The Marjorie Taylor Greene thread.

Status
Not open for further replies.
And the Trump tariffs worked so well. Farmers here had to be bailed out when China quit buying soybean.

Wonder how they get past these trumpsters with the fantastic claims that came out of Trump or Greene. Oh yeah, brains. You need brains.
Let her do it. And call the bill the "Marjorie Taylor Green Retaliatory Tariff Bill" in her honour. Publicise the bill's name and her name in the conservative media, especially among the MAGAchuds. See how that all pans out if it ever passes and she sinks the US rural economy which is already doing it tough like Donny tried to do.
 
Let her do it. And call the bill the "Marjorie Taylor Green Retaliatory Tariff Bill" in her honour. Publicise the bill's name and her name in the conservative media, especially among the MAGAchuds. See how that all pans out if it ever passes and she sinks the US rural economy which is already doing it tough like Donny tried to do.

There's that idea again of hoping someone screws up so much that people don't vote for them. It clearly doesn't work, and just means we got a screw up in the bargain.
 
Let her do it. And call the bill the "Marjorie Taylor Green Retaliatory Tariff Bill" in her honour. Publicise the bill's name and her name in the conservative media, especially among the MAGAchuds. See how that all pans out if it ever passes and she sinks the US rural economy which is already doing it tough like Donny tried to do.
The problem is, for that to actually be damaging to her, the people in the rural economy would have to understand the connection between tariffs and the collapsing economy.

Trump brought in tariffs. It was obvious that Trump was the one doing it. It actually increased the trade deficit and caused significant economic disruption. And yet he still managed to get high support from rural areas.

It would be even less effective to tie MTG to tariffs, since the economy is bounding back after the combination of Covid and Stubby McBonespurs, so the economy would likely continue growing (even if tariffs are slowing that growth.)
 
The problem is, for that to actually be damaging to her, the people in the rural economy would have to understand the connection between tariffs and the collapsing economy.

Trump brought in tariffs. It was obvious that Trump was the one doing it. It actually increased the trade deficit and caused significant economic disruption. And yet he still managed to get high support from rural areas.

It would be even less effective to tie MTG to tariffs, since the economy is bounding back after the combination of Covid and Stubby McBonespurs, so the economy would likely continue growing (even if tariffs are slowing that growth.)
Not actually the case. They know full well what was done and who did this. The only beneficiaries are Big Agribusiness, not the smaller farmers. The smallholders are living that pain, and now the COVID crisis on top of that. So if MTG wants to increase tariffs, a lot of pitchforks will start to be sharpened.

https://news.cgtn.com/news/2019-08-...tating-to-rural-America-JmT03wqCJO/index.html

https://www.americanprogress.org/is...ration-failed-rural-america-10-ways-overcome/
 
Last edited:
Trump brought in tariffs. It was obvious that Trump was the one doing it. It actually increased the trade deficit and caused significant economic disruption. And yet he still managed to get high support from rural areas.
It would be even less effective to tie MTG to tariffs, since the economy is bounding back after the combination of Covid and Stubby McBonespurs, so the economy would likely continue growing (even if tariffs are slowing that growth.)
Not actually the case. They know full well what was done and who did this. The only beneficiaries are Big Agribusiness, not the smaller farmers. The smallholders are living that pain, and now the COVID crisis on top of that. So if MTG wants to increase tariffs, a lot of pitchforks will start to be sharpened.

https://news.cgtn.com/news/2019-08-...tating-to-rural-America-JmT03wqCJO/index.html

https://www.americanprogress.org/is...ration-failed-rural-america-10-ways-overcome/
I am not denying that the Trump administration caused harm among rural voters.

I'm saying that for whatever reason, those rural voters still voted for Trump in 2020, even after the hardships caused by the Trump administration and their tariff-happy ways.

From: Politico
Roughly two-thirds of rural voters across the country cast their ballots for Trump
 
I am not denying that the Trump administration caused harm among rural voters.

I'm saying that for whatever reason, those rural voters still voted for Trump in 2020, even after the hardships caused by the Trump administration and their tariff-happy ways.

From: Politico
Roughly two-thirds of rural voters across the country cast their ballots for Trump
A more correct title would have been "More than two-thirds of rural voters did not vote for Democrats due to poor messaging".

You should read the rest of that article. Then imagine what would happen if MTG implemented tariffs. It would be a suicide note.
 
I'm saying that for whatever reason, those rural voters still voted for Trump in 2020, even after the hardships caused by the Trump administration and their tariff-happy ways.

From: Politico
Roughly two-thirds of rural voters across the country cast their ballots for Trump
A more correct title would have been "More than two-thirds of rural voters did not vote for Democrats due to poor messaging".
The republicans didn't really have much of a message either.

Plus, in my opinion, if people were so decimated by the tariffs, voters should have been willing to switch to the democrats regardless of their 'messaging'.
You should read the rest of that article.
I did read the article.

It was an opinion piece. (Normally I don't use those as a reference, but it had the simplest reference to Trump's success in rural areas in a main stream site, so I used it.) Furthermore, it was an opinion piece by a Democrat, who probably felt it was necessary not to engage in any negative characterization of republican voters.

I have always found the whole 'messaging' thing to be a bit.... weak. After all, Biden wasn't exactly hiding his plans... he wanted to improve schools and health care in rural areas, do some infrastructure projects, and fix issues with trade. He told them "this is what we want to do for you" (which is pretty clear messaging), and they rejected him in order to vote for a racist con-artist who got involved in trade wars which harmed their ability to earn a living.
Then imagine what would happen if MTG implemented tariffs. It would be a suicide note.
I still don't see why you think MTG would be harmed politically from bringing in Tariffs when Trump wasn't. They'd be doing the same thing. (The only difference is, MTG would be a congress critter and not the president, which makes it easier to shift the blame even more.)
 
Because they haven't recovered from the first belting from Donny's tariffs, and a lot more of them will be ultra-sensitive to a second round of the same but worse. Even ingrained rusted-on better-dead-than-Dem GOP voters will falter.
 
Because they haven't recovered from the first belting from Donny's tariffs, and a lot more of them will be ultra-sensitive to a second round of the same but worse. Even ingrained rusted-on better-dead-than-Dem GOP voters will falter.

That assumes that they will be able to join the dots and link the tariffs to their economic woes. The trouble is that the media consume, and/or the people they interact with would never give that information. Instead they are told repeatedly that all of their woes are due to The Democrats/immigrants/China (delete as applicable).

Whatever message the Democrats come up with will be discounted by those same media sources - which is not to say that the Democrats shouldn't try, jus that success will likely be unlikely.
 
That assumes that they will be able to join the dots and link the tariffs to their economic woes. The trouble is that the media consume, and/or the people they interact with would never give that information. Instead they are told repeatedly that all of their woes are due to The Democrats/immigrants/China (delete as applicable).

Whatever message the Democrats come up with will be discounted by those same media sources - which is not to say that the Democrats shouldn't try, jus that success will likely be unlikely.
Of course! It's not a foregone conclusion that the Dems will simply romp it in on the back of all the calamity the GOP caused. But Jan-6 has had an effect. Some of these people are seeing themselves in the mirror for the first time. And to begin to question is the doorway to a change of heart.

Then again, they also seem to be committing a combination of the Sunk Cost Fallacy and the Gambler's Fallacy: The family has voted GOP for generations, and even though this has has done nothing but lose the farm and ruin the family business and prospects to date, sooner or later voting GOP must surely pay off big time because they keep being told it will. So they will do it again next time!
 
Of course! It's not a foregone conclusion that the Dems will simply romp it in on the back of all the calamity the GOP caused. But Jan-6 has had an effect. Some of these people are seeing themselves in the mirror for the first time. And to begin to question is the doorway to a change of heart.

Then again, they also seem to be committing a combination of the Sunk Cost Fallacy and the Gambler's Fallacy: The family has voted GOP for generations, and even though this has has done nothing but lose the farm and ruin the family business and prospects to date, sooner or later voting GOP must surely pay off big time because they keep being told it will. So they will do it again next time!

....not least because they have been told that voting for the Democratic party will mean that they'll lose the farm/business because of "death taxes", that they'll be overrun with illegal immigrants (but not the nice kind who have been working on their farm or for their business), BLM will completely undermine the forces of law and order and that any chance of the GOP-led recovery which is just around the corner will be lost. :rolleyes:
 
....not least because they have been told that voting for the Democratic party will mean that they'll lose the farm/business because of "death taxes", that they'll be overrun with illegal immigrants (but not the nice kind who have been working on their farm or for their business), BLM will completely undermine the forces of law and order and that any chance of the GOP-led recovery which is just around the corner will be lost. :rolleyes:
And would they like to sell their little farm to Giant AgriBiz at pennies in the dollar of its real value? Everyone else is!
 
A more correct title would have been "More than two-thirds of rural voters did not vote for Democrats due to poor messaging".

You should read the rest of that article. Then imagine what would happen if MTG implemented tariffs. It would be a suicide note.

So they were won over by the message of the policy of what ever Trump wants?

Seems like something that should be supported. It seems more likely that they voted to trigger the libs and will be shocked shocked that they might be in the people hurt in addition to the people that the party is supposed to hurt.
 
So they were won over by the message of the policy of what ever Trump wants?
I think it is more like "Let's keep voting GOP until they get it right".

Seems like something that should be supported. It seems more likely that they voted to trigger the libs and will be shocked shocked that they might be in the people hurt in addition to the people that the party is supposed to hurt.
That is the lesson some of them are learning, the hard way.
 
I think it is more like "Let's keep voting GOP until they get it right".

That is the lesson some of them are learning, the hard way.

tbh, the same thing is happening here in the UK. People are voted for the Conservative Party in 2015, 2017 and 2019 because they wanted change from the failing policies of the Conservative Party :boggled:

Thanks to the mishandling of Covid (with the notable exception of the vaccine rollout over which the government had little direct control) and the omnishambles that is Brexit, those same people are even worse off than they were back in 2010 when the Conservatives came to power as the senior partner in a coalition. :(
 
If only all the Trump loving voters could see that video. Most will not. My conservative family members, I kid you not, did not know who MTG was until I showed them very recently.

Email from my sister today in response to the Trump "router" quote, plus some other doozies:

None of this has anything to do with Biden’s mental health or cognitive impairment/decline. Biden can barely string together a coherent sentence. Not even going to entertain that there is a comparison here.

Wow, ya. My response: "if you say so"

I wote back a short one saying look I don't care if you hate the libs, it just bothers me to think you and others in my family might still be a Trump fan. Are you?

We'll see how that goes. Sigh I can't stand this.

And a lot of the family do see it now, but they STILL watch FOX, still think the libs are worse.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom