Foolmewunz
Grammar Resistance Leader, TLA Dictator
George Washington – Cut down a cherry tree and could not tell a “lie”
Benjamin Franklin – Discovered electricity during a thunderstorm flying a key attached to a “kite”
Paul Revere – Gave instructions to place lanterns in a steeple when the British were coming; one if by land, two if by “sea” (which is like the “ocean”)
OK. That’s not an exact match, but with the limited vocabulary available in the Ovilus, that seems like a pretty good match. The man in the video claims the odds it could get three words that matched those three cards in some way are “astronomical”. Are they? We can’t calculate the exact odds, but we can get a rough idea. To do so, we must consider a number of things.
The model used was the Ovilus X, which has 2048 words. The word list is available from the manufacturer here: http://digitaldowsing.com/ovilus-word-list/. I did a quick run through the list and came up with almost 10% of the words matching “Paul Revere” in some way more or less as well as “ocean” does. So each random word would have about a 10% chance of matching one of the cards. Even if we only grant 5% of the words as a possible match, that is still hardly “astronomical”. But, we might think, words like “lie” and “kite” are certainly better matches, so maybe it really is unlikely to have happened by chance.
Next, we have to consider all of the words available. It wasn’t three words that matched three cards. It was 12 words that all had a possibility (of 5-10%) of matching a card. Six of the words (half of them) were simply dismissed as irrelevant to the claim. This practice of remembering the hits and forgetting the misses is called “selection bias”. When we consider all of the words given, the odds are moving far away from “astronomical”.
Also, we don’t know how many times this person has tried this experiment. In the beginning, he claims he “tried using the cards” (whatever that means) the previous year without any success. Whatever the odds are of getting a match to the cards, because the experiment has been done twice, we can double those odds. The odds are starting to look move “even” than “astronomical”.
And he may have conducted many other similar experiments that were not at the same site with no “positive” results and not posted a video for those. Of course, many, many people have probably done experiments with the Ovilus and came up with nothing and never posted a video or otherwise reported it. The fact that typically only interesting or positive results get published is called “publication bias” or “the file drawer effect”. If we consider all of the experiments with the Ovilus that have ever been done, the odds that there will occasionally be a coincidence is not “astronomical” or even “even” but downright “probable”. It would be more surprising of such instances didn’t happen.
But, we may think, perhaps the spirits don’t often communicate via the Ovilus and this happened to be one of those rare “real” cases. Putting aside the total odds (which we shouldn’t do) we still are left with what may appear to be three amazing “hits”. But are they really “hits”?
We have to consider the context of the questions. The experimenter did not ask, “What is in my equipment bag?” He just asks for…anything. The only question he specifically asks related to the claim is for something confirming “Paul Revere” after “kite” which resulted in “however” (which is certainly not a hit). This means that the word could have been matched to anything related to an items in any of his bags, the location, the date of he experiment, etc. He had a packet of fake colonial currency in his bag. Given a different set of random words, those words may have “amazingly” matched those items,
or anything related to the any items he had in any bags
or in his pockets
or in the surrounding area
or the Monmouth Battlefield where the experiment took place
or the George Washington waypoint marker the Ovilus was sitting on
or June 28th (the date of the Battle of Monmouth and date of the experiment)
or anything related to the Battle of Monmouth
or any of the equipment itself
or the man doing the experiment
or the jug of water used as the “trigger object”
or Old Tennet Church where the chimes rang during the session
or…well, you can see where this is going.
The claim is that a spirit is using the Ovilus to select words from the dictionary to communicate something to the experimenter. If I think of words associated with “George Washington” it will be quite a while before I get to “lie”. There are certainly better words to communicate that I am talking about George Washington, even within the limited dictionary of the Ovilus.
The claim is that the spirit wanted to communicate an indication of “Paul Revere” and chose the word “ocean” in reference to “two if by sea”. But if that was the intent, wouldn’t the spirit just use the word “sea” which is in the Ovilus X dictionary? Or if the spirit happened to not find that “sea” was available, perhaps “Paul” which is also in the dictionary. If this were, in fact, a communication from a spirit about the three trading cards, I would be a bit more impressed if it had given the following words (all of which are in the Ovilus X dictionary):
George
Washington
Paul
Reverend
Bend
Frank
Lynn
I agree that it's the old EVP pair of doilies or "business as usual" in ghost hunter world. And quite obviously, the spirits are being their usual oblique selves. Why not "George Washington" to identify, say, George Washington? How about "Old North Church" for Revere?
More interesting is that the spirits have been caught fibbing again. Have they been reading too many spirit spam messages? Washington and the cherry tree is totally unsupported. Ditto Franklin and the kite. But since the device is made by dowsers, I guess we're getting confirmation bias of the user.
