The Mentality of Skeptics

They say it doesn't exist and that there isn't any evidence, yet they spend a lot of time on just this one subject.

And, of course, you'll be providing evidence of this...

Who, in your opinion, are these "denialists", and how is it that you know, better then they do, what they think?
 
It was a sudden and dramatic switch in beliefs. At no point did he accept the fact that he doesn't know the answer.

OS, is there any acceptable reason, to you, for one to conclude that bigfoot does not exist? Even if that person is quick to point out that if decent evidence were to be presented, then that conclusion could easily change?

Or is it as simple as: Say you think bigfoot does not exist=state of denial
 
OS, is there any acceptable reason, to you, for one to conclude that bigfoot does not exist? Even if that person is quick to point out that if decent evidence were to be presented, then that conclusion could easily change?

Or is it as simple as: Say you think bigfoot does not exist=state of denial

Follow-up for OS: Are Missourians denialists?
 
Last edited:
Descriptions of things borne out of legend usually do vary greatly.

Easily verified by anyone who has bothered to read Loren Coleman's 'The Field Guide to Bigfoot, Yeti, and Other Mystery Primates Worldwide.'

Picked up my copy back in April of '99 and saw where Coleman had asserted that there were NINE entries in his classification system. (Coleman's updated edition published in 2006 still has the 9 classifications)

1. Neo-Giant (Patty) 1967
2. True Giant (Pitt Lake Giant) 1965
3. Marked Hominid (Pennsylvania 'pot-bellied' Creature) 1972-73; (Yellow Top) 1970; (Momo) 1972
4. Neandertaloid (Nuk-luk) 1964
5. Erectus Hominid (Minnesota Iceman) 1968
6. Proto-Pygmy - None in North America
7. Unknown Pongid (Skunk Ape) 1970; (Lake Worth Monster) 1969
8. Giant Monkey (Devil Monkey) 1997
9. Merbeing (Thetis Lake Monster) 1972; (Sea Ape) 1741

Even tossing aside the Proto-Pygmies, we're still left with EIGHT classifications of bigfoot/yeti. Yeah, EIGHT different types of bigfoot/yeti stomping around in the wilderness and no one has brought in any verifiable evidence for any of them.

Coleman gives an example of the classifications, including illustrations for each of them, and provides a dozen samples for North America alone. He also provides a 'descriptive incident' for each sample that includes dates, locations, and the names of the witnesses.

The notion of EIGHT types of bigfoot* wandering the woods and waterways of North America is laughable.

Anyone interested in the wide variety of monsters the human mind can manufacture should pick up a copy. :D

*In his 2006 update, Coleman states, "Some people did not understand that our classifications of "types" was never meant to translate into zoological species; the types might simply reflect a variety of geographical races or perhaps even differences in genus or families of primates."

:eye-poppi

RayG
 
OS, is there any acceptable reason, to you, for one to conclude that bigfoot does not exist?

The conclusion that something doesn't exist is supposed to be based on a complete lack of evidence. It's impossible to properly conclude that an unknown doesn't exist unless you give it its own properties and limitations in your own mind. What people here are really doing is ignoring the evidence that doesn't meet the level of proof so they can convince themselves that their belief of non-existence is correct. It ends up being a fragile belief and a religion.
 
The post you quoted is from August 30, 2015.

How about this from less than a month ago? (post #83 in this thread)

I don't know about the total, but from what I've seen, nearly every forum member who posts in the Bigfoot threads on a regular basis on this forum has this problem.

Memory getting any better?

RayG
 
The conclusion that something doesn't exist is supposed to be based on a complete lack of evidence. It's impossible to properly conclude that an unknown doesn't exist unless you give it its own properties and limitations in your own mind. What people here are really doing is ignoring the evidence that doesn't meet the level of proof so they can convince themselves that their belief of non-existence is correct. It ends up being a fragile belief and a religion.

Again; suppose you provide evidence for any of this. Feel free to use any post I have made on this forum (in any thread) to demonstrate how I am exhibiting this behaviour.

I eagerly anticipate your presentation of what you are calling "evidence".
 
The conclusion that something doesn't exist is supposed to be based on a complete lack of evidence. It's impossible to properly conclude that an unknown doesn't exist unless you give it its own properties and limitations in your own mind. What people here are really doing is ignoring the evidence that doesn't meet the level of proof so they can convince themselves that their belief of non-existence is correct. It ends up being a fragile belief and a religion.
What evidence?
 
The conclusion that something doesn't exist is supposed to be based on a complete lack of evidence. It's impossible to properly conclude that an unknown doesn't exist unless you give it its own properties and limitations in your own mind. What people here are really doing is ignoring the evidence that doesn't meet the level of proof so they can convince themselves that their belief of non-existence is correct. It ends up being a fragile belief and a religion.

Well you certainly seem to be describing your own doubts about your alien monkey-man.
Your flawed logic seems to follow your own path of denial it goes something like this....


Maybe as you mature your world view will be reality based as opposed to the near delusional behavior you currently display.
 
Last edited:
The conclusion that something doesn't exist is supposed to be based on a complete lack of evidence.

Well, according to your definition, there must be no evidence at all before one can declare something non existent? Based on the type of evidence presented, so far, for bigfoot, then you must also have great disdain and disappointment for all the unicorn, leprechaun and werewolf denialists out there.

You stipulate a complete lack of evidence. This allows you, in your estimation, to point to the rather weak evidence for bigfoot presented so far. Thus, according to the OSLOS (OS Laws of Skepticism), one simply cannot deny the existence of bigfoot because SOME evidence has been presented. Completely, and willfully I might add, ignoring the fact that the testable evidence for bigfoot presented so far does not support the claim. This reduces us to merely anecdotes. And then again, you end up in the leprechaun trap of your own making. If anecdotes are good enough for bigfoot, then they must be good enough for just about anything according to the OSLOS.
 
Last edited:
Asking someone to prove their claim is very different from telling them that their claim isn't true. By telling them that their claim is false, you would be placing a burden of proof on yourself.

But the Missourian didn't tell you your claim was false. The Missourian asked you to show him the evidence and said in effect, 'convince me'.

<crickets sfx while waiting for convincing evidence>

Next question: what if the Missourian says your evidence is unconvincing? Is the Missourian being a denialist then?

Is there a difference between the Missourian being personally unconvinced and the Missourian generalising to say the evidence ought not to be convincing to the general public? Is either position denialist?
 
OS, how about this statement?

I find the evidence for bigfoot does not support the claim that bigfoot is an undiscovered ape in North America. Therefore I am unconvinced and believe that bigfoot does not exist as a flesh and blood animal. I believe the evidence points to a social construct. If better evidence were to be presented, I would happily reassess.

Am I being a denialist simply because I did not reach the same conclusion as you? I think the evidence does point to something. So much so that I am willing to state what I believe the evidence does point to--a myth.

Are you a myth denier?
 
Asking someone to prove their claim is very different from telling them that their claim isn't true. By telling them that their claim is false, you would be placing a burden of proof on yourself.
As always, what you end up saying here is that any assertion, no matter how crazy, cannot be denied without explicit disproof even if the utter lack of evidence makes it impossible to evaluate except as a pure statement.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom