The Guardian and Loose Change Again

Its now known that the Manhattan Project, as classified as it was and is, was breached by the KGB. You can probably call up the Russian GOv't and find out all the nuclear secrets you wanted with a little cash.
 
Last edited:
Dylan Avery said:
--------------------------------------------------------
Dylan writes an open letter:

Dear Letters,

The fact that George Monbiot's article contains more ad-hominem attacks and circular logic than an actual debate on evidence shows how little Manbiot understands the core issues of the 9/11 Truth Movement.


The fact that DA said this demonstrates how little he understands about journalism. You want details? Get a book. This is a summary.



Dylan Avery said:
"The next evident flaw is that the plot they propose must have involved tens of thousands of people ... People appear on the Jerry Springer Show to admit to carnal relations with their tractors. "


Before I go into any a response to DA's comments, I just wanted to point out that he uses fantastic quote mining here to imply the article compares 9/11 to people having sex with tractors.

Of course the article didn't do that at all, so I'm beginning to suspect DA has the reading comprehension skills of a 5 year old.


Dylan Avery said:
That suggestion is ludicrous and is not based in any reality or fact. The Manhattan Project cost nearly $2 billion dollars and employed over 100,000 people, and a majority of the details surrounding it remain classified to this day.


Others have addressed this aspect, but I just wanted to add another thing. The Manhattan Project did remain a secret, for a while. But any comparison with a theoretical 9/11 conspiracy is grossly flawed. The comparison would only be valid if, after Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the project was still secret, and the US Government denied involvement.

The same was true of the Doolittle Raid. While they were training etc... it was so secret that the crew didn't even know what they were training for. But it didn't remain secret after the raid had been completed. Same for Operation Eagle Claw. Or frikken Operation Overlord (probably the most secret operation ever carried out)! Secret operations only ever remain secret until the actual operation is carried out. After that, the cat is out of the bag.

The problem with the 9/11 CT is it requires the secret to be maintained AFTER THE EVENT.



Dylan Avery said:
We've spoken to a number of those people, including Mike Walter. We never said a cruise missile did hit. We merely advanced it as a possible theory. Anything could have happened at the Pentagon, and the core issue remains that the government has controlled the information from start to finish, and has refused citizens' requests at almost every turn.


Back peddling much?


Dylan Avery said:
That statement is false. The actual collapse mechanism for the entire building was never documented by NIST, and they have openly stated that it was not their job. We have footage of them on camera saying so.


Ah, so he has reading AND listening comprehension issues.

NIST did study the collapse mechanism. That's what they were there to study. What they didn't study was the collapse PROGRESSION - that is the sequence of collapse. The laws of physics coupled with some basic calculations make it clear that after initiation, the collapse was not going to stop. Therefore studying the collapse progression was pointless. In order to make buildings safer, one must try to prevent the collapse initiation.

Consider this scenario. A space shuttle is on re-entry when super-heated gasses enter the aircraft wing via a section of the hull where heat tiles had fallen off. In a matter of a few heart beats the ship becomes unstable, and the enormous g-force acting on the vessel tears it to pieces, scattering debris across the United States.

In the investigation, should NASA:
A) Study how and why the heat tile was removed, and develop systems for preventing this from happening, or for detecting it earlier to enable repair before re-entry
B) Waste valuable time and limited resources investigating the accident from the moments AFTER break-up initiated, trying to trace the path and fate of every single componant of the entire shuttle.


Dylan Avery said:
FEMA themselves admitted in their 2002 status report, "The specifics of the fires in WTC 7 and how they caused the building to collapse remain unknown at this time. Although the total diesel fuel on the premises contained massive potential energy, the best hypothesis has only a low probability of occurrence. Further research, investigation, and analyses are needed to resolve this issue."


I like how they use "admitted" instead of "concluded", as if FEMA let slip a nasty little secret.

But anyway. Dear Dylan Avery. Note the bolding letters. It is now 2007. Not 2002.



Dylan Avery said:
They're still alive, therefore, their movie is false. This premise was first advanced by Maddox, an online satirist who dresses like a pirate.


And it's probably the single most powerful argument AGAINST your theories.

-Gumboot
 
Dylan writes an open letter:

[Blah blah blah ad hominem, blah circular, blah blah debate, blah blah mysterious deaths]

-----
ETA: the letter is already gone :confused: :confused: :confused:

Do you mean to tell me that Dylan "Ban-Happy" Avery actually deleted his own open letter?

Can somebody confirm this?

You know there's a little too much funny on your farm when you start censoring yourself. Unbelievable.
 
Do you mean to tell me that Dylan "Ban-Happy" Avery actually deleted his own open letter?

Can somebody confirm this?

You know there's a little too much funny on your farm when you start censoring yourself. Unbelievable.

He and JDX are the censor NAZIs for 9/11 truth. You can not have a truth movement if you have lax censorship.

Dylan the liar-king leader of the pack of nuts. Nuts have to delete their own letter of lies. Maybe he does not own the rights to the quotes and lies anymore!
 
After Killtown's "numbers in the smoke" posts, and that *$(@*! buffoon claiming "it was all a cartoon!", I thought I'd have to wait a while until another Twoofer trumped them - perhaps a couple of weeks.

Clearly I underestimated Dylan.

Apropos of that, how many of their LC Forum members are simply there to laugh themselves sick at the antics there? Shades of Florence Foster Jenkins, I suspect.
 
Dont get a lot by Monbiot in Aussie papers, but this is the first one I have agreed with. Good to see. But, according to CTs anything from mainstream press is written for sheeple and is thefore safely ignored.


All the while using the press articles when needed to push a theory!
 
gumboot said:
Before I go into any a response to DA's comments, I just wanted to point out that he uses fantastic quote mining here to imply the article compares 9/11 to people having sex with tractors.
Indeed, that unnecessarily denigrates people who have sex with tractors. :D
 
Jeez, all of two weeks?

"After doing at least 2 weeks of solid research i came to the conclusion that NIST and The Commission report were just quite simply inaccurate, and there was plenty of valid material omitted."

At least TWO WEEKS of SOLID research!

That'd do it.


Dang, it took me less time to research the history of the Falkland Islands for a term paper for my class on the British Empire in college 20 years ago.

I wonder how many conspiracy theory websites he googled? :boggled:
 
Here's the question Dylan should be asking:

was the Mannhatten project a secret 5+ years AFTER HIROSHIMA?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom