How 'bout I start with post #4, where the well started getting poisoned.
Ectoplasm is as genuine as bigfoot.
Isn't that a strawman of sorts? It goes from 'Mentality' to ectoplasm to bigfoot. Maybe it isn't a strawman, perhaps it would be better called 'wrongfooting'. I like that, it has a nice ring. I hereby dub thee Law of Wrongfooting™
And then move on to post #6 where Beerina makes a very astute observation:
Beerina
Sarcastic Conqueror of Notions
There is a difference between asking for evidence and assuming something is false sans evidence.
That's really only valid for the usual paranormal stuff (which has actually been examined a lot) and much less valid in other contexts.
Unfortunately sometimes skeptics get confused on that and treat every subject as if it were a paranormal claim.
And then we move on to post #14
HarryHenderson
Graduate Poster
You're treating "skepticism" as if it's a way of life or something. It's not that complicated. It's an intellectual (as opposed to emotional) reaction to the "reality" of claims of fantastical-ness without any evidence.
It's no secret you claim there is a Bigfoot. Okay, my eyes are open, SHOW ME Bigfoot! But you can't (or won't). Why should we believe there's a Bigfoot when you, a believer, can't point us in any proper direction to see one? Where again are we being the unreasonable ones?
Blind faith should be just a band, but it's not and your version of it is totally immune to any "skepticism" we might interject anyway. That is, I'm still not sure what your beef actually is. That there is no Bigfoot?
As you can see, it's already getting pulled into a SkeptiBunker comfort zone away from an uncomfortable zone of mentality/psychology.
Then we move to post #23
JoeBentley
Self Employed
Remittance Man
Originally Posted by Slowvehicle View Post
I don't suppose you have examples of this...do you?
"Like this one time, I like totally and for realz saw a bigfoot, but the big mean skeptics didn't just believe me without evidence and starting talking about stuff like 'evidence' and 'burden of proof' and it made me feel really bad."
Then we go to post #24
06:29 PM #24
William Parcher
Show me the monkey!
Why do you dislike a world without Bigfoot? Why would you dismiss such a world so easily?
The above post is not even remotely about the original thread title, "Mentality of a skeptic".
Law of "What's that got to do with the color of the Moon?"™
And then we move to post #25
OntarioSquatch
Graduate Poster
Originally Posted by Slowvehicle View Post
I don't suppose you have examples of this...do you?
Ontario: A Bigfoot proponent posts an audio of an alleged Bigfoot. The "skeptic" gets anxious and says its a common forest animal, but it turns out to be just a person pretending to be a Sasquatch.
Originally Posted by JoeBentley View Post
"Skeptics are closed mind and/or big meanie heads, therefore my (insert pet Woo here) is true."
Rules lawyer the argument all you want, there's still no magic monkey man.
Ontario: Just because the mentality of most skeptics is flawed, doesn't mean the woo believers are correct, but anyway, I think you totally missed the point of this thread.
The word Sasquatch or Bigfoot or Monkey Man were brought up 6-7 times before Ontario used the word and the last bolde part sums it up pretty well.
Again, in an inexorable manner and fashion, SkeptiBunkers™ keep tugging and pulling the thread intent away from something that seems to cause them emotional discomfort in their comfort zone of 'woo'.