Lordy!
The stock market was way up today because Trump and Xi were able to work it out! I mean, how in Gods name is that something to criticize?
There are quite a few questions surrounding Trump and Xi "working it all out" that immediately come to mind. I'm not an expert, but have read a lot on the subject and maybe someone with more knowledge than me could chime in. Here are some things that concern me:
1. You don't have the kind of substantive grievances Trump had, then "work it out" in a week or two.
2. China promises to buy a bunch more stuff and one immediate question about that is, what did the U.S. give up to get this seemingly enormous advantage?
3. A Chinese official described the framework as "win-win" and IMO that is not a very Chinese thing to say; rather something that would be said because the Chinese know what Trump wants to hear.
4. Xi is very clever, and much more experienced that Trump at this sort of thing. He's just consolidated power as essentially the first emperor since Mao. IMO he could run circles around people like Trump and Mnunchin. China plays a very long game and thinks strategically, while Trump is inexperienced and easily manipulated. Advantage Xi.
5. The fact that China can agree to import more U.S. products is based on government's ability to manage a top-down economy. By Western standards values he really should not be in a position to make these kinds of commitments. Yet he can just say it and make it happen. That in itself shows how much more powerful he is than Trump, and probably wasn't much of a concession seeing how quickly he agreed to it.
6. The fact that Trump is calling for major sanctions on Iran, then backs off immediately because he wants to save Chinese telecom jobs. He's talking tough, pleasing his base, but then *immediately* backs down. Not a super-savvy negotiating tactic, nor an indication that he was ever operating in good faith when it came to getting tough.
7. The timing of the promised $500 million investment in Trump's Indonesia project.
8. The fact that, as far as I can tell, the U.S. needs China more than China needs the U.S. It has other markets for getting raw materials and plenty of demand for its goods elsewhere, for example in its own huge domestic market. And it is not hampered by citizens clamoring for environmental protections, good working conditions etc. Luring the U.S. into complacency then pulling the rug out is absolutely something it could pull off.
9. Something is telling me China is playing its cards much closer to its chest than the U.S. is.
10. The fact that China is absolutely not going to back down on establishing regional military power, which is presumably not addressed in the trade deal.
Some of these are interrelated and do call for speculation on my part. But really I have a feeling that the Chinese regard the Americans as children - who don't save; who are attracted by shiny baubles; who have not faced much adversity in their lives. Who can be taken advantage of by promising short-term gain.
As far as the stock market: That's not creating wealth; it's just a giant parimutuel wagering venue. It's susceptible to speculation and manipulations. Too much "irrational exuberance" is not a good thing. Bubbles tend to burst. It's all based on perception, and perception can change overnight.
Am I being overly negative? Maybe so. But there is more to this sudden calling off of tariffs than meets the eye. It raises questions, to say the least.