The reason for a death penalty

If you start with the premise, 'the victim is already dead', then logically you shouldn't put the murderer in prison either. After all, lowering the quality of his life won't bring the victim back...

And if you insist on using hyperbollox terms for judicial execution, would you also call imprisonment 'state-sanctioned kidnapping' and fines 'state-sanctioned theft'?
 
If you start with the premise, 'the victim is already dead', then logically you shouldn't put the murderer in prison either.
Ah. So you admit, then, that the only reason to kill them is punishment for previous actions.

'Kay, that was a major premise earlier. I'm glad we're back to being honest now. Killing murderers is no longer over prevention...

Beerina said:
How about closure > scumbag murderer's life? I think you left that part out of the equation, or inequality, as it were.
Hey, it's "Kill all the Wolves, we Can Just Clone 'Em Back" Beerina!

How've things been, pardner? By the way, I love the avatar choice. That's how I always imagine you look, every time I read one of your posts. ;)






Out of curiosity, can any of you guys actually back up your claim about closure? Can you demonstrate, definitively, scientifically, and objectively that the closure that is brought from the death penalty is significantly powerful enough to be enough to warrant the death penalty?

In short, can you demonstrate that the closure is immediately brought by the execution of a killer, that could not possibly have ever ever come up without the execution?

I welcome your attempts.

Either way, posts like Beerina's above demonstrates more and more to me, personally, that this is less over what's good for the victims, and more over what gets us to kill people we hate.
 
Last edited:
Ah. So you admit, then, that the only reason to kill them is punishment for previous actions.

'Kay, that was a major premise earlier. I'm glad we're back to being honest now. Killing murderers is no longer over prevention...

Personally, I claimed no such premise. And remember, I'm against the death penalty, though I accept the closure argument as valid.

Out of curiosity, can any of you guys actually back up your claim about closure? Can you demonstrate, definitively, scientifically, and objectively that the closure that is brought from the death penalty is significantly powerful enough to be enough to warrant the death penalty?

I can certainly make an appeal to common sense.
 
Personally, I claimed no such premise.

Then why else would it logically follow?

Remember, you made this claim:

If you start with the premise, 'the victim is already dead', then logically you shouldn't put the murderer in prison either.
It seems that the only reason that you're doing anything to him is vengeance over the victim's death.

I merely pointed out that the real victim is already dead. You are not protecting "the victim", you are protecting "the victim's family". Semantics, I know, but I'm a stickler like that.

Otherwise, I fail to see the logic that follows your post.

And remember, I'm against the death penalty, though I accept the closure argument as valid.
And so am I, and so do I not.

I can certainly make an appeal to common sense.

Which has little meaning to a skeptic.

In short, your "common sense" tells you that only by killing the killer does the family get any kind of meaningful closure from the event? There is no other possible method?
 
Last edited:
Personally, I claimed no such premise. And remember, I'm against the death penalty, though I accept the closure argument as valid.



I can certainly make an appeal to common sense.

Why not just do a survey of families who have lost a loved one to murder and have had the killer executed? It seems like it would be fairly straightforward, but I don't think I have ever seens a study of this type.

As for the appeal to common sense, common sense says the death penalty is a deterent to murder, but one look at the statistics says that it is not.
 
Knowing their loved one's killer is in turn dead would be a great comfort to the victim's family, and I would only very reluctantly deny them that comfort. I've no problems with the death penalty in principle (and don't you think you're going off the rails a bit calling it 'murder'?), but there are practical objections which, for me, outbalance the closure argument. I make no apologies for putting the victim before the villain, though.

It wouldn't, not for me. I take great resentment at being implied that I am that weak, and that I can only sleep once my fathers killer is killed by the state in turn. And as a member of such a family, I take no shame in saying that any other victim's family who wish to dish out this inhumane abomination to give themselves comfort, are failing humanity.

I suggest you show a little bit more respect for 'victims' than that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom