The Placebo Effect

If there is no such thing as a placebo effect then does that mean that there is no such thing as a nocebo effect?
No, but the question is what exactly those nocebo effects are. From arthwollipot's link, but a comment, not the article itself:
Rogue Medic
Nocebo effects can be very common. OTOH, the adverse effects are all the effects* that participants noticed and recorded, so they may not be due to the placebo (nocebo), but just the ordinary symptoms that come and go as part of daily life. They seem relevant because the researchers require the participants to record anything that might be a symptom.
As with asymptomatic infections during the pandemic, what is a symptom to one person is not a symptom to another - and what is a symptom during a study is just an ordinary part of life outside of the study.
* In this context, symptoms would be a better word than effects.

In some (probably many) cases, it may be a question of misattribution: You got vaccinated and felt bad, the next day (for whatever reason), couldn't sleep, (or slept longer than you usually do), and now you attribute it to the vaccination.
This is similar to some cases of the Havana 'syndrome' where some people come down with all kinds of actual physiological symptoms, many of them with well-known causes, but in the context of the 'syndrome' narrative, the symptoms are attributed to imaginary attacks with 'directed energy weapons' (DEWs).
See Joy's story, as told by 60 Minutes and The Insider: post 2,447, 2,455, 2,458 in the 'syndrome' thread. Joy's disease is a fairly typical case of semicircular canal dehiscence/Minor's syndrome, but she attributes it to something else, the alleged DEW attacks, and the media tells her story without investigating it properly, i.e without consulting (unbiassed) medical experts.

See also Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) (Wikipedia) and how it has been abused by anti-fvaxxers.
 
Last edited:
This is the kind of "magic placebo" myth that I have been trying to debunk in this thread. I randomly came across it in my social media feed. I didn't go looking for it.

1777667775536.png

No, the placebo meme is not as effective as regular memes, your regular memes are just not funny.

But the joke relies on the "powerful placebo" myth and even fosters the illusion that the myth is real. Again, I didn't seek this out - it came to me randomly - or at least algorithmically-generated - on social media. I post it here to illustrate how prevalent the "powerful placebo" myth really is in society and why it is important to understand why it is wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom