Cont: The Marjorie Taylor Greene thread - Part II

If MTG had been alive in 1938, she'd have believed that all Adolf wanted was Austria and the Sudetenland and had no designs on the rest of Europe. She'd have still believed it even after he invaded Poland because she wouldn't have known where Poland was. Oh, hell...or what Poland was.
 
I don't agree with either of those two statements.

As someonw who is a very heavy duty Civil War buff, I fully agree.
Grant and Sheridan job was to crush the rebellion, which they did, dictating the post war policy toward the South was not their job. I agree that the failure to secure the rights of Blacks n the South was a disaster for the US, but it was not Grant and Sheridan's ' job to do that at least as far being generals go. Now when Grant was elected President, then it did become his job.
And I would like Gulliver to explain exactly what he would have replaced the constituion with. Probably a overwhelming powerfu central govenrment which would have reduced the states of administrative conviences, something which would not sell even today.
 
Last edited:
If MTG had been alive in 1938, she'd have believed that all Adolf wanted was Austria and the Sudetenland and had no designs on the rest of Europe. She'd have still believed it even after he invaded Poland because she wouldn't have known where Poland was. Oh, hell...or what Poland was.
Why would she have been concerned about a country in Africa?


;)
 
True. I think the Peculiar Institution was dying anyway. The Industrial Revolution would have made slavery financially untenable and it would have ended eventually anyway. But that would not have helped those enslaved then..

Yea they would have abolished slavery sometime in the next 40-50 years. Keep in mind a triumphant south means no lost cause lies and slavery being the literal cornerstone of their nation. It strikes me that changing the confederates constitution to permit the abolition of slavery would be a bigger bar than people realize.

You would have at least a generation more slavery.
 
If MTG had been alive in 1938, she'd have believed that all Adolf wanted was Austria and the Sudetenland and had no designs on the rest of Europe. She'd have still believed it even after he invaded Poland because she wouldn't have known where Poland was. Oh, hell...or what Poland was.

.... why should Americans give all that much concern as to where poles are made?! We should make them here!
 
Yea they would have abolished slavery sometime in the next 40-50 years. Keep in mind a triumphant south means no lost cause lies and slavery being the literal cornerstone of their nation. It strikes me that changing the confederates constitution to permit the abolition of slavery would be a bigger bar than people realize.

You would have at least a generation more slavery.

Given that the passed but not enacted confederate constitution specifically stated that no law, amendment or other change to the constitution could outlaw slavery, then I'd say it would only have happened with societal collapse.
 
Given that the passed but not enacted confederate constitution specifically stated that no law, amendment or other change to the constitution could outlaw slavery, then I'd say it would only have happened with societal collapse.

Money has more influence than anything else. With the rise of the Industrial Revolution, slavery would have become financially unsupportable. Companies replace workers with automation because it's financially to their benefit.
 
There will always be a desirable use for disposable people if it's allowed.
 
Money has more influence than anything else. With the rise of the Industrial Revolution, slavery would have become financially unsupportable. Companies replace workers with automation because it's financially to their benefit.

Why is slavery so incompatible with industrialization?
 
Too much potential for extremely expensive sabotage.

While Nazi Germany used slave workers for weapons production with some efficiency it dose require a lot of guards and constant threats of violence, which is not really productive for peace-time industry.

Another, and more important thing: Civilian industry needs customers for its products. If you just have a slave-owning elite to supply, you don't need much industry. Thus, the working class must be able to buy your products, and this means you have to employ them, rather than own them.

Hans
 
Unverified.

380706067_799982398840428_1727974910197914029_n.jpg
 
Unverified.

[qimg]https://scontent-ord5-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t39.30808-6/380706067_799982398840428_1727974910197914029_n.jpg?_nc_cat=1&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=49d041&_nc_ohc=FQgE66fhDqsAX-KKXnh&_nc_ht=scontent-ord5-1.xx&oh=00_AfDfODxBYYHONAMDZhqttxCL-TV9KL-G66RE0xUY_bONwQ&oe=6512805B[/qimg]

I looked it up. It's real.
 
Unverified.

[qimg]https://scontent-ord5-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t39.30808-6/380706067_799982398840428_1727974910197914029_n.jpg?_nc_cat=1&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=49d041&_nc_ohc=FQgE66fhDqsAX-KKXnh&_nc_ht=scontent-ord5-1.xx&oh=00_AfDfODxBYYHONAMDZhqttxCL-TV9KL-G66RE0xUY_bONwQ&oe=6512805B[/qimg]

Comparing MTG to a Neandrathal is really unfair to Neadenthrals.
 
Unverified.

[qimg]https://scontent-ord5-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t39.30808-6/380706067_799982398840428_1727974910197914029_n.jpg?_nc_cat=1&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=49d041&_nc_ohc=FQgE66fhDqsAX-KKXnh&_nc_ht=scontent-ord5-1.xx&oh=00_AfDfODxBYYHONAMDZhqttxCL-TV9KL-G66RE0xUY_bONwQ&oe=6512805B[/qimg]

If the loincloth fits, wear it.

Please.
 
While Nazi Germany used slave workers for weapons production with some efficiency it dose require a lot of guards and constant threats of violence, which is not really productive for peace-time industry.

Another, and more important thing: Civilian industry needs customers for its products. If you just have a slave-owning elite to supply, you don't need much industry. Thus, the working class must be able to buy your products, and this means you have to employ them, rather than own them.

Hans


North Korea is using slave labor to pay for the luxury consumption of their Dear Leader, so that works, too, economically.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom