehicles in the U.S. contained only U.S.-origin components.

I'm fairly certain that car prices in the U.S. would rise. But that might be offset by other factors and would maybe serve to keep manufacturing in the U.S.

There's no simplified formula; it's something involving trial & error, unless there's shortcut through all these issues that is not widely known.
 
Trump is saying countries who we levy tariffs against can avoid those tariffs by trading through Mexico and Canada. You’re saying that isn’t true?

Not true or not based on fact. I wouldn't put it past Trump to say anything ignorant and this is ignorant.

Goods are not dutiable based on the last country they passed through but on the country of origin, which is a requirement on your customs filing. You cannot buy Chinese-made shirts through a trading company in Toronto and claim them as Canadian origin. It is against the law. Period.
 
CNN just had to do a story about Trump putting the "me" into Memorial Day. Sure, Trump's tweet does show his obsession with himself. But does everything have to be a news story? CNN is unfortunately *enabling* this guy. I think they've gotten a little less blatant lately. Sure, I want to read about it but it doesn't need to be a push on my cell phone ...

You're sort of slaying the messenger. YOU sign up for newsfeeds on your cell phone and you blame the people selling you news? It's news if people want to read it and people want to read about Hillary wearing a coat in the spring and Trump's horrific ego. I click on about ten different news organizations a day. I have never accepted any of their invitations to clutter up my telephone, email or computer screen with what they deem to be important.

I'm yer basic misanthrope. What the **** do I care "what's trending?"
 
I don't think that Donald Trump knows what's best for the U.S. and would not misrepresent the situation in any way.

Another is to really drill down on the data, down to the literal nuts and bolts, to find out how much a vehicle in the U.S. would cost if the U.S. used only domestic supply chains, certifying that all vehicles in the U.S. contained only U.S.-origin components.

I'm fairly certain that car prices in the U.S. would rise. But that might be offset by other factors and would maybe serve to keep manufacturing in the U.S.

There's no simplified formula; it's something involving trial & error, unless there's shortcut through all these issues that is not widely known.
 
But more specifically he is saying Mexico and Canada can integrate imported parts into things they manufacture. That is the loophole.

So Canadian Cheshire Cheese Cake is all good :D
 
Last edited:
I don't think that Donald Trump knows what's best for the U.S. and would not misrepresent the situation in any way.

Another is to really drill down on the data, down to the literal nuts and bolts, to find out how much a vehicle in the U.S. would cost if the U.S. used only domestic supply chains, certifying that all vehicles in the U.S. contained only U.S.-origin components.

I'm fairly certain that car prices in the U.S. would rise. But that might be offset by other factors and would maybe serve to keep manufacturing in the U.S.

There's no simplified formula; it's something involving trial & error, unless there's shortcut through all these issues that is not widely known.

At the risk of making an argument from incredulity.....

If it would save money to have an all-US supply chain, at least one of the major manufacturers would have given it a go in the last few years. Instead it seems that a globalised supply chain offers the best cost/quality combination.

I don't know about cars, but an all-US Fender guitar sells for around £1500 here in the UK, a Mexican-made one for about half that (and the components and quality is reportedly comparable - at least according to Guitarist magazine) and a Chinese or Korean made one cheaper again (and my Korean-made Telecaster plays fine).
 
At the risk of making an argument from incredulity.....

If it would save money to have an all-US supply chain, at least one of the major manufacturers would have given it a go in the last few years. Instead it seems that a globalised supply chain offers the best cost/quality combination.

I don't know about cars, but an all-US Fender guitar sells for around £1500 here in the UK, a Mexican-made one for about half that (and the components and quality is reportedly comparable - at least according to Guitarist magazine) and a Chinese or Korean made one cheaper again (and my Korean-made Telecaster plays fine).

If they didn't have the 'made in' info on them you wouldn't be able to tell a US, Mexican or Far East fender apart by the quality of construction or sound.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom