The Real way to Save America

Please read the opening post before voting

  • Aye

    Votes: 2 20.0%
  • Nay

    Votes: 8 80.0%

  • Total voters
    10

L.Y.S.

Illuminator
Joined
Aug 8, 2011
Messages
3,467
Ok guys, I'm going to go with a new and fresh approach to this argument. Instead of simply stating what I think should happen, I will give you the information, and based on that, when you click my wiki link, you go either aye or nay. I will cover some issues of the major points of the proposed second bill of rights.


Medical Care: (watch the American one then the world one.)

special: Sick Around America
special: Sick Around the World

Education:

Declining By Degrees: Higher Education at Risk (Another PBS special)

Social Security:

Yale University Lecture of the subject matter.

Wraps up the previous Yale lecture. Critical points on this video are from 20 minutes till about 60 minutes.

A fair and balanced debate on the issue (A series of articles) This is for those who don't wish to take about 180 minutes to view each critical point on the previous videos. I'm giving you a shortcut...

Employment, with a living wage:

A great historical documentary about why we have limits on corporate power.

After several days of analysis, determine your aye or nay. I repeat several days; do not make wildcat type mistakes here. Wildcat as a benefit of the doubt, I will allow you an additional count because the thread was different from when you first entered it.

All in favor say aye.
 
Last edited:
By the way guys, if you'd like to see any of the other Frontline specials on anything, here is the link.

If you want to talk about it, feel free to mention the specific video in another thread, and let’s go at it!

I hope you all enjoy these specials as I have.
 
If you want an informed response then you won't get it if you expect everybody to wade through more than 3 hours of videos.

A summary in your own words might help.
 
If you want an informed response then you won't get it if you expect everybody to wade through more than 3 hours of videos.

A summary in your own words might help.

Thanks for the idea. I have to review some of the stuff because it has been awhile since I myself have seen some of these documentaries.
 
If you want an informed response then you won't get it if you expect everybody to wade through more than 3 hours of videos.

seconded.

Also, in all my years at JREF forums, I have never seen a poll that needed a Planet X option more than this poll does.
 
Probably, at any rate, if you guys wanna get informed, look at the materials. I did this thread because I was tired of uneducated people bashing good ideas. If you disagree with it, then explain how you disagree with it. I'll summarize the videos, but I still think going through the videos would create a far superior interactive experience in this thread. However, I know that most people aren't that patient. I ask that you only take a week of your time and go through the videos. Nothing much, an hour a day would suffice, and by 4 or 6 days you would have the information necessary to make a decision.
 
Probably, at any rate, if you guys wanna get informed, look at the materials. I did this thread because I was tired of uneducated people bashing good ideas. If you disagree with it, then explain how you disagree with it. I'll summarize the videos, but I still think going through the videos would create a far superior interactive experience in this thread. However, I know that most people aren't that patient. I ask that you only take a week of your time and go through the videos. Nothing much, an hour a day would suffice, and by 4 or 6 days you would have the information necessary to make a decision.

You know, I decided to be more opening minded about your request. So I went to the link about why we have limits on corporate power. A PBS documentary on the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire of 1911.

First question: why is watching a documentary more useful than linking to a Wikipedia article, linking to some other historically accurate summation, or even having you write a paragraph or two about what happened in this incident?

Second question: Why are tragically inappropriate working conditions1 in NYC one hundred years ago a reason why employment should be a Constitutionally-protected right? Specifically:
The right to a useful and remunerative job in the industries or shops or farms or mines of the nation;​


1) conditions which are now outlawed by local fire ordinances, state safety regulations (NY DOSH), and by federal laws (OSHA, Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) etc.).
 
Last edited:
Probably, at any rate, if you guys wanna get informed, look at the materials. I did this thread because I was tired of uneducated people bashing good ideas. If you disagree with it, then explain how you disagree with it. I'll summarize the videos, but I still think going through the videos would create a far superior interactive experience in this thread. However, I know that most people aren't that patient. I ask that you only take a week of your time and go through the videos. Nothing much, an hour a day would suffice, and by 4 or 6 days you would have the information necessary to make a decision.

How about you taking a week of your time and go through the videos and write a synopsis for us? Nothing much, an hour a day would suffice, and by 4 or 6 days you would have something that everyone else could use to make a decision about YOUR poll.
 
How about you taking a week of your time and go through the videos and write a synopsis for us? Nothing much, an hour a day would suffice, and by 4 or 6 days you would have something that everyone else could use to make a decision about YOUR poll.

I've actually seen most of the documentaries in question.

You know, I decided to be more opening minded about your request. So I went to the link about why we have limits on corporate power. A PBS documentary on the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire of 1911.

First question: why is watching a documentary more useful than linking to a Wikipedia article, linking to some other historically accurate summation, or even having you write a paragraph or two about what happened in this incident?

Second question: Why are tragically inappropriate working conditions1 in NYC one hundred years ago a reason why employment should be a Constitutionally-protected right? Specifically:
The right to a useful and remunerative job in the industries or shops or farms or mines of the nation;

1) conditions which are now outlawed by local fire ordinances, state safety regulations (NY DOSH), and by federal laws (OSHA, Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) etc.).

Yeah, this thread is actually a failed experiment. However, I'm not upset about it. I'm still learning the ropes to posting here. I'm going to let this thread die out and get buried over time. In about a week I'll make a new one that just gives information for users. There will be no specific votes and or questions coming from the new thread. Just facts, that people who decide to view it, will view it.
 
I've actually seen most of the documentaries in question.



Yeah, this thread is actually a failed experiment. However, I'm not upset about it. I'm still learning the ropes to posting here. I'm going to let this thread die out and get buried over time. In about a week I'll make a new one that just gives information for users. There will be no specific votes and or questions coming from the new thread. Just facts, that people who decide to view it, will view it.

so that means I won't be getting an answer to my second question?

As for educated versus uneducated board members. I have found this forum to be filled with far more educated users than any other forum I have viewed on the internet. I suspect that the vast majority of posters know that it is U.S. laws passed in the past 100 years to prevent sweatshops, restrict child labor, ensure worker safety, and guarantee the right to unionize were based on significant events in the history of the nation.

If you want to make an argument, simply lay out the (well-defined) premises and indicate how they lead to a particular conclusion. Be sure you can provide documentation for your claims and a reasonable discussion can then take place. There is however, one caveat - 10-15% of the users in the politics subforum are incapable of discussing certain issues in an adult manner. These posters will resort to name-calling, bickering, pontification, and pettifoggery. The wisest course is to avoid these posters.

ETA: oh, and I was serious about adding a Planet X option to any future polls. That choice is sort of a catchall to represent: my answer does not appear; my position cannot be classified into just one poll choice; the subject is far to complex to be represented by only these choices; the subject, as defined in the opening post, is far too silly to discuss; too much rhetoric, not enough substance; I do not fit the narrowly-defined voting criteria that you set out for voters but want to indicate that I read your thread; and other stuff as well.

MORE ETA: does the website already have a good description of what Planet X represents?
 
Last edited:
so that means I won't be getting an answer to my second question?

As for educated versus uneducated board members. I have found this forum to be filled with far more educated users than any other forum I have viewed on the internet. I suspect that the vast majority of posters know that it is U.S. laws passed in the past 100 years to prevent sweatshops, restrict child labor, ensure worker safety, and guarantee the right to unionize were based on significant events in the history of the nation.

If you want to make an argument, simply lay out the (well-defined) premises and indicate how they lead to a particular conclusion. Be sure you can provide documentation for your claims and a reasonable discussion can then take place. There is however, one caveat - 10-15% of the users in the politics subforum are incapable of discussing certain issues in an adult manner. These posters will resort to name-calling, bickering, pontification, and pettifoggery. The wisest course is to avoid these posters.

ETA: oh, and I was serious about adding a Planet X option to any future polls. That choice is sort of a catchall to represent: my answer does not appear; my position cannot be classified into just one poll choice; the subject is far to complex to be represented by only these choices; the subject, as defined in the opening post, is far too silly to discuss; too much rhetoric, not enough substance; I do not fit the narrowly-defined voting criteria that you set out for voters but want to indicate that I read your thread; and other stuff as well.

MORE ETA: does the website already have a good description of what Planet X represents?

Again, this thread bombed. I say that we just let this thread die out. Great concept, just horrible implementation on my part. I should've taken awhile to develop this thread. It had many great ideas in it, but my method of presentation was poor.

The point of the 100 year old video was to give historic insight into the importance of corporate regulations. It wasn't to say that we don't have any, but in fact we may need more. But I failed to bring up another video that was critical to the argument and therefore I had an only half presented argument.

All in all, this thread sucked... And I'm not ashamed to admit it. Now if we all could let this thread die underneath the mounds of post about Rick Perry and Michele Bachmann I'd be happy.
 
Again, this thread bombed. I say that we just let this thread die out. Great concept, just horrible implementation on my part. I should've taken awhile to develop this thread. It had many great ideas in it, but my method of presentation was poor.

The point of the 100 year old video was to give historic insight into the importance of corporate regulations. It wasn't to say that we don't have any, but in fact we may need more. But I failed to bring up another video that was critical to the argument and therefore I had an only half presented argument.

All in all, this thread sucked... And I'm not ashamed to admit it. Now if we all could let this thread die underneath the mounds of post about Rick Perry and Michele Bachmann I'd be happy.

I actually agree that we do need more regulation - specifically, mining regulations are rather lax at this point.

One last piece of advice. When you present an argument, you will be asked about the ramifications of your argument. In this case, one of the first questions you will face in the new thread will be "what tax rates do you expect to see once the Second Bill of Rights is passed?"
 
By the way guys, if you'd like to see any of the other Frontline specials on anything, here is the link.

If you want to talk about it, feel free to mention the specific video in another thread, and let’s go at it!

I hope you all enjoy these specials as I have.

Did you happen to catch the Frontline expose of wikileaks?
 
Very bad poll. No planet X option.

Very bad OP. We are being asked to do a great deal of work without justification.

I vote 'Nay' on general principles.

Please do not feel as though you need to create too many threads. Many here make that mistake.

Oh, answering the question that you should have asked: No, I don't think America can or will be 'saved'. We are watching the traditional winding down of an empire.
 
Very bad poll. No planet X option.

Very bad OP. We are being asked to do a great deal of work without justification.

I vote 'Nay' on general principles.

Please do not feel as though you need to create too many threads. Many here make that mistake.

Oh, answering the question that you should have asked: No, I don't think America can or will be 'saved'. We are watching the traditional winding down of an empire.

Yeah I already said the thread sucked lol. I agree with your last paragraph, most individuals will not. I think America is too large and too based on expansion of economics to survive.
 
In your repeated posting style of argumentation, do you say this all the time to strangers to make yourself "one of the guys"?

Ha-ha I have a very emotional style of communication and often I do use this form of communication to gain trust and friendships. However, I am learning how to make logical arguments. It'll take time but I'll make it happen. Anyway, I'm going to try and let this thread die now...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom