SpitfireIX
Philosopher
I had to think about this for a while, but I'd say the all-time most laughable theory I've ever seen was from some guy I encountered on a computer wargaming forum who claimed that Roosevelt had foreknowledge of Pearl Harbor. This is not a new idea, of course, but this guy's particular wrinkle was that the reason FDR didn't warn the Army and Navy commanders in Hawaii was that he wanted the Japanese to be ambushed and destroyed, but was afraid that they might be tipped off and cancel the attack if American forces were on the alert.
Our hero further claimed that FDR's "plan" should have worked, if only Kimmel and Short hadn't been asleep at the switch and started immediately readying every plane they had as soon as the Japanese strike was detected on radar or by search planes. He also had this idea that a single bomb hit would have been likely to have sunk or disabled each Japanese carrier (as they were so far from the nearest Japanese base), so FDR would have reasoned that not much of a counterstrike from Oahu would have been required.
Anyone who's really interested and/or morbidly curious can find the thread here.
Our hero further claimed that FDR's "plan" should have worked, if only Kimmel and Short hadn't been asleep at the switch and started immediately readying every plane they had as soon as the Japanese strike was detected on radar or by search planes. He also had this idea that a single bomb hit would have been likely to have sunk or disabled each Japanese carrier (as they were so far from the nearest Japanese base), so FDR would have reasoned that not much of a counterstrike from Oahu would have been required.
Anyone who's really interested and/or morbidly curious can find the thread here.