The Myth of Progressive Collapse - The Conspiracy Deepens!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Architect

Chief Punkah Wallah
Joined
Aug 29, 2006
Messages
9,827
Location
UK
Everyone in the Truth Movement knows, of course, that progressive collapse such as that encountered at the World Trade Centre is impossible, inasmuch as the lower structure should have significantly slowed or even arrested the failure completely at an early stage. We've heard lots about massive redundancy and safety factors by way of evidence that thesre structures can take punishment and still stand.

The one thing that has always puzzled me is how the NWO managed to keep all us architects and engineers quiet about it.

Well today I saw just how far the evil tendrils of the Bush Neocon administration stretched, and the lengths which they would go to in order to spread the myth still further.

Following a comprehensive 5 year review, the structural requirements of the Scottish Building Standards have been revised to include specific and addition requirements in order to ensure that the extent of any collapse due to damaged structural elements will "not be disproportionate to the original cause".

But this isn't just some poxy national requirement, but is rather based on the new requirements of Structural Eurocode 1, Parts 1-7 (Accidental Actions). Yup, that's right; the Bush Neocons are controlling the various national and EU building standards agencies.

Wow!

As I worked my way through the requirements, in particular a redesign of structural members to act as vertical and horizontal ties in the event of columnular damage and the new regulation requiring a maximum collapse area of 15% of the fabric, supported by various papers and British Standards, it occurred to me that there is no extreme to which the NWO will not go.

And if it's happening in Scotland, it must be happening in Europe, the Antipodes, and the Americas.

Wow!!

I'm almost afraid to take a look at the International Fire Engineering Guidelines (that's IFEG for all you laymen) - I'll bet they've got all sort of mythical stories about failing steel and the like in there!!!

If they're really this powerful, maybe we should just join 'em?


;)
 
Everyone in the Truth Movement knows, of course, that progressive collapse such as that encountered at the World Trade Centre is impossible, inasmuch as the lower structure should have significantly slowed or even arrested the failure completely at an early stage. We've heard lots about massive redundancy and safety factors by way of evidence that thesre structures can take punishment and still stand.

The one thing that has always puzzled me is how the NWO managed to keep all us architects and engineers quiet about it.

Well today I saw just how far the evil tendrils of the Bush Neocon administration stretched, and the lengths which they would go to in order to spread the myth still further.

Following a comprehensive 5 year review, the structural requirements of the Scottish Building Standards have been revised to include specific and addition requirements in order to ensure that the extent of any collapse due to damaged structural elements will "not be disproportionate to the original cause".

But this isn't just some poxy national requirement, but is rather based on the new requirements of Structural Eurocode 1, Parts 1-7 (Accidental Actions). Yup, that's right; the Bush Neocons are controlling the various national and EU building standards agencies.

Wow!

As I worked my way through the requirements, in particular a redesign of structural members to act as vertical and horizontal ties in the event of columnular damage and the new regulation requiring a maximum collapse area of 15% of the fabric, supported by various papers and British Standards, it occurred to me that there is no extreme to which the NWO will not go.

And if it's happening in Scotland, it must be happening in Europe, the Antipodes, and the Americas.

Wow!!

I'm almost afraid to take a look at the International Fire Engineering Guidelines (that's IFEG for all you laymen) - I'll bet they've got all sort of mythical stories about failing steel and the like in there!!!

If they're really this powerful, maybe we should just join 'em?


;)

Playing to the easy audience as I always suspected Architect.

And you wonder why your posts are held in question.

Hope the ego points are worth it.

MM
 
Playing to the easy audience as I always suspected Architect.
From this vantage point, it seems Architect was just being satirical. However, if you wish to point out specific errors in facts in Architect's post (such as the changes to the building codes he mentioned), then by all means please proceed, so that others, such as myself, can understand your objections.
 
Playing to the easy audience as I always suspected Architect.

And you wonder why your posts are held in question.

Hope the ego points are worth it.

MM

Mirage, honestly, why should Architect care at all that you question his post?

Honestly.
 
Playing to the easy audience as I always suspected Architect.

And you wonder why your posts are held in question.

Hope the ego points are worth it.

MM
Held in question by who? You?

Excuse me while I stifle this yawn. BFD!
 
Playing to the easy audience as I always suspected Architect.

And you wonder why your posts are held in question.

Hope the ego points are worth it.

MM


Hey, that's telling him! Another of your information-packed, incisive rebuttals of someone who is much smarter and knows vastly more than you.

Could you flesh out that business about Architect's posts being "held in question"? By whom are they held in question?

We understand that his professional expertise in a field germane to 9/11 controversies is inconvenient to your baseless fantasies. Perhaps you could try a different approach for a change and show us some actual evidence that supports the pernicious myths you promote?
 
Playing to the easy audience as I always suspected Architect.

And you wonder why your posts are held in question.

Hope the ego points are worth it.

MM

*YAWN* Go troll somewhere else. You are like the town loon here. No one respects you, they only laugh.
 
The fact remains, whether MM wants to believe or not, that after 5 years of study much of the world is actually learning things from the WTC collapses and adjusting building codes and similar things accordingly.

This is NOT the action of experts looking at something 'so obviously' a hoax.
 
Does anyone else suspect that MM maybe just got home from a night of honky-tonkin'? Lotsa posts with nothing but bile and bitterness in them. Hmm, get shot down, did we? A bit tipsy? Gotta take it out on someone, I guess.
 
I'm so ****ing sick of this "OK so the NIST worked how the collapse initiated but what what happened after that!?" ****. Hey here's an idea: After it started to collapse, IT COLLAPSED!


And you wonder why your posts are held in question.


Who holds his posts in question?
 
Playing to the easy audience as I always suspected Architect.

And you wonder why your posts are held in question.

Hope the ego points are worth it.

MM

if you have oppositional argument, make it. insulting the post, and the poster, accomplishes nothing. do you understand?

architect's arument:

(i) if the towers were brought down by CD, then it's very unlikely that changes to structural safety standards would be necessary-- especially outside the united states.
(ii) changes to safety standards have been implemented, even outside the united states.
(iii) [truther_logic] .'. the NWO is amazingly powerful.[/truther_logic]

the argument is inductive, but it makes a solid case by showing the likely absurdity that follows when one assumes that the towers were brought down by CD. if one doesn't make such an assumption, then one must conclude that it is much more likely that the towers were NOT brought down by CD.

demonstrate that his argument fails, or concede that it does not. posting fluff like, "Hope the ego points are worth it" doesn't actually address the argument, and just annoys readers, like myself.
 
Last edited:
MM

That the OP is toungue-in-cheek is without doubt. But here's the rub: if it's so "obvious" that the structural models have been fiddled, then just how did learned organisations such as the SBSA, the BSI, and the Eurocodes group all fall for it? Either they're incompetent - which I think you'll find would be a rather difficult position to sustain - or they're part of the "plot"........

Really, I'd love to know! Alternatively I'd love to see some sort of technical response relating to these codes and the inclusion of progressive collapse criteria.
 
MM

That the OP is toungue-in-cheek is without doubt. But here's the rub: if it's so "obvious" that the structural models have been fiddled, then just how did learned organisations such as the SBSA, the BSI, and the Eurocodes group all fall for it? Either they're incompetent - which I think you'll find would be a rather difficult position to sustain - or they're part of the "plot"........

And hey don't forget the old NHS, why if your leg wasn't gammy you'd nae be coming on here.
 
Playing to the easy audience as I always suspected Architect.

And you wonder why your posts are held in question.

Hope the ego points are worth it.

MM

Well you band him from the tough auidence, so what is he supposed to do?
 
Architect Is Trying To Play Both Sides Of The WTC-7 CD/Building Fire Fence . . .

Hi Architect:

I am afraid that Miragememories has Architect ‘busted’ in Post #2 for pretending to represent Bushie opposition, when in fact he is here to push the Official Bush Administration “Building Fires Did It” Explanation for the WTC-7 Collapse we just debated here (my rebuttal is here). This is the same egomaniac bashing Richard Gage’s head in with his nonsense on this thread where he took a few boasting potshots at me as well here and here and here (my favorite). Architect begins his “Building Fires Did It” charade, saying,

Architect >> Everyone in the Truth Movement knows, of course, that progressive collapse such as that encountered at the World Trade Centre is impossible, inasmuch as the lower structure should have significantly slowed or even arrested the failure completely at an early stage. We've heard lots about massive redundancy and safety factors by way of evidence that thesre structures can take punishment and still stand.


Now this guy is sounding like a real Architect or Engineer from AE911Truth.org, as we know the Official “Building Fires Did It” and “Progressive ‘pancake’ Collapse” Explanations are Bogus with no basis in reality whatsoever. 47-story modern day skyscrapers do not collapse into their own footprints CD-style (like this) from building fires in just a few cotton picking hours and WTC-7 was not hit by any Jetliner or anything remotely similar (my WTC-7 CT thread is here). If Architect agrees that the Official Bushie version of the WTC-7 collapse is bogus, then why is he attacking Richard Gage and me for holding the very same views? :0) Before looking at the remainder of Architect’s OP, that has no third-party links to anything at all to support his statements, let’s consider his position in the Controlled Demolition VERSUS Building Fires Did It ongoing debate where his true intentions for being here are better defined. He writes,

Richard Gage-bashing Thread

Architect >> Just an aside, Terral, do YOU accept that normal office fires can cause failure of structural steelwork?


No sir. I do not accept that normal building fires burn hot enough to cause catastrophic collapse of any modern day skyscraper (see short video explanation). We have Dr. Steven Jones' work (here = video) that tells the WTC CD story. However, the fact that this supposed “Architect” is here to push the Official Cover Story LIE is made clear in posts like this one:

Richard Gage-bashing Thread

Architect >> Terral, you should be aware that I am a chartered architect specialising in the design of tall structures. I have completed a number of major projects for a leading UK practice, including Manchester's tallest building, and now run my own firm. I sit on the national council and the professional practice committee of our professional institute. I am therefore in a position to comment both of the technical issues involved and, unlike you, on the wider professional views on the subject.

If you doubt any of this, as some previous posters have done, then feel free to PM Chillzero, the Mod, as she had sight of the necessary evidence of same.

Now, back on topic:

1. What evidence do you have that a substantive proportion of trained professionals have concerns about the NIST findings?

2. DO you, or do you not, believe that normal office fires can and do cause failure of structural steelwork?


I do not care if you are the man in the moon. WTC-7 was clearly taken down using Controlled Demolition, which is the conclusion of all the architects and engineers at AE911Truth.org this same Richard Gage represents. The fact is that Architect stands ‘against’ the 911Truthers at AE911Truth.org in support of the Official Bush Administration / DoD / FBI “Inside-Job” Cover Story, which is very easy to figure out by his comments here:

Richard Gage-bashing Thread

Architect >> I challenged Gage to a debate on TAM's site and he refused to respond.

Draw your own conclusions.

Me, I reckon he's unprofessional in holding out such half-arsed nonsense as professional opinion. We throw people out of the RIBA for that, but I can't speak for the AIA's standards.

Incidentally he's resurrected the old Fireproof Steel Thread and seems to be getting all the arguments wrong there now.


But wait one minute! What about Architect’s statements to start ‘this’ thread?

Architect >> Everyone in the Truth Movement knows, of course, that progressive collapse such as that encountered at the World Trade Centre is impossible, inasmuch as the lower structure should have significantly slowed or even arrested the failure completely at an early stage. We've heard lots about massive redundancy and safety factors by way of evidence that thesre structures can take punishment and still stand.


This guy is trying to have things ‘both ways,’ as if building fires ‘cannot’ cause a progressive collapse, according to the Official Bushie LIE, ‘AND’ can cause a progressive collapse at the very same time. Architect panders to “Bushie-bashing” then works every day to prop up Bushie LIES, which is simply part of the pattern of deception we see in all of his posts.

Architect OP >> The one thing that has always puzzled me is how the NWO managed to keep all us architects and engineers quiet about it.

Well today I saw just how far the evil tendrils of the Bush Neocon administration stretched, and the lengths which they would go to in order to spread the myth still further.


Please forgive, but there are only two directly opposing explanations for the WTC-7 CD-like collapse and Richard Gage is definitely pushing the Controlled Demolition Explanation and NOT the “Building Fires Did It” nonsense being pushed by this so-called Architect. He embarrasses himself by talking trash against Bush ‘and’ Richard Gage, because those two parties represent the ONLY two explanations for what took WTC-7 down in about 6.6 seconds. So, where does the Architect stand on this WTC-7 case? Does he stand with Richard Gage he is bashing on the one hand, OR with Senor Bushie he is bashing here on this thread? :0)

Architect >> Following a comprehensive 5 year review, the structural requirements of the Scottish Building Standards have been revised to include specific and addition requirements in order to ensure that the extent of any collapse due to damaged structural elements will "not be disproportionate to the original cause".


What you do over in Scotland is your own business having absolutely nothing to do with 9/11, the WTC attacks or anything going on over here in the colonies. You only embarrass yourself with statements characterizing the leader of our US government as “the evil tendrils of the Bush Neocon administration” to then bow down and pay homage to ‘his’ WTC-7 “Building Fires Did It” ridiculous explanations.

Architect >> But this isn't just some poxy [proxy] national requirement, but is rather based on the new requirements of Structural Eurocode 1, Parts 1-7 (Accidental Actions). Yup, that's right; the Bush Neocons are controlling the various national and EU building standards agencies.


In other words, the entire assembly of Eurocode architects and engineers are incapable of updating their own national building requirements apart from the supervision of the dimwit sitting in our White House. :0) Is that a kick in the pants or what?

GL,

Terral
 
Last edited:

That's a lot of text to essentially say "I know nothing, but I'm going to do my best to insult you and see which claims I make with irrelevant links happen to stick.

Figure out that steel doesn't have to melt to explain the collapse yet?

Figure out curvilinear distortion yet?

Shown us pictures of the A-3 yet? Provided any real proof that it wasn't a 757 yet? (No, just complaining about the size of the hole doesn't count. I mean actual proof, aka evidence.)
 
This guy is trying to have things ‘both ways,’ as if building fires ‘cannot’ cause a progressive collapse, according to the Official Bushie LIE, ‘AND’ can cause a progressive collapse at the very same time.
Reading comprehension isn't your thing, is it?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom