Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

You're hilarious.

You type screeds of nonsensical garbage, but when asked for evidence of your stupid claims (don't forget, it was you saying how many kids are in hospital due to the new plague variant) you post 5000 words of obfuscation, whining and nothing of relevance.

Do go on...


And, as is his wont, The Atheist ignores an entire post with facts - in particular the facts contradicting his moronic idea that "only a handful of children under 5 died from covid worldwide."
That he never presented the least bit of documentation for his claim is 'forgotten' in his panic attack.
 
Last edited:
I'm looking for details on Pfizer's Vaccine Protocol (C4591001 Amendment 9, Oct. 29 2020) change.
(...)
Anyone seen any detail on this?


That was four years ago, and I don't remember if I have seen anything like that - and certainly no details. Our knowledge about both the vaccines, the virus, its variants and their ability to evade previously acquired immunity has been updated several times since then.

The irony is that the minimizers were the ones who were most adamant that people had acquired life-long immunity - whether by infection of vaccination:
Overselling the vaccine in 2021 was not being pro-vaccine. It was pro-stop-worrying-about-the pandemic, from the doctors who assured us herd immunity was imminent.
(...)
No vaccine is 100% effective or safe, and being pro-vaccine means acknowledging their blemishes and areas of uncertainty, at least with new vaccines.

When the original COVID mRNA vaccine data was announced (here and here), they were 95% effective against COVID infection and even better against severe disease, though not 100% effective as several doctors claimed. There was a lot to be positive about, and it was vital to convey this information to the public. I encouraged vaccination with every patient I saw, and I still do. Countless people are alive today because doctors properly extolled the benefits of the COVID vaccines.

While optimism was entirely appropriate in early 2021, so was caution and humility. The virus was just a just year old, and January 2021 was the deadliest part of the pandemic. Over 3,000 Americans died on some days that month. The virus had given us many reasons to respect it in that first year, and we didn’t know what variants might be on the horizon.

The vaccines, of course, were brand new. Only 36,930 people had been vaccinated in the two mRNA trials, and they lasted just several months. The median age was 52-years, and trial participants are often unrepresentative of the public at large. There were just 347 cases of COVID, 40 severe cases, and only 1 COVID death in these trials.

It wasn’t possible to conclude from the original vaccine trials that the vaccines would be 100% effective against death. These trials taught us a lot, but they were the starting point of us learning about these vaccines, not the end. Over the next few months, hundreds of millions of people around the world would be vaccinated. We still had a lot to learn about their real-world effectiveness, especially over the long-term. We had literally everything to learn about their impact on viral transmission.

Because I am pro-vaccine, I hope I never portrayed them as a perfect panacea that would end the pandemic, and I did my best to acknowledge their unknowns. For example, in April 2021 I said:
"Im very very optimistic vaccines will cut transmission of disease. I’m not certain of it. This is why I wear a mask still in public and when treating covid patients.
Overhyping Vaccines Wasn’t Pro-Vaccine. It Was Pro-Stop-Worrying-About-COVID. (Science-Based Medicine, Oct 1, 2023)


Many quotations from minimizers overhyping COVID-19 vaccine efficacy back in early 2021!
 
Many quotations from minimizers overhyping COVID-19 vaccine efficacy back in early 2021!

To be fair, vaccinations rapidly decreased cases, hospitalizations and deaths in the first part of 2021. Levels then went back up as new variants started popping up. Especially Delta which escaped vaccination even 3 months earlier. Prior to that there were few breakthrough infections from either vax or prior infection so there was reasonable hope vaccination would be sufficient to end Covid-19. By summer that hope was dispelled.
 
Thanks a lot for posting this, please keep on. It’s more difficult, in my experience, to get good info now that everyone see Covid as something to live with. I got it once, did really well with Paxlovid, am 71 years old, and I don’t want to get it again, and this masking info helps.


I think it's the other way round, cause and effect: Making it difficult for us to get good info makes everyone see Covid as something to live with - which was also what we were told to do: learn to live with the virus! I have actually heard people say that since the media no longer releases daily updates, it must mean that the virus is gone. The numbers they may see, i.e. the number of new registered positive cases, is obviously a tiny fraction of what they used to be. When you look at the graphics, there appears to be zero cases now compared to 2021 when Denmark was world leader in testing. Even though most people no longer get tested nowadays, it doesn't occur to them that the only people who do get tested are the ones who are hospitalized.

Only 85+ are eligible for Paxlovid in Denmark - and in the rest of the Nordics, too, I think. :mad:

Got any good sources of info on Covid risk on planes? I know about most of the relevant factors but haven’t stumbled on good empirical studies. A friend who is older than me keeps on getting on planes and getting Covid soon afterwards, several times now. An anecdote, sure, but it drives me to find out good data.

I saw something fairly comprehensive about the spread of virus on planes. I'll try to find it again. I remember somebody writing that there is more virus in the air onboard before take-off and after landing. Airports and trains to and from airports also aren't C19 safe spaces ...

Some of the Covid-conscious people on X, many of the doctors, many of them frequent flyers, say they haven't been infected yet and attribute it to wearing good respirators. I've only flown once during the pandemic: Copenhagen-Paris-Havana and back. A lot of coughing going on everywhere, but I didn't catch anything. I wore an FFP2/N95 but took it off on the plane during meals/coffee.
And I got vaxxed in Cuba before returning.
 
To be fair, vaccinations rapidly decreased cases, hospitalizations and deaths in the first part of 2021. Levels then went back up as new variants started popping up. Especially Delta which escaped vaccination even 3 months earlier. Prior to that there were few breakthrough infections from either vax or prior infection so there was reasonable hope vaccination would be sufficient to end Covid-19. By summer that hope was dispelled.


That was not the Danish experience. By the end of 2021 when almost everybody (except kids) had been vaxxed in the summer and boosted in the fall, restrictions and mask mandates were suspended. In the winter of 2021-22, we were supposed to have acquired "super immunity," i.e. 'hybrid immunity'. It was very obvious that we hadn't.

TeTrIs, working from home, masking in indoor public places and schools going online in the early spring of 2020 and in the winter of 2020-21 kept the numbers relatively low before vaccinations. Learning to live live with the virus post-vax killed an awful lot of Danes in the winter of '21-'22 - and even in the early spring. The cumulative death toll of C19 almost doubled in the first four months of 2022:
Cumulative confirmed COVID-19 deaths, Jan 1 to May 1, 2022.

It is what makes it seem to some antivaxxers as if people were killed by the vaccines. Post hoc ergo procter hoc. However, it is fairly obvious that the dying didn't start in the summer of 2021 when most of the population had had the first two jabs. It didn't begin until all other precautions except vaccinations were suspended.
 
It does sound good, but there have been an awful lot of attempts to make a nasal spray against Covid. The stories about them all sounded good as long as they were at the developmental stage. Cuba's Mambisa was one of them, but in spite of the success of their conventional C19 vaccines, Mambisa didn't seem to work in the end.
The Finns talked about this one for a couple of years. I don't know what happened to it.
 
Our Freedumb-Lovin' Right to Get Infected

Got any good sources of info on Covid risk on planes?


I can't find the one I was thinking of. It seemed to have been written by somebody who knew all about ventilation on planes.
This new study is probably right, and it points to the tragedy of our current situation:
Results
The study found that compared to short-haul flights without enforced masking, long-haul flights with no strict masking had a 25.93-fold increase in COVID-19 incidence rates, while medium-haul flights had a 4.66-fold higher incidence rate. However, long-haul flights where masking was enforced reported no transmission of SARS-CoV-2, indicating that masking could significantly lower aircraft-acquired COVID-19.

Furthermore, in flights with unenforced masking, each hourly increase in flight duration increased the transmission incidence rate by 1.53-fold. The reduced duration of exposure to aerosols and the non-inclusion of meals make shorter flights safer since they lower the probability of expelling aerosol particles or coming in contact with them.

The study also found that long-haul flights with enforced masking had almost no reports of SARS-CoV-2 transmission within the aircraft despite meals being served. The researchers believe the enforced masking could have caused the passengers to eat as quickly as possible. Furthermore, enforced masking also allows the flight attendants to ensure that passengers are appropriately masked.

Conclusions
Overall, the study found that flight duration was a factor in the transmission of SARS-CoV-2 within the aircraft in flights with non-enforced masking. In contrast, long-haul flights with enforced masking had no reports of transmission of SARS-CoV-2 within the aircraft despite serving meals. The researchers also found that each additional hour of flight was associated with a 1.53-fold higher probability of viral transmission in flights without enforced masking. These findings highlight the protective effect of face masks against SARS-CoV-2.
Study shows enforced masking on long flights prevents SARS-CoV-2 transmission (News-Medical, May 28, 2024)


But we obviously can't have enforced masking! Not even on airplanes, of all places! That would interfere with our freedom to catch and spread the virus!
At least, we can mask up ourselves and hope that it's enough to protect us from the freedumb-lovin' antimasker morons and their disinformed victims.
On the planes to and from Cuba, I noticed that some of the air hostesses wore face masks. So did some of the people in the group I was traveling with - mainly because I had recommended it - FFP2 specifically. (We would be visiting hospitals and policlinics in Cuba!) Most of the other passengers didn't, not even the coughers.

Some of the people in my group who didn't mask up on the plane got a bad cough a few days after we had arrived in Havana. Nobody wearing face masks did. One of the people who developed a cough has since then (Sep-Oct '22) come down with Parkinson's, but it's impossible to say if one particular case is due to the infection.
 
Last edited:
I can't find the one I was thinking of. It seemed to have been written by somebody who knew all about ventilation on planes.
This new study is probably right, and it points to the tragedy of our current situation:



But we obviously can't have enforced masking! Not even on airplanes, of all places! That would interfere with our freedom to catch and spread the virus!
At least, we can mask up ourselves and hope that it's enough to protect us from the freedumb-lovin' antimasker morons and their disinformed victims.
On the planes to and from Cuba, I noticed that some of the air hostesses wore face masks. So did some of the people in the group I was traveling with - mainly because I had recommended it - FFP2 specifically. (We would be visiting hospitals and policlinics in Cuba!) Most of the other passengers didn't, not even the coughers.

Some of the people in my group who didn't mask up on the plane got a bad cough a few days after we had arrived in Havana. Nobody wearing face masks did. One of the people who developed a cough has since then (Sep-Oct '22) come down with Parkinson's, but it's impossible to say if one particular case is due to the infection.
Thanks for all that! I guess we have to grin (underneath a mask) and bear it for plane flights. Do you think that wearing a mask offers significant protection to the individual wearing the mask on a plane without enforced masking?
 
Thanks for all that! I guess we have to grin (underneath a mask) and bear it for plane flights. Do you think that wearing a mask offers significant protection to the individual wearing the mask on a plane without enforced masking?


I was under the impression that masks don’t really protect you when you wear them. It is the infected person who should wear a mask.

You should wear a mask in order to protect other people because there is no way you can know if you are infected or not.

(I don’t wear a mask for the same reason as most other people: it is a hassle, and you is always sure you are not infected yourself)
 
Thanks for all that! I guess we have to grin (underneath a mask) and bear it for plane flights. Do you think that wearing a mask offers significant protection to the individual wearing the mask on a plane without enforced masking?


Wearing a mask of good quality offers significant protection to the individual wearing the mask everywhere.
Everybody knows that:
Masks? I've openly stated my son and I wear them.
Planes aren't any different from all other indoor public spaces in that respect.
And it not only helps protect you and your loved ones. Seeing you wear one helps people who would like to mask up but are too afraid to do so because they fear nothing more than standing out. (There are a lot of those.)
It's called salting the vibes.


ETA: Rolfe (a veterinarian virologist, IIRC) pointed this out very early on in the thread about Sweden's pandemic response: Viral load (Wikipedia) plays a role in infection:
Viral load is often expressed as viral particles, (virions) or infectious particles per mL depending on the type of assay. A higher viral burden, titre, or viral load often correlates with the severity of an active viral infection.
1) You have to breathe in a certain amount of virus (or number of virus particles) to get infected.
2) But even if you breathe in enough virus to get infected, the face mask may at least have helped you lower the potential viral load, thus making the infection less severe than it would otherwise have been.
 
Last edited:
I was under the impression that masks don’t really protect you when you wear them. It is the infected person who should wear a mask.

You should wear a mask in order to protect other people because there is no way you can know if you are infected or not.

(I don’t wear a mask for the same reason as most other people: it is a hassle, and you is always sure you are not infected yourself)


It works both ways! (Why wouldn't it?!) In both cases, the point is that as much as possible of the air that you breathe, in or out, passes through the filter.
But it is much easier to test how much virus escapes into the air from a person wearing a face mask than it is to test how much (less) virus a person wearing a mask breathes in. To emulate the latter, they had to wrap a hamster cage in filters and place it in a room contaminated with SARS-CoV-2, if I remember correctly. (It worked!)

Unless you test whenever you are about to leave your home, you can't be sure that you are not infected. Asymptomatic and presymptomatic transmission of the virus is real.

As for the hassle, putting on a mask isn't more difficult than putting on your glasses. Putting on a face mask is slightly less of a hassle than putting on hearing aids.
Besides, I've never had to change the batteries of a face mask in the middle of a conversation.
 
Last edited:
As for the hassle, putting on a mask isn't more difficult than putting on your glasses. Putting on a face mask is slightly less of a hassle than putting on hearing aids.
I wear glasses, and I can assure you that it is a constant hassle to keep them from fogging when wearing a mask. Some masks are better than others, but I have yet to try a mask that didn’t leave some air passing the glasses after wearing it a while.

Fortunately I manage well without glasses, so if I don’t need to look far, I can take them off.
 
True. I only use glasses indoors, mainly for reading, so it hasn't been a problem for me, but I have heard many others complain about the same thing.
However, your problem points to another one, which is worse: The masks apparently let air escape that doesn't go through the filter. This means that they probably also let air in the same way.

Your face masks don't fit properly. Have you tried the duckbill ones? And/or the ones that go over the head instead of behind the ears?
 
I wear glasses, and I can assure you that it is a constant hassle to keep them from fogging when wearing a mask. Some masks are better than others, but I have yet to try a mask that didn’t leave some air passing the glasses after wearing it a while.

Fortunately I manage well without glasses, so if I don’t need to look far, I can take them off.

True. I only use glasses indoors, mainly for reading, so it hasn't been a problem for me, but I have heard many others complain about the same thing.
However, your problem points to another one, which is worse: The masks apparently let air escape that doesn't go through the filter. This means that they probably also let air in the same way.

Your face masks don't fit properly. Have you tried the duckbill ones? And/or the ones that go over the head instead of behind the ears?

It's almost never a fit issue.

It's because exhaled air goes through the same path as inhaled air which is pretty much the entire mask. Since exhaled air is virtually 100% humidity and lighter than the cooler air, the air that leaves on the top surface of the mask condenses water on the nearby glasses. One solution is to use a N95 with an exit port. Problem with that is it only provides user protection but doesn't protect others. One thing to try is to put some tape over the top portion of the mask. Not too much (< 20% of mask surface) as it will increase inhale/exhale air resistance. Not a perfect solution but should help in most conditions.
 
No, it's almost always a fit issue, which is why taping the top of the mask to the skin will actually help, but it will make it even more of a hassle, obviously. And for people who are already embarrassed about masking up, it will make them even more conspicuous.
Some people recommend 3M aura masks.
There is also the option to treat the glasses with anti-fog lens spray. I think all opticians sell it. I use it for the face shield of my motorcycle helmet.
How to Keep Glasses from Fogging with a Mask (WarbyParker, Aug 13, 2024)
The YouTube video accompanying the article shows a surgical mask, which is better than nothing, but not really good. There are several other YouTube videos about this problem and solutions to it.
 
From foggy lenses to foggy brains

RESULTS
The mean age of the COVID-19 group was 56.0±6.6 years, while that of the control group was 58.1±7.3 years. Longitudinal models indicated a significant decline in cognitive throughput (β=-0.168, P=.001) following COVID-19, after adjustment for pre-COVID-19 functioning, demographics, and medical factors. Observed changes in throughput were equivalent to 10.6 years of normal aging. COVID-19 was associated with observed cognitive decline and was worse among patients with PASC or severe COVID-19.
Characterization of change in cognition before and after COVID-19 infection in essential workers at midlife (American Journal of Medicine Open/Science Direct, Aug 13, 2024 )


I assume that "10.6 years of normal aging" doesn't mean older but wiser.
 
Breakthrough?

It remains to be seen if anything will come of it, but ...
SARS-CoV-2 uses its spike protein to attach to the angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 on human cells, initiating a process that allows it to enter the cell. The spike protein has two main parts: the S1 domain, which varies greatly among different strains of the virus, and the S2 domain, which is highly conserved across different coronaviruses. This similarity makes the S2 domain a promising target for vaccines and therapies that could work against many virus strains.
By combining simulations and theoretical predictions with structural information from their experimental collaborators, including initial and final configurations as well as intermediate states during the viral invasion, the researchers obtained a detailed picture of the infection process at an atomic level.
Researchers make breakthrough in fight against COVID-19 (Rice University, Aug 16, 2024)


This idea is not unlike the one that the Cuban vaccines are based on: to target the receptor-binding domain (RBD). Since the RBD doesn't vary (i.e. mutate) as much as the top part of the spike protein, new variants are less likely to become immune evasive as fast as is currently the case. At least, that's what I assume is the idea.

The YouTube video accompanying the article from Rice University:
A team led by Jose Onuchic at Rice University and Paul Whitford at Northeastern University, both researchers at the National Science Foundation Physics Frontiers Center at the Center for Theoretical Biological Physics (CTBP) at Rice, has made a discovery in the fight against severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2), the virus responsible for COVID-19.
The team, in partnership with an experimental effort led by Yale University researchers Walter Mothes and Wenwei Li, has uncovered new insights into how the virus infects human cells and how it can be neutralized. Their findings were published in the journal Science on Aug. 15.
SARS-CoV-2 uses its spike protein to attach to the angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 on human cells, initiating a process that allows it to enter the cell. The spike protein has two main parts: the S1 domain, which varies greatly among different strains of the virus, and the S2 domain, which is highly conserved across different coronaviruses. This similarity makes the S2 domain a promising target for vaccines and therapies that could work against many virus strains.
By combining simulations and theoretical predictions with structural information from their experimental collaborators, including initial and final configurations as well as intermediate states during the viral invasion, the researchers obtained a detailed picture of the infection process at an atomic level.
Researchers make breakthrough in fight against COVID-19 (Rice University on YouTube, Aug 16, 2024)


An old (in terms of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic) Chinese article:
Coronavirus disease 2019 is a newly emerging infectious disease currently spreading across the world. It is caused by a novel coronavirus, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2). The spike (S) protein of SARS-CoV-2, which plays a key role in the receptor recognition and cell membrane fusion process, is composed of two subunits, S1 and S2. The S1 subunit contains a receptor-binding domain that recognizes and binds to the host receptor angiotensin-converting enzyme 2, while the S2 subunit mediates viral cell membrane fusion by forming a six-helical bundle via the two-heptad repeat domain. In this review, we highlight recent research advance in the structure, function and development of antivirus drugs targeting the S protein.
Structural and functional properties of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein: potential antivirus drug development for COVID-19 (NIH, Aug/Sep 2020)
 
This is the article for those of your friends and members of your family who give up if you present them with abstracts or summaries of studies, people who may have inadvertently become minimizers because the media gives them the impression that COVID-19 is just another mild virus like the ones we are used to getting every four or five years:

Needless to say, words have meaning. The selection of words modulates the message understood by the receiver. With regard to COVID, terms such as “seasonal”, “like a cold”, and “like the flu” can be selected by writers to paint a portrait that lulls the reader into a false sense of security, drawing comparisons between a virus that has been around for less than five years to other viruses or conditions with respect to which the audience has grown familiar with. Moreover, even stock photos selected for certain news articles can subtly influence your response to the content expressed in that piece. A selected photo of a person gently cradling a tissue paper over their nose, instead of a person waiting for treatment in the ER, may give off the impression that they are harmlessly recovering from a tear-jerking soap opera instead of from a viral illness. In fact, we want to believe that COVID-19 is as gentle as a cold, as this outcome is far more pleasing, so this skewed presentation of the risk is far more palatable than what is expressed in the scientific literature.

However, COVID-19 is not a cold or the flu. Understanding that this virus is not a seasonal nuisance like the common cold is crucial in the fight against it, as explained herein.

We emphasize that the purpose of this piece is to correct some of the language circulating in the media and to arm you with accurate information so that you can make reasoned decisions that are aligned with your health goals. As much as an athlete who is training for a triathlon may want to avoid regularly smoking or taking recreational drug.
No Amount of Hand-Washing Can Make COVID-19 a Seasonal Virus - with a COVID-19 Primer (WHN Science Communications, Aug 14, 2024)


Authors: Špela Šalamon, MD, PhD Yaneer Bar-Yam, PhD, Matti TJ Heino, Nicholas Bertram, Stephane Bilodeau, PhD Greta Fox
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom