The people who challenged my atheism most were drug addicts and prostitutes

Zelenius

Muse
Joined
Jul 8, 2008
Messages
908
This isn't something I believe, it's a quote from journalist/photographer former Wall Streeter Chris Arnade in "The people who challenged my atheism most were drug addicts and prostitutes":

Sarah, 15 years on the streets, wears a cross around her neck. Always. Michael, 30 years on the streets, carries a rosary in his pocket. Always. In any crack house, in the darkest buildings empty of all other furnishings, a worn Bible can be found laying flat amongst needles, caps, lighters, and crack pipes.

This may be one of the most extreme examples of "I'm an atheist, but most people, especially poor desperate people need religion!" I've ever seen. In a way, I am not even sure what the point of this article is, since it isn't shocking news to anyone that very poor, desperate people are more likely to be very religious than educated, more successful people(Marx said it best). Besides the silly, predictable attack on Dawkins, what bothered me the most is this notion that atheism is inherently "elitist". Or at least Arnade's atheism. Like most atheists, I am very far from being in the elite, though I am fortunate to have a roof over my head.

I admire the work Arnade does by telling the stories of homeless, drug addicted, extremely religious prostitutes in Hunts Point, in the Bronx. I don't believe he's "exploiting" them, since the ones he posts about all want to share their story. He's tried to help some of them get clean, but having followed his blog over the years this appears at best a fool's errand. I also think his attack on atheism is largely baseless, though I can understand these homeless people being prone to wishful thinking and superstition because of their very difficult lives.

That said, do these people truly "need" religion? Or is it possible that religion even harms them, making it easier to throw away this life because they believe they will have it better in the mythical after-life? To me, it looks like religion is a "placebo" for these desperate people, used in place of real medical treatment.

I believe above all they need long-term medical treatment and education to help them get clean, since they all suffer from the "disease" of addiction, which is likely co-morbid with several other serious mental/and or physical diseases. The idea that these people are sub-human "scum" probably makes it harder to provide the right services to them, though I must admit I am very ignorant of how the system works when it comes to this. There are services out there for sure, and they either avoid them or these services have failed them. Although they suffer from the "disease" of addiction, they still need to make the "choice" to get clean.

At least Arnade does a good job of humanizing these drug addicted prostitutes for his readers, which is a step in the right direction.
 
Last edited:
And Jesus knew the answer -
"All you who labour, all you who suffer
Only believe in me"
But Judas sought a world where no-one
Starved or begged for bread
................
"So renounce all earthly treasures
And pray to your heavenly father"
And he pacified the hopeless
With the hope of life eternal
 
How, exactly, does this work? The argument is "People who are at rock bottom are religious." This is presented as an argument FOR religion?!

Don't get me wrong, correlation doesn't equal causation. However, it does suggest that we need to look further into the question. And here, there are certainly questions about why religion is so common at the bottom.For example, we have to ask why the presence of religion, if it was such a positive influence, isn't moving these people past their problems. Why does such a powerful driving force for good (the conclusion we're supposed to draw, and accepted ad arguendum) not prevent the perpetuation of self-destructive behavior? Shouldn't it be causing drug adicts to give up their adiction?

Basically the data presented show that wealthy, happy, prosperous people tend to be more atheistic, while poor, despirate, and self-destructive people tend towards theism, and particularly Catholicism/Christianity. At minimum we need to question what the causal factors are here.
 
Basically the data presented show that wealthy, happy, prosperous people tend to be more atheistic, while poor, despirate, and self-destructive people tend towards theism,

This should be a surprise to anyone. In fact, it is the selling point of religion.

"When you are miserable and your life is desperate, God is there to get you through the hard times." Shoot, I've even heard a preacher make that exact sales pitch in a sermon. He even said, "If your life is great, then good for you. But if you are having problems, look to God for help."

For one, I couldn't believe that he could say something like that, but then I realized that he could, because everyone can always find some reason to be unhappy, so it's a pretty sure thing.

Of course, I was looking around this church, which is filled with all these well-to-do families with their smiling kids and thinking, why are you all so unhappy? Is my life perfect? Of course not. However, I look at my life and think, I've got a wife, kids, a job, a house...ya know what? My life is pretty damn good. So all his stuff about how life is so miserable, and turning to God in those troubled times just didn't make sense to me.
 
How, exactly, does this work? The argument is "People who are at rock bottom are religious." This is presented as an argument FOR religion?!

Don't get me wrong, correlation doesn't equal causation. However, it does suggest that we need to look further into the question. And here, there are certainly questions about why religion is so common at the bottom. For example, we have to ask why the presence of religion, if it was such a positive influence, isn't moving these people past their problems. Why does such a powerful driving force for good (the conclusion we're supposed to draw, and accepted ad arguendum) not prevent the perpetuation of self-destructive behavior? Shouldn't it be causing drug adicts to give up their adiction?
Basically the data presented show that wealthy, happy, prosperous people tend to be more atheistic, while poor, despirate, and self-destructive people tend towards theism, and particularly Catholicism/Christianity. At minimum we need to question what the causal factors are here.

I've been thinking the same thing myself, and I'm surprised more people haven't voiced the very damning highlighted part. Of course, there are some recovering drug addicts who are "born-againers", who credit their religion with giving them the strength to break their addiction. Maybe it did, maybe it didn't, but its very difficult to find out the truth here, though this in no way validates their religious beliefs. I've also known some very religious self-destructive people, as well as self-destructive atheists.

Interestingly enough, there is actually a large monastery in the middle of this very poor, drug and violence plagued neighborhood in the Bronx that is the focus of Arnade's project. Surprise surprise, this seems to be of little help to the homeless drug-addicts, and based on my experiences in this neighborhood(it's not that far away from me and I've been there countless times), I've never seen the sisters out on the streets trying to help the drug addicted prostitutes(I even thought the monastery was abandoned, though I did read in some articles that the sisters do try to help sometimes).

In fact, the prostitutes often congregate just outside the high walls of the monastery in what is pretty much the center of the de facto red light district of the Bronx. One time at night I saw about a dozen of them scattered along in front of the monastery walls or just across the street(I never sought out their services). The cops up the street usually turn a blind eye to what is going on, though occasionally they do arrest everyone in sight about once a month, or if the local community complains enough.

All-in-all, this article has no argument, though maybe Arnade is trying to tell us to not promote atheism to drug-addicted prostitutes? Is that what it's all about? But who does that? And I agree with you about trying to find out what the causal factors are, though it could be very complicated.
 
Last edited:
pgwenthold said:
Of course, I was looking around this church, which is filled with all these well-to-do families with their smiling kids and thinking, why are you all so unhappy? Is my life perfect? Of course not. However, I look at my life and think, I've got a wife, kids, a job, a house...ya know what? My life is pretty damn good. So all his stuff about how life is so miserable, and turning to God in those troubled times just didn't make sense to me.
I've wondered the same thing. You see a church full of people declaring themselves to be miserable and degraded and pathetic, and that life is brutal and nasty and short, yet they go home to central air conditioned houses, turn on television sets, grab a beer from a refrigerator, and take an asprin for the pain in their joints caused by over-eating. Compare that with the life of pretty much anyone in 1800, 1700, 1600, 1500....

But my problem with this notion is a bit more than that. If someone is allegedly helping you, they get you out of the negative situation you've found yourself in. However, it doesn't appear that God is doing that. God appears, if anything, to be keeping people in bad situations. This is corroborated by several thinkers of the Christ Cults, including the (in)famous Mother Terresa.

The evidence seems to support the notion that God, if He exists, is a sadistic dick. And that's the evidence provided by the "Pro God" side!
 
This information makes me wonder if the church marquees will soon be displaying things like:

JOIN THE CHURCH BECAUSE WE HAVE MANY RELIGIOUS DURG ADDICTS AND PROSTITUTES

Or perhaps:

LOTS OF DRUG ADDICTS AND PROSTITUTES ARE RELIGIOUS, AND SO SHOULD YOU

And so on.
 
If the author has only had his atheism challenged by the poor and needy, he should get out more.
 
Many people in our society, addict or not, were imprinted with religion from a very young age. This and the fact that religion gives them some kind of hope in their darkest hours is, I believe, are the driving forces for their religious beliefs.
 
I've wondered the same thing. You see a church full of people declaring themselves to be miserable and degraded and pathetic, and that life is brutal and nasty and short, yet they go home to central air conditioned houses, turn on television sets, grab a beer from a refrigerator, and take an asprin for the pain in their joints caused by over-eating. Compare that with the life of pretty much anyone in 1800, 1700, 1600, 1500....

But my problem with this notion is a bit more than that. If someone is allegedly helping you, they get you out of the negative situation you've found yourself in. However, it doesn't appear that God is doing that. God appears, if anything, to be keeping people in bad situations. This is corroborated by several thinkers of the Christ Cults, including the (in)famous Mother Terresa.

The evidence seems to support the notion that God, if He exists, is a sadistic dick. And that's the evidence provided by the "Pro God" side!

I don't know, the concept of "homeless, drug abusers, and prostitutes are very religious therefore maybe God actually exists" is new to me, so I've never thought about it before. Mainly because it is so mindboggingly stupid that I wouldn't have imagined it.

Personally, this is the example of where I say, if that is the type of thing that would actually convert a supposed atheist, then I don't want that person running around claiming to be an atheist in the first place.
 
This information makes me wonder if the church marquees will soon be displaying things like:

JOIN THE CHURCH BECAUSE WE HAVE MANY RELIGIOUS DURG ADDICTS AND PROSTITUTES

Or perhaps:

LOTS OF DRUG ADDICTS AND PROSTITUTES ARE RELIGIOUS, AND SO SHOULD YOU

And so on.

"Don't become a drug addict or prostitute. Let God help you with that."
 
I don't know, the concept of "homeless, drug abusers, and prostitutes are very religious therefore maybe God actually exists" is new to me, so I've never thought about it before. Mainly because it is so mindboggingly stupid that I wouldn't have imagined it.

Personally, this is the example of where I say, if that is the type of thing that would actually convert a supposed atheist, then I don't want that person running around claiming to be an atheist in the first place.


It's hard to understand exactly the point he is trying to make, but I don't think it is necessarily that these homeless, drug-addicted prostitutes are kind of convincing him that maybe there is a God(Arnade is still an atheist). Rather, his point is that he sees his atheism as some kind of "luxury", and that if he didn't have it so good, he might not be an atheist today. And that atheists shouldn't try to convince very poor, desperate people that there is no God, though this isn't something that atheists tend to do.

Having followed his blog for a while, he seems kind of embarrassed over his atheism when he is in the company of the very religious drug addicted prostitutes. He's learned to keep his mouth shut about what he really believes when they tell him "pray for me". Their religion seems to be the only thing that gives them comfort in this world, he claims.

Regardless, his article seems muddled.
 
Zelenius said:
Rather, his point is that he sees his atheism as some kind of "luxury"...
That's telling by itself. Atheism is the rational conclusion. To argue that rationality is a luxury inverses causality. Being rational wouldn't necessarily ensure wealth, but it certainly would help these people!

Their religion seems to be the only thing that gives them comfort in this world, he claims.
Ironically, so do the drugs.
 
This isn't something I believe, it's a quote from journalist/photographer former Wall Streeter Chris Arnade in "The people who challenged my atheism most were drug addicts and prostitutes":

Ironic. It was that a god permits addicts and prostitutes' terrible, illegal lives, that challenged my religiosity. That and Yahweh sitting on his ass while babies got raped to death, not stopping it because he was good and could.
 
He'd be a great deal less likely to find a prostitute asking someone to 'pray for them' or to find a bible in a crack house in the UK. I'm not sure why that should be other than we are a much less religious society, and we have more safety nets for the homeless and those suffering from addiction.

If Arnade is saying that atheism is a luxury that the poor and dispossessed can't afford, then I disagree with him.
 
So religion preys on the most vulnerable members of society, and that's an argument FOR religion? Uh huh.
 
So religion preys on the most vulnerable members of society, and that's an argument FOR religion? Uh huh.

Exactly! Oh and don't forget that Richard Dawkins is an ivory tower elitist, completely removed from society so he doesn't know what he's talking about.

Ironically enough, argumentum ad homeless drug addicted prostitute is an "argument" only an atheist could make. A religious person trying to attack atheism would be too embarrassed to acknowledge the extreme religiosity of the people Arnade is trying to give a voice to. It almost seems like a twisted kind of parody. It's not just that this line of "argument" doesn't work, it's that it more strongly implies the opposite of the point Arnade is trying to make.
 
Last edited:
The thing that really bugs me about this is, if I wanted to pick the most judgmental group of folks, it's be the religious not atheists.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom