As I did in the thread in Education (linked upthread by Towlie), I'm pasting a brief sample from the rebuttal to the Board's blatantly spurious claims. I'm also pasting the preamble to the rebuttal, to clarify that, despite what is evidently widespread opinion, Texas is not a seething bed of ultra-conservative right-wing fundamentalism at all levels of government and constituency. The state, as might be expected from such a vast geographical area with several of the nation's largest cities, also harbors a number of liberals, intellectuals and critical thinkers.
In July a failed State Board of Education candidate, Randy Rives of Odessa, asked the Texas board to adopt a resolution condemning what he alleged were “pro-Islamic/anti-Christian distortions” in social studies textbooks. The proposed resolution includes a variety of claims designed to demonstrate the alleged bias in high school world history textbooks published in 1999. First, those textbooks are not in Texas classrooms. Publishers updated those textbooks, which Texas adopted in 2002. A review of those newer textbooks, which carry a copyright of 2003, at the Texas Education Agency reveals that the Rives’ claims are superficial and grossly misleading. Below is a sampling of claims in the Rives resolution and the facts that counter them.
CLAIM
World history textbooks provide, in some cases, twice as much coverage for Islamic beliefs, practices and holy writings than they do for Christianity.
FACT
This claim is based on an incomplete review of the textbooks. In fact, the review appears to ignore whole sections of textbooks that discuss Christianity. Among the ignored topics were the church in the Byzantine Empire; monasticism and church reform in the Middle Ages; the Holy Roman Empire; canon law; religion as a unifying force in Europe; the Reformation; and Christian influences on art, architecture and culture in the Renaissance and other eras. Example:
· McDougal’s world history textbook, p. 425, in a discussion of writers during the Northern Renaissance: “Although some of Erasmus’s most stinging barbs were aimed at the clergy, his work is strongly Christian. Erasmus believed in a Christianity of the heart, not one of ceremonies or rules. He thought that in order to improve society, all people should study the Bible.”
CLAIM
World history textbooks “dwell” on atrocities committed by Christian Crusaders during the Middle Ages while ignoring similar atrocities by Muslim leaders such as Tamerlane.
FACT
These claims are based on passages often taken out of context or ignored altogether. That the Crusaders were guilty of various atrocities against Muslims, Jews and Christians is historical fact. In addition, however, nearly all world history textbooks used in Texas classrooms also discuss conquests and atrocities committed by Muslim leaders, including those by Tamerlane.
Examples:
· Glencoe’s textbook, p. 269, includes this passage about a Muslim attack on Delhi in India in the 14th century: “As many as 100,000 Hindu prisoners were massacred before the gates of the city. It was India’s first meeting with
Timur Lenk (Tamerlane).”
· McDougal’s textbook, p. 444, discusses the same massacre: “In 1398, he swept through northern India, leaving destruction and decaying corpses in his wake. He butchered the inhabitants of Delhi and made a pyramid of their skulls.”
· The same McDougal textbook also describes how Timur the Lane (Tamerlane) burned Baghdad to the ground.