Merged The Royal Society of Medicine and Chiropractic

http://www.chiropracticlive.com/?p=842
Interesting website. "Resisting the medicalisation of chiropractic"? Whose side are they on again?

And I like the 3 chimps picture of the GCC. Seems all is not cosy back at the ranch.
The comments are intriguing. Seems they have given their European colleagues the impression Chiro is under tyrannical threat in the UK and the small band of brothers is willing to go to the stake for their principles.


FYI, the newly-formed Alliance of UK Chiropractors (AUKC) incorporates three out of the four existing UK chiropractic associations, representing around 50% of UK chiropractors – and that is a conservative figure since the British Chiropractic Association (BCA) has recently joined the AUKC in a vote of no confidence in the GCC.

It's worth noting that the AUKC’s stated intention is to “create a vitalistic chiropractic model of health”. Indeed, it represents chiropractors “who stand behind the founding principles of chiropractic as a vitalistic drug free profession based on the identification and reduction of vertebral subluxations”. It would appear that the AUKC is currently working on various strategies to get the 'right people' at the helm of the GCC.


ETA: If anyone is wondering what a McTimoney chiropractic adjustment looks like, see 1:40, 1:56 and 3:20 in here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cGIEfpRui28
 
Last edited:
Should have linked to the ChangeDetection page I had set up to monitor changes to the RSM McTimoney page:

https://www.changedetection.com/log/uk/ac/rsm/share_log.html

This shows all changes since 2 November including the original comment by Les Rose on 28 October:
Posted by Les Rose | 28 October 2010 7:37 AM

This is astounding. Chiropractic is neither science nor medicine, it is a belief system based on imaginary ideas about how the body works. This entry dishonours both the Society and the genuine people listed here.
 
And they have added an invitation to report unsuitable or abusive comments. Should we use this to report unsuitable `honours'?
 
I just got this from the RSM:
Statement by The Royal Society of Medicine

Over two years ago The Royal Society of Medicine launched an initiative to raise money for the provision of medical education, called the Wall of Honour. The project has to date been very successful and over £589,000 has been raised. Donors have responded enthusiastically to the idea that they (not the Society) have the opportunity to honour someone who works (or worked) in the healthcare and medical sector.

In autumn 2010, the Society expanded its website to include a 'Virtual' Wall of Honour which provided the donor, family, friends, colleagues and admirers to share personal thoughts, stories, anecdotes and photos of the person being honoured. This facility was launched following feedback from those who were unable to travel to London due to ill health or because they are based overseas.

In recent weeks some people - who are not family, friends or colleagues of the person being honoured - have chosen to abuse the purpose of the Virtual Wall of Honour by placing a variety of personal views on the website and specifically on the page dedicated to John McTimoney.

The donor who gave money to honour John McTimoney is entirely within their rights to honour him and at the same time to support the medical education provided by the Society.

The acceptance of this donation does not mean that the Society endorses the work of John McTimoney. Nor does the Society endorse the names or work of any of the 461 names inscribed on the Wall. The Wall solely exists for families, friends and colleagues to remember someone close to them.

As stated from the day the website was launched, the Society reserves the right to remove or edit entries made on its website and those submitting comments have agreed to abide by the RSM's terms and conditions. These particular pages are not a forum for debate or discussion. Due to the misuse of the website the Society will now pre-moderate all contributions on all pages.

It should be noted that anyone who has an interest in medicine or healthcare has been able to join the RSM as an Associate Member for many years. Membership of the RSM does not automatically mean that the Society as an organisation endorses what its individual members do, say or practise.
So they are now going to stop free speech and carry on allowing quackery to be presented under their banner.
 
I posted this, but a bit late to the party.

"McTimoney is deserving of honour when and only when the mythical chiropractic subluxation can be shown to exist."
 
I replied to [email protected]

Mr. Summerfield,

"Statement by The Royal Society of Medicine

Over two years ago The Royal Society of Medicine launched an initiative to raise money for the provision of medical education, called the Wall of Honour. The project has to date been very successful and over £589,000 has been raised. Donors have responded enthusiastically to the idea that they (not the Society) have the opportunity to honour someone who works (or worked) in the healthcare and medical sector." [italics added]

Chiropractic is quackery and not in the "healthcare and medical sector." Your acceptance of McTimoney insults the real heathcare and medical professionals you "honor." Surely, you can find medical professionals to educate the Society about chiropractic quackery. If not, I can provide many references.
 
Last edited:
In recent weeks some people - who are not family, friends or colleagues of the person being honoured - have chosen to abuse the purpose of the Virtual Wall of Honour by placing a variety of personal views on the website and specifically on the page dedicated to John McTimoney.

The donor who gave money to honour John McTimoney is entirely within their rights to honour him and at the same time to support the medical education provided by the Society.


The acceptance of this donation does not mean that the Society endorses the work of John McTimoney. Nor does the Society endorse the names or work of any of the 461 names inscribed on the Wall. The Wall solely exists for families, friends and colleagues to remember someone close to them.


I pasted the above in brown, because that's the colour weasels are.

"We don't approve of Nazis / drug pushers / gun runners / paedophiles, but we will take their money."

What a very, very pathetic excuse for a justification of simple greed.
 
RSM said:
The acceptance of this donation does not mean that the Society endorses the work of John McTimoney.

However, the acceptance of positive testimonials and the rejection of negative comments suggests that it does.
 
If I'd paid to have McTimoney 'honoured' I'd be pretty hacked off at the shockingly poor quality picture they are using.
 
Here's a suggestion: let's pool together so that we might honour Harold Shipman (who most certainly worked in health-care).

I'm up for £10.
I'm tempted. I think your £10 is pretty safe because the RSM will reject the application. So then we can ask on what grounds. Would it come down to whether he made a positive or a negative contribution to health? They are then making a value judgment, which they say they are not doing at the moment as they don't endorse any nominee.

Your main problem is getting this out to 250 people willing to chip in.
 
I think there are serious negative media issues nominating Shipman.

However, how about some other doctor? I'm thinking Dr Who! They may reject that on the basis he's fictional, but are there any other doctors who would be sufficiently controversial as far as the RSM are concerned, but who would be safer with regards to the media?
 
I think there are serious negative media issues nominating Shipman.

However, how about some other doctor? I'm thinking Dr Who! They may reject that on the basis he's fictional, but are there any other doctors who would be sufficiently controversial as far as the RSM are concerned, but who would be safer with regards to the media?
Andrew Wakefield? We could form a spoof antivax group.
 
Wouldn't it be better to get some of the high profile people on the wall to write an open letter to the RSM asking for their names to be removed while McTimmony's is on it? They might also suggest that those who have made bequests to the RSM in their wills consider changing them to support an organisation that promotes real science and medicine.

Hit them where it hurts - bad publicity that costs them money.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom