The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
Out of context again. You must stop doing that, BiWi.

The context was, someone argued that Rudy made up his story about a strange man 'on the threshold of Meridith Kercher's room'. I remarked that he managed to describe Raff surprisingly accurately, i.e., a fluently Italian man (and thus, not a sundry Albanian as claimed by Knox and Raff's defences viz a viz their star witness,Aviello), shorter than himself, brown hair (as opposed to Italian black), held the blade in his left hand, was wearing a jacket with a Napapirje logo and wore on his head a white beanie with a red stripe. He said the figure was backlit, from the dim light in Mez' room and the hall light having been switched off whilst he was in the loo.

The PR-gang jumped in and claimed (falsely) that (a) Raff was taller (b) was right-handed, so therefor could not be the man in Rudy's description (c) did not own any such clothing and (d) all Italians have mousy hair.

So, it is nothing to do with 'belief in Rudy', but rather, 'how did Rudy manage to describe Raff so accurately'?

Do try to keep focussed.

You do realize you never produced any evidence of how tall Raffaele is, right? Other than you claiming it, all we got was some evidence of Guede's height. And yes, he's Italian, speaks Italian and doesn't have black hair. That narrows the suspect list down to a few million men. Everything else about the description doesn't match Raffaele. That you see this as "describing Raff surprisingly accurately" is not surprising - those guilt-colored glasses are misleading you once again - but the rest of the 'specific' details don't match Raffaele. And the point was, if you're going to be holding a knife to attack (or defend) yourself, you're going to hold it in your dominant hand. Guede said the guy was holding it in his left hand and Raffaele is right handed. Why you can't understand (or refused to acknowledge) this rather simple concept is bewildering.

And btw, I realize sticking to the truth is difficult for you but you could at least be honest about Aviello. Aviello made the claim that his brother confessed to the killing. Neither Amanda or Raffaele, or their defense counsels had anything to do with him. He was hardly their "star witness", as you claim. Why do you feel the need to lie about such things? Do you think it aids in your credibility?
 
FYI it is illegal to carry an offensive weapon in a public place in England. This includes knives, batons and coshes.

A knife is not a weapon anymore than a hammer or a vehicle is a weapon. The only person I have ever cut with a knife is myself. Not deliberately of course.
 
So, it is nothing to do with 'belief in Rudy', but rather, 'how did Rudy manage to describe Raff so accurately'?

Do try to keep focussed.

It was a typo when Mignini typed out for Rudy what he was supposed to say to merit a reduced sentence for murder.
 
Out of context again. You must stop doing that, BiWi.

The context was, someone argued that Rudy made up his story about a strange man 'on the threshold of Meridith Kercher's room'. I remarked that he managed to describe Raff surprisingly accurately, i.e., a fluently Italian man (and thus, not a sundry Albanian as claimed by Knox and Raff's defences viz a viz their star witness,Aviello), shorter than himself, brown hair (as opposed to Italian black), held the blade in his left hand, was wearing a jacket with a Napapirje logo and wore on his head a white beanie with a red stripe. He said the figure was backlit, from the dim light in Mez' room and the hall light having been switched off whilst he was in the loo.

The PR-gang jumped in and claimed (falsely) that (a) Raff was taller (b) was right-handed, so therefor could not be the man in Rudy's description (c) did not own any such clothing and (d) all Italians have mousy hair.

So, it is nothing to do with 'belief in Rudy', but rather, 'how did Rudy manage to describe Raff so accurately'?

Do try to keep focussed.

Sorry, we don't own guilt glasses. Raffaele had been all over the news. Pretty damn easy if you ask me. And as Stacy pointed out it really wasn't that accurate.
 
Last edited:
FYI it is illegal to carry an offensive weapon in a public place in England. This includes knives, batons and coshes.

Typical misleading comment from Vixen. It is perfectly legal to carry a pocketknife in England - and Italy, which is really the only relevant issue here - as long as the blade is 3 inches or less. The knife Raffaele carried around with him was perfectly legal in Italy, and anyone not wearing guilty-colored glasses would view his walking into the police station with it as an indication of someone with nothing to hide. Conversely, if he had just committed a crime using a knife it's only logical to assume he would have wanted to distance himself from knives in general and certainly would never have walked into a police station with one in his pocket.
 
To make it simple. You get a parking ticket. You apeal it. You fail and are told to pay the penalty.

You then go to a Family Law court to finalise your divorce. The judge happens to write in his summing up that you succeeded in your appeal against your parking ticket.

Homework: what is the actual legal situation in respect of the parking ticket?

I'll just get into my listening pose.


If I take my parking ticket aboard an Amtrak train and demand that they let me ride to Knoxville, Tennessee, because obviously I have a ticket, they'll laugh at me (for a moment, before demanding actual payment in lieu of kicking me off the train). It's a ticket, but it's the wrong kind of ticket.

Similarly, if you jump aboard the train of history clutching your little "judicial fact," and demand that history be rerouted to your destination of seeing the Amanda Knox case your way, those aboard will continue to laugh at you, because the fact you have is the wrong kind of fact.

A judicial fact is not a historical fact. The only people expected to honor an Italian judicial fact are certain Italians who are part of the Italian judicial system. Just as I can't pay my parking ticket with an Amtrak ticket, because only Amtrak puts any value on Amtrak tickets, you cannot sway the historical record with an Italian judicial fact.

Now, here's the hell of it. Even though only Amtrak cares about Amtrak tickets, Amtrak doesn't actually have to honor Amtrak tickets if they don't feel like it. There's fine print on there somewhere that says so. It's a general fact of the world that those who make rules for themselves can and often do break those rules at will. The same is true of Italian judicial facts. The Italian judiciary has to honor Italian judicial facts... unless they don't feel like it. In which case they won't.

The end result is no one's getting railroaded to Knoxville this time.
 
Typical misleading comment from Vixen. It is perfectly legal to carry a pocketknife in England - and Italy, which is really the only relevant issue here - as long as the blade is 3 inches or less. The knife Raffaele carried around with him was perfectly legal in Italy, and anyone not wearing guilty-colored glasses would view his walking into the police station with it as an indication of someone with nothing to hide. Conversely, if he had just committed a crime using a knife it's only logical to assume he would have wanted to distance himself from knives in general and certainly would never have walked into a police station with one in his pocket.

Exactly. This is the difference that Vixen is blind to. It demonstrates how a guilty and an innocent person thinks and behaves. Raffaele knows he's innocent and even though it seems as if the police are talking to him and Amanda a lot, they don't think for a second that people are really looking at them as suspects. And even if they might be, they think that the truth will keep them immune. Raffaele owns a knife and thinks nothing of it. If he really murdered someone with a knife, no way in hell is he going into the questura with one.

Raffaele and Amanda were planning a trip to Gubbio. Had they had a consciousness of guilt, they would have gone putting as much distance between themselves and the crime. The body may have been discovered as much as 24 to 48 hours later. No, they sound the alert. They aren't lawyering up. They are being as helpful as possible.

In contrast, Rudy runs even though no one is looking for him.
 
A knife is not a weapon anymore than a hammer or a vehicle is a weapon. The only person I have ever cut with a knife is myself. Not deliberately of course.

Be that as it may, in England & Wales you would be committing a criminal offence if you walk around with a knife as a weapon. It matters not a whit if the purpose is 'to defend myself'. Likewise a hammer.

Cars are covered by 'death by dangerous driving', 'Grievous Bodily Harm' (GBH) or attempted murder if deliberate, or even murder if you kill someone.
 
Typical misleading comment from Vixen. It is perfectly legal to carry a pocketknife in England - and Italy, which is really the only relevant issue here - as long as the blade is 3 inches or less. The knife Raffaele carried around with him was perfectly legal in Italy, and anyone not wearing guilty-colored glasses would view his walking into the police station with it as an indication of someone with nothing to hide. Conversely, if he had just committed a crime using a knife it's only logical to assume he would have wanted to distance himself from knives in general and certainly would never have walked into a police station with one in his pocket.

He wasn't carrying a pen knife.
 
If I take my parking ticket aboard an Amtrak train and demand that they let me ride to Knoxville, Tennessee, because obviously I have a ticket, they'll laugh at me (for a moment, before demanding actual payment in lieu of kicking me off the train). It's a ticket, but it's the wrong kind of ticket.

Similarly, if you jump aboard the train of history clutching your little "judicial fact," and demand that history be rerouted to your destination of seeing the Amanda Knox case your way, those aboard will continue to laugh at you, because the fact you have is the wrong kind of fact.

A judicial fact is not a historical fact. The only people expected to honor an Italian judicial fact are certain Italians who are part of the Italian judicial system. Just as I can't pay my parking ticket with an Amtrak ticket, because only Amtrak puts any value on Amtrak tickets, you cannot sway the historical record with an Italian judicial fact.

Now, here's the hell of it. Even though only Amtrak cares about Amtrak tickets, Amtrak doesn't actually have to honor Amtrak tickets if they don't feel like it. There's fine print on there somewhere that says so. It's a general fact of the world that those who make rules for themselves can and often do break those rules at will. The same is true of Italian judicial facts. The Italian judiciary has to honor Italian judicial facts... unless they don't feel like it. In which case they won't.

The end result is no one's getting railroaded to Knoxville this time.

Strangely enough, I have been to Knoxville, Tennessee.

As for your analogy: sad fact is, were Amtrak to take you to court over your parking ticket which you claim can be any ticket in the world of the anarchist, in whose favour do you think the judge will find?

Take your time now.
 
Exactly. This is the difference that Vixen is blind to. It demonstrates how a guilty and an innocent person thinks and behaves. Raffaele knows he's innocent and even though it seems as if the police are talking to him and Amanda a lot, they don't think for a second that people are really looking at them as suspects. And even if they might be, they think that the truth will keep them immune. Raffaele owns a knife and thinks nothing of it. If he really murdered someone with a knife, no way in hell is he going into the questura with one.

Raffaele and Amanda were planning a trip to Gubbio. Had they had a consciousness of guilt, they would have gone putting as much distance between themselves and the crime. The body may have been discovered as much as 24 to 48 hours later. No, they sound the alert. They aren't lawyering up. They are being as helpful as possible.

In contrast, Rudy runs even though no one is looking for him.


Do you have any evidence the pair 'planned to go to Gubbio'?

Falls into the realms of the Popovic triangle.
 
When you come to Europe, leave your knives and guns behind.

Oh, DARN! And here I was planning to carry a foot long unprotected kitchen knife in my purse for protection.

Out of context again. You must stop doing that, BiWi.

The context was, someone argued that Rudy made up his story about a strange man 'on the threshold of Meridith Kercher's room'. I remarked that he managed to describe Raff surprisingly accurately, i.e., a fluently Italian man (and thus, not a sundry Albanian as claimed by Knox and Raff's defences viz a viz their star witness,Aviello), shorter than himself, brown hair (as opposed to Italian black), held the blade in his left hand, was wearing a jacket with a Napapirje logo and wore on his head a white beanie with a red stripe. He said the figure was backlit, from the dim light in Mez' room and the hall light having been switched off whilst he was in the loo.

The PR-gang jumped in and claimed (falsely) that (a) Raff was taller (b) was right-handed, so therefor could not be the man in Rudy's description (c) did not own any such clothing and (d) all Italians have mousy hair.

So, it is nothing to do with 'belief in Rudy', but rather, 'how did Rudy manage to describe Raff so accurately'?

Do try to keep focussed.

It's sad, but unsurprising, that you resort once again to this nonsense. After failing to ever produce a single piece of evidence that RS ever owned or wore a Naparijini jacket or a cap with a red stripe, you trot this out again.

Guede not only said that the man held the knife in his left hand, but that he attacked him:

He turned around and came at me. I backed off trying to defend… to wave my hands. Look, it happened in a flash, I didn't have time to…I asked: "What happened?" and that person turned around. It happened in a flash…and I tried to back away while protecting myself from his hands. So much so that during the interrogation and the trial I said that the moves of that person… I don't know what was in his hands., I said I thought it was a scalpel because I was cut.
Leosini-Guede interview January 21, 2016

A person would not attack someone with a knife with his non-dominant hand. As I showed in the video, RS writes with his right hand.

You think that brown hair is uncommon in Italy? REALLY? All Italians have "Italian black" hair? LOL! Brown is the most common hair color in Italy, not black. Comodi, Maresca, Massei, Bongiorno, Romanelli and others were brunettes. So Guede describing a brunette who spoke Italian in Italy was really taking a chance with getting the odds right, heh? And no one claimed "all Italians have mousy hair". Stop fibbing.

By the way, that pic you love to show of RS holding the knife also shows his hair completely covered by the cap. Hmmmmm.
 
Guede insisting on every occasion that the murder weapon was small and scalpel like, which is consistent with the murder weapon as described by the medical examiner, must mean the murder weapon was a giant cleaver - cold and objective analysis.
 
Do you have any evidence the pair 'planned to go to Gubbio'?

Falls into the realms of the Popovic triangle.

Dr. Sollecito testified that Raffaele told him on Nov. 1 that he and Amanda were going to Gubbio on Nov. 2. He also said he called the next morning earlier than he normally would have because he knew they were going to Gubbio.

What motive could you possibly come up with for RS and AK to lie about planning to go to Gubbio?
 
Last edited:
Do you have any evidence the pair 'planned to go to Gubbio'?

Falls into the realms of the Popovic triangle.

They said they were. Nevertheless, they still would not likely have been there for the discovery of the body. You can argue the opposite but just like the knife on Raffaele, you cannot draw any reliable inferences. Rudy's behavior is the only one of the three that fits a classic guilty conscience.

I'm not saying their behavior proves their innocence, I'm just saying that it doesn't support an assumption of guilt.
 
He wasn't carrying a pen knife.

You're right, he was carrying a pocket knife and it was a legal knife to carry around in Italy. It wasn't an "offensive weapon" or whatever other biased term you wish to apply to it.
 
Do you have any evidence the pair 'planned to go to Gubbio'?

Falls into the realms of the Popovic triangle.

For someone so willing to accept anything said by anyone without the slightest hint of evidence to back it up so long as it's anti-Amanda, you seem very concerned about acquiring definitive evidence to back up things favorable to her. Why is that? You're not biased, are you?

Popovic gave direct testimony of asking Raffaele to take her to the station and later returning to his place to tell him she no longer needed a ride. The scenario was confirmed by Popovic's mother, who did not ship the suitcase as originally planned. There were no contradictions to her testimony, it's confirmed by multiple people and she isn't a heroin addict. I'm amazed that you still question her testimony but vigorously defend the testimony of Curatolo and all the problems that came with it. Hmmm...

As for evidence of the planned trip to Gubbio, I know Raffaele's father confirmed he was aware of their plans. I'm sure that fails the Vixen sniff test. Since the police never questioned this, I don't know if Laura or Filomena were asked if they were aware of their plans. They were going to drive so there would be no travel tickets to prove it. It is what they told the police from the very start and they've never wavered. Since you've claimed to be unbiased and open minded I guess you'll just have to trust them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom