The Golden Compass is Controversial?

Aurelian

Tire Kicker
Joined
Mar 29, 2006
Messages
469
I will admit I haven't heard the back-story on the Philip Pullman trilogy, and all of my kids that are old enough to read them have enjoyed them immensely (and me, too) so I was surprised to find this bit of alleged controversy:

http://snopes.com/politics/religion/compass.asp

If the objection is that he's "killing God", well, Aslan died, and there's that whole Jesus death on the cross thing...and quite frankly, I think Pullman was way too subtle, as in, it takes 23 pages to explain why a/n (adjective) Christion shouldn't see the movie?

I'm just shaking my head, thinking, oh ye of little faith...generating free publicity for the movie...

Maybe I just bankrupted my brain by reading Faulkner, but is anyone else here suprised to see The Golden Compass et al being offered as a response to C.S. Lewis's Chronicles of Narnia?

Other comments are welcome too!

A.
 
Maybe I just bankrupted my brain by reading Faulkner, but is anyone else here suprised to see The Golden Compass et al being offered as a response to C.S. Lewis's Chronicles of Narnia?

Other comments are welcome too!


This flared up in my wife's "moms' group." Some people were very angry that an "anti-Christian" children's movie was being released. I saw the commercials and I don't know what the heck they're talking about. It looked exactly the same as Narnia to me.
 
This flared up in my wife's "moms' group." Some people were very angry that an "anti-Christian" children's movie was being released. I saw the commercials and I don't know what the heck they're talking about. It looked exactly the same as Narnia to me.

Pullman in the novels does take some nasty shots at Religon in general and Christianity in particular,without a doubt. That's a given.
But I strongly suspect that has been pretty much toned and down or removed for the film version.
It's pretty obvious that New Line wants another "LOTR" with this film....which is why Pullman's cracks at religon will probably be left on the cutting room floor..or,rather,never made it into the script in the first place.
 
If the objection is that he's "killing God", well, Aslan died, and there's that whole Jesus death on the cross thing...and quite frankly, I think Pullman was way too subtle, as in, it takes 23 pages to explain why a/n (adjective) Christion shouldn't see the movie?


In "The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe," it is not so much that Aslan died that was the basis of the salvation of Narnia, it was his triumph over Death itself - his Resurrection.

The same holds true for those of us who follow Christianity. We don't concern ourselves overly much with the death of Jesus, we look to His resurrection, and see a source of hope for victory over Death.*

Of course, the resurrection of Jesus is pure woo to most people who read this. But, it's what Christians believe, even if others don't.

* - Now, there is a semi-official "Cult of Death" within many denominations, wherein its members focus solely upon the crucifixion of Jesus, His suffering, His last words, and His eventual death. Little, if any, emphasis is given to His resurrection. The cult leaders use this to exploit the guilt inherent in the idea that "Jesus died for your sins" to (for example) manipulate people into "donating" as much money as can be had from them. Look into any church that displays a dying, emaciated man on a cross, and you will have found one of these "Death Cult" churches.

(It's like telling your kid to "Behave, or you'll make the baby Jesus cry!")

Now that's not just woo, it's exploitive woo, and on an order of magnitude that even Sylvia Browne could never hope to achieve!

As for the movie ... mneh ... it's gonna be a movie. I'm no big fan of Nicole Kidman or Philip Pullman to begin with, so I have no interest in watching yet another propaganda piece. Even "Passion of the Christ," while interesting at times, would not have been something that I would have paid to see.
 
Last edited:
Of course it's controversial.
I read it, I enjoyed it (although the ending made me sad).

But he is, as you mentioned, "killing god". And not figuratively, either. It stnads to reason that some (a lot, in North America) people will find this offensive.

To put it in perspective, Jesus and Aslan, in their respective stories, were sacrificed as atonement for the wrongs of others. And were resurrected. Truth be told I liked the Chronicles of Narnia better than the Bible.

In His Dark Materials, god, and indeed the whole heavenly host, is destroyed because of the harm they cause.

I don't know about it being a response to Narnia, although I've heard it described as such in several places. Maybe I'm overlooking the correlations.

Nonetheless, I am giddy with anticipation of the movie. The trailer for it (which I saw mid-summer) is what caused me to track down and buy the books in the first place. I just ope Hollywood doesn't botch it.
 
He's not killing god. He's killing an angel that claimed he was god. Whether or not there is actually any god in Pullman books is in itself a matter for debate, though given Pullman's stand on religion I'd be betting 'no'.

I wish that the people who criticise the books would actually read them...not referring to any of you guys/gals.

ETA: To clarify - Pullman has said that his books are about 'killing god', but as I understand it he doesn't mean the literal death of the Authority in the books - rather the overall theme and tone of the books.
 
Last edited:
Nobody goes anywhere near the Authority in The Golden Compass! Why fundie Christians got to be trippin? They are ruinin this for everybody.
 
Have to admit, I must be extraordinarily metaphor blind. I read all three books a while back and failed to notice any of the anti-god stuff. I recently read an interview with Pullman in a back copy of "The New Yorker" in which he was practically claiming to have preempted Harris , Hitchens and Dawkins in the "Advertising atheism" business.

As "kids books" they were certainly more interesting to this adult than the Narnia stuff, but I can't help feeling people are reading in more than was meant - and like any smart writer, Pullman is nodding sagely and acting like we are doing well to understand his wisdom.

I'd certainly recommend them to kids over Lewis, but purely because Pullman is a far better writer.
 
As bolo said, they don't even get there untill later in the series. And as Moby said, they kill the angel who claimed to be god. From memory he just claimed to be god since he was just the first bit of matter to become selfaware. And also they dont kill him as much as set him free (via death), since he had become imprisoned by another powerful angel who called himself "The Authority". Again, this is from memory and it was a few years ago so feel free to point out any mistakes.

It does amuse me that they make such an outcry against what they believe opposes their views. Can you smell the rampant fear? lol.
 
Nobody goes anywhere near the Authority in The Golden Compass! Why fundie Christians got to be trippin? They are ruinin this for everybody.

Wow! I never knew that we had so much power over other people, especially well-educated and intelligent individuals such as yourself.
 
As bolo said, they don't even get there untill later in the series. And as Moby said, they kill the angel who claimed to be god. From memory he just claimed to be god since he was just the first bit of matter to become selfaware. And also they dont kill him as much as set him free (via death), since he had become imprisoned by another powerful angel who called himself "The Authority". Again, this is from memory and it was a few years ago so feel free to point out any mistakes.

It does amuse me that they make such an outcry against what they believe opposes their views. Can you smell the rampant fear? lol.

Close. Very close. I'll put the corrections in spoilers:

The Authority is actually the angel who claims to be god. And they quite literally 'set him free' - they don't directly kill him in the book, instead they break open the cage he was protected/imprisoned by, and when he walks outside a gentle breeze causes him to come apart.

The powerful angel you're thinking of is Metatron, Regent of the Authority. The Authority voluntarily gave up his powers (or so it is suggested in the books) to Metatron, and 'retired' to 'contemplate deeper matters'. The Authority is the philosopher (or that is how he is portrayed until we meet him), Metatron is the ruler in day to day matters.


Can't tell I love the books, can you?
 
I haven't read the Pullman books but as a child I hated The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe - it has such a smug, patronizing tone.
 
Fnord said:
Nobody goes anywhere near the Authority in The Golden Compass! Why fundie Christians got to be trippin? They are ruinin this for everybody.

Wow! I never knew that we had so much power over other people, especially well-educated and intelligent individuals such as yourself.


"We?"

I never pictured you as a fundie. (Still don't.)

I'm one who never even heard of the books, or the movie, until the outrage popped up. So now I'll have to see the movie, just to check it out.

But I wonder sometimes about Christians who are so upset when someone tries to present a different belief system to their kids, but who are perfectly comfortable with Christians trying to convert non-Christian kids.
 
Maybe they will picket the movie theater here, that would be cool.

I'd see it twice.
 
Nobody goes anywhere near the Authority in The Golden Compass! Why fundie Christians got to be trippin? They are ruinin this for everybody.

Wow! I never knew that we had so much power over other people, especially well-educated and intelligent individuals such as yourself.

Well, in this case, it's just the power to reveal a plot point that doesn't occur until the third book.
 
I haven't read the Pullman books but as a child I hated The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe - it has such a smug, patronizing tone.

Ooh I loved that one. Of course, I enjoyed reading the series of books a long, long time ago.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom