Beerina
Sarcastic Conqueror of Notions
- Joined
- Mar 3, 2004
- Messages
- 34,961
Closure < Human Life.
Any questions?
How about closure > scumbag murderer's life? I think you left that part out of the equation, or inequality, as it were.
Closure < Human Life.
Any questions?
Ah. So you admit, then, that the only reason to kill them is punishment for previous actions.If you start with the premise, 'the victim is already dead', then logically you shouldn't put the murderer in prison either.
Hey, it's "Kill all the Wolves, we Can Just Clone 'Em Back" Beerina!Beerina said:How about closure > scumbag murderer's life? I think you left that part out of the equation, or inequality, as it were.
Ah. So you admit, then, that the only reason to kill them is punishment for previous actions.
'Kay, that was a major premise earlier. I'm glad we're back to being honest now. Killing murderers is no longer over prevention...
Out of curiosity, can any of you guys actually back up your claim about closure? Can you demonstrate, definitively, scientifically, and objectively that the closure that is brought from the death penalty is significantly powerful enough to be enough to warrant the death penalty?
Personally, I claimed no such premise.
It seems that the only reason that you're doing anything to him is vengeance over the victim's death.If you start with the premise, 'the victim is already dead', then logically you shouldn't put the murderer in prison either.
And so am I, and so do I not.And remember, I'm against the death penalty, though I accept the closure argument as valid.
I can certainly make an appeal to common sense.
Personally, I claimed no such premise. And remember, I'm against the death penalty, though I accept the closure argument as valid.
I can certainly make an appeal to common sense.
Knowing their loved one's killer is in turn dead would be a great comfort to the victim's family, and I would only very reluctantly deny them that comfort. I've no problems with the death penalty in principle (and don't you think you're going off the rails a bit calling it 'murder'?), but there are practical objections which, for me, outbalance the closure argument. I make no apologies for putting the victim before the villain, though.