Cont: The Marjorie Taylor Greene thread - Part II

The trouble with that sort of thing is that whatever people write, administer, and score the tests would immediately be accused of using it to filter out political opponents. There's precedent to worry, honestly. "Literacy tests" or supposed civics exams administered unfairly were part of how black voters were disenfranchised in the Jim Crow era.
Understood. But there's plenty of precedent for (relatively) independent assessment of a minimum acceptance criteria. E.g. Passing a driving license test, getting a trade certification, becoming a JP, getting a passport. Maybe you could make politics a trade-certifiable profession like law?
Yeah but none of those things have the ability to impact the politics of the country.

Imagine a republican-controlled government making part of the "trade-certified politician" requirements that the person has to watch a minimum of 100 hours of Fox news and write an essay on how Tucker Carlson is the second coming of jebus.
 
It's quite the irony that in the upper reaches of the pecking order in society the the job requirements become practically non-existent. Just think. The most powerful person on the planet needs only to be at least 35 years old. Not a SINGLE, quantifiable performance standard need be met. An evident crook or a drooling idiot can get there. With good makeup and handlers, a corpse, perhaps. Just get enough votes.

That's the Trojan horse, the Achilles heel of democracy. A populace having sufficient ignorant, misinformed, manipulated, disenfranchised, angry, or malign voters will screw itself over.

Democracy may suck at times but any other type of government sucks all the time.
 
Yeah but none of those things have the ability to impact the politics of the country.

Imagine a republican-controlled government making part of the "trade-certified politician" requirements that the person has to watch a minimum of 100 hours of Fox news and write an essay on how Tucker Carlson is the second coming of jebus.
If legislated properly, that is not how it works.

Your driver's license, or a pilot's license, or a law degree, etc., all have independent criteria that is effectively non-political. You can be a raging Commie, bomb-adjacent anarchist, or tall-and-square bleeds-red-white-and-blue right-wing Navy admiral. But something like a driving license test is not about any of that. It is about the knowledge level and demonstrated ability to command a road vehicle safely in concert with thousands of other drivers.

Similarly, a political candidate's "license" should test the demonstrated knowledge of the house of government they are a candidate for, and the ability to understand and follow the current operating protocols of that house. The "road rules" if you will of government. It does not play, and should not be allowed to play, on political leaning either way. If you are a seig-heiling fascist and you pass the test, OK, you can stand. If you are a bleeding-heart liberal and you fail the test, you don't get to be a candidate. And if they fail, maybe have a time period before they can try again? Next election?

You can then legislate that if a member of that house breaches the licensing standard they supposedly passed, they can be liable for sanctions by the house. With a standard to compare them to, judgement is much easier. "Here's the standard you know you were supposed to uphold. You have not. Sanctions will follow." My suggested first level of sanction is loss of standing as a candidate come the next election cycle, just like if they failed the test. A more severe sanction would be expulsion from that house.

None of this would prevent the deplorable display of recalcitrance such as EmptyG displayed at the SOTU address last week. But it does highlight that they are failing to meet the Congressional member standard, which she clearly would have done had there been a standard, she would be facing major penalties. Not that it would worry her - she will always claim she was the victim. But too bad. Tell it to the hand.
 
emptyg apparently acted unhinged during a private classified debriefing session with Biden Administration officials.
One lawmaker who attended the briefing said the exchange between Greene and the officials included profanities. “When she got to ask questions,” the lawmaker recalled, “she was yelling out saying ‘********,’ and, you know, ‘I don’t believe you.' Just screaming and yelling, irrational in my estimation,” the lawmaker added. The Hill link

greene's side of it?
“I had to wait in line the whole time. I was I think the second to last person, and I chewed them out just like the American people would’ve,” Greene told The Hill. “I tore ‘em to pieces.”

By the way, this past week greene took to carrying a white balloon around, including in the halls of Congress. The white dress greene wore to the State of the Union address was supposed to make people think of the balloon.

[IMGW=600]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1457&pictureid=13333[/IMGW]
 
The trouble with that sort of thing is that whatever people write, administer, and score the tests would immediately be accused of using it to filter out political opponents. There's precedent to worry, honestly. "Literacy tests" or supposed civics exams administered unfairly were part of how black voters were disenfranchised in the Jim Crow era.
A perfect job for ChatGPT!
 
Her behavior is such a gift to Democrats it makes me want to donate to her campaign.
 
emptyg apparently acted unhinged during a private classified debriefing session with Biden Administration officials.


greene's side of it?


By the way, this past week greene took to carrying a white balloon around, including in the halls of Congress. The white dress greene wore to the State of the Union address was supposed to make people think of the balloon.

[IMGW=600]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1457&pictureid=13333[/IMGW]

Is anyone surprised? She's a monkey. Monkeys throw ****. It's all you can expect from her kind.
 
emptyg and woman staffer at a local discount clothes store.

emptyg: "I'm looking for a white coat to wear to the State of the Union address."
Staffer: "A white coat...?"
emptyg: "Remind people of the balloon."
Staffer: "I guess..."
emptyg: "Do you like this coat?"
Staffer: "Mmm no, not really."
emptyg: "I'll take it!"
 

Attachments

  • Queen of the night.jpg
    Queen of the night.jpg
    71.6 KB · Views: 12
Both statements I quote are true and therein lies the dilemma. I've watched local news interviews with Greene supporters and they usually say they support her because "she's a fighter." Because, "she goes up to Washington and stirs things up." That sounds great only what is she fighting for? What 'things' is she stirring up? You watch interviews from sources like the David Pakman Show or by Jordan Klepper. Greene supporters usually can't answer those questions. When asked their reaction is: they're drawing a blank.

That's where this really becomes dangerous. People who enthusiastically support a polarizing political figure like Greene yet can't verbalize 'why.' Especially people who, because of their social or economic status, are largely insulated from the damage Greene does.


I look at that photo of Marge walking with her supporters and wonder what kind of people must they all be?

We have photographic evidence here that each person in that photo must be either a hater, a complete idiot, or probably both.

I dunno, just thinking out loud. It's interesting for some reason. You want to sort out the real idiots? Here ya go! I think you gotta be an idiot to support any politician enough to be seen with them in public (to be excited about them).
 
I look at that photo of Marge walking with her supporters and wonder what kind of people must they all be?

We have photographic evidence here that each person in that photo must be either a hater, a complete idiot, or probably both.

I dunno, just thinking out loud. It's interesting for some reason. You want to sort out the real idiots? Here ya go! I think you gotta be an idiot to support any politician enough to be seen with them in public (to be excited about them).

The collective IQ at a Trump rally or a MTG townhall could actually go into the negative numbers.
 
If legislated properly, that is not how it works.

Your driver's license, or a pilot's license, or a law degree, etc., all have independent criteria that is effectively non-political. You can be a raging Commie, bomb-adjacent anarchist, or tall-and-square bleeds-red-white-and-blue right-wing Navy admiral. But something like a driving license test is not about any of that. It is about the knowledge level and demonstrated ability to command a road vehicle safely in concert with thousands of other drivers.

Similarly, a political candidate's "license" should test the demonstrated knowledge of the house of government they are a candidate for, and the ability to understand and follow the current operating protocols of that house. The "road rules" if you will of government. It does not play, and should not be allowed to play, on political leaning either way. If you are a seig-heiling fascist and you pass the test, OK, you can stand. If you are a bleeding-heart liberal and you fail the test, you don't get to be a candidate. And if they fail, maybe have a time period before they can try again? Next election?

You can then legislate that if a member of that house breaches the licensing standard they supposedly passed, they can be liable for sanctions by the house. With a standard to compare them to, judgement is much easier. "Here's the standard you know you were supposed to uphold. You have not. Sanctions will follow." My suggested first level of sanction is loss of standing as a candidate come the next election cycle, just like if they failed the test. A more severe sanction would be expulsion from that house.

None of this would prevent the deplorable display of recalcitrance such as EmptyG displayed at the SOTU address last week. But it does highlight that they are failing to meet the Congressional member standard, which she clearly would have done had there been a standard, she would be facing major penalties. Not that it would worry her - she will always claim she was the victim. But too bad. Tell it to the hand.

Yes, that's how such a scheme for qualifying candidates should be run. I'm saying that's not how it will be. It will just be another power play to try to keep your opposing party's candidates off the ballot. Do you see any way to prevent that?
 
Yes, that's how such a scheme for qualifying candidates should be run. I'm saying that's not how it will be. It will just be another power play to try to keep your opposing party's candidates off the ballot. Do you see any way to prevent that?
I agree - it's completely idealistic and overly-optimistic. Because there's always people like Trump who simply ignore any pesky rules they don't like, and shameless, scruple-free manipulators who are prepared to manipulate the rules to their own advantage.

So the truthful answer is: No. There's no guaranteed way to prevent circumvention of any political rules for personal gain. The system relies on personal honesty and integrity, of which many politicians nowadays have exactly none.
 
I agree - it's completely idealistic and overly-optimistic. Because there's always people like Trump who simply ignore any pesky rules they don't like, and shameless, scruple-free manipulators who are prepared to manipulate the rules to their own advantage.

So the truthful answer is: No. There's no guaranteed way to prevent circumvention of any political rules for personal gain. The system relies on personal honesty and integrity, of which many politicians nowadays have exactly none.

Democracy mainly relies on a well-educated population who can read and write, figure stuff out by themselves, and the majority of whom can see through obvious liars.

Hans
 
Democracy mainly relies on a well-educated population who can read and write, figure stuff out by themselves, and the majority of whom can see through obvious liars.

Hans
Maybe the voting criteria is a level of education for potential voters. If you are SRSLY SURE-NUFF DUM then you can't vote either.
 
I agree - it's completely idealistic and overly-optimistic. Because there's always people like Trump who simply ignore any pesky rules they don't like, and shameless, scruple-free manipulators who are prepared to manipulate the rules to their own advantage.

So the truthful answer is: No. There's no guaranteed way to prevent circumvention of any political rules for personal gain. The system relies on personal honesty and integrity, of which many politicians nowadays have exactly none.

Nope. The system must have:
- rule of Law
- a free press
- an educated citizenry.

Because scum ALWAYS will rise to the top otherwise.
 
Democracy mainly relies on a well-educated population who can read and write, figure stuff out by themselves, and the majority of whom can see through obvious liars.

Hans

True. Have you listened to Trump rally attendees? We're doomed.

If Republicans have their way, our children won't be taught critical thinking skills, actual history, or allowed to read books that might upset their widdle fweelings and make them think. But they'll sure as hell be made to recite that good old Pledge of Allegiance with its "one nation under God", and learn that Creationism is just as valid as Evolution in science class.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom