The God of the Universe ...

Ok...but natural selection doen't REQUIRE a deity to run it. There may or may not be one watching the process, we don't know. Do you see how this is the case?
No, this is merely the default position you are stating here. Whereas to the degree that you stress it, you're saying God does not exist which, in fact you do not know. To me, it sounds like you've become entrenched in your views, and don't really want to know.
 
Last edited:
If God exists, then He has to be consistent and pragmatic, regardless of any representation of Him in the past.

Has to? I thought the deities worked more or less in mysterious ways. Or is that only when it suits your arguments?
 
Of course it looks like all I would be doing here is reiterating what I said in the original post.

Which brings us back to my point. If your deity is so mysterious, how can you then assign attributes to it with great certainty?

Edit:
Or even with any certainty at all?
 
Which brings us back to my point. If your deity is so mysterious, how can you then assign attributes to it with great certainty?

Edit:
Or even with any certainty at all?
Simply because we exist, and the rules that govern our existence are consistent. Of this much I am quite sure.
 
Simply because we exist, and the rules that govern our existence are consistent. Of this much I am quite sure.

You are not answering my question though. Physical world that we live by has nothing to do with your deity. You are just assigning properties to what is supposed to be mysterious and able to exist outside our natural laws. Once again: How can you do that with any kind of certainty?
 
No, this is merely the default position you are stating here. Whereas to the degree that you stress it, you're saying God does not exist which, in fact you do not know. To me, it sounds like you've become entrenched in your views, and don't really want to know.

No. A deity is not REQUIRED. Kind of like the appendix? You don't need it. Really.

Arguments can be made to weather or not a deity exists, but one is simply not required to operate natural selection.

I've been on the "God is necesary side" too. I am quite capable of changing my mind once EVIDENCE is provided. This same evidence that we've been requesting from you for weeks now. This same evidence that you've been refusing to provide for weeks now. So, your attack about being entrenched is a tad telling.
 
You are not answering my question though. Physical world that we live by has nothing to do with your deity. You are just assigning properties to what is supposed to be mysterious and able to exist outside our natural laws. Once again: How can you do that with any kind of certainty?
And if a tree fell in the woods and nobody was there to hear it, would it make a sound?
 
And if a tree fell in the woods and nobody was there to hear it, would it make a sound?
And if there's nobody around to hear it means that nobody knocked the tree down. It fell by itself.
 
These characteristics are not attributable to any concept of God that I have ever seen. (except for perhaps Loki, who loves jokes, but then he's just A god not The God.)

You see ? This is exactly the sort of discrimination that monotheists do. Please be more respectful of the old gods. Loki is a very sensitive (and, might I say, crazy) deity.
 
You can't have your cake and eat it, at least in this world. Which, may be the point. Why would He design something temporal, and subject to decay?

Because you ARE temporal, and subject to decay, and know nothing else ? Humm... maybe God's not so divine after all, eh ?
 
So, is there anything about existence which is not circular? ... Or, contained within the whole of existence itself? So, you can dichotomize all like ...

That's not the point. You argument is circular. You assume your conclusion as a premise! You can "prove" anything, that way.
 
If God exists, then He has to be consistent and pragmatic
Have I got this right? What you're saying here is that because the universe appears to work without apparent intervention from "God," He must be pragmatic and consistent?

i.e. You're trying to get around the absence of any evidence for God's existence by claiming that God exists, but He doesn't actually do anything?
 
Have I got this right? What you're saying here is that because the universe appears to work without apparent intervention from "God," He must be pragmatic and consistent?
Yes. Otherwise without some standard of consistency, how do we go about defining anything? It would be impossible.

e. You're trying to get around the absence of any evidence for God's existence by claiming that God exists, but He doesn't actually do anything?
Again, if a tree fell in the woods and nobody was there to hear it, would it make a sound?
 
Yes. Otherwise without some standard of consistency, how do we go about defining anything? It would be impossible.

Again, if a tree fell in the woods and nobody was there to hear it, would it make a sound?

:blink: :blink: :blink:

So...because we have no evidence of a god, there must be a god, cause else how would everything run so smoothly? Is THAT your argument?

Can we shut down the forum again and see if it makes any sense when we get back?
 
No, this is merely the default position you are stating here. Whereas to the degree that you stress it, you're saying God does not exist which, in fact you do not know. To me, it sounds like you've become entrenched in your views, and don't really want to know.

Funny that you would say this, Iacchus.
 
Yes. Otherwise without some standard of consistency, how do we go about defining anything? It would be impossible.

So... if there were evidence for God, that would show that god exists... and if there isn't any... then it shows that god exists ?

Again, if a tree fell in the woods and nobody was there to hear it, would it make a sound?

Yes it would. How does tha relate to GOD ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom