The Trump Presidency VII

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is it an actual offence in the US to burn the national flag?


Not necessarily.

Texas v. Johnson (1989)

The Court rejected "the view that an apparently limitless variety of conduct can be labeled 'speech' whenever the person engaging in the conduct intends thereby to express an idea," but acknowledged that conduct may be "sufficiently imbued with elements of communication to fall within the scope of the First and Fourteenth Amendments." In deciding whether particular conduct possesses sufficient communicative elements to bring the First Amendment into play, the court asked whether "an intent to convey a particularized message was present, and [whether] the likelihood was great that the message would be understood by those who viewed it."

The Court found that, "Under the circumstances, Johnson's burning of the flag constituted expressive conduct, permitting him to invoke the First Amendment. ... Occurring as it did at the end of a demonstration coinciding with the Republican National Convention, the expressive, overtly political nature of the conduct was both intentional and overwhelmingly apparent." The court concluded that, while "the government generally has a freer hand in restricting expressive conduct than it has in restricting the written or spoken word," it may not "proscribe particular conduct because it has expressive elements."
​

United States v. Eichman (1990)

In an opinion by Justice Brennan and decided along the same 5–4 lines as in Texas v. Johnson, the Court held that the federal government, like the states, cannot prosecute a person for burning a United States flag, because to do so would be inconsistent with the First Amendment. The Government conceded that flag-burning constitutes expressive conduct and enjoys the First Amendment's full protection.​
 
Last edited:
So the flag code is pointless?

You need to get one like the RN has for the White Ensign. If they see anything over than an RN Ship or Shore Establishment flying it they will take it down.

many years ago on a visit to Leith Docks (Edinburgh) our 1st Ltnt spotted a White Ensign being flown on a motor yacht. He sent a PO and four seamen across and they removed it.


Yes. What the U.S. definitely needs is more and different police.

I guess Flag Cops would be as good a place as any to start.
 
Oh look, President Donald Trump posthumously pardoned boxer Jack Johnson.

He’s such a racist! :rolleyes:


https://theconservativetreehouse.co...rump-posthumously-pardons-boxer-jack-johnson/

Um. Right. He pardons a black man, so could not be racist. Is that how it works?

Because some might think that his insistence that decent folk were at an event involving chants of "Jews will not replace us!" counts as evidence to the contrary.

That, and his company's discriminatory practices back in the seventies.

And many, many other incidents well known to us all, but never mind. He pardoned a long-dead black man, so totally not a racist. That was easy.
 
Um. Right. He pardons a black man, so could not be racist. Is that how it works?

Because some might think that his insistence that decent folk were at an event involving chants of "Jews will not replace us!" counts as evidence to the contrary.

That, and his company's discriminatory practices back in the seventies.

And many, many other incidents well known to us all, but never mind. He pardoned a long-dead black man, so totally not a racist. That was easy.

I find it hilarious you think he’s a racist, that is quite an extreme position.
 
I find it hilarious you think he’s a racist, that is quite an extreme position.

I have not quite said that I think he's a racist.

But, yeah, there's some pretty decent evidence to that. I'm fair-minded enough to say that such evidence isn't at the level of proof (a non-racist might discriminate against black renters for reasons of profit, for instance, and it is just conceivable that he didn't understand the connections between Charlottesville and racism, or perhaps chose to ignore it not because he is racist -- heaven forfend! -- but because it was politically advantageous to do so, which would be totally dickish but not literally racist).

So, yeah, maybe not racist. Probably so, but maybe not.

But pardoning a long dead black boxer has **** all to do with anything.
 
President Donald Trump has praised an NFL ban on players kneeling during the national anthem, questioning whether such protesters should stay in the US.

He said: "You have to stand proudly for the national anthem or you shouldn't be playing, you shouldn't be there, maybe you shouldn't be in the country."

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-44232979

They should go back to Africa where they came from! *********** n-word's!
 
So, yeah, maybe not racist. Probably so, but maybe not.
I cut him more slack in this area than a lot of people here do, partly on the grounds that bigotry does not equal racism.

But boy does he pander to it (and other forms of bigotry and xenophobia), which is worse in a way.
 
President Trump’s proposed budget for 2019 would result in significantly higher deficits over the next decade than the White House estimated, the Congressional Budget Office said Thursday. The difference comes partly from CBO’s belief that the tax bill signed into law last year will not create as much revenue as the White House has promised.

The administration said its budget proposal would lower the deficit by $5.2 trillion over 10 years. But the CBO said the Trump budget — which combines spending reductions on domestic programs with last year’s large tax cut package — would lower the deficit by $2.9 trillion.

In selling the tax law last year, the White House and Republicans said it would lead to broad gains in salaries and wages throughout the economy. But CBO estimated the White House’s forecasts were overly rosy. Ultimately, it said tax revenue would be $1.2 trillion lower over the next 10 years, compared with the White House’s estimates.

White House officials have routinely criticized the CBO’s methodology, accusing the budget office of refusing to factor in the type of economic forecasts that Republicans use when measuring the impact of tax cuts.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...er-trump-budget-than-administration-projects/

It needs a wishful thinking term in the equation, so it fully takes into account the laffer curve (also known as the economic homeopathic principle) which states that the less you tax the more monies you get. Republican science.
 
I cut him more slack in this area than a lot of people here do, partly on the grounds that bigotry does not equal racism.

But boy does he pander to it (and other forms of bigotry and xenophobia), which is worse in a way.

It's a bit odd to think it would be better if he really believed that black and brown people are inferior rather than just pretended to believe it because it's useful to do so. But I get your point. The former view is simple ignorance, terrible, hateful ignorance, but ignorance, whereas the latter is intentional self-interest at the expense of others.

But like you, I don't call this heinous behavior racism. It is no less bad and perhaps it's even worse than racism, but it's not quite racism.
 
I cut him more slack in this area than a lot of people here do, partly on the grounds that bigotry does not equal racism.

But boy does he pander to it (and other forms of bigotry and xenophobia), which is worse in a way.

People say this frequently and I think it's possible that you're all getting it wrong. There can be strains of inherent racism, unintentionally, in many of us. Bigotry, to me at any rate, connotes a thought-out philosophy or policy.

There's quite a difference between "I just don't trust or like people who are different from me (no matter how hard I try) because of how I was raised or .... reasons" versus "I hate blacks/browns/beiges/Jews and don't want them in my cafeteria, lunch counter, school or movie theater". The latter obviously encompasses segregationists so maybe my interpretation is from growing up in that era (in the south), but bigotry to me is far worse.
 
I cut him more slack in this area than a lot of people here do, partly on the grounds that bigotry does not equal racism.

But boy does he pander to it (and other forms of bigotry and xenophobia), which is worse in a way.

By his deeds and his words Trump shall be known.

How exactly are racial bigotry and racism different from one another?

Never heard there was a subtle difference.
 
I cut him more slack in this area than a lot of people here do, partly on the grounds that bigotry does not equal racism.

But boy does he pander to it (and other forms of bigotry and xenophobia), which is worse in a way.

And this is why I keep saying that he is, in fact, a US-style white supremacist. It's not "I felt nervous when the elevator doors opened and a black guy stepped in.", it's "I condone police violence based on skin color, am rolling back civil rights protections, support suppressing nonwhite voters,, outright insult black veterans and use racial slurs directly in front of Native American WW2 veterans, and wish to use the federal government specifically to drain wealth from black and Native American people and enrich myself and my white friends."

He is far beyond just some subconscious bigotry, and well into outright Jim Crow, George Wallace 1964 territory.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom