Cont: The Marjorie Taylor Greene thread - Part II

Is she ?

Her views seem pretty mainstream for today's GOP.

Are there any major points on which her opinions deviate significantly from the core of the Republican voters ?


A lot of what she says doesn't seem "mainstream" to me, lol. Don't mistake votes for people supporting all of her crazy rhetoric. For example, I strongly disagree about the likelihood of finding "butt plugs and dildos" at Target. It would not be one of my speaking points.

Even if she were in agreement with all of mainstream GOP policy, she is still clearly a nutcase. But plenty of us are willing to vote for these nutjobs (she is really pushing it, though) rather than have a Dem in office.They're just that bad.
 
Last edited:
A lot of what she says doesn't seem "mainstream" to me, lol. Don't mistake votes for people supporting all of her crazy rhetoric. For example, I strongly disagree about the likelihood of finding "butt plugs and dildos" at Target. It would not be one of my speaking points.

Is it crazy rhetoric or are there really a large number of Republican Party members who think that American society is far too permissive and that things like sex toys being on sale in Target and CVS are examples of this ?

I would contend that yes, there is a feeling that society is too permissive which is why so much Republican policy focuses on pushing back against it.

Even if she were in agreement with all of mainstream GOP policy, she is still clearly a nutcase. But plenty of us are willing to vote for these nutjobs (she is really pushing it, though) rather than have a Dem in office.They're just that bad.

I'll simply repeat what I said earlier. Her rhetoric seems to align with the views of the GOP members.
 
Is it crazy rhetoric or are there really a large number of Republican Party members who think that American society is far too permissive and that things like sex toys being on sale in Target and CVS are examples of this ?


If I went to my local Target and found some butt plugs and veiny jelly dongs on the shelf, I would be pretty concerned. But it isn't a reality, yet. If I thought MTG was speaking metaphorically, about what we are exposing our children to, I might be able to support what she is saying...in spirit. But I don't think she is. And that is where the crazy comes in. And it isn't like this is isolated crazy, or her most egregious behavior.

ETA: Now as a side note, I just checked the Target website. It does have quite a few obvious sex toys. But I think most are delivery only.
 
Last edited:
If I went to my local Target and found some butt plugs and veiny jelly dongs on the shelf, I would be pretty concerned. But it isn't a reality, yet. If I thought MTG was speaking metaphorically, about what we are exposing our children to, I might be able to support what she is saying...in spirit. But I don't think she is. And that is where the crazy comes in. And it isn't like this is isolated crazy, or her most egregious behavior.

She was talking about Target and CVS. AIUI both stores carry a range of products. Whether they're exactly the products you describe is another matter. A simple internet search is sufficient to establish this.

It's unsurprising that you support her message though, and that's why I argue that she's not crazy, rather she simply reflects a majority view within the party.

Face it, Marjorie Taylor Greene is and her fellow travellers are the modern day Republican Party.
 
It's unsurprising that you support her message though, and that's why I argue that she's not crazy, rather she simply reflects a majority view within the party.


Except I didn't say I support what she is saying.

If I thought MTG was speaking metaphorically, about what we are exposing our children to, I might be able to support what she is saying...in spirit. But I don't think she is. And that is where the crazy comes in. And it isn't like this is isolated crazy, or her most egregious behavior.
 
Last edited:
Except I didn't say I support what she is saying.

My apologies, I misunderstood what you were saying. I thought you supported Marjorie Taylor Greene's attempts to shield American children from the worst excesses of the permissive society (such as sex toys being available in mainstream stores such as CVS and Target). :confused:
 
My apologies, I misunderstood what you were saying. I thought you supported Marjorie Taylor Greene's attempts to shield American children from the worst excesses of the permissive society (such as sex toys being available in mainstream stores such as CVS and Target). :confused:


Honestly, I don't know what your point is. I literally said I don't support what she is saying, because I don't think it is a metaphor. Now if you think it would be fine for such sex toys to be on the self at Target, that is a different matter.
 
Honestly, I don't know what your point is. I literally said I don't support what she is saying, because I don't think it is a metaphor. Now if you think it would be fine for such sex toys to be on the self at Target, that is a different matter.

They are on the shelves, so it's not a different matter.

"Crazy" Marjorie Taylor Greene is, IMO, making exactly the argument you support - that these items should be removed from sale in order to protect children from the permissive society and that's a mainstream view within the GOP.
 
They are on the shelves, so it's not a different matter.

"Crazy" Marjorie Taylor Greene is, IMO, making exactly the argument you support - that these items should be removed from sale in order to protect children from the permissive society and that's a mainstream view within the GOP.


As I far as I can tell from my Target , and the website, butt plugs and jelly dongs are not for sale on the local shelves. Do you have any reason to suspect differently?

Also, are you dodging the question of where you stand on the matter? Do you think it would be acceptable for these items to be on Target shelves where children could view and access them, or not? Do you support MTG "in spirit" on this matter?

I've already said I can't support what she has said, because it appears to be factually incorrect.
 
Last edited:
As I far as I can tell from my Target , and the website, butt plugs and jelly dongs are not for sale on the local shelves. Do you know differently?

AIUI from listening to Marjorie Taylor Greene, she was railing against the sale of sex toys in outlets such as Target and CVS. I do not believe that she guaranteed that all items would be available in all branches.

Here is a link which clearly indicates that such products are available for sale in Target:

https://au.lifestyle.yahoo.com/xrat...play-goes-viral-rant-backfires-054532623.html

Also why are you dodging the question of where you stand on the matter? Do you think it would be acceptable for these items to be on Target shelves where children could view and access them, or not? Do you support MTG "in spirit" on this matter?

Yes, I think it is perfectly acceptable for Target to stock such products so long as the packaging does not contravene the law (for example by being covered in sexually explicit images). The packaging in the photo in the link above is perfectly acceptable IMO.

I am bewildered at the harm that can come to children from seeing a box that contains a sex toy. I'm also astonished at the pearl-clutching going on as I distinctly remember such "massagers" being on sale in US supermarkets back in the '70s.
 
AIUI from listening to Marjorie Taylor Greene, she was railing against the sale of sex toys in outlets such as Target and CVS. I do not believe that she guaranteed that all items would be available in all branches.

Here is a link which clearly indicates that such products are available for sale in Target:

https://au.lifestyle.yahoo.com/xrat...play-goes-viral-rant-backfires-054532623.html



Yes, I think it is perfectly acceptable for Target to stock such products so long as the packaging does not contravene the law (for example by being covered in sexually explicit images). The packaging in the photo in the link above is perfectly acceptable IMO.

I am bewildered at the harm that can come to children from seeing a box that contains a sex toy. I'm also astonished at the pearl-clutching going on as I distinctly remember such "massagers" being on sale in US supermarkets back in the '70s.


First, I haven't seen these at local supermarkets, ever (from your article):

Front and center for little eyes to see. A vibrator that you can **** in BOTH *****. Because that is appropriate for little ones to see while shopping for vitamins.


Now, your article is from Australia, where it seems to have created controversy. But obviously, if so many people support it, it would be a valid concern as to what is permissible for children to access. I wouldn't call that particular item a butt plug or anatomically correct jelly dong, though. Which is the imagery MTG is promoting, imo.

But from a standpoint of what I see on the shelves and website here, these items she mentioned are not typically stocked on US shelves at Target. Hence, I am not backing her statement.
 
Last edited:
First, I haven't seen these at local supermarkets, ever (from your article):

Maybe you have to be more observant ?

Maybe you need to switch stores ?

Now, your article is from Australia, where it seems to have created controversy. But obviously, if so many people support it, it would be a valid concern as to what is permissible for children to access. I wouldn't call that particular item a butt plug or anatomically correct jelly dong, though. Which is the imagery MTG is promoting, imo.

The article is from Australia but the picture and many of the posts were from the US though it seems that any controversy was muted.

But from a standpoint of what I see on the shelves and website here, these are not typically stocked on US shelves at Target. Hence, I am not backing her statement.

Regardless, you do seem to back her crusade to protect American children from the threat posed to them by the sale of sex toys in outlets such as Target and CVS.

As I say, Marjorie Taylor Greene isn't "crazy", she's what passes for GOP mainstream these days. I mean, I think she's crazy, but then again I think the GOP mainstream is crazy.
 
Regardless, you do seem to back her crusade to protect American children from the threat posed to them by the sale of sex toys in outlets such as Target and CVS.

As I say, Marjorie Taylor Greene isn't "crazy", she's what passes for GOP mainstream these days. I mean, I think she's crazy, but then again I think the GOP mainstream is crazy.


It seems you are really stretching here, to paint it as though all of her views and commentary are mainstream GOP. First, I have made it clear that I don't support her statement as fact, for numerous reasons, including the imagery she is evoking . Second, I have stated she is crazy. Third, a general concern about what children have access to, is not an endorsement of her every statement or position.

And again, what is pictured in that article is definitely not the imagery/products I associate with "butt plugs and dildos", as MTG put it.
 
Last edited:
It seems you are really stretching here, to paint it as though all of her views and commentary are mainstream GOP. First, I have made it clear that I don't support her statement as fact, for numerous reasons, including the imagery she is evoking . Second, I have stated she is crazy. Third, a general concern about what children have access to, is not an endorsement of her every statement or position.

I know you have stated that she is "crazy", I'm trying to point out that her views are simply the modern day GOP mainstream.

Which of her policy positions do you disagree with ?
 
I know you have stated that she is "crazy", I'm trying to point out that her views are simply the modern day GOP mainstream.

Which of her policy positions do you disagree with ?


I disagree with her general insanity. I don't endorse her crazy rhetoric. Even if she votes on party lines which is what people are counting on, it doesn't mean they endorse her other actions. Whereas it seems you are implying that her craziness is totally acceptable and embraced by most all Republicans.
 
I disagree with her general insanity. I don't endorse her crazy rhetoric. Even if she votes on party lines which is what people are counting on, it doesn't mean they endorse her other actions. Whereas it seems you are implying that her craziness is totally acceptable and embraced by most all Republicans.

I have yet to see any evidence for her supposed "craziness".

That the 2020 election was stolen, and that the January 6 insurrection was therefore justified is now a core narrative of the GOP.

That society is too permissive and that this is damaging American children is absolutely at the core of ridiculous GOP legislation like the Missouri library legislation.

Your one piece of evidence of her "craziness" is that she may have exaggerated (though IMO the jury is still out on that) exactly what sex toys are available in Target and CVS, not the thing that I think is crazy, that children can somehow be damaged by seeing packaging that contains a sex toy.

If you think that Marjorie Taylor Greene is crazy, I think you need to face up to the possibility that your liberal views are quickly turning you into a RINO. ;)
 
That the 2020 election was stolen, and that the January 6 insurrection was therefore justified is now a core narrative of the GOP.


I am not sure how well that one is holding up with the constituency. I have never believed there was widespread tampering. Certainly not that 1/6 was justified. I don't think most Republicans support that, and especially not her latest rhetoric about "being succesful, and armed".

Maybe I'm wrong, but I don't see it IRL. Maybe I am just not hanging with the " proper" crowds.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom