Cont: The Marjorie Taylor Greene thread - Part II

Isn't aiding a foreign power at war with you treason? Because Russia is definitely making war on the US.

I think that making political decisions that benefit the adversary probably doesn't fall under it. Or else one could be sent up for treason for proposing a peace treaty.

The constitutional definition seems to concern itself with direct aid, basically either attacking or helping the adversary attack the US.
 
From Florida, I see. Has anyone checked the water in Florida for high lead content? It would explain a lot.

I'm sure the current government would be happy to put some more lead in the water if prompted.
 
I think that making political decisions that benefit the adversary probably doesn't fall under it. Or else one could be sent up for treason for proposing a peace treaty.

The constitutional definition seems to concern itself with direct aid, basically either attacking or helping the adversary attack the US.

The US withdrawing from NATO is a move meant to aid the enemy nation on a par with the US giving them the codes to their nukes and access to the launch mechanisms.
 
The US withdrawing from NATO is a move meant to aid the enemy nation on a par with the US giving them the codes to their nukes and access to the launch mechanisms.

Um..no. The Goofball from Georgia's declared motive is not to aid some unidentified 'enemy' but because she doesn't want the US spending "taxpayer money" on aid to Ukraine while she says NATO is not "paying their fair share".
"They are not a reliable partner whose defense spending should be paid for by American citizens," Greene said while introducing the amendment. "For the better part of the last decade, Germany has contributed only around 1 percent of its GDP to finance NATO obligations, while the United States is paying around 4 percent of our GDP to defend NATO countries."

"The United States has been financing and promising to defend NATO countries for decades and paying more than its fair share," she continued. "Western European countries could and should be stepping up their financial contributions to ensure the security of NATO. Instead, they are entirely beholden to Russia and U.S. taxpayers expected to foot the bill."

As usual, she's parroting Trump because she hasn't enough brain cells for an original thought. Her claims are also false:

The U.S. does not spend 4 percent of gross domestic product “to defend NATO countries.” The 4 percent reference is apparently a reference to the entire defense budget, of which NATO spending represents only a fraction of America’s financial commitment. Even so, defense spending hasn’t exceeded 4 percent of GDP since 2013.

Spending specifically allocated to NATO represents a far lower figure.

The United States covers about 16 percent of NATO’s civil and military budget, which had a combined total budget of roughly $2.6 billion, according to NATO. The U.S. share amounts to approximately $423 million. The U.S. additionally contributed $220 million towards the NATO Security Investment Program (military construction) in fiscal year 2023.
 
Um..no. The Goofball from Georgia's declared motive is not to aid some unidentified 'enemy' but because she doesn't want the US spending "taxpayer money" on aid to Ukraine while she says NATO is not "paying their fair share".


As usual, she's parroting Trump because she hasn't enough brain cells for an original thought. Her claims are also false:
I would submit that the declared motive is irrelevant relative to the expected result, even if it's not false. I might declare my motive is to rid the streets of litter, but if my action is to go to a MacDonald's and gun everyone down before they have a chance to toss their garbage out in front of my house, my motive shrinks in significance even though the action promotes the desired goal.
 
I would submit that the declared motive is irrelevant relative to the expected result, even if it's not false. I might declare my motive is to rid the streets of litter, but if my action is to go to a MacDonald's and gun everyone down before they have a chance to toss their garbage out in front of my house, my motive shrinks in significance even though the action promotes the desired goal.

What you say is true, but there is no evidence that MTG's 'true' motive supports GF's hyperbolic post to which I was responding:

Originally Posted by Gulliver Foyle View Post
The US withdrawing from NATO is a move meant to aid the enemy nation on a par with the US giving them the codes to their nukes and access to the launch mechanisms.
 
I would submit that the declared motive is irrelevant relative to the expected result, even if it's not false. I might declare my motive is to rid the streets of litter, but if my action is to go to a MacDonald's and gun everyone down before they have a chance to toss their garbage out in front of my house, my motive shrinks in significance even though the action promotes the desired goal.

Results cannot be the only thing that matters, or else every friendly fire mishap is an act of treason. Every blunder that loses a battle, every risk taken that plays out unfavorably.
 
Last edited:
Results cannot be the only thing that matters, or else every friendly fire mishap is an act of treason. Every blunder that loses a battle, every risk taken that plays out unfavorably.
I did say the expected result. You do not expect a friendly fire mishap. But if you set the barn on fire to roast a pig, you cannot count the loss of the barn as a surprise no matter how delicious the pig.
 
Um..no. The Goofball from Georgia's declared motive is not to aid some unidentified 'enemy' but because she doesn't want the US spending "taxpayer money" on aid to Ukraine while she says NATO is not "paying their fair share".


As usual, she's parroting Trump because she hasn't enough brain cells for an original thought. Her claims are also false:

Her declared motive is not her actual motive, which is also the actual effect of a withdrawal from NATO, giving the military initiative over to the US's enemies.

That being said, I do think the EU nations (including Ireland) should be planning for a mutual defence system which doesn't depend on NATO, given how badly the republicans want to surrender the US to its enemies.
 
Apparently there was some Republican candidate thing last night. Tucker Carlson went after Pence for his support of Ukraine, and the big news today is that Carlson and Trump are the only ones with the guts to say we shouldn't waste effort in support of the Ukraine.

Then today, Russia backs out of a humanitarian wheat agreement.

Gee, I wonder who bolstered their decision to do that?

Back in the old days, there was the old line of Loose Lips Sink Ships, and Be Careful What you Say because Hitler Might Be Listening.

Now we have people blatantly telling the Russians they don't care.

It's not so much that the US loves Ukraine, but that Russia is still the enemy.
 
Her declared motive is not her actual motive, which is also the actual effect of a withdrawal from NATO, giving the military initiative over to the US's enemies.

Stating an opinion as fact does not make it a fact.


That being said, I do think the EU nations (including Ireland) should be planning for a mutual defence system which doesn't depend on NATO, given how badly the republicans want to surrender the US to its enemies.

You got an 'A' in Hyperbole 101, didn't ya?

The extremist far right including the Freedom Caucus with the likes of Gaetz, MTG, Biggs, and Roy are against sending aid to Ukraine as well as very long shot POTUS candidate , Vivek Ramaswamy . But other Republicans support it : GOP POTUS candidates Chris Christie, Nikkie Haley, Tim Scott, Mike Pence, Will Hurd, Asa Hutchinson.

Only 70 of 225 Republican House members voted to end Aid to Ukraine this week.
 
Her declared motive is not her actual motive, which is also the actual effect of a withdrawal from NATO, giving the military initiative over to the US's enemies.

That being said, I do think the EU nations (including Ireland) should be planning for a mutual defence system which doesn't depend on NATO, given how badly the republicans want to surrender the US to its enemies.


Even if the U.S. were to withdraw there would still be a NATO. So they already have a mutual defense system.
 
I haven't followed this thread much, but I felt the need to post this.
Apparently, somebody has replaced MTG with a mirror universe copy who endorses Joe Biden.


My god, that woman is an idiot. She has no idea what she's saying, does she?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom