Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

This doesn't make sense if re-infections are multiplying LC risk anywhere near what is reported.

You may not have noticed, but people do not get Covid any more. They have "a nasty cold" or "a 100 day cough" etc etc

Self-report studies can over-estimate, but they can also underestimate. If you don't think you've had Covid recently, you're not going to think your new onset issues are caused by Covid, are you? Voila, self-report long covid decreases.

This isn't a surprise, indeed with the declining in testing - both officially and with at-home RATs, I predicted more than a year ago that until we get a confirmed LC test, data on Long Covid prevalence will be increasingly unreliable.

That said, we know that (a) different variants appear to have different risk and (b) multiple vaccinations may decrease risk

How much the waning of protection from vaccines effects LC risk is unknown. How much of an interaction there is between different vaccines and different variants is unknown.

It's virtually impossible now to separate cohorts based on these factors, or have uninfected controls.
 
For the first time, the disease known as Long COVID was addressed on Capitol Hill. Led by U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vermont), the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee heard testimonies from Long COVID patients as well as experts studying the disease. Their focus was on improving patient care and advancing research. Clinical epidemiologist Dr. Ziyad Al-Aly joined the CBS 2 stream to break down his testimony as well as the next steps he hopes to see in the fight against Long COVID.
Leading researcher breaks down first-ever Long COVID Congressional hearing (CBS News, Jan 23, 2024 - 4:39 min.)


His words, "They're absent from the workplace, they're absent from school. You don't really see them ...," remind me of a very short video I saw recently:
Watch this video to find out how easily it is to become invisible after a COVID-19 infection.
Go to ontarioschoolsafety.com to find out how you can help protect Ontario school children and staff from becoming invisible.
Invisible (Long COVID) (Ontario School Safety on YouTube, Nov 5, 2023 - O:57 sec.)


Also from Ontario School Safety on YouTube:
 
Nailed.
That's definitely one of the problems. People who think they have long covid have a vested interest in saying they have long covid.
Given the inability to test for diagnosis, nobody knows what the numbers are, and I'm sorry, but if the long covid consists of anosmia, I don't care and don't believe they should be counted. But they are.


There is no "inability to test for diagnosis."
I have posted links to to articles about Long Covid tests recently: posts 299 and 302.
And that is in addition to my link to the article about a test for CFS, which was also claimed to be non-existent: post 254.

Now, it is again being implied that Long Covid is psychogenic or 'only' "consists of anosmia," as if it weren't an objective fact that COVID-19 leaves permanent physiological damage in its victims, damage for which there are objective criteria. See posts 7, 263, 276, 278 and 290.

marting has found one study based on the reporting of subjective symptoms.
Does it debunk all the studies based on objective criteria for Long Covid? Of course, it doesn't!
Does it prove that all Long Covid symptoms are nothing but psychogenic? Of course not!
Does it prove the objective criteria for Long Covid? Of course, it doesn't! That's not what it set out to do.
Does it prove that not a single one of those reports isn't psychogenic? Of course, it doesn't!
Should those reports be investigated and should the people who reported symptoms be examined and properly, objectively diagnosed? Of course, they should!

Is there any reason, i.e. any fact-based reason, to continue to make entirely unsubstantiated claims that people with Long Covid don't have physiological health problems and that they make it all up, i.e. that they only claim to have it because they "have a vested interest in saying they have long covid"?
Of course, there isn't.
 
Did you actually read the page?

"The data showed long COVID prevalence among all United States adults fell from 7.5% to 6%."

That's exactly what I said - a fall from 7.5 to 6 is a 20% drop when I went to school.
 
marting has found one study based on the reporting of subjective symptoms.
Does it debunk all the studies based on objective criteria for Long Covid? Of course, it doesn't!
Does it prove that all Long Covid symptoms are nothing but psychogenic? Of course not!
Does it prove the objective criteria for Long Covid? Of course, it doesn't! That's not what it set out to do.
Does it prove that not a single one of those reports isn't psychogenic? Of course, it doesn't!
Should those reports be investigated and should the people who reported symptoms be examined and properly, objectively diagnosed? Of course, they should!

Of course it doesn't debunk anything. It's a pathetic paper. I was frankly shocked Nature published it. I ran across it because I was searching for info that explained the decreasing levels of long covid reported by the CDC. This seems in conflict with the multiplier factors reported of long covid on multiple infection. CDC has reported that essentially everyone has gotten covid by 2022 and covid infections have continued. Hence multiple infections that presumably multiply the long covid incidence. What's disgusting about the paper is that it leaves the cursory reader with the impression long covid is a continuing and very large fraction of those that get covid over 2 years while burying the obvious implications of a 3% response rate. I read the whole paper assuming there would be some discussion that they at least sampled non-responders to get some idea of the usefulness of the responding data. Nada. Just a bad paper.
 
That implied the risk of LC fell 6% when it actually fell 1.5% according to the CDC article.

Maths works like this:

If a percentage of 7.5 falls to 6, that is a decrease of 20%.

Saying 1.5 is both incorrect and an unsurprising effort to misinform. It's pretty obvious that something that has already fallen by 20% when infections are still being vastly reduced will fall further.
 
That's not the risk of getting long covid from a sars-cov-2 infection though, is it?

Considering virtually everyone has had covid, that's exactly what it is. I again stress that number will include people who developed anosmia.

Remind me to start a gofundme for the poor darlings.
 
Considering virtually everyone has had covid, that's exactly what it is. I again stress that number will include people who developed anosmia.

No, it's not that either. That figure, for example, obviously does not include people who have recovered.
 
Article based on the study in Cell (see post 301):
Because a loss of dopamine-producing neurons is associated with Parkinson’s disease—a slowly developing neurodegenerative condition that leads to tremors and, often, dementia—people who’ve been infected with COVID are at an increased risk of developing symptoms of the disorder at some point in their lives, the researchers wrote.
“We keep discovering new cell types that can be infected by the virus,” Dr. Shuibing Chen, professor of chemical biology in surgery at Weill Cornell Medicine and lead author on the study, tells Fortune. “We’re still trying to understand how it damages them. We need to keep the work ongoing, keep watching to see what happens.”
Regardless, the virus’s detrimental effect on dopamine neurons may explain neurologic symptoms in those with an active COVID infection, like headache, loss of smell, and a persistent unpleasant taste in the mouth, according to researchers.
It may also explain more immediate neurologic symptoms of long COVID, like brain fog, sleep issues, depression, and anxiety.

COVID survivors may be at a greater risk of developing Parkinson’s disease–like symptoms, researchers warn. What you need to know to protect your health (Fortune, Jan 24, 2024)


In case anybody prefers a summary in German, there's a thread on X:
Menschen, die mit #SARSCoV2 infiziert waren könnten ein höheres Risiko für Parkinson-ähnliche Symptome haben
„Das geht aus einer neuen Studie hervor, die in der Zeitschrift Cell veröffentlicht wurde. Die Forscher verwendeten menschliche Stammzellen, …
#COVID19 #Coronavirus
Ralf Wittenbrink (X, Jan 25, 2024))
 
marting has found one study based on the reporting of subjective symptoms.
Does it debunk all the studies based on objective criteria for Long Covid? Of course, it doesn't!
Does it prove that all Long Covid symptoms are nothing but psychogenic? Of course not!
Does it prove the objective criteria for Long Covid? Of course, it doesn't! That's not what it set out to do.
Does it prove that not a single one of those reports isn't psychogenic? Of course, it doesn't!
Should those reports be investigated and should the people who reported symptoms be examined and properly, objectively diagnosed? Of course, they should!


Of course it doesn't debunk anything. It's a pathetic paper. I was frankly shocked Nature published it. I ran across it because I was searching for info that explained the decreasing levels of long covid reported by the CDC. This seems in conflict with the multiplier factors reported of long covid on multiple infection. CDC has reported that essentially everyone has gotten covid by 2022 and covid infections have continued. Hence multiple infections that presumably multiply the long covid incidence. What's disgusting about the paper is that it leaves the cursory reader with the impression long covid is a continuing and very large fraction of those that get covid over 2 years while burying the obvious implications of a 3% response rate. I read the whole paper assuming there would be some discussion that they at least sampled non-responders to get some idea of the usefulness of the responding data. Nada. Just a bad paper.


My post was about The Atheist's interpretation of your post.
 
Last edited:
My post was about The Atheist's interpretation of your post.

Really? In what way? I don't see your responses having anything to do with The Atheist's comment to my post.

Nailed.

That's definitely one of the problems. People who think they have long covid have a vested interest in saying they have long covid.

Given the inability to test for diagnosis, nobody knows what the numbers are, and I'm sorry, but if the long covid consists of anosmia, I don't care and don't believe they should be counted. But they are.

His first paragraph is a reasonable interpretation of the fact the survey response rate dropped to 3% yet that 3% reported a high percentage of long covid symptoms. The problem is obvious.

The second paragraph was a more general statement, not specific to the paper I posted which had a long list of symptoms from mild to serious. It's just that the paper purports to provide statistics and leaves a casual reader with highly dubious stats while downplaying the limitations of such a poorly responded survey.
 
Really? In what way? I don't see your responses having anything to do with The Atheist's comment to my post.



His first paragraph is a reasonable interpretation of the fact the survey response rate dropped to 3% yet that 3% reported a high percentage of long covid symptoms. The problem is obvious.

The second paragraph was a more general statement, not specific to the paper I posted which had a long list of symptoms from mild to serious. It's just that the paper purports to provide statistics and leaves a casual reader with highly dubious stats while downplaying the limitations of such a poorly responded survey.

You and dann agree that long Covid exists and is a major problem. I think any interpretation that says otherwise is due to a communication error.

But then informed people agree that long Covid exists and is a major problem. There have been many studies reported in this thread that say that. None that says otherwise.
 
But then informed people agree that long Covid exists and is a major problem.

I'm quite certain it exists. I just think it's vastly over-stated and isn't a major problem.

Governments aren't reporting significant pressure on health systems from it, and you can bet they would be if it were anything like as bad as the crazy numbers being thrown around in this thread.
 
I'm quite certain it exists. I just think it's vastly over-stated and isn't a major problem.

Governments aren't reporting significant pressure on health systems from it, and you can bet they would be if it were anything like as bad as the crazy numbers being thrown around in this thread.

Why would there be when people would just be staying home? Try looking for absenteeism from work and school.
 
Really? In what way? I don't see your responses having anything to do with The Atheist's comment to my post.

His first paragraph is a reasonable interpretation of the fact the survey response rate dropped to 3% yet that 3% reported a high percentage of long covid symptoms. The problem is obvious.


The problem may be obvious, but it doesn't lead to the conclusion that "People who think they have long covid have a vested interest in saying they have long covid."
 
Interessant - NHS UK untersagt Blutspenden für alle Personen mit Longcovid bis 6 Monate nach Ende aller Symptome
NHS Blood and Transplant
Give blood
- - -
If you have been diagnosed with Long Covid or have had symptoms for over 12 weeks then please use this entry.
(...)
If you have been diagnosed with Long Covid or have had symptoms for over 12 weeks then you need to wait until it is at least six months since all symptoms have gone.https://my.blood.co.uk/your-account...031&title=Long+Covid+:+COVID-19+(Coronavirus)
Dr.med.Hank Schiffers, MD, MBA, Lean Sensei (X, Jan 25, 2024)


The NHS seems to be aware that Long Covid, much like AIDS/HIV, is not due to any "vested interest."
 
Im Jahr 2023 hat der Krankenstand in Deutschland den Rekordwert von 2022 noch einmal übertroffen, was die deutsche Wirtschaft in die Rezession gedrückt hat. Das berichtet die "Rheinische Post" mit Verweis auf eine Studie des Verbands der forschenden Pharma-Unternehmen (VFA): "Erhebliche Arbeitsausfälle führten zu beträchtlichen Produktionseinbußen - ohne die überdurchschnittlichen Krankentage wäre die deutsche Wirtschaft um knapp 0,5 Prozent gewachsen", heißt es demnach in der noch unveröffentlichten Studie. So aber sei die Wirtschaft um 0,3 Prozent geschrumpft. "Wäre der Krankenstand nicht erneut so hoch gewesen, wären im Jahr 2023 etwa 26 Milliarden Euro zusätzlich erwirtschaftet worden. Anstelle einer milden Rezession hätte es 2023 einen Zuwachs von knapp einem halben Prozent gegeben", schreiben die Autoren Claus Michelsen und Simon Junker laut dem Bericht.
Studie: Rekord-Krankenstand führte zur Rezession (n-tv.de, Jan 26, 2024)
In 2023, sick leave in Germany once again exceeded the record of 2022, which pushed the German economy into recession. This is reported by the "Rheinische Post" with reference to a study by the Association of Researching Pharmaceutical Companies (VFA): "Significant loss of work led to considerable production losses - without the above-average number of sick days, the German economy would have grown by almost 0.5 percent," it says in the still unpublished study. However, the economy has shrunk by 0.3 percent. "If sick leave had not been so high again, around 26 billion more euros would have been generated in 2023. Instead of a mild recession, there would have been an increase of almost half a percent in 2023," the authors Claus Michelsen and Simon Junker write according to the report .
Study: Record sick leave led to recession

What could be the cause of all those sick days?
I think C19 is a valid guess - both the acute phase and Long Covid.

IClaims around the number of long covid cases aren't borne out by reality. We're surrounded by claims that somewhere between 3 and 20% of covid cases result in long covid, yet if that were the case, we'd be seeing vast increases in sick leave and absenteeism, along with corresponding pressure on health systems, because pretty well everyone has had covid.
I participated in a study of sick leave for one of my customers recently, and it was starkly noticeable that sick leave and absenteeism hasn't increased at all. If a significant percentage of people were suffering from long covid, we would have seen an increase, yet there is none.


So what are we to believe in this case, a personal anecdote with no documentation or a study on a national scale?
Who was the alleged customer in the anecdote? Might that customer, or maybe the poster, have had a vested interest in the alleged outcome of the alleged study?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom