The Otto Weininger Syndrome

Skeptic

Banned
Joined
Jul 25, 2001
Messages
18,312
The author of this piece is not exactly someone I always agree with and she has a tendency to demonize opponents. But she does have a point in this particular case: it is true that, for many Jews, alas, self-hate is the main motivation and all the talk of peace and happiness and equality and criticism "more in sorrow than in anger" is just fluff.
 
yes Skeptic, only a self-hating Jew talks about peace, democracy, and equality.

very good.

what the **** are you trying to say about the Jewish people? that a TRUE Jew wants to rule Palestine from the Sea to the River, and a TRUE Jew wants to strip Arabs in Israel of political rights, and a TRUE Jew wants to confiscate Arab private property and build Jewish settlements?

Only self-hating Jews wants a two-state solution, wants full-democracy in Israel, wants full political rights for all non-Jews, and wants the end to illegal settlements and confiscation of private property?


Your opinion of Jews...is no different than that of Neo-Nazis.

Your opinion of Jews, is vile, insulting, outrageous, and a disgrace. Shame on you for how you view your own flesh and blood.
 
Last edited:
i also found it a bit anti semitic to say "it is true that, for many Jews, alas, self-hate is the main motivation and all the talk of peace and happiness and equality and criticism "more in sorrow than in anger" is just fluff."

i only hope also Sceptic has a bit of self hate so he can talk about peace and happiness from time to time.
 
i also found it a bit anti semitic to say "it is true that, for many Jews, alas, self-hate is the main motivation and all the talk of peace and happiness and equality and criticism "more in sorrow than in anger" is just fluff."

it is 100% anti-Semitic to suggest that the only Jews who talk about peace and the two-state solution, and democracy, and civil and political rights for all, are self-hating Jews.

its basically arguing that a regular Jew...is a fascist, racist, authoritarian, genocidal pig.

but who knows, maybe this is what Skeptic actually believes. I cry for his ancestors though..if this is the case.
 
Last edited:
Labelling people you disagree with as mentally ill ("syndrome") is very Stalinist.
 
Labelling people you disagree with as mentally ill ("syndrome") is very Stalinist.

Indeed. He would fit in famously with Stalinists if they weren´t communists. He would also fit in famously with Nazis if they didn´t have that prejudice about Jews.
 
Labelling people you disagree with as mentally ill ("syndrome") is very Stalinist.

It depends what they disagree on. If they disagree on what political party should rule, it is. If they disagree on whether they are Napoleon or not, not necessarily.

When we have Jewish "peace" activists whose only disagreement, and a minor one at that, with Hamas & co. is exactly in what way should the Jewish state be destroyed, this is far more like the second case like in the first case.

To give an analogy from Stalin's time, sure, Stalin sent lots of Russians to mental institutions for disagreeing with him. But if a Russian had come to meet with Hitler and tell him he is 100% correct about how the inferior Slavs must be thrown into the sea enslaved, Stalin would have a point about that one.
 
What do we call a strawman analogy again?

Who is "we"?

You and I and a bunch of others call it "argument by bullflop" or something like that.

"Skeptic" and the rest of the bizarre alternate universe where he gets his wisdom from call it "reality".
 
Who is "we"?

You and I and a bunch of others call it "argument by bullflop" or something like that.

"Skeptic" and the rest of the bizarre alternate universe where he gets his wisdom from call it "reality".

Wasn't implying we were all part of the same gang. I just used it as a rhetorical device. :o
And actually Skeptic may call it the same, just not on this issue.
 
It depends what they disagree on. If they disagree on what political party should rule, it is. If they disagree on whether they are Napoleon or not, not necessarily.

When we have Jewish "peace" activists whose only disagreement, and a minor one at that, with Hamas & co. is exactly in what way should the Jewish state be destroyed, this is far more like the second case like in the first case.

So....labeling them as mentally ill isn't Stalinist because they're Enemies of the State.
 
Of course, she doesn't say that those who act like this are mentally ill in the clinical sense. She makes it quite clear they know very well to take care of their own interests and careers. It's just their people they dislike as uniquely evil. Anyway, shouting "STALINIST!" isn't much of a criticism. It's more a refusal to discuss the evidence.
 
Of course, she doesn't say that those who act like this are mentally ill in the clinical sense. She makes it quite clear they know very well to take care of their own interests and careers. It's just their people they dislike as uniquely evil. Anyway, shouting "STALINIST!" isn't much of a criticism. It's more a refusal to discuss the evidence.

shouting "Weininger" doesn't make much of a difference.
 
Sorry folks, but I just had to point out the GREAT irony...and UTTER Chutzpah..of a thread about so-called "self-hating Jews", being written on a computer, during the Jewish Sabbath.

Was a ham and swiss sandwhich eaten while this thread was created? Maybe a lobster role with parmesan?

This thread is a hateful embarrassment to the Jewish people.
 
Sorry folks, but I just had to point out the GREAT irony...and UTTER Chutzpah..of a thread about so-called "self-hating Jews", being written on a computer, during the Jewish Sabbath.

Was a ham and swiss sandwhich eaten while this thread was created? Maybe a lobster role with parmesan?

This thread is a hateful embarrassment to the Jewish people.

Uh, you posted on the 5th as well.

I don't believe either Skeptic, myself, or really any of the other Jewish people on the forum ever claimed to be particularly observant.

I completely fail to see what the point of your post was, unless you intend to start a "frummier than thou" routine. Which would be extremely annoying, and rather stupid (considering, as I said, you posted on Shabbos).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom