The Trump Presidency VII

Status
Not open for further replies.
That really did make me laugh out loud!

It’s actually done so the majority cannot dictate over the minority. Exactly what you rail against! Hilarious!

Majority of what? Why should geography empower the strength of a vote? it makes no sense to me.
 
Its complicated, but lots of YouTube videos on the intent, strengths and weaknesses of the Electoral College system.

Even if you think it is a strong system, it wasn't designed to fix the size of the house of representatives. It would have a lot more support if the population to electoral strength ratios were the same as 1796.
 
Its complicated, but lots of YouTube videos on the intent, strengths and weaknesses of the Electoral College system.

Mostly to justify a pre-existing position, which is to be expected.

We have over 500,000 elections (give or take in a given year) in this country; all are decided by majority rule except one.
 
Mostly to justify a pre-existing position, which is to be expected.

We have over 500,000 elections (give or take in a given year) in this country; all are decided by majority rule except one.

There is only one where multiple states participate.

ETA: actually it is extremely consistent with those 500,000 elections. All those elections are handled entirely by populations in a single state. Electors are handled in a single state. Having populations across multiple states vote for a single office would be unique.
 
Last edited:
Mostly to justify a pre-existing position, which is to be expected.

We have over 500,000 elections (give or take in a given year) in this country; all are decided by majority rule except one.

I suppose, but even the way the Senate is set up modifies pure majority rule, at least in the legislative branch, does it not? What I mean is, Alaska has exactly the same representation in the Senate as California.

I'm not so much making a case for the Electoral College, so much as asserting a case can be made.
 
I suppose, but even the way the Senate is set up modifies pure majority rule, at least in the legislative branch, does it not? What I mean is, Alaska has exactly the same representation in the Senate as California.

I'm not so much making a case for the Electoral College, so much as asserting a case can be made.
The Senate sucks as well for the same reasons. My votes don't count as much as minority right wingers. It wasn't as much of an issue when the Congress was more bipartisan. Now that the country is so divided it's a serious issue. Add in that the far right controls the GOP, they are trying to suppress votes, gerrymandering more, and stuffing the federal court system with religious and Ayn Rand ideologues and you have a Constitutional disaster unfolding.
 
Last edited:
The uncorrupted vote is essential to having a healthy country. ID laws are very simple and easy to comply with. If you’re too dumb to have an ID, you shouldn’t vote. I find I fascinating you’re on about being educated in civics but you’re having a problem with voter ID?

And the thought of a person with no ID being so busy they can’t vote within the time frame is absolutely hilarious, it’s been one day to vote for how many years, but the low education democrat voter just can’t get it done. Lol

I also find it hilarious you think the left wouldn’t disenfranchise the voter, the left has been hiding what they truly believe for decades. Why do you think NO ONE wants to be called a leftist?

Oh look! A post that has absolutely no bearing on reality.

Please, continue.
 
The uncorrupted vote is essential to having a healthy country. ID laws are very simple and easy to comply with. If you’re too dumb to have an ID, you shouldn’t vote. I find I fascinating you’re on about being educated in civics but you’re having a problem with voter ID?

Let us start with the easy question. How do you determine if something is sufficiently easy and simple? I'm not asking about voter ID laws. I'm asking about a generic thing.
 
Todays tweeting starts

"Fantastic to have 400,000 GREAT MEN & WOMEN of Rolling Thunder in D.C. showing their patriotism. They love our Country, they love our Flag, they stand for our National Anthem! Thanks to Executive Director Artie Muller."
 
So the better situation is to have the minority dictate over the majority? Like installing the candidate who gets over 3 million fewer votes? Like permitting extreme Gerrymandering that nets a win with less support? That's to be preferred, is it? By that reasoning, shouldn't we *always* install the candidate with the *least* support?

It’s so a few large cities filled with people who want others to pay their way because they are greedy and selfish, can’t force us into their devious, disgusting plan.
 
Because we aren’t a democracy, our government has many checks and balances.

That is not a check or a balance on the exercise of governmental power - that is a way of telling one group of people that, so far as having a say in government, that some people are more important than others.
 
That is not a check or a balance on the exercise of governmental power - that is a way of telling one group of people that, so far as having a say in government, that some people are more important than others.

Actually the opposite, it creates a fairness in the vote and government that doesn’t allow the majority vote to always win. So that, once AGAIN, a few loser cities cannot dictate to the rest of the country.

It has also made our country the best in the world.
 
Because we aren’t a democracy, our government has many checks and balances.

Checks and balances refers to the roles of the three co-equal branches of government. It has nothing to do with voting. The presidency and the VP are probably the only -- certainly the only major -- public offices in America where the winner of the election isn't necessarily the candidate who received the most votes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom